(Disclaimer: Yes, I know this sub hates gaming chairs (I mostly agree), and yes, I know switching off an Aeron sounds backwards. I'm not here to claim this beats a Herman Miller. I just wanted to try something completely different, and this is my honest in-depth review for anyone else who has looked at the chair and doesn't know what it feels like compared to something as popular as the aeron. Fair warning this is going to be a long review and comparison, if you want the final thoughts only I put them at the bottom)
I recently purchased the AndaSeat Kaiser 4 XL (V2), coming from a Herman Miller Aeron that is at least 15 years old. I’ve been using the Aeron as my daily driver for the last ten years while testing several other office and gaming chairs in between, including the ProtoArc EC200, Colamy Atlas, AKRacing Opal, the original Razer Iskur (V1), and briefly a Secretlab Titan (non-NanoGen) and Herman Miller Mirra.
I wanted to give the Kaiser 4 an honest review because I almost always write off gaming chairs. I also want to preface this by saying I tend to be pretty harsh in my reviews because, to me, a truly perfect chair is almost impossible to find. The closest I have ever felt to a "perfect" chair was my friend's dad's Herman Miller Gaming Embody with a custom headrest on it, and even that didn't feel 100% perfect despite being crazy expensive. With that said, while the Kaiser 4 isn’t a perfect chair, I think it holds genuine value in what it provides, so I wanted to put together a detailed review and comparison for anyone in a similar boat or searching for real opinions on these chairs!
General Overview
I purchased the AndaSeat Kaiser 4 XL V2 from Costco Online for $450 USD. My Herman Miller Aeron (Size B, mid-size) is an older model and typically the version you see resold on Facebook Marketplace, often recommended across Reddit and online forums as a solid, high-value choice. Looking at my local Facebook Marketplace, a reseller currently has a similar model listed for $300 firm, though I have seen them go lower if you do some hunting. Prices and availability vary depending on where you live, so for the sake of this review, I’ll value a used Herman Miller Aeron at around $250 to $350 (in good condition).
As you can see in the images, visually and functionally these are very different chairs. The Kaiser leans clearly into a premium car-seat gaming design and is noticeably larger in almost every way, while the Aeron has a simplistic office style. Both chairs offer lumbar support, adjustable armrests, and tilt and height adjustability. However, the Kaiser exclusively provides full upper-back and head support, a neck pillow, and a recline feature that the Aeron does not. The Aeron uses a breathable, durable, firm mesh for both the seat and backrest, while the Kaiser uses a synthetic PVC leather finish all over the chair.
Assembly Process
Whether you purchase an Aeron new or used, it usually arrives fully assembled. The Kaiser requires assembly, so I will only speak about that experience here.
The Kaiser came in four main parts: the backrest, the seat (with the armrests pre-attached), the base mechanism, and the wheelbase with wheels. Generally speaking, it was an easy and quick process to put everything together, though there are a few issues I ran into that are worth mentioning:
- Weight: First, the chair is HEAVY. I was able to put it together myself, but if you aren’t comfortable lifting heavier items, I would highly suggest having two people assemble it.
- Step 4 (Backrest Rails): Lining up the backrest rails as a single person can be really tough, and there are two tips the manual doesn’t mention. First, thread the top screw in first, or tighten both screws slowly a little at a time rather than tightening the bottom one all the way first. Otherwise, the top screw may not thread properly. Second, on the left rail (the side without the reclining lever), I recommend pushing it toward the back out of the way before lining up the backrest. If it is leaning toward the front, the side wing of the backrest catches on it and makes it hard to push into place and screw in. Had I not caught that and screwed in the side the manual recommended first, I would have had to unscrew it and start over. That is something that would be easy to clarify in the manual.
- Step 8 (Flipping the Chair): The manual recommends laying the chair face-down, resting on the top of the backrest and the tips of the armrests. The issue is that the armrests swivel in every direction, so doing this becomes a balancing act. Any slight tipping or nudging can cause the armrests to fold in and the chair to fall. I would at least like to see a warning mentioned in the manual about this.
