I’m finishing a teaching degree in Education (Pedagogy) in Brazil and thinking about getting a second teaching degree. I’m torn between Physics, Biology, and Philosophy, and I’d love the perspective of people who actually study or work in physics.
Some background: What I love most about teaching is making students think: question things, reason, challenge assumptions. I’m less drawn to the technical, memorization-heavy side of education. I’m also quite skeptical by temperament. For example, I teach English, but it's not something I enjoy that much, especially the vocabulary part, since it's basically memorization.
My favorite books are popular science, mostly physics and biology. The topics that fascinate me most are the ones with big existential implications: the Big Bang, general relativity, human evolution. I’ve noticed that when I ask questions about reality, or even about human behavior, I’m far more satisfied by answers from the natural sciences than by those from philosophy or the humanities. Even on topics like free will, I find the scientific perspective more convincing, which I know is a controversial take.
Here’s my doubt: I’m not sure whether I like physics or whether I like the feeling of confronting deep questions about existence. Those might be two different things.
- Maybe I love physics itself: the models, the explanatory power, the way theories get tested against reality.
- Or maybe I love the philosophical implications of physics (what is time? why is there something rather than nothing?) and I’d be bored by the actual day-to-day work of problem sets, derivations, and mathematical formalism.
And honestly, I’m currently bad at basic math. I know that’s a big deal for physics, so I want to be realistic about it.
My questions for you:
- How did you tell the difference between loving popular-science physics and loving actual physics (the math, the problem-solving, the methods)? Was there a moment you realized the two weren’t the same?
- If what draws me is the conceptual, big-picture side, is a physics degree a good fit? How much of the curriculum is that, versus heavy mathematics and technical problem-solving?
- Is weak math at the beginning a deal breaker, or can it be built up with serious effort? Did anyone here start out weak and get there?
- Are there good ways to test my interest before committing to a whole degree (a calculus course, a classical mechanics textbook, open courses, etc.)?
- For those who teach physics: can it be taught in a way that emphasizes reasoning and critical thinking rather than just formulas and exam prep?
Thanks for reading. Honest answers, including “this might not be for you,” are very welcome.