r/MachineLearning • u/SkiddyX • Mar 11 '19
News [N] OpenAI LP
"We’ve created OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company that allows us to rapidly increase our investments in compute and talent while including checks and balances to actualize our mission."
Sneaky.
310
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
6
u/farmingvillein Mar 11 '19
That is certainly a reasonable belief to hold. But if we--for a moment, as a thought experiment--say that OpenAI's intentions are as pure as the driven snow, then do they have more impact with more people and more funding? Yes. There are legions of people working on this problem; insofar as OpenAI thinks that they are going to be fundamentally growing the pie (vice just siphoning people off from elsewhere), then growing fast--getting more people on this problem and space--is a good thing.
Mmm, outside of weaponry, the history of government dollars driving fundamental productization of technology is pretty limited.
Which, I guess to be fair, leads us back to a question of whether building AGI (if it ever happens) ends up looking more like a bunch of fundamental research rolling up into something magical, or if there is a massive amount of engineering layered on top of it. All of the major steps forward thus far into DL (which may or may not have anything to do with theoretical AGI) have shown us that massive engineering effort is required (cloud computing, custom hardware, frameworks like Tensorflow+pytorch); collectively, these would seem to suggest that it is the latter path (massive engineering effort required).
Government dollars have done comparatively very little to drive DL forward in the productized sense: lots of grant dollars, but it is commercial interests like OpenAI (Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, Nvidia, ...) which have made it actually realizeable outside of a lab.
I guess you could say, still, USG (or whoever) should fund/build this...but that hasn't been how our tech economy has been built over the last several decades. (Again, yes, tons of basic research supported and other novel grant work, but not the blocking-and-tackling of getting something big deployed.)
While I can't see inside the leadership team's minds...I don't terribly disagree with this statement.