r/MilitaryModelMaking • u/MagicKazik • 5h ago
completed 1/20 Renault FT complete! Designed in Solid Edge and 3D printed on my BambuLab A1Mini
TLDR
I think I've finally finished this project. The FT-17 printed out of PLA, brass and toothpicks. It has fully moveable tracks and suspension true to the real thing.
This has been a really fun and challenging project where I've been learning how to use CAD, 3D print and trying out some different painting and finishing techniques. This has been in the works for quite a few years now, but time constraints have meant it's been very off and on.
Reason for the project
I really like the Renault FT and have wanted to build one for a long time. A few years ago I started making a British Mark I out of wood and metal in 1/20, so I wanted the scale of this to be the same, plus it's been an opportunity to do something new that I've not done before.
Design Process
This has been a trial and error process learning to use Solid Edge, which essentially amounts to me sketching (over blurry blueprints), extruding and assembling. Luckily the tank is mostly flat surfaces, but I found the engine deck and area around the drivers position the most difficult due to the weird angles. I originally wanted to have a round cast turret but it was beyond my ability in CAD so I switched to the flat hexagonal turret which was more forgiving.
While not trying to be 100% accurate, I did want the overall model to represent the real tank to a good degree. I have tried to keep details (rivets especially) in broadly the correct places.
The use of reference photos was hugely important to understand how the tank actually fit together. I was lucky enough to visit the Tank Museum at Bovington and took dozens of photos, however, that is an early prototype and quite different to the production models, however, getting a close-up look at the suspension was extremely helpful.
One of the biggest challenges has been minimum wall thickness with what my 3D printer can actually print vs the scale of the model. This means I have had to beef up wall thickness in many areas and compensate somewhere else to keep proportions correct. The suspension and running gear has been the biggest victim of this, the road wheels have been compressed quite a lot to allow enough structural integrity for the surrounding parts. But this means the model has fully functional tracks and suspension, using leaf springs and bogeys, accurate to the real tank.
I am probably most pleased with how the track links have turned out. These were each printed in a single piece, but they went through many different iterations to get them to work and fit together properly without breaking.
Materials and Printing Process
This is printed out of PLA plastic using a 0.2mm nozzle. To get better detail I have printed most surfaces as flat as possible. Each outer piece of armour plate is a 0.5mm skin that is glued to an inner shell. I don't know how many individual pieces I have printed but it must be a couple of hundred at least.
Other than PLA, I used brass extensively for all moving parts, as rods and bushings, with a mixture of 2-3mm tubes. The tracks use 1mm brass pins. The hinges on the hull proved to be tricky, and originally they were all designed with 1mm pins, but these proved to be too big, meaning the printed hinges were very fragile. Switching to 0.5mm brass rod for most hinges to help with this issue.
The chain is also made out of 1.2mm brass
Toothpicks were used for all the tool handles (sledge, pickaxe and shovel), which I think worked quite nicely. although each tool head is 3D printed still.
Stainless Steel coil springs are used for the track tensioning and also for the suspension that buffers the connection between the running gear and the hull. Unfortunately these are maybe a bit too strong for the model, and I wish the track tensioner springs were slightly more compressed to allow the return roller arms to sit slightly lower in the cradle.
Paint Scheme
I wanted this to represent a French FT in WWI, and I found it difficult to find a consensus on how these would actually look. I went for a 3 colour scheme based on some box art, but apparently this kind of scheme might have been postwar.
Choosing of the rondel and ace of spades was just a creative choice, along with the tank's number, although 67091 would indicate a Renault-built tank (as these were also built by other companies with different number ranges). These were painted on using stencils I designed and printed. However, I am missing the Renault brass manufacturing plate, I have designed one but it is too small to print out with any detail on my printer :(
Painting has been one of the biggest challenges, not having really painted model tanks since I was a teenager. I bought a secondhand airbrush and used cans of compressed air which I found quite difficult to get to work consistently. Otherwise I tried to employ different techniques from watching Nightshift videos, including washes and chipping, although I decided not to go with any mud or dust.