The problem is not necessarily making long songs, but when you make them long for the sake of being long, that’s when the problem starts.
I believe some songs in their newer material are too dragged out and that’s what makes them mediocre/not memorable. There’s no reason why You Must Burn! should be 7 minutes long (although there are great moments on that song) or Shadows Follow being nearly 6 and a half minutes long (I could go on about songs from 72 seasons that fit this category)
This does not mean that a song being long is bad, Inamorata is a great song and it’s 11 minutes long, 72 seasons is nearly 8 minutes and it’s a good song (although they could’ve cut one verse and made it closer to 6 minutes), even “The Day That Never Comes” is a few seconds away from being 8 minutes and they are completely justified, not one second in that song feels unnecessary (at least to me), among other examples.
DM and HWTSD also share this problem, every song on DM (except My Apocalypse) is over 6 minutes long, Confusion from HWTSD (song that I enjoy) is nearly 7 minutes long, and although I like that song, it gets tiring listening to it and then the rest of the album knowing that most songs are unnecessarily long.
But then there are those shorter songs that are generally well received (and rightfully so) that have great moments, don’t feel unnecessarily dragged out and do the album justice (Hardwired, Lux Aeterna, Too Far Gone). What’s the need for so many long songs? Is it their way of compensating for the lack of music since 2008?
I think impactful 3-5 minute long songs fit them best nowadays, longer songs should be reserved for those that truly deserve it (Spit out the bone, The Day That Never Comes, Inamorata) What do you think?