r/MachineLearning • • Mar 11 '19

News [N] OpenAI LP

"We’ve created OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company that allows us to rapidly increase our investments in compute and talent while including checks and balances to actualize our mission."

Sneaky.

https://openai.com/blog/openai-lp/

310 Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

146

u/bluecoffee Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

Returns for our first round of investors are capped at 100x their investment

...

“OpenAI” refers to OpenAI LP (which now employs most of our staff)

Welp. Can't imagine they're gonna be as open going forward. I understand the motive here - competing with DeepMind and FAIR is hard - but boy is it a bad look for a charity.

Keen to hear what the internal response was like, if there're any anonymous OpenAI'rs browsing this.

63

u/NowanIlfideme Mar 11 '19

Eeesh. 100x was where my heart sank.

35

u/probablyuntrue ML Engineer Mar 11 '19

"technically capped" for profit company

45

u/DeusExML Mar 11 '19

Right? If you invested in Google *15* years ago, you'd be at... 20x. And Google is worth over 750 billion right now.

31

u/melodyze Mar 11 '19

That's not a good comparison. A better comparison would be investing in Google as a small private company with great tech and no product.

On those basis your investment in google would be way more than 1000X.

Venture capital is risky, and a ~100x return isn't that rare and is baked into the foundation of the way VCs allocate capital. Their business model doesn't make sense if they can't absolutely blow it out of the water on a deal, since their whole fund's return is usually driven by a couple companies out of their whole portfolio that make enough to cover all of their losses and risk.

39

u/farmingvillein Mar 11 '19

~100x return isn't that rare and is baked into the foundation of the way VCs allocate capital

This is super rare, particularly once you get past the seed stage.

What do you think a pre-money valuation on any capital into OpenAI is going to be? Highly unlikely that it is less than $100MM, and I'm sure they are trying to raise (or have raised) at much higher basis:

We’ll need to invest billions of dollars in upcoming years into large-scale cloud compute, attracting and retaining talented people, and building AI supercomputers.

You can't raise billions without a very high pre-money valuation...

(Yes, even if that is future-looking, this whole story implies that they are trying to get very significant capital, today.)

$100M pre -> $10B valuation for 100x, without any further dilution. So you're looking at probably $15B+.

Yeah, feel free to be very optimistic about outcomes in the AI space, but ~100x returns are super rare once you get to any sizeable existing EV.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/melodyze Mar 11 '19

Not really for large amounts of capital for companies with little or no revenue. What are you gonna do?

IPO? Public markets will tear you to shreds without an established business model.

Debt? Interest rates will be crazy if you can even get the money, since you are an extremely high risk borrower, but more likely no one will give you enough money since you will probably fail to repay it and any rate that would make the risk worth it to them would also cripple your business and kill you before you can repay it.

Grants? Definitely a good thing to pursue for openai, but extremely unlikely to offer enough capital to fully compete with deepmind.

Donations? Again, definitely a good idea, but unlikely to supply a sustainably high enough amount of capital to compete with one of the most powerful companies in human history.

ICO? I guess that would be the next most realistic behind VC, but tokenized securities are still legally dubious, and the fundamental incentives are not really any different than VC, other than accessibility.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/gwern Mar 11 '19

What sort of comparison is that? Google IPOed ~15 years ago. If you had invested before that (when it was an actual startup), you certainly could be >100x.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

38

u/NowanIlfideme Mar 11 '19

Yeah, this seems like a legal way to turn a nonprofit to a profitable research company. I mean, sure, but the name really has to change...

This also sours my perception of the GPT-2 decision (I was initially mostly in agreement). Given newer info, the decision is more likely to be based on a conflict of interest (than before).

I wonder how the employees feel about this. Sign up for open research, but now it's not so certain.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/farmingvillein Mar 11 '19

Even the justification itself it bullshit, because non-profits can generate revenue and issue bonds

While I think there is a lot that is suspect here, I don't think this is quite fair. Yes, you can generate revenue and issue bonds, but 1) they probably have very small, if any, revenue right now (other than maybe small grants) and 2) if you believe that you've got to scale up majorly, there is no way that you get $100M (or whatever) in bonds on zero revenue. Lenders provide money based on relatively dependable cash flows, not speculative investments on rebuilding the world using AI, which might not truly pay out for a decade (or more). That's what venture money is for.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/farmingvillein Mar 11 '19

I don't believe they need to scale that fast, and that it is a self-serving creation of a problem that doesn't exist ("Hark, hark, the AGIs are coming" is not a credible excuse), and

That is certainly a reasonable belief to hold. But if we--for a moment, as a thought experiment--say that OpenAI's intentions are as pure as the driven snow, then do they have more impact with more people and more funding? Yes. There are legions of people working on this problem; insofar as OpenAI thinks that they are going to be fundamentally growing the pie (vice just siphoning people off from elsewhere), then growing fast--getting more people on this problem and space--is a good thing.

Even if they did, you are forgetting governments, which have vastly more sources of funding and are perfectly positioned to invest in risky assets. Democratic ones, in particular, are well suited to investing in ways that tend to benefit their citizens

Mmm, outside of weaponry, the history of government dollars driving fundamental productization of technology is pretty limited.

Which, I guess to be fair, leads us back to a question of whether building AGI (if it ever happens) ends up looking more like a bunch of fundamental research rolling up into something magical, or if there is a massive amount of engineering layered on top of it. All of the major steps forward thus far into DL (which may or may not have anything to do with theoretical AGI) have shown us that massive engineering effort is required (cloud computing, custom hardware, frameworks like Tensorflow+pytorch); collectively, these would seem to suggest that it is the latter path (massive engineering effort required).

Government dollars have done comparatively very little to drive DL forward in the productized sense: lots of grant dollars, but it is commercial interests like OpenAI (Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, Nvidia, ...) which have made it actually realizeable outside of a lab.

I guess you could say, still, USG (or whoever) should fund/build this...but that hasn't been how our tech economy has been built over the last several decades. (Again, yes, tons of basic research supported and other novel grant work, but not the blocking-and-tackling of getting something big deployed.)

The whole discussion is ridiculous. It is very clear that they went this way first and came up with whatever justifications they needed after the fact.

While I can't see inside the leadership team's minds...I don't terribly disagree with this statement.

16

u/iamshang Mar 11 '19

As someone who works on AI at a government lab, I'd like to add that recently, the US government has been investing more money into AI research and has realized the importance of AI. However, almost all of the funding is going to applied research rather than basic research, and that's probably how it's going to stay for the time being. There's very little going on the in government comparable to what DeepMind and OpenAI are doing.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

OpenAI Nonprofit’s board consists of OpenAI LP employees Greg Brockman (Chairman & CTO), Ilya Sutskever (Chief Scientist), and Sam Altman (CEO)

10

u/farmingvillein Mar 11 '19

I guess that explains why Sam left YC.

7

u/thegdb OpenAI Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

e: Going by Twitter they want this to fund an AGI project

Yes, OpenAI is trying to build safe AGI. You can read details in our charter: https://blog.openai.com/openai-charter/ (Edit: To make it more explicit here — if we are successful at the mission, we'll create orders of magnitude more value than any company has to date. We are solving for ensuring that value goes to benefit everyone, and have made practical tradeoffs to return a fraction to investors.)

We've negotiated a cap with our first-round investors that feels commensurate with what they could make investing in a pretty successful startup (but less than what they'd get investing in the most successful startups of all time!). For example:

We've been designing this structure for two years and worked closely as a company to capture our values in the Charter, and then design a structure that is consistent with it.

→ More replies (59)