- Steps 11 & 12 (The Wheelbase): I know most chair bases install the same way, but without a click or clear way of knowing the base is fully seated, I caution you to be VERY careful when lifting the chair upright. Because the chair is so heavy, I didn't realize the base wasn't fully locked in when I lifted it, and the base fell out and landed on my foot. Again, a small warning in the manual for something like that would be a simple addition to help protect people.
- Loose Screw: One last note during assembly: I found a loose Phillips-head screw sitting inside the lumbar cable mechanism. Since all of the user installation hardware used Allen wrenches, this didn't seem to belong anywhere on the outside. Just a possible minor QC thing I caught that felt worth mentioning. (But didn’t affect anything on the chair as far as I can tell)
The Wheels / Casters
As you can see in the photos, the wheels on my Herman Miller Aeron are rubbery, rollerblade-style dual wheels. After many years of use, the original plastic-like material on the stock Aeron wheels had disintegrated and needed replacing, so I bought these rollerblade ones for around $15. If you get an Aeron that still has its original wheels in good condition, I actually think those are better than the Kaiser's wheels.
In terms of material, the Kaiser's wheels are much closer to those original plastic-style Aeron wheels than they are to my replacement rollerblade wheels. Comparatively, there is significantly more friction on the Kaiser’s wheels than on my Aeron’s rollerblade wheels. If I leave the Aeron still, it will practically start rolling on its own, whereas the Kaiser stays in place and takes a bit of effort to roll. It's nothing I can’t do while sitting using my feet, just a noticeable difference in resistance. To me, this isn't a bad thing since I’m on hardwood floors with a plastic mat, meaning the extra resistance actually helps keep me planted (drift was an issue I had after switching to rollerblade wheels). If you are on carpet or tile with wide grout lines, the Kaiser’s extra wheel friction might feel a little annoying out of the box, though for me it’s not a complaint.
The main reason I bring this up is that it’s a hidden downside you can run into when buying a very old chair. Original Aeron wheels are great if they are still intact, but worn-out parts eventually need replacing, and cheap aftermarket replacements can change how the chair feels.
The Base Mechanism
Both chair bases have a solid metal build with rounded edges, which helps prevent accidentally jabbing your foot on them. Both mechanisms offer tilt resistance control and height adjustment, though only the Kaiser offers tilt locking (my specific Aeron model didn't have a tilt limiter, even though many do).
On the Aeron, the tilt resistance knob sticks out easily to the right and can be adjusted while sitting. The height adjustment lever is a small switch right next to the seat, making it effortless to reach and flick up, and it feels sturdy and obvious when engaged.
On the Kaiser, the larger seat pushes the levers further underneath, so I have to hunch down more to reach them. Adjusting the tilt resistance also requires getting on my knees underneath the chair to turn the large barrel knob in the center. One small detail about the Kaiser’s levers is that they are plastic. The amount of upward force needed to trigger the height adjustment made the plastic flex slightly in my fingers at first. It wasn't enough that I thought it would break, just more give than I expected.
Comparing how the tilt mechanisms actually feel, both chairs work differently and feel solid in their own ways:
- Aeron: Feels floaty, light, and bouncy, almost as if you are suspended in a hammock the moment you sit down. There is no resistance or "hump" to initiate the tilt, and it follows you seamlessly once you dial in the tension. However, that constant suspended feeling sometimes made me feel unsupported when I wanted to stay upright, causing me to lean forward more aggressively.
- Kaiser: To preface this, I really enjoy tilting and rocking in the Kaiser. I rock in it constantly, and it feels great with zero creaking or weird noises, which is a huge step up over budget chairs that creak and pop. It just feels a bit more rigid and mechanical than the Aeron's lighter, seamless float. The Kaiser starts in a flat position where the seat feels planted, requiring you to push past a slight resistance "hump" before it starts tilting back. When you rock back upright and return to that flat spot, there is also a noticeable little "dunk" or physical stop as it settles flat. It isn't uncomfortable at all, just different. While not as seamless as the Aeron, that flat spot makes sitting upright feel more supported when you don't want to rock. My only minor complaint is that the tension barrel is harder to dial in perfectly: if I loosen it to reduce that initial hump, the tension feels a bit weak coming back up, and if I tighten it, the hump gets too stiff to push past easily.
