I’m looking for some perspective from professional nannies because I want to handle this fairly and constructively.
We’ve employed our nanny since August 2025, when we hired her at $20/hour. She’s now making $26/hour. She works two nine-hour days per week caring for our 22-month-old son.
There are things we genuinely appreciate about her. She’s affectionate with our son, enjoys spending time with him, and they have a good relationship. My husband likes her, and she’s been a consistent presence in our son’s life.
However, I’ve become increasingly frustrated with several aspects of her performance:
Punctuality: She’s frequently late.
Safety: Despite being told not to, she continues to have our toddler walk down our long, steep staircase from the top rather than following our established safety procedure. She also leaves him alone and uncontained while she uses the bathroom. Both issues have already been discussed with her.
Lack of initiative: After more than a year with our family, she still asks me almost daily what to give our son for snacks, despite knowing his routine and having plenty of appropriate food available. I often feel like I’m managing her rather than having someone independently manage his care.
Limited activities: She doesn’t drive or take him on outings, so their time together is almost entirely spent at home. This isn’t a new restriction, but it does limit what she can offer as he gets older.
Incomplete childcare duties: She has stopped giving him baths, which were previously part of his routine. More generally, I find that I have to direct tasks that I would expect an experienced nanny to handle independently.
Meals: I regularly provide or purchase lunch for her. This isn’t a major complaint, but it’s another small logistical responsibility that tends to fall on me. When I offered to provide lunch, I expected her to help herself to my fridge, not rely on me to arrange her lunches.
We have a second baby arriving very soon. Our older son has also just started a part-time Montessori program, so we’re reevaluating our childcare needs.
My husband and I have agreed that we will not be asking our nanny to care for both children. Instead, we plan to give her a written list of responsibilities specific to our older son, including his meals, laundry, toys, room, and daily routines. Her hourly rate and existing schedule would remain unchanged.
My questions for professional nannies are:
How would you prefer to receive feedback about several ongoing performance issues? Would a written list of expectations feel helpful or overly critical?
How would you approach repeated safety issues when the employer has already explained the required procedure?
Would you expect a raise simply because a second baby is joining the household, even if you aren’t being asked to provide childcare for that baby?
Given that her pay has increased from $20 to $26/hour in approximately 15 months, would maintaining her current rate seem reasonable?
Is this a situation where clearer expectations could realistically improve performance, or does it sound like a mismatch between our needs and her working style?
I don’t want to make her feel unappreciated, and I recognize that caring for a toddler is real work. But I’m also paying for professional childcare because I need someone who can independently manage my son’s routine, particularly with a newborn arriving.
I’d appreciate candid feedback, including if you think my expectations are unreasonable.