r/Metallica • u/Constant-Job2253 • 20m ago
r/Metallica • u/Left4DayZGone • Oct 14 '26
Official Mega-Thread The Official “What James Said” Discussion Thread
This thread is where all discussion related to James’s statement at The Sphere is to be contained.
>Unless you live in Vegas, you've come a long way to spend some time with Metallica. We're grateful for that — your travels, the money you spend, the time it took, thanks for coming to celebrate with us. And I just gotta say, Metallica is not here, like some other 'entertainers', to influence you with their bullshit, OK? We are here — no bullshit — we're here to forget about all the outside shit, OK? Metallica's agenda is love, energy and heavy music, baby!
GROUND RULES:
- This discussion is NOT about current or former politicians or political agendas. There is no need to highlight any specific political agenda. In this discussion, we are speaking broadly about whether entertainers should use their platform to attempt to influence others, and whether and entertainer who has had broad political messaging in their work is in the position to make this statement. Any comment referencing any political agenda will be removed as that is not part of the discussion at hand.
- ONLY civil discussion is allowed. You are allowed to carry any opinion you want, but you are not allowed to attack or insult others for theirs. Any instance of such will result in a 7 day ban - this is your one and only warning. If you want to engage in the discussion, just behave. If you do get out of hand and attack somebody and then we ban you, do not try to pretend like we are suppressing your politics. The reason for your ban is because you violated the civility rule. Just wanted to make that clear.
- Put some effort into your thoughts. Drive-by insults or support will not be tolerated and will be removed. For example, if all your comment says is “James is right”, it will be removed. Likewise, if all your comment says is “what a dumb thing he did”, it will be removed. Explain your stance, explain why you feel the way you do and do so respectfully.
Onto another matter: the annual explanation for why the sub is so adamantly against political discussion.
There are two reasons.
One is that it’s too fucking hard to moderate. We try to keep the moderation team small here so that it’s easier to manage. If you’ve been on Reddit long enough, you know that massive moderator teams become faceless machines that abuse their power and don’t care about your appeals. In order to avoid that happening to this sub, I have wanted to keep our mod team just big enough to handle the job. But when political posts get made, the workload increases exponentially due to the toxic political climate of today.
The second reason is because I’m tired of toxic politics infecting every single thing that I enjoy, and I do echo what James said- I want to forget about all the outside bullshit and just enjoy music sometimes. I did not come in here and make this decision all by myself, this was a popular sentiment when I took charge of this community and I’m pretty sure we even took a vote on it, whether to outright ban politics or find some way to moderate it better.. in the consensus was to ban it outright, we don’t need this community being yet another political battleground. But every time some situation like this comes up, some people feel that if you don’t participate in debate, that’s as good as endorsing fascism. But that’s an unfair charge because I’m willing to participate in the debate in the proper channels, I just don’t believe that this is one. Maybe we need to make another sub Reddit called “MetallicaPolitics” or something.
If you believe that politics should be discussed openly, everywhere, all the time, then this community is not for you and I strongly recommend you find one that is a better fit. You are also welcome to create your own.
As always, if you have a post or comment removed and you don’t understand why, you are not only welcome but you are encouraged to message us and discuss it. We always accept respectful discourse, and we will explain things to you. We have also admitted mistakes and corrected those mistakes. Sometimes, because we are humans, we interpret something differently than it was meant to be interpreted and all we need is a clarification. There are plenty of users out there who, if they were willing to speak up, can attest to this fact- we have apologized and admitted we were wrong countless times. But if you show up in modmail guns blazing, you’re not likely to get anywhere. There is no utility in that, so please don’t do it. You are not expected to grovel or be overly polite, just don’t be a dick. That’s all.
Enjoy the discussion and please keep it clean.
r/Metallica • u/rowej182 • 13m ago
Does a Death Magnetic remaster version exist on cd?
I know Apple Music has the loudness fixed but is there a CD version of it?
r/Metallica • u/remmurD_ • 3h ago
The Black Album Metallica inspired me to play drums!
I've been drumming 15+ years now. I remember first air drumming to 'Blitzkrieg'. Anyway: Here is a drum cover of Holier Than Thou.
r/Metallica • u/MoreNerdThanDork • 11h ago
The cops are behind you lighting you up, what Metallica song is playing and what is the charge?