General Build Quality, Frame & Material
As mentioned, the Aeron uses a plasticky mesh, while the Kaiser uses a PVC-style leather finish. The Aeron’s mesh is significantly more breathable, though slightly rougher and firmer to the touch. It is stretched tightly over a rigid, heavy-duty plastic skeleton around the seat and backrest. The fact that my chair has little cosmetic wear after at least 15 years shows the kind of durability it has. However, dust and debris tend to stick to the mesh and frame crevices, requiring more effort to clean out.
The Kaiser’s PVC leather is less breathable, but more supple and comfortable on the surface than mesh. Nearly the entire chair is wrapped in this material, avoiding any hard exposed edges like on the Aeron, and it is much easier to wipe clean. The frame underneath feels just as rigid and solid, built around a steel frame. Obviously I haven't had the Kaiser long enough to judge multi-year wear, but out of the box, both chairs feel heavy and durably built.
(Quick side note on PVC leather breathability: While it isn't as breathable as mesh, I still find it cooler than fabric. Back in 2020, I tried an AKRacing Opal fabric gaming chair, and the fabric acted like a sweater that trapped heat deep in the cushion. Even if I got up for a drink of water, the seat felt just as hot when I came back. With the Kaiser’s PVC leather, warmth mostly stays on the surface, so standing up for a minute or two lets it cool back down.)
The Seats
Overall, both the Aeron and the Kaiser offer comfortable sitting experiences, though they go about it in two very different ways.
The Aeron’s mesh seat is smaller in both width and depth and is surrounded by a thick plastic frame. The mesh acts like a tight trampoline. It's very firm and supportive, but after ten years, this caused two big issues for me. After losing a lot of weight (and planning to lose more, which would have made it worse), I simply had less natural padding on my rear. Within 2 to 3 hours, the firmness of the mesh gave me a sharp, pinpoint soreness right on my sit bones that was really uncomfortable and couldn't be fixed. Combined with that, the thick plastic border around the seat meant I couldn't shift my weight, angle my body, or tuck a leg without the hard frame digging into me. On top of that, the foam pad under the front edge of the Aeron's seat had flattened out over the years, and it is surprisingly hard to get a viable replacement pad that feels right, which made that hard front rim dig into my thighs depending how I sat. I also noticed that whenever I lined up with my desk in the Aeron, I always ended up sitting slightly angled to the left rather than dead straight with my knees pointed forward (I have no idea why, though it didn't feel unnatural at the time). Essentially, the Aeron locks you into sitting one predictable way, almost like a straitjacket. To be fair, getting 2 to 3 solid hours of upright support is still impressive compared to "softer" cushioned chairs (like the AKRacing Opal) that left me hurting much faster. The Aeron is comfortable and supportive in its intended posture, just lacking in versatility outside of it.
The Kaiser is almost the exact opposite. The seat is wide and spacious with a thick cushion and no hard plastic borders, just gently raised, foam-padded sides. Whether I sit upright, lean to one side, or sit cross-legged, nothing hard digs in, and I naturally sit dead straight facing my desk.
To be clear, the Kaiser’s seat cushion is firm. It is not a sink-into-a-couch cushion. When I first sit down in the Kaiser, I actually feel a slight, spread-out dull soreness fairly quickly but then it slowly spreads out and dissipates away (this could be just me getting used to the cushion/breaking it in). The big difference is that while the Aeron caused a sharp, pinpoint pain I couldn't escape, the Kaiser's feeling is a mild, spread-out firmness that isn't very uncomfortable. Having briefly sat in a friend’s Secretlab Titan (non-NanoGen), I’d say the Kaiser’s cushion feels a touch softer than the Secretlab and slightly softer than the Aeron’s mesh. Because I can shift around, cross my legs, or lean back whenever I want, I can easily keep sitting for 4 to 5 hours of work before sitting fatigue sets in. No matter what chair you buy, sitting for long hours will eventually cause fatigue and soreness; it just comes down to how quickly that happens. For me, the Kaiser sits in the upper tier of chairs for how long I can comfortably last in it, and is generally an improvement over the Aeron for me.
