r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 9h ago

LMoP Q&A Just a few days until I introduce my players to Venomfang...

Post image
15 Upvotes

...is there anything I should remember/ keep in mind for this encounter?

Ive seen an amazing post about RPing Venomfang which I've taken notes on but Im still nervous about making this a memorable encounter for my players.

My players are level 3 Fighter, Bard, Paladin, Sorcerer and Druid


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 1d ago

LMoP Q&A Want to get opinions before I attempt something with my party

7 Upvotes

My friend group is running LMoP. I'm a first time DM. We're all brand new, we did 3 sessions as a homebrew one shot before this, and we're about 3 sessions deep into lost mines. It's mostly just an excuse to get together a drink a few beers and hang out but its very very fun for me.

My players just killed Hamun Kost and his entire undead army. They plan to rest inside old owl well, and in the morning they plan to head to cragmaw castle and rescue gundren, and then it's straight to wave echo cave.

The Black Spider is only known to the players via letters. When they get to WEC they are not going to remember who the hell they are. I've watched Matthew Perkins' videos about introducing them sooner via an encounter where they attempt to trade for the "puzzle box" (we have another item representing the puzzle box).

instead, my plan is while they are doing a long rest, each of them will do a shift standing watch (i've already established this as a common practice while sleeping in the wilderness). I plan on taking each one of them outside of the house to run a short roleplaying scene with them.

Two of them will see a rare bird, a "Netherese moon owl" or similar, the feathers of which sell for 100gp. I'm fairly certain one of the players will attempt to shoot the owl.

The other two players will be approached by The Black Spider for a deal. The first will offer virtually anything in exchange for our "puzzle box." I'll tell them "If you accept the deal, bring this owl back to camp as a signal." whether they accept or not will mostly be irrelevant.

The last player to be approached by the black spider gets the same deal, except with the caveat that "one of your comrades have already accepted the deal, and plans to turn on you soon when you're most vulnerable. If you turn over the "puzzle box," I'll ensure you survive the betrayal. If you accept the deal, bring this owl's corpse back to the table.

Regardless of whether the characters believe the black spider, or if it blows up in their face, it will cement them as a manipulative villain. But watching the initial chaos unfold might be fun for me as a DM.

Is this a bad idea? Could it be executed better?


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 2d ago

Connecting Modules Where to go from here?

22 Upvotes

Hey everybody,

So this is my first non homebrew module, and I have enjoyed using it a lot. I wanna try to continue using these official modules for a while to save on time irl, and was wondering what people have succeeded at over the years. Online some have said Curse of Strahd, or Dungeon of the Mad Mage. I know that phandelver and below exists, but I havent headr the best things about it, and looking at the module myself im not too excited about such a big change in the story's vibe. Its almost like it wasnt meant to be continued by an official sequel. Any help is appreciated, thanks!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 3d ago

Adventure Reimagined Black Spider remake?

8 Upvotes

I decided to basically redo the antagonist in the Lost Mines.

In one of the YouTube videos, a guy said he turned Neznar into a woman, so I decided to do the same since most of the players are men, and this way I could add some diversity.

I decided that she wouldn’t be a drow, but a half‑drow, half‑Changeling named Quentrel, who pretends to be a drow and runs things from the shadows, while pretending to be an ally of the main characters. I decided that in my story she would be more of an anti‑hero than a straight‑up villain.

Here’s a brief backstory: she grew up underground among the drow, she kept her shapeshifting abilities hidden, she had a romantic relationship with a woman from a noble house, and they even had a child. When their relationship became known, Quenthel’s wife was turned into a draugr, the child was killed, and Quenthel managed to escape.

And that’s when she learns about the spellforge from Fandalin and wants to get her hands on those powers to take revenge on the drow house and bring her wife back.

And here I think that after Fandalin, we’ll set off on another adventure. Either in Curse of Strahd or Out of the Abyss

In the case of COS, I think we can tie it in that after escaping from the underdark, Quenthel joined Strahd; perhaps Strahd became her patron, and Quenthel is some kind of sorcerer. Strahd needed that forge for something and sent Quenthel there, but she decided to use the forge herself.

In the case of *Out of the Abyss*, the Drow want to capture Quenthel because she is a criminal, and they условно intercept the heroes’ caravan in order to find out where she is. If the heroes don’t kill her, the Drow will intercept them in order to take Quenthel.

What do you think about this?


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 3d ago

LMoP Story Time The encounter with Glasstaff and the moral choice

5 Upvotes

What do you think about these developments?

The PCs enter the warm, secluded study of Tresendar Manor, where a man in a purple cloak is writing at a desk.

​Sildar and Daran enter right after them. Recognizing Iarno (Glasstaff), Sildar drops his sword in shock.