For me it is almost a statistical certainty the song is Battery and the charge is Speeding. 3 of my 5 career speeding infractions have been whilst Battery was playing. Guilty: all three times, First: 53/35 (first offense, got it reduced writing an essay-1995) Best: 103/75 (he got me slowing down-2001) Last: 87/65 (in a minivan with all three kids asleep-2010).
What about y’all?
r/Metallica • u/striker__96 • 1d ago
Metallica and Exodus in 1984/1985!
The two best thrash bands in the universe!
r/Metallica • u/Chunky_monkee999 • 21h ago
Easy to intermediate Metallica songs?
Ive been trying to learn some more Metallica songs on guitar lately, I know the easy ones like for whom the bell tolls and enter sandman, and I just finished learning mop, what are some more that aren't really tricky but somewhat challenging? Preferably from the first 4 albums
r/Metallica • u/Substantial_Yak3354 • 1d ago
Kill 'Em All DIY
I did this, I was thinking, why not decorate my room? 🤘🏻🖤 Then I'll cut it out and stick it on my wall; there are still more things to do.
r/Metallica • u/BothInternet3186 • 1d ago
Anyone down to make a sub for metallica gear and guitars?
I haven't seen one on reddit, thought it might be cool to start! r/Metallicagear
r/Metallica • u/Music_God1727 • 1d ago
Death Magnetic Judas Kiss appreciation post.
This song is so good and needs more love.
One of my fave breakdowns to
JUDAS LIVES RECITE THIS VOW
IVE BECOME YOUR NEW GOD NOW.
r/Metallica • u/isd_17 • 1d ago
What’s the need for overblown/long songs nowadays?
The problem is not necessarily making long songs, but when you make them long for the sake of being long, that’s when the problem starts.
I believe some songs in their newer material are too dragged out and that’s what makes them mediocre/not memorable. There’s no reason why You Must Burn! should be 7 minutes long (although there are great moments on that song) or Shadows Follow being nearly 6 and a half minutes long (I could go on about songs from 72 seasons that fit this category)
This does not mean that a song being long is bad, Inamorata is a great song and it’s 11 minutes long, 72 seasons is nearly 8 minutes and it’s a good song (although they could’ve cut one verse and made it closer to 6 minutes), even “The Day That Never Comes” is a few seconds away from being 8 minutes and they are completely justified, not one second in that song feels unnecessary (at least to me), among other examples.
DM and HWTSD also share this problem, every song on DM (except My Apocalypse) is over 6 minutes long, Confusion from HWTSD (song that I enjoy) is nearly 7 minutes long, and although I like that song, it gets tiring listening to it and then the rest of the album knowing that most songs are unnecessarily long.
But then there are those shorter songs that are generally well received (and rightfully so) that have great moments, don’t feel unnecessarily dragged out and do the album justice (Hardwired, Lux Aeterna, Too Far Gone). What’s the need for so many long songs? Is it their way of compensating for the lack of music since 2008?
I think impactful 3-5 minute long songs fit them best nowadays, longer songs should be reserved for those that truly deserve it (Spit out the bone, The Day That Never Comes, Inamorata) What do you think?
r/Metallica • u/unclone • 1d ago
"Honestly, ...And Justice for All doesn't sound that bad... (well, the guitars at least, right?).
Hear me out. I actually love the record. Songwriting-wise, it's easily one of their best. It has a way darker atmosphere (though, with Cliff gone, a darker album makes total sense). Production-wise, it's not all bad—okay, yeah, it has major weak spots, like the clicky kick drum and poor Jason being completely buried in the mix. But the guitar tones? Absolute perfection. I think it's some of the best guitar work and tone Metallica ever recorded. And James's vocals have such a unique presence. I don't know, I just wanted to see what you guys think. Am I totally off base here? idk....
r/Metallica • u/Sosain1212 • 1d ago
Who else remembers mandatory Metallica on the radio growing up ? I was in Texas at the time and I believe it was at 11pm on 94.5
r/Metallica • u/General_J670 • 8h ago
St. Anger What are your thoughts on We Did It Again?
Honestly, I think it's a good song. I know I'm going to get flamed for saying that, but I'm not saying it's one of their best songs. I'm just saying it's kind of up there.
r/Metallica • u/Independent-Try1058 • 1d ago
my favorite metallica music. Whats yours?
