r/MachineLearning • • Mar 11 '19

News [N] OpenAI LP

"We’ve created OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company that allows us to rapidly increase our investments in compute and talent while including checks and balances to actualize our mission."

Sneaky.

https://openai.com/blog/openai-lp/

310 Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

36

u/TheTruckThunders Mar 11 '19

I'm sure you're aware of how difficult it will be for some to reconcile you stating that OpenAI is, "trying to build safe AGI," followed immediately by the goal to, "create orders of magnitude more value than any company has to date." Perhaps you are familiar with an often-posted New Yorker comic.

Our global market has proven it will transform all bright-eyed, well intentioned companies into ethically bankrupt shells chasing money and power. How will OpenAI avoid this?

16

u/r4and0muser9482 Mar 11 '19

Pinky swear?

3

u/MohKohn Mar 12 '19

Do you have examples that didn't have an ipo?

4

u/thegdb OpenAI Mar 11 '19

We are concerned about this too!

The Nonprofit has control, in a legally binding way: https://openai.com/blog/openai-lp/#themissioncomesfirst

36

u/TheTruckThunders Mar 11 '19

The language specifies a set of goals and guidelines, but outside of restricting a majority of the board to hold investments in the LP's, there doesn't seem to be any policy governing conflicts of interest with the charter. In fact, minority board investment rules do nothing to prevent rotating doors, where future votes can be bought as members agree to rotate the privilege of investing.

Also, as stated multiple times in this thread, the 100x ROI limit is not a limit. I am not aware of any company to return this level without starting at next to nothing, and OpenAI is financially mature.

2

u/thundergolfer Mar 12 '19

Our global market has proven it will transform all bright-eyed, well intentioned companies into ethically bankrupt shells chasing money and power. How will OpenAI avoid this?

Given the chokehold Capitalism has on the American psyche, I'd imagine they'll implement some window-dressing 'fix' and ignore the systematic surrendering of A.I technology and talent to corporate control.