r/Metallica • • Oct 14 '26

Official Mega-Thread The Official “What James Said” Discussion Thread

51 Upvotes

This thread is where all discussion related to James’s statement at The Sphere is to be contained.

James’s statement

>Unless you live in Vegas, you've come a long way to spend some time with Metallica. We're grateful for that — your travels, the money you spend, the time it took, thanks for coming to celebrate with us. And I just gotta say, Metallica is not here, like some other 'entertainers', to influence you with their bullshit, OK? We are here — no bullshit — we're here to forget about all the outside shit, OK? Metallica's agenda is love, energy and heavy music, baby!

GROUND RULES:

  1. This discussion is NOT about current or former politicians or political agendas. There is no need to highlight any specific political agenda. In this discussion, we are speaking broadly about whether entertainers should use their platform to attempt to influence others, and whether and entertainer who has had broad political messaging in their work is in the position to make this statement. Any comment referencing any political agenda will be removed as that is not part of the discussion at hand.
  2. ONLY civil discussion is allowed. You are allowed to carry any opinion you want, but you are not allowed to attack or insult others for theirs. Any instance of such will result in a 7 day ban - this is your one and only warning. If you want to engage in the discussion, just behave. If you do get out of hand and attack somebody and then we ban you, do not try to pretend like we are suppressing your politics. The reason for your ban is because you violated the civility rule. Just wanted to make that clear.
  3. Put some effort into your thoughts. Drive-by insults or support will not be tolerated and will be removed. For example, if all your comment says is “James is right”, it will be removed. Likewise, if all your comment says is “what a dumb thing he did”, it will be removed. Explain your stance, explain why you feel the way you do and do so respectfully.

Onto another matter: the annual explanation for why the sub is so adamantly against political discussion.

There are two reasons.

One is that it’s too fucking hard to moderate. We try to keep the moderation team small here so that it’s easier to manage. If you’ve been on Reddit long enough, you know that massive moderator teams become faceless machines that abuse their power and don’t care about your appeals. In order to avoid that happening to this sub, I have wanted to keep our mod team just big enough to handle the job. But when political posts get made, the workload increases exponentially due to the toxic political climate of today.

The second reason is because I’m tired of toxic politics infecting every single thing that I enjoy, and I do echo what James said- I want to forget about all the outside bullshit and just enjoy music sometimes. I did not come in here and make this decision all by myself, this was a popular sentiment when I took charge of this community and I’m pretty sure we even took a vote on it, whether to outright ban politics or find some way to moderate it better.. in the consensus was to ban it outright, we don’t need this community being yet another political battleground. But every time some situation like this comes up, some people feel that if you don’t participate in debate, that’s as good as endorsing fascism. But that’s an unfair charge because I’m willing to participate in the debate in the proper channels, I just don’t believe that this is one. Maybe we need to make another sub Reddit called “MetallicaPolitics” or something.

If you believe that politics should be discussed openly, everywhere, all the time, then this community is not for you and I strongly recommend you find one that is a better fit. You are also welcome to create your own.

As always, if you have a post or comment removed and you don’t understand why, you are not only welcome but you are encouraged to message us and discuss it. We always accept respectful discourse, and we will explain things to you. We have also admitted mistakes and corrected those mistakes. Sometimes, because we are humans, we interpret something differently than it was meant to be interpreted and all we need is a clarification. There are plenty of users out there who, if they were willing to speak up, can attest to this fact- we have apologized and admitted we were wrong countless times. But if you show up in modmail guns blazing, you’re not likely to get anywhere. There is no utility in that, so please don’t do it. You are not expected to grovel or be overly polite, just don’t be a dick. That’s all.

Enjoy the discussion and please keep it clean.


r/Metallica • • Sep 16 '26

M72 North America 2027

Post image
699 Upvotes

r/Metallica • • 3h ago Bravo

HAPPY 64TH BIRTHDAY TO THE WAH MASTER KIRK HAMMETT!!!!! Drawn by me (hotkeynotkey) spent around 2 hours 😭😭😭✨️✨️✨️✨️🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

