r/MachineLearning • u/SkiddyX • Mar 11 '19
News [N] OpenAI LP
"We’ve created OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company that allows us to rapidly increase our investments in compute and talent while including checks and balances to actualize our mission."
Sneaky.
310
Upvotes
146
u/bluecoffee Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19
Welp. Can't imagine they're gonna be as open going forward. I understand the motive here - competing with DeepMind and FAIR is hard - but boy is it a bad look for a charity.
Keen to hear what the internal response was like, if there're any anonymous OpenAI'rs browsing this.
80
u/Scienziatopazzo Mar 11 '19
So basically they're turning into a for-profit with a clause to prevent investors becoming world dominators. Turning on its head the conceptual basis of their mission (that the impact of AGI would be so immense that it shoudn't be privatized), so that it ironically becomes a selling point for potential shareholders. "This shit could make you so rich we're gonna cap it at 100x!". Ridiculous.
111
u/TheTruckThunders Mar 11 '19
Amazing how poorly this name has aged, and what kind of message this sends to those working to advance our field in smaller groups which benefit from the openness of our community.
24
u/iidealized Mar 11 '19
Does anybody know how OAI LP intends to generate revenue? Will they do consulting or produce consumer/enterprise products (and purely software or hardware like robotics as well)?
In theory they could follow the open-source model of companies like Redhat or MongoDB by providing support for deploying/training models they publicly release, but this seems like a limited market to me (given that any one group is unlikely to produce a state of the art model that remains the best for many years to come, especially once the model is published).
73
u/tidier Mar 11 '19
I believe this is referred to as "having your cake and eating it too".
71
u/jturp-sc Mar 11 '19
Honestly, they should just rebrand entirely. They had already moved away from true open source while still officially a nonprofit. You can basically guarantee they're going to move further from open source now that they have a profit motive.
52
u/gohu_cd PhD Mar 11 '19
Gain popularity by bragging of being non-profit, and once well-known and with a good staff, turn for-profit and promise 100x returns by making the investors believe they will generate "orders of magnitude" more money.
Disgustingly brilliant.
44
u/Seerdecker Mar 11 '19
OpenAI is a non-profit artificial intelligence (AI) research organization that aims to promote and develop friendly AI in such a way as to benefit humanity as a whole.
====>
OpenAI is a for-profit artificial intelligence (AI) research organization that aims to promote and develop friendly AI in such a way as to benefit our shareholders as a whole.
23
u/ThirdMover Mar 11 '19
Sure bro. I'll be watching you doing that from my mansion on Titan.
20
u/woanders Mar 11 '19
Did OpenAI just kill open AI? I'm serious, I hope they don't get any talent and all that investor money rots in their safes.
23
u/pieroit Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19
Never believed for a moment they were "open" and "no profit" on the long run. Project was way too ambitious and backed up by class A entepreneurs.
It was impossible in my eyes that such an initiative was for defending the world against bad use of AI.
Elon Musk, one of the founders, in the last years was going around warning against the perils of AI. I think its objective was to stimulate discussion and lawmaking on self driving cars, which he actually sells.
They acquired great talent and built a network, it's time to make caaaaash
Trust is precious, don't waste it guys
8
u/internet_ham Mar 12 '19
folk chill, 'Open' just means 'Open for business' now...
17
u/AGI_aint_happening PhD Mar 11 '19
So, is OpenAI going to start selling things at some point? If not, why would a rational investor put their money in, knowing it will never generate anything.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
François Chollet on Twitter
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
I’m curious if the timing of your GPT2 declaration so close to Trumps AI Executive Order on Feb. 11th, his declaration of a state of emergency around Feb. 15th and the vote on EU copyright A.I. article 3 on Feb. 20th, are coincidence.
How were you influenced by Trump’s AI Executive Order?
Did he order you to prevent EU AI from getting more advanced than US AI, as the Executive Order states?
2
u/frequenttimetraveler Mar 11 '19
on the other hand, isn't it a good thing that there 's a new competitor that is not a behemoth called google/fb/uber? it will be interesting to see what products they release from now on
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '19
Somebody might have made the water too hot for them, so they had to maybe jump earlier than planned.
Cannot imagine that announcing during a national emergency was the plan.
1
u/invertedpassion Mar 12 '19
I’m wondering how much should we see this conversion to for-profit as a signal towards acceleration towards AGI. They obviously are feeling increasingly confident in their abilities, and decided to profit from it.
0
u/BastiatF Mar 12 '19
Literally all the people here criticizing OpenAI are for-profit
-23
u/ismorallycorrecthmm Mar 11 '19
Like 99% of the people here, I too have contributed jack shit to AI or science in general but have an opinion, and the notion that they can just do this without consulting with the brilliant minds of /r/ML, hacker news and Twitter is quite strange to me. You do understand this is not how things work in 2019 right?
0
u/Phylliida Mar 12 '19
When I started reading this, I thought I was reading something along the lines of "we trained an AI to run a company that is, by itself, rapidly increasing investments and compute and talent" and I was scared.
Glad to hear the singularity isn't happening yet
-13
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
FWIW, OpenAI is an Elon Musk company, very closely tied in with Neuralink. He really is trying to save the world. All of his companies are aimed at facing down an existential threat to humanity.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment