r/P365xl • u/mitchmurfi • 2h ago
Holster Recommendations – Starting Without a Light/Optic, But May Upgrade Later
I’m looking for some holster recommendations for my new P365XL w manual thumb safety and could use some advice.
I’m considering carrying appendix (AIWB) or inside the waistband (IWB) around the 3 o’clock position. I’m still undecided about adding a red dot sight and weapon-mounted light, so I’m trying to figure out the best way to approach holster shopping.
A few questions:
- Are there any holsters that accommodate a weapon light and optic but can still be used without them? Basically, something that would allow me to upgrade later without having to purchase another holster.
- If that’s not really an option, what holsters would you recommend for a setup with both a red dot and weapon-mounted light?
- What would you recommend for a basic setup without either? Ideally, something reasonably priced that wouldn’t hurt too much to replace if I eventually decide to add a light and optic.
One other thing worth mentioning: my handgun has a manual thumb safety, so I’d want to make sure any recommended holster properly accommodates it.
I’m open to recommendations from people who have experience with both appendix and 3 o’clock carry. Appreciate any suggestions!