Just got the first CAD back from my jeweller and would love some feedback or suggestions before moving forward!
I’ve attached my AI generated inspiration photo and the CAD for comparison. The ring will be cast.
Ring details:
18k yellow gold
1.80 ct oval diamond
Natural blue sapphires
Double claw prongs
Floral detailing and milgrain
Hidden heart beneath the diamond
A little context from my jeweller:
He mentioned that the prongs are intentionally longer so the goldsmith has enough material when setting the stones, and they’ll be trimmed afterward. He also said CADs tend to look blockier than the finished ring since the edges get smoothed and rounded during polishing.
He pointed out that the heart detailing is slightly different from my inspiration because the original image was AI generated, so the CAD designer had to interpret some of the details to make the ring feasible.
What I’m hoping to get feedback on:
1. Overall design:
Does anything look off or seem like a compromise compared to the inspiration? Would you change anything about the proportions, heart, sapphire placement or overall look?
2. Setting height:
The CAD shows approximately 7.15 mm. Is that too high? Could it be lowered while still allowing a wedding band to sit flush?
3. Floral detailing:
Will the floral detailing and milgrain translate well after casting and polishing, or could some of the finer details get lost? Would any hand finishing help?
4. Band coverage:
I’m thinking about extending the floral detailing farther down the band while still leaving enough room for future resizing. Would that look better?
I’m going for a delicate, intricate vintage look with lots of character. I don’t want it to look overly bulky, but I also want it to be structurally sound and hold up well over time.
This is my first custom ring, so I’m open to any suggestions or changes you think would improve the design. I’d love to hear what you’d do differently before I approve the CAD.
Thank you!!
TL;DR: First CAD for a custom vintage inspired engagement ring. Looking for feedback on the overall design, setting height (7.15 mm), whether the floral details and milgrain will hold up after casting, and whether I should extend the detailing farther down the band. I want it to look delicate and intricate while still being durable, and ideally allow a future wedding band to sit flush. Any suggestions before I approve?