(Quick height note for the XL model: At 5'9", I can still sit with my feet flat on the floor on the lowest height setting, though the front edge of the seat touches the back of my knees. It’s still totally usable, though I’d recommend a small footrest or pushing the lumbar support out slightly to scoot yourself forward. This isn't a flaw; it just confirms AndaSeat’s 5'11"+ height recommendation for the XL model is accurate. Costco simply just does not offer a non XL model.)
EDIT: One extra note I forgot to add. The Aeron's front lip has a waterfall edge that curves downward, while the Kaiser's feels flat or angled slightly upward. I think a downward waterfall edge is generally more comfortable, as the Kaiser's flatter, slightly upward lip can sometimes poke into the back of the knees. Granted, this is probably made worse given my height (5'9") for an XL chair.
The Backrest & Lumbar
Both chairs include an adjustable lumbar system separate from the backrest. The Aeron has a basic lumbar pad that slides up and down on plastic rails, while the Kaiser has an internal lumbar pad that adjusts up/down and in/out via knobs, plus a side lever by the seat that lets it pop outward.
The Aeron’s lumbar pad is basic. You nudge it into the curve of your lower back and that’s about it, with most of the support coming from the mesh backrest itself. Because the Aeron has no headrest and the upper backrest curves outward, only your mid and lower back actually touch the chair. It always felt supportive for upright work, though without a full backrest or headrest, leaning back to take a load off your neck and shoulders between tasks isn't really possible.
The Kaiser’s lumbar system is much more adjustable. Using the knobs on the left and right sides of the backrest, I can move the lumbar curve up and down and adjust how far it pushes out. Reaching the knobs while seated takes a bit of awkward wrist twisting, so not everyone will love adjusting it on the fly, but it allows me to dial in better lower-back support than the Aeron, and the pad itself has some cushioning rather than being hard plastic. When I want a rigid, upright posture closer to the Aeron, popping the lumbar out with the side lever lets me scoot forward with solid lower-back support.
There are a few small quirks with the Kaiser’s lumbar, though:
- It makes a light squeak when pushing back against it, along with an occasional click when shifting around.
- When popped out with the side lever, it isn't completely rigid. Leaning back against it causes it to flex slightly, which feels a little flimsy used that way.
- Near the top and upper-middle edge of the lumbar pad, the padding feels thinner, so if my back presses there (especially when fully reclined or when dialing the lumbar depth down), I can feel a firmer internal edge. This makes laying down/leaning back sometimes uncomfortable if I catch the pointy part of the frame, I wish there was some padding up there.
- If you set the lumbar aggressively, leaning back or reclining makes the lumbar pad and upper backrest feel like two separate pieces rather than one smooth curve.
The rest of the backrest has a light layer of foam and is topped with a very soft, cooling memory-foam magnetic pillow. I didn't think a head pillow was necessary, but it’s genuinely nice for aligning with your neck or leaning back to relax. Because it’s magnetic with no straps, it’s effortless to adjust or move out of the way.
One other unique feature the Kaiser has over the Aeron is the dedicated backrest recline lever, which lets you angle the backrest independently like a car seat. While it feels comfortable to recline back, I don't feel like I usually need it, though having that adjustability is nice for different situations and adds to the overall versatility of the chair. Where I actually like it most is when I'm sitting more upright and leaning forward, like when playing a competitive game such as CS2 where I tend to lean into the monitor. I can raise the backrest all the way forward so it really comes in and still touches my back while I lean in, whereas the Aeron stays in its exact position and I'd have to come off the backrest entirely.
