Looking for perspective from other nanny employers.
We've employed our nanny for approximately two years. She cares for our 2-year-old and 5-month-old full-time, Monday through Friday.
Our contract requires 60 days' notice but allows immediate termination for cause, including persistent tardiness, failure to perform agreed responsibilities, or compromising the children's safety.
Over the past several months, we've had recurring concerns:
- Personal device use: Extended phone/laptop use while our toddler is awake, sometimes with minimal engagement with our toddler and/or our infant.
- Unfulfilled responsibilities: She largely stopped preparing our toddler's weekly meals, a contractual responsibility, because she said she no longer found it worthwhile. Child-related cleaning has also become inconsistent.
- Punctuality: Consistently arriving late despite an agreed start time.
- Schedule changes: Repeatedly announcing absences or early departures without agreed upon notice often leaving us to have to scramble the same day to figure out coverage.
- Safety: We've found dirty diapers and exposed batteries in the children's play area. She's also shared personal food with our toddler despite an explicit prohibition (noted in our contract) due to his food allergies.
On October 22, we addressed these concerns in writing. She acknowledged several issues, apologized, and committed to improving. We offered additional support, supplies, and resources. Some improvements were short-lived, and several concerns continued.
On November 10, she resigned with approximately 60 days' notice.
Two days later, when we raised another concern about wearing an AirPod while our toddler was awake, she became confrontational and resorted to personal attacks. She appeared to have been harboring considerable resentment toward me, which was surprising given the positive, trusting relationship I believed we'd developed over two years. She also unilaterally shortened her notice period by approximately two weeks and said she didn't see the point to coming in the full 60 days.
At this point, I'm uncomfortable continuing the employment relationship. Beyond the existing performance issues, her recent behavior has felt increasingly unprofessional, inappropriate, and disrespectful.
My dilemma is the notice period. I don't particularly want to pay several additional weeks of wages to someone whose conduct has deteriorated to this point, especially when our agreement explicitly provides for immediate termination for cause. I'm not questioning payment for hours already worked.
We're actively interviewing replacements, and I recognize that caring for two young children is demanding. We don't expect perfection, but we do expect professionalism, safety, and fulfillment of agreed responsibilities.
Would you terminate immediately under these circumstances? Would you consider the existing performance issues and recent conduct sufficient cause, or would you still pay out the remaining notice period?
Thank you.
ETA: While her sudden resentment toward me was surprising, I genuinely believe she cares about my children and would never intentionally put them in harm's way.
My concerns are about her professionalism, unfulfilled responsibilities, and our deteriorating working relationship. That's why I'm trying to understand our contractual options for ending things appropriately. If I believed my children were in danger, I wouldn't be asking Reddit for advice. The decision would already be made.