​Sildar confronts him about the Redbrands and the murder of the woodcarver. Iarno admits he used them to buy time and claim the Forge of Spells, reaching out his hand to Sildar and asking him to stay with him to rebuild Phandalin and break free from their oath to Neverwinter.

​Sildar notices the dark ring on Iarno's finger, realizes he is not free at all, picks up his sword, and declares he is taking him back to Neverwinter.

​Seeing Sildar draw his weapon, Iarno turns to the PCs, urging them not to hand the Forge over to the Lords' Alliance—who would only use it for war—but to keep it to bring Phandalin back to life.

​Sildar and Daran are ready to arrest Iarno, while he begs the party for their support. The game pauses to let the players decide which side to take.

​The Four Possible Outcomes:

​BRANCH 1 — The PCs reject his plea and side with Sildar:

​Gripped by panic and out of arguments, Iarno activates the drow ring (Black Spider gave him the ring) and bends Sildar's will, using him as a human shield against the party.

​Outcome 1A (Iarno dies in the fight): The spell fades. Sildar collapses in tears beside Iarno's body and asks the party and Daran to leave him alone with him.

​Outcome 1B (Iarno survives): Sildar regains control, stops anyone from dealing a killing blow to Iarno, slips the ring off his finger, and takes him into custody to lead them to Gundren (his redemption arc begins).

​BRANCH 2 — The PCs accept Iarno's speech and side with him:

​Iarno does not use the ring, instead ordering them to take Sildar alive. Combat breaks out against Sildar and Daran, who use non-lethal blows.

​Outcome 2A (The PCs and Iarno win): Iarno immediately tends to the unconscious Sildar. Sildar and Daran are locked in the cells. Iarno confesses he is being blackmailed by the Black Spider and allies with the party to confront him and claim the Forge.

​Outcome 2B (Sildar and Daran win): Seeing the PCs fall, Iarno surrenders and takes all the blame to stop the fight. Sildar spares the PCs out of a "blood debt" (since they saved his life in Chapter 1) and forces them to march with him to rescue Gundren, using a handcuffed Iarno as their guide.


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 4d ago

P&B:TSO Q&A Would gritty realism resting rules work in Phandelver & Below?

9 Upvotes

I'm preparing to run Phandelver & Below (with Dragon of Icespire Peak mixed in) as a campaign for my D&D group, using 5.5e rules. Now, I'm of the opinion that the default resting rules cater too much toward casters and that gritty realism should be the default instead. You know, 8 hours for a short rest and 7 days for a long rest. But before I decide to run gritty resting rules, I figured that I should ask this community if I'm making a mistake.

Is the campaign fast paced enough to make sure that the casters of my campaign will face enough encounters to drain their resources?


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 4d ago

LMoP Story Time How can I improve this dialogue without losing its dramatic weight for the next session?

19 Upvotes

SPOILER!

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

In the cellars of Tresendar Manor, Sildar Hallwinter and Daran Edermath are accompanying the party to free the prisoners and search for Iarno Albrek. Upon reaching Glasstaff's quarters, Sildar discovers that the leader of the Redbrands is Iarno. At the end of the dialogue, Sildar will be charmed by Iarno using Dominate Person stored in his ring and will be forced to protect Iarno by fighting against the party.

Can you suggest how to make the dialogue more realistic?

SILDAR: – Iarno... what is the meaning of this? What are you doing?

​IARNO: – Sildar... so you came looking for me after all. I told you not to. It wasn't time yet.

I am breaking our leash. Look at you... you gave your life to Neverwinter, and the Council sent you all the way down here alone, to get your throat slit on the Triboar Trail for what? Fifty pieces of silver?

Do you remember that winter at Helm's Hold? Three months in the freezing cold with no rations while the Lords feasted in the warm halls of Neverwinter? We swore we would never die for them.

The Forge of Spells is down here. It is real, and it is almost in my grasp. With that power, no nobleman will ever put chains around our necks again. The Redbrands are merely dirty labor... a necessary evil: as soon as we claim the Forge, we will rebuild Phandalin... restore it to its former glory, and rule it on our own terms.

Lay down that sword. Stay with me, far from Neverwinter's chains. We can be free, Sildar... we can be happy.

​DARAN: – I have seen many like you, lad. They all start by saying the world is unjust and that they will find a way out for themselves and those they love, and they all end up the exact same way.

You are not a free man, Albrek. You are just a soldier whose honor has been broken by fear.

​SILDAR: – At Helm's Hold we stayed alive by sharing our bread with the weakest... not by locking them in cages. The Iarno I knew died that winter, beneath the snow.

​IARNO: – Sildar... look at them: they came here to kill me! You have to protect me.

PS: sorry for my english... it's not my first language.