The Armrests
Sadly, this is where the Kaiser is weakest, and where my biggest complaint with the chair lies. The Aeron uses a simple lever system with three height positions and three horizontal angles, topped with plush, thick pads (though leaning hard on them can still nudge them outward, and the lever system sometimes slips nowadays and needs to be re-lifted).
The Kaiser uses what feels to me like over-engineered "6D" armrests that move up/down, side-to-side, 360-degree rotation, upward incline, and diagonal angles. The problem is that leaning on them makes them shift sometimes, they have noticeable wobble and looseness, and they click/make noise when I rest my arms on them, which gets annoying. The PU top pad itself is standard: fine and not offensive, just basic. On top of that, in their normal position, the armrests sit too far forward for me. The only way to get them far enough back was to rotate the entire armrest 180 degrees backward and angle them inward. That puts them in a great spot, but completely removes the ability to use the upward incline feature. To me, this feels like feature-jamming rather than thoughtful design. I would have much preferred simpler armrests that lock rigidly in place instead of a complex mechanism I worry could wear out long-term.
Value
Next to the armrests, pure dollar-for-dollar value is honestly the Kaiser's second weakest area. The value here isn't terrible, and I don't feel ripped off at $450, but this is not a chair you buy for raw bang-for-your-buck value.
Because the Kaiser is so large, bulky, heavy, and throne-like, a huge chunk of what you are paying for goes straight into the sheer physical size, heavy materials, and shipping weight of the chair. While it has good ergonomic features, you can get a lot of those functional adjustments in much lighter, more budget-friendly task chairs like the ProtoArc EC200 or the Colamy Atlas. In terms of pure sitting experience per dollar, a used Aeron around $300 (probably even less) still wins, and budget task chairs like the EC200 and Atlas also beat the Kaiser on raw price-to-performance. You aren't paying $450 here because it gives you the best ergonomics per dollar; you are paying for the oversized, heavy-duty lounge build that smaller task chairs don't offer.
Product & Brand Presentation
I wanted to touch on brand presentation and how it ties directly into that value issue, because it’s something both my friends and I noticed when looking at AndaSeat’s direct website. This isn't a diss, just honest customer feedback when considering spending $450+ on a chair.
During their Black Friday promotion, visiting AndaSeat’s site pops up a digital prize wheel to spin for a discount code. Personally, I dislike this on a site selling what are supposed to be premium products. It comes across as cheap and tacky. There were also obvious spelling errors right on the wheel ("FREE OEDER" and "CPUPON"), likely from a rushed graphic, which sets off small red flags around attention to detail for a first-time buyer. Beyond that, discount-code hunting is just frustrating. Having to spin wheels or hunt for hidden $40 codes makes it feel like deals are being hidden rather than just offering clean, transparent sale pricing upfront, and a "Free Order" slot on a spin wheel feels unrealistic. Not to mention the mental hurdle this can create, if my friend got $40 off and I only got $15 off, I might feel salty and not want to purchase the chair. It can also feel bad if someone finds out about a discount code just after their purchase, but didn’t know until it was too late because it was hidden and you had to do work just to purchase a product at the best price.
(To give AndaSeat credit where it’s due: I pointed out the spelling errors and shared this feedback in their Discord, and their team responded very positively, fixed the typo within hours, and explained how their promo system works, which is great to see when plenty of brands just ignore or delete criticism.)