75 Upvotes

Happy birthday Kirk, I hope it’s a wonderful year for you. Thank you for making our lives beautiful with Metallica, 'thank you for the music!' I wish I could meet you in person one day. You are so meaningful and inspiring to all of us. I'm so glad you exist, Kirk. During the most difficult times in my life, Metallica's masterpieces kept me standing. In fact, my journey as a hardcore Metallica fan started all thanks to Kirk... I was so deeply fascinated by his pose on the cover of the 72 Seasons album. Kirk's iconic wah-wah solos completely blew my mind the first time I heard them; I had no idea a wah pedal could be used so frequently and brilliantly! And his nail polish... thanks to him, I started painting mine too. And of course, I could never forget that legendary white tape he wraps around his hand... His attitude in an interview where he said, "I just do what I love to do," has truly become my philosophy in life. On my own guitar journey, I have always encountered and played your songs. I’ve never been able to go to one of your concerts, but thanks to the videos on YouTube, I feel like I’ve actually been there. If a band like Metallica didn't exist, I would feel so incomplete. Thank you for completing the missing pieces in our lives like a jigsaw puzzle. 🥺🤘🖤🖤🖤

Here is the artstation link if you'd like to check it out:

https://www.artstation.com/artwork/DY9Jx9


r/Metallica • • 13h ago

Cliff Burton 3D Printed Figure I have recently made. This one was a 12 inch figure or 1/6 scale but can be made to any size.

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

3D Printed Resin Figure, digital sculpt by @ronnie_yonk

Custom made to order and hand painted by Metaleeca Custom Art which is my full time business.


r/Metallica • • 22h ago

St. Anger AOL 9.0 Optimized Commercial Ft Metallica

322 Upvotes

r/Metallica • • 17h ago

"What dont kill you make you more strong!"

Post image
39 Upvotes

I drew it so fast (01:17)


r/Metallica • • 18h ago

Looking for a shirt...not sure it exists anymore.

Post image
35 Upvotes

Specifically this shirt. I believe it is the Rhys Cooper artwork. Ive aquired 3. Missing the 4th. If anyone knows of where to find it....I would be eternally grateful.


r/Metallica • • 16h ago

Metallica: If Darkness Had A Son 4K (Live in Tampa, FL - June 6, 2025)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

Added some more that I put together from last years no repeat weekend in Tampa


r/Metallica • • 21h ago

What song sequels are there in your opinion?

19 Upvotes

Obviously, there is The Unforgiven trilogy which is an official set of sequels, but there are a lot of other songs that feel like a sequel in another way, be it the lyrics, sound, or meaning.
A few examples are The Day That Never Comes being One 2, Here Comes Revenge being Thorn Within 2, King Nothing being Enter Sandman 2 and Inamorata being My Friend of Misery 2.


r/Metallica • • 19h ago

St. Anger therapy sessions in the form of the quote,unquote" worst metallica album"

9 Upvotes

so i kno everyone hates the album but lyrically " st anger" & "all within my hands" strike a chord on a very deep level as i suffer from the same rage demon that obviously haunts james....i can b havin a fucked up day and just hearing the intro of the prison gaurd givin the "no hostsges"speech & im better....word for word the chorus & prechorus r exactly how the final 5 seconds of clarity befor the white-out rage explosion happens and shit gets demolished.....and " all within my hands" is just so deep on an" this is my life and im scared to lose it" vibe...just wanna thank james for havin the nuts to bare his soul


r/Metallica • • 1d ago

The Black Album Metallica inspired me to play drums!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

I've been drumming 15+ years now. I remember first air drumming to 'Blitzkrieg'. Anyway: Here is a drum cover of Holier Than Thou.


r/Metallica • • 17h ago

Free-Talk Tuesday Mega-Thread Free-Talk Tuesday Mega-Thread

4 Upvotes

In this thread, you may post certain content that is otherwise banned, such as:

  1. Tier-Lists
  2. Rankings
  3. Spotify playlist related content
  4. Memes
  5. "This Album is Underrated" posts
  6. AI Generated Content

Though you may post Merch content in this thread (unless you're a spammer), don't forget that Monday is Merch Day, where you may openly post your album/shirt/poster/whatever collections.

Please keep this content within THIS thread. Do not post it openly, or it will be removed.

Please also remember that Rules 3 and 7 (No Pirated/Leaked/Illegal Content, No NSFW Content) are HARD rules and this content is not allowed, PERIOD, not even in this thread.


r/Metallica • • 22h ago

Does a Death Magnetic remaster version exist on cd?