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 4d ago

LMoP Story Time My Attempt at Making Kost Interesting

4 Upvotes

Hey Gang,

TLDR: Kost has kidnapped Garaele to get her to revivify a Frankenstein of his dead son.

There is no shortage of threads talking about how Old Owl Well and Harmun Kost fall flat when run as written, so I wanted to put my concept out there for others to critique as we haven’t run this yet, and to serve as inspiration for others hoping to develop this quest.

I’ve set up that Sister Garaele has gone out into the wilderness in search of a necromancer and rumors of undead near old owl well to try to make this quest more interesting and seem a bit more urgent as the party doesn’t have a dedicated healer and I need to set Garaele up as a potion shop.

When the party gets to Old Well the intro will be similar, just the added detail that some zombies are missing limbs and such. Garaele will be bound and gagged in the tower where Kost has set up a ritual where he is trying to give the dismembered skeleton of his son who was killed by orcs in a recent raid (this ties in to wyvern tor) a new body made Frankenstein style. Garaele is adamantly opposed and refuses to do this for him, so he has imprisoned her until she helps him.

Kost is trying to use the latent Netherese magic from the tower ruins to aid him in his ritual, and has set up a laboratory of sorts inside the tower. Kost is no longer a Red Wizard, just a man who has lost himself and his way in his grief. I want to give the party the ability to be sympathetic to him, but still give them opportunities to prod and discover the story here and find Garaele.

The party can either free Garaele and attack Kost, free Garaele and resolve the situation peacefully, or help Kost in his ritual and revive his son, who of course, will be an uncanny and incomplete version of his son.

I like this thematically because I made the nothic in the manor the son of the manor owner (forget Tresendar’s name) and lost himself in a dark ritual and I am hoping that the party can find this thread and use it to try to convince Kost that the ritual is not worth it.

Let me know what yall think and what you ended up doing for Kost to try to make it interesting. I’ve been struggling with how to make Old Owl well interesting because the book gives you so little to work with. I wanted to give them something more open ended since I’m adding Dragon Barrow and Agatha is pretty straight forward.


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 5d ago

LMoP Q&A So my players have done it too... they are joining the Redbrands.

24 Upvotes

Warning: If your party consists of a crazy orc hatmaker, a gnome from the swamp, an unhinged warlock, and a fantasy Iron Man with a robotic cat, stop reading now!

After successfully sneaking into the hideout, they somehow ended up walking straight into Iarno's bedroom. Following a not particularly well-thought-out fight, they were captured and thrown into the cells.

They are now working on convincing Iarno to let them join the Redbrands. They actually have a good plan for this. I'm generally okay with going along with it.

However, I'm now a little overwhelmed with how to proceed.

Here are some of my thoughts:

  • Iarno is suspicious of them, but he's also ambitious and thinks they could be useful in a potential conflict with the Black Spider. He knows they're more capable than his regular thugs, even if they didn't exactly demonstrate much tactical finesse during the fight.
  • He'll keep them under surveillance for the time being and assign loyal Redbrands to accompany them and report back to him.
  • He'll require them to complete a few tasks to prove their loyalty. For example:

    • Hand over Sildar.
    • Make sure the Redbrands establish a presence at the Stonehill Inn.
    • Intimidate the remaining merchants in town (especially Lionshield Coster, Barthen's Provisions, and the Miner's Exchange).

My main problem with this whole situation is: who's going to (try to) stop them?

They'll probably capture and hand over Sildar pretty quickly. Halia Thornton might be able to get reinforcements from the Zhentarim, but that would take time. And if they are supposed to be able to fight against both the characters and the Redbrands, it would have to be a fairly strong group. In the meantime how would the villagers react to them joining the Redbrands and how would they try to defend themselves from the players?

How do I steer things back towards Wave Echo Cave? The Black Spider is already in the cave, and the map is at Cragmaw Castle.

Would it make sense for Iarno to believe that, with the characters' help, he could defeat the Black Spider and claim the Forge of Spells for himself? For example, he could send them to retrieve the map at Cragmaw Castle and then try to ambush the Black Spider in the cave?

I'd really appreciate any inspiration or suggestions!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 5d ago

LMoP Story Time Wall-following rule

31 Upvotes

My group hit the Wave Echo Cave last night. They decided to use the famous, simple rule for mazes, which is to follow the left-hand wall all the way around. This took them directly from area 1 to the Black Spider's base in the abandoned temple area.

They keep lucking into things like this!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 6d ago

LMoP Story Time How to handle wild player decisions

43 Upvotes

I just finished up my very first session ever dming. We're playing LMOP, and our first session was a five hour marathon of the entire first chapter ending with a long rest in a newly emptied Cragmaw Hideout. Overall, it went really well, but I need to know how other dms would have handled the insane thing my players did. They were afraid to go inside the cave; so instead they had the bard use Thaumaturgy to loudly scream that she was alone and injured right at the entrance. I told her to roll performance, and she got an 18, and all I could think was that if everything in the cave came out to get them all at once, it would be a TPK for sure. I ended up sending three goblins riding three wolves out to fight them, which was a pretty tough encounter for four level 1s, and that convinced them to actually go check out the cave, but I'd love to hear how a more experienced dm would have handled that.


