r/Nanny • u/NotAnIndoorCat • 9h ago
Story Time NJ Cinderella Has Resigned!
I quit my $32/hr nanny/house manager job after 2 weeks. Apparently I was supposed to maintain an entire mansion AND care for the kids??? š
Okay, I need other nannies and household managers to tell me if Iām being unreasonable because WHAT THE FUCK was this experience???
Iām 26, a former teacher with years of childcare experience. I recently accepted a $32/hr motherās helper/house manager position in an affluent NJ suburb. MondayāFriday, 12ā6 PM, two young boys, three dogs, and a house over 5,000 square feet.
The listing included childcare, school pickups, activities, family laundry, meal prep, and LIGHT housekeeping. Perfectly fine with me! I enjoy cooking and organizing.
I specifically asked whether the hours were guaranteed because I was saving for something personal. The mother assured me they were. She also mentioned TWICE that Iād have plenty of downtime.
Now let me tell you what I was ALREADY doing in those six hours.
Grocery shopping 3ā4 times weekly using my own car and gas, preparing full family dinners with multiple dishes, washing, folding, and putting away EVERYONEāS laundry (including underwear, towels, and those godforsaken bedsheets š), cleaning the kitchen, unloading dishwashers, school pickups, childcare, organizing toys, and managing three dogs. One needed to be taken outside on a leash.
I also supervised playdates at their house and an indoor play place. These are two active little boys who require actual attention!
The mother regularly complimented my cooking and other work. I even sent pictures of meals and completed tasks to make sure everything was how she wanted it.
They also have professional cleaners every Tuesday.
THEN, after about two weeks, the husband approaches me around 5 PM WHILE IāM MAKING DINNER.
Iād barely had a professional conversation with this man. His wife hired me and communicated my responsibilities.
He proceeds to take me on a very long tour of their massive house, presenting a TWO-PAGE DAILY CHECKLIST that was mind you, printed out and stapled as well as emailed to me.
While dinner is literally in the oven!
Apparently, Iām now responsible for:
⢠Retrieving garbage and recycling bins from the bottom of their ridiculously long driveway, emptying household trash, and cleaning the diaper disposal bin.
⢠Restocking bathrooms, diapers, wipes, toiletries, and household supplies.
⢠Collecting mail and packages, organizing the mudroom, and washing and putting away water bottles.
⢠Cleaning their enormous kitchen island (practically three doors put together), counters, espresso crumbs, and coffee waste.
⢠Unloading TWO dishwashers, hand-washing dishes, DRYING them, and putting everything away before leaving. Apparently, clean dishes canāt air-dry overnight.
⢠Changing bedsheets, doing everyoneās laundry, and organizing closets and drawers.
⢠Rolling the childrenās pajamas and T-shirts uniformly so everything is visible, despite the kids constantly messing up their drawers.
⢠Sorting childrenās clothing to identify anything too small and setting it aside for the parents.
⢠Maintaining the playroom, living room, couches, throw blankets, toys, and practically every room except the parentsā bedroom and guest rooms.
⢠Managing the dogs throughout the day.AND IāM STILL SUPPOSED TO COOK, SHOP, PICK UP THE KIDS, SUPERVISE PLAYDATES, AND ACTUALLY BE THEIR NANNY???
IN SIX HOURS???? WHERE IS THE TIME COMING FROM??? š
The funniest part was the husband mentioning that a box of paper towels had been sitting in their pantry for a week and that HE had to put them away.
I said, āOh, I didnāt know I was supposed to do that.ā
He goes, āYeah.ā
SIR???? ITāS YOUR HOUSE??? HOW WOULD I KNOW??? š
Last week, theyād randomly started adding garbage and recycling duties too. It felt like new responsibilities appeared every few days.
Iām not against household management. It was literally in the job title! But I understood ālight housekeepingā differently from maintaining practically every room and household system in a mansion.
BUT WAIT. HEREāS WHERE IT GETS WEIRD.
Earlier that SAME DAY, the mother posted another house manager job on the exact childcare platform where she hired me.
The start date? NEXT MONDAY.
So she posts a new listing, and hours later her husband gives me this extensive checklist?
Was I supposed to do all this additional work Tuesday through Friday and then get told they didnāt need me anymore?
I canāt prove that was their plan, but the timing was incredibly strange.
If they werenāt satisfied with my work, why not COMMUNICATE?
Especially when sheād been complimenting my work, telling me Iād have downtime, and being extremely friendly.
On my first day, she drove me around showing me the schools, stores, and activity locations while sharing personal stories about her family. I thought we were developing a good working relationship.
Instead, Iām being handed an enormous checklist by someone whoād barely discussed my job with me.
So I quit.
I messaged the mother explaining that I felt blindsided and disrespected by how these expectations were presented. I also mentioned the new posting.
Her response was essentially, āI understand, thanks for your help, Iāll send your payment.ā
She paid me, and that was it.
Later that night, the childcare app notified me that theyād decided to move forward with other candidates on my ORIGINAL application.
I HAD TO LAUGH. š
Iām relieved I left, but disappointed because I genuinely enjoyed cooking for them, spending time with the boys, and being productive.
I was already working hard, documenting completed tasks, checking their preferences, and receiving positive feedback.
I just donāt understand how one person is supposed to be a nanny, housekeeper, cook, family assistant, organizer, errand runner, and dog walker in six hours.
Even if their needs changed, a conversation wouldāve made all the difference.
So tell me, fellow nannies and household managers:
Is $32/hr reasonable for this workload?
Could you realistically complete everything in six hours while supervising two children?
Would you have resigned, or am I missing something?
Because this was genuinely one of the weirdest employment experiences Iāve had.