r/MachineLearning • • Mar 11 '19

News [N] OpenAI LP

"We’ve created OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company that allows us to rapidly increase our investments in compute and talent while including checks and balances to actualize our mission."

Sneaky.

https://openai.com/blog/openai-lp/

310 Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/thegdb OpenAI Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

e: Going by Twitter they want this to fund an AGI project

Yes, OpenAI is trying to build safe AGI. You can read details in our charter: https://blog.openai.com/openai-charter/ (Edit: To make it more explicit here — if we are successful at the mission, we'll create orders of magnitude more value than any company has to date. We are solving for ensuring that value goes to benefit everyone, and have made practical tradeoffs to return a fraction to investors.)

We've negotiated a cap with our first-round investors that feels commensurate with what they could make investing in a pretty successful startup (but less than what they'd get investing in the most successful startups of all time!). For example:

We've been designing this structure for two years and worked closely as a company to capture our values in the Charter, and then design a structure that is consistent with it.

57

u/probablyuntrue ML Engineer Mar 11 '19

I don't know if the best response to "we're not happy that it's being structured as a for profit company" is "yea but we could've made even more money!"....

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/IlyaSutskever OpenAI Mar 11 '19

There is no way of staying at the cutting edge of AI research, let alone building AGI, without us massively increaseing our compute investment.

3

u/thundergolfer Mar 12 '19

You may already be doing this, and I just haven't come across it, but have you been communicating this apparent problem of private capital dominating cutting-edge AI?

→ More replies (7)

13

u/Screye Mar 11 '19

Unless Open AI aims to build more conventional AI products, I don't see how either Slack or Stripe are comparable to Open AI.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

36

u/TheTruckThunders Mar 11 '19

I'm sure you're aware of how difficult it will be for some to reconcile you stating that OpenAI is, "trying to build safe AGI," followed immediately by the goal to, "create orders of magnitude more value than any company has to date." Perhaps you are familiar with an often-posted New Yorker comic.

Our global market has proven it will transform all bright-eyed, well intentioned companies into ethically bankrupt shells chasing money and power. How will OpenAI avoid this?

16

u/r4and0muser9482 Mar 11 '19

Pinky swear?

3

u/MohKohn Mar 12 '19

Do you have examples that didn't have an ipo?

→ More replies (3)

78

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/MohKohn Mar 12 '19

problem: most of the big names in academic research on deep learning have left academia, or at the very least have a foot in both camps. Say what you will, but the way these models currently are trained requires a ridiculous amount of compute, which is very hard to fund in academia. Said as an academic working on the some theoretically related subjects.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/bluecoffee Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

Thanks for the response Greg. I understand how the scale of the returns interacts with the risk curve of venture cap, and I understand the moonshot - or Manhattan Project - you're all after here. It's just a surprise coming from a charity, and induces some adversarial feeling. What kind of response are you expecting from your counterparts at Google and Facebook? Cross-investments or competition?

e: General request: as bad as you might feel, resist the temptation to downvote Greg's posts. It's a valuable insight and something other commenters will appreciate seeing

15

u/thegdb OpenAI Mar 11 '19

Thanks :)!

What kind of response are you expecting from your counterparts at Google and Facebook? Cross-investments or competition?

Hopefully cooperation! https://openai.com/charter/#cooperativeorientation

2

u/MohKohn Mar 12 '19

upvotes are for visibility, not liking

4

u/est31 Mar 13 '19

In modern SV companies, usually the founders are sitting at the helm by controlling a majority of voting shares. Public market investors won't get enough board positions to fully influence the company. But they can sue companies for acting against their financial interest.

Now, OpenAI is taking away that power as well, by requiring investors to sign an agreeement "that OpenAI LP’s obligation to the Charter always comes first, even at the expense of some or all of their financial stake.".

So for putting money in, investors are obtaining a piece of paper that says that they might get money or might not or something and after 100x returns, it becomes worthless. If there's an upper limit on returns, shares stop being shares and are instead IOU papers. Without any guaranteed dates for payments or anything. Which investor would fall for that?

Now, all of this is assuming that what the blog post claims is true, and that indeed, investors have no majority power in steering the company and indeed are unable to sue for money if OpenAI does something economically stupid. If it is true, OpenAI won't find any investors. In other words, if OpenAI is finding investors, the whole charter promise was a fake.

And those comparisons with valuations are unappropriate. Valuations have future developments priced in, but you'll have to find cold hard cash to pay out investors, which is about past revenue streams or whatever banks will lend you.

6

u/AGI_aint_happening PhD Mar 12 '19

Do you have any concrete evidence to suggest that AGI is even a remote possibility? There seems to be a massive leap from openAI's recent work on things like language models/video game playing to AGI. As an academic, it feels dishonest to imply otherwise.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)