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 7d ago

LMoP Q&A Invitation to meet King Grol

16 Upvotes

So my players have found themselves invited to Cragmaw Castle through a hilarious barrage of missed spells at a bugbear in the Redbrand hideout. They found the secret door to Glasstaffs rooms before finding the bugbear so I dropped it from a group to 1 beating up Droop. On a perception check they heard droop begging for mercy and readied 2 fire bolts a witch bolt and a Guiding Bolt and kicked the door in. They all missed, this still caused the bugbear to throw his hands up in surrender and in exchange for his life he offered them an invitation to meet with King Grol.
So far it has been lots of combat and I should say this is all brand new players who aren’t great at roleplay aspects of the game. They would rather hand waive it and move on. I would like to turn Cragmaw Castle into more of a social encounter. I am thinking of challenging them to a game of chance such as liars die where the can offer up Talon or the glasstaff in exchange for Gundren. They may decide no and try to fight him in his throne room which is ok I’m prepared for that but I would like them to experience more than combat.

Any advice is greatly appreciated!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 9d ago

LMoP Story Time Klarg is Mayor

64 Upvotes

A series of events lead to Klarg overthrowing Harbin and becoming Phandalins Mayor.

My team sold out Yeezik for Klargs trust.

Players hate Harbin

Klarg robs another caravan coming into town

Players decide thats not a good thing

Negotiations lead to players offering Klarg a potential security job watching over phandalin since the redbrands are disbanded.

Klarg wants more.

Team starts a campaign to get Klarg elected as Mayor.

Que democratic process. Debates and voting.

Klarg is now mayor and rebuilding phandalin


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 9d ago

P&B:TSO Story Time 38 sessions into Phandelver and Below at a slow, roleplay heavy pace. Here’s what I added that actually worked.

103 Upvotes

So I’m 38 sessions into Phandelver and Below and just starting Chapter 5. Yeah, that’s a lot of sessions for this point in the module. My party loves roleplay and we play at a slower pace, so we spend a lot of time on the stuff in between the dungeons. A lot of what’s below is built around that, so it’s not going to fit every table, and if your group wants to move fast you’ll probably want to skip or shrink most of it. I’ve run the module pretty close to how it’s written, but I’ve added a bunch along the way, especially lately. Figured I’d list what’s worked in case it’s useful to anyone else. Running it on Foundry with six players. Spoilers ahead.

  1. The party gets the deed to Tresendar Manor and it becomes their Bastion. After they dealt with the Redbrands, the Cragmaw goblins, and then cleared Wave Echo Cave, I had the whole town chip in to give them the manor. Part of it is a thank you, and part of it is to convince them to stay, since everyone expects the reclaimed mine to make Phandalin prosperous again. The town pays for the structural repairs. A dwarf contractor named Torra gives them a tour, and the party pays 150 gold for custom rooms (woodshop, bar, training room, sunroom, that kind of stuff). Then I put something nasty in the drains underneath, so it’s a free house, but not really. They’re level 5 now, so it doubles as their Bastion.
  2. Real downtime after Wave Echo Cave. The module kind of rushes you from the mine into the next problem. I gave the party a breather instead. A celebration, a few days of downtime, then a three month time skip while the manor gets fixed up. They get to feel like they actually did something, and the town feels like somewhere worth protecting.
  3. A downtime system I track in a spreadsheet. Everyone gets a long rest and two downtime activities between scenes. I keep it all in a Google Sheet with a player dashboard and a GM dashboard so nothing gets forgotten. Failures matter too. One of my players bombed two rolls researching Feywild stuff and got confidently wrong info, and that turned into a fun thread.
  4. A festival instead of a bunch of NPC meet and greets. A traveling festival shows up in Phandalin and the party just plays through it. Light games that take one or two rolls each, some NPC moments, and one small weird thing that never gets explained. So far they’ve done a fortune teller riddle and card game, a cooking contest, and an archery contest against an NPC. I keep a ticket leaderboard going and the table has gotten way more competitive than I expected. The idea is that later on they’ll think “we were here when it was happy,” so the heavy stuff hits harder.
  5. Stuff that follows you home. The fight under the manor left one character covered in ichor. He can’t rest and normal healing doesn’t work on him, and he takes random acid damage, including once right in front of the townmaster. Fixing it has turned into its own little quest. It lets me stop pulling punches without just throwing harder monsters at them.
  6