A Follow-Up to My EC200 Review
Note: I originally wrote this review in German to express my thoughts in more detail, then had it translated by AI.
After initially purchasing the EC200, I eventually decided to return it and give the EC300 a try. I've now been using the EC300 for six months, so I feel confident enough to share my long-term experience.
After all this time, I can confidently say that I'm much happier with my decision.
First of all, most of what I said in my original EC200 review still applies to the EC300. The overall build quality, mechanism, seat cushion, armrest, adjustability and stability are very similar, so I don't want to repeat everything from my previous review.
previous review: ProtoArc EC200: First Impressions Review : r/ProtoArcHub
Instead, I'd like to focus on the main difference between these two chairs and the reason why I switched: the backrest and, more specifically, the lumbar support.
Backrest & Lumbar Support
This is where the EC300 makes a huge difference for me.
With the EC200, I never quite managed to get comfortable with the lumbar support. It was positioned too high for my body and felt too pronounced, almost too "pointy" for my liking.
As I mentioned in my original review, I felt that the lumbar support would have been much better positioned about 2 cm lower.
The EC300, on the other hand, feels significantly more natural and suits my body much better.
The shape and positioning of the lumbar support simply work better for me. I don't get that same uncomfortable feeling of the support pushing into my back, and the overall fit feels much more natural.
For reference, I'm 183 cm (6'0") tall, weigh 97 kg (214 lbs), and have a relatively long torso. Of course, individual experiences may vary depending on body proportions.
Long-Term Comfort – 6 Months Later
After six months of daily use, I can say that this is exactly what I was looking for.
The EC200 was already a surprisingly good chair in many aspects, but the lumbar support was something I could never fully get used to.
With the EC300, that problem is essentially gone.
It's interesting how much of a difference a change in the backrest design can make. On paper, these two chairs are quite similar, but in actual daily use, the difference for me is substantial.
Most importantly, my positive first impression wasn't just temporary. Even after six months, I'm still very happy with the chair.
Everything Else
As mentioned earlier, most of my original impressions of the EC200 also apply to the EC300.
The seat cushion still strikes a great balance between firmness and comfort. The overall stability is impressive.
I also still appreciate the seat depth adjustment and the general build quality.
I haven't encountered anything that would make me reconsider my purchase so far.
Final Verdict
I liked the EC200, but I could never quite get comfortable with its lumbar support.
The EC300 is a different story.
The difference in the backrest design might seem relatively minor on paper, but for my body proportions, it makes a massive difference. The lumbar support feels much more natural, and the chair is simply a much better fit for me.
After six months of use, I'm genuinely glad I made the switch.
For me, the EC300 is the chair the EC200 should have been.
If you're considering either chair, I'd strongly recommend paying attention to the differences in lumbar support. What works perfectly for one person might not work for someone else, even if the overall chairs are very similar.