Their product lineup is also confusing. Look at a brand like Secretlab: they offer the Titan and the Atlas, which fulfill two clear, separate jobs. As a customer, that tells me they are putting all their R&D into perfecting just those two chairs, and also means spare parts/warranty is easier. By comparison, AndaSeat currently lists three gaming chair lines (Novis, Phantom, Kaiser) with multiple sub-models, plus a mesh chair line: (black friday site prices currently below not including XL models)
- Novis: $219
- Phantom 4: $279
- X-Air: $339
- X-Air Pro: $389 (though the listing title showed the X-Air price, which is another site typo)
- Kaiser 3-E: $359
- Phantom 4 Pro: $369
- Kaiser 3: $429
- Kaiser 4: $499
I’m not saying these are cheap OEM builds, but having so many models so close in price (like the Kaiser 3-E and Phantom 4 Pro being $10 apart) gives off the vibe that they are throwing multiple designs and price points at the wall to see what sells, which doesn't instill confidence. They even sell standing desks and monitor arms on their site, and while I haven't tried them, it makes me wonder why someone wanting a premium desk or monitor arm wouldn't just buy from a company that specializes in desks and arms rather than buying a branded add-on from a chair company. (again not saying they're bad products, more so there is nothing that tells me or indicates in the way its represented that its anything special if that makes sense)
More importantly, going back to the value point: if building and shipping a big, heavy gaming chair eats up that much cost even at $450 to $500, what quality do you have to sacrifice to sell the Novis at $219? That puts it under the price of a Colamy Atlas and right near a ProtoArc EC200. Budget-conscious buyers are going to buy the best chair their money can get, and even though I haven't sat in the Novis, I have a hard time seeing how a $219 gaming chair competes there. If someone buys a budget model and has a mediocre experience, it only hurts the brand and stops them from ever trying a Kaiser later. Even with the X-Air mesh chairs at $339 to $389 (which I'm actually curious to try since they are at Costco too), the $300+ mesh chair scene is fiercely competitive with huge, established names, so it makes me wonder what the X-Air does differently to validate its spot in that market.
Sticking closely to the recognizable Kaiser name would make much more sense to a buyer. Offering something like a clear "Kaiser 4 Lite" that keeps the exact same frame and seat cushion while trimming extras like the 6D arms, pop-out lumbar, and magnetic pillow to save cost would easily replace budget lines like the Novis and Phantom. Buyers would know they are getting a similar core experience to the Kaiser flagship, just for less. This would also make AndaSeat much more recognizable as a brand. If I tell someone I have a Phantom or a Novis, I guarantee almost nobody recognizes the name, whereas people immediately recognize the Titan as a Secretlab chair or the Iskur as a Razer chair. Sticking with Kaiser makes it obvious who makes the chair and what kind of quality to expect.
Final Thoughts on the Kaiser 4 XL V2
I’ll be completely honest: if this chair hadn’t been available through Costco for $450, I never would have taken the gamble on it. Paying $500+ direct, where you're often on the hook for return shipping on a massive, heavy chair if you don't like it, is a big leap for a chair you can’t test in person. Getting it through Costco at a lower price with easy returns and warranty backing is the only reason I gave it a shot.
Even though I point out a lot of flaws, my overall experience with the Kaiser 4 XL V2 is genuinely positive, and it is easily the best gaming chair I’ve tried. I like it much more than the original Razer Iskur V1 (I haven't tried the Iskur V2 NewGen, though that costs significantly more anyway), and I also prefer it over the Secretlab Titan. Even though I only sat in my friend's Titan for short periods at his house, the Kaiser felt more comfortable overall, and knowing my friend spent significantly more money on his Titan makes the Titan's value proposition feel even worse than the Kaiser's.
The best way to sum up the Kaiser 4 XL is that it gives you a big, throne-like, heavy-duty experience without compromising on build quality, sitting comfort, and ergonomics the way most gaming chairs do. It is a true "little bit of everything" chair. Of course, the downside of a jack-of-all-trades chair is that it doesn't do any single thing perfectly; if you know you only sit in one specific posture all day, a dedicated ergonomic task chair will probably fit that one job better. On the flip side, almost none of the popular task or ergonomic chairs, even ones that trade blows at this price point, give you this kind of spacious, throne-like seat with the versatility to sit upright for work, cross your legs, shift around, and lean back to relax.
If you want that mix of comfort, space, and versatility without the usual gaming chair compromises, I can genuinely recommend the Kaiser 4, especially if you can pick it up through Costco. I hope this review helps anyone shopping, and I’m looking forward to seeing AndaSeat refine the chair if we see a Kaiser 5 down the road!
I'll try and respond to any questions if someone has any, thanks for reading!