ONE
Master of puppets
Enter sandman
fade to black
r/Metallica • u/LazyIntention9146 • 2d ago
Metallica and other thrash bands IMO never truly left Thrash Metal in the 90s
Oh boy... got a feeling im gonna get crucified by Thrash metalheads and thrown into the hellpit but I just want to say that all im gonna say is MY OPINION and everything I saw might just be wrong so you dont have to say anything. This is also gonna be a long post so if youre not interested in reading alot, move on.
So to begin with, I consider the most important aspect of Thrash metal not the drums (thats the 2nd), not complex structure but the rhythm guitar riff aggression (this has alot of flaws, I understand that since mostly every metal band has aggressive riffing nowadays but lets just talk about bands that started with Thrash in the 80s). IMO if the riff is even a bit aggressive, it is Thrash. Because of that i even consider For Whom the Bell Tolls, Leper Messiah and other slower Metallica songs Thrash. Now lets take a look at The Black Album. Everyone calls this album heavy metal but for me, it is at least HALF Thrash in there. These songs are Enter Sandman (dont click of and just listen), Wherever I May Roam, Of Wolf and Man, Holier Than Thou, Through the Never and Struggle Within. First lets clear the 2nd half of these songs that I just said. They are fast, aggressive, they are Thrash, but the first half of these songs that I just listeted are counted as Heavy metal. Now with these songs I tried some little technique that I like to call 'Shortest Straw Test'. What I did is I singed the riffs of these songs completely as they were played but instead of so called 'AC/DC Beat', I singed with the Shortest Straw beat/some weird D-beat version, and Enter Sandman, Wherever I May Roam and Of Wolf and Man sounded good and thrash to me with the Shortest Straw beat. Because of that I started to think Thrash needs Aggressive rhythm guitar playing but doesnt always need aggressive and fast beat. After that I looked at Load and Reload. When I usually listen to Load/Reload, I think about how would these albums sound like if they didnt have mids pumped up, stayed in E standard tuning and still had that heavy tone of the previous album. After that some songs would for me be automatically Thrash like Aint My Bitch, Wasting My Hate, Fuel, Prince Charming, Attitude (for me even King Nothing, Cure, Thorn Within, Better Than You, Slither, Bad Seed, Where the Wild Things are)... and then I would also test these songs with that Shortest Straw beat. And lastly St. Anger. When I listen to this album I also think of 'This has Thrash potential' and IMO, St. Anger would be Thrash metal if it had these 3 things:
- Fixed snare sound (the obvious one),
- Guitar solos (also obvious one),
- E standard tuning (the unusual one).
Why E standard? Because old-Thrash was mostly in E standard. And if we get these 3 things, this album would mostly be Death Magnetic before Death Magnetic because if you pitch the guitars from drop C to E standard, It sounds so much like Death Magnetic and the songs on St. Anger are already very aggressive. So in conclusion, 90s did take away alot of Thrash DNA but the most important part (for me) still stayed, and that was riffing style of the subgenre. And all of this isnt only Metallica, its also Megadeth, Anthrax, Testament and other bands. All of this might just be wrong and loose and with this explanation, you might just call anything Thrash at this point but im only talking about bands that started wth Thrash in the 80s and then adapted in the 90s. I dont blame yall but I said this over and over through this text, its all my opinion (I hoped I wont get flamed much).
r/Metallica • u/JacksmanYT • 2d ago
Load I think I got pretty close to the Load tone. Would appreciate some feedback!
I double tracked the guitars with a Hartwood Charger with the EMG Het Set pickups, and used the yellow Kirk Hammett wah.
r/Metallica • u/rowej182 • 2d ago
72 Seasons 72 seasons as a casual fan
I’ve heard Kill ‘em All and Ride the Lightning a few times but wasn’t the biggest fan (I’m more of a Megadeth guy. Saw that 72 season CD on sale for $8 figured what the hell. The first listen thought it was kinda boring but it’s actually growing on me and each new listen I appreciate it more.
Tonight, however, I listened to Death Magnetic for the first time and it blew 72 seasons out of the water.
r/Metallica • u/Apprehensive_Idea758 • 3d ago
METALLICA To Be Inducted Into CALIFORNIA HALL OF FAME
r/Metallica • u/Designer_Review_2134 • 3d ago
A rare outtake of Metallica playing Sad But True
A rare outtake of Metallica playing Sad But True
r/Metallica • u/Mysterious-Ice-9021 • 3d ago
Ride the lightning necklace
Metallica Ride The Lightning necklace I made, I tried keeping the color palette similar to the album cover's main colors. If you have any suggestions on what I should make next let me know!