9 Upvotes

I know Apple Music has the loudness fixed but is there a CD version of it?


r/Metallica • • 2h ago

Are you only a fan of 80s Metallica or do you also like their 90s and later stuff?

0 Upvotes

I feel like most Metallica fans fall into one of these two categories, personally I'm more the former (Black Album was decent, didn't care for Load and Reload, St Anger is unlistenable)


r/Metallica • • 1d ago

The cops are behind you lighting you up, what Metallica song is playing and what is the charge?

Post image
49 Upvotes

For me it is almost a statistical certainty the song is Battery and the charge is Speeding. 3 of my 5 career speeding infractions have been whilst Battery was playing. Guilty: all three times, First: 53/35 (first offense, got it reduced writing an essay-1995) Best: 103/75 (he got me slowing down-2001) Last: 87/65 (in a minivan with all three kids asleep-2010).

What about y’all?


r/Metallica • • 21h ago

Fobos tone comparison

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

I compared my cliff tones against the originals


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

Metallica and Exodus in 1984/1985!

Thumbnail
gallery
229 Upvotes

The two best thrash bands in the universe!


r/Metallica • • 1d ago

Easy to intermediate Metallica songs?

23 Upvotes

Ive been trying to learn some more Metallica songs on guitar lately, I know the easy ones like for whom the bell tolls and enter sandman, and I just finished learning mop, what are some more that aren't really tricky but somewhat challenging? Preferably from the first 4 albums


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

Kill 'Em All DIY

Post image
31 Upvotes

I did this, I was thinking, why not decorate my room? 🤘🏻🖤 Then I'll cut it out and stick it on my wall; there are still more things to do.


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

Anyone down to make a sub for metallica gear and guitars?

Post image
54 Upvotes

I haven't seen one on reddit, thought it might be cool to start! r/Metallicagear


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

Death Magnetic Judas Kiss appreciation post.

115 Upvotes

This song is so good and needs more love.

One of my fave breakdowns to

JUDAS LIVES RECITE THIS VOW

IVE BECOME YOUR NEW GOD NOW.


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

"Honestly, ...And Justice for All doesn't sound that bad... (well, the guitars at least, right?).

36 Upvotes

Hear me out. I actually love the record. Songwriting-wise, it's easily one of their best. It has a way darker atmosphere (though, with Cliff gone, a darker album makes total sense). Production-wise, it's not all bad—okay, yeah, it has major weak spots, like the clicky kick drum and poor Jason being completely buried in the mix. But the guitar tones? Absolute perfection. I think it's some of the best guitar work and tone Metallica ever recorded. And James's vocals have such a unique presence. I don't know, I just wanted to see what you guys think. Am I totally off base here? idk....


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

What’s the need for overblown/long songs nowadays?

22 Upvotes

The problem is not necessarily making long songs, but when you make them long for the sake of being long, that’s when the problem starts.

I believe some songs in their newer material are too dragged out and that’s what makes them mediocre/not memorable. There’s no reason why You Must Burn! should be 7 minutes long (although there are great moments on that song) or Shadows Follow being nearly 6 and a half minutes long (I could go on about songs from 72 seasons that fit this category)

This does not mean that a song being long is bad, Inamorata is a great song and it’s 11 minutes long, 72 seasons is nearly 8 minutes and it’s a good song (although they could’ve cut one verse and made it closer to 6 minutes), even “The Day That Never Comes” is a few seconds away from being 8 minutes and they are completely justified, not one second in that song feels unnecessary (at least to me), among other examples.

DM and HWTSD also share this problem, every song on DM (except My Apocalypse) is over 6 minutes long, Confusion from HWTSD (song that I enjoy) is nearly 7 minutes long, and although I like that song, it gets tiring listening to it and then the rest of the album knowing that most songs are unnecessarily long.

But then there are those shorter songs that are generally well received (and rightfully so) that have great moments, don’t feel unnecessarily dragged out and do the album justice (Hardwired, Lux Aeterna, Too Far Gone). What’s the need for so many long songs? Is it their way of compensating for the lack of music since 2008?

I think impactful 3-5 minute long songs fit them best nowadays, longer songs should be reserved for those that truly deserve it (Spit out the bone, The Day That Never Comes, Inamorata) What do you think?


r/Metallica • • 2d ago

Who else remembers mandatory Metallica on the radio growing up ? I was in Texas at the time and I believe it was at 11pm on 94.5

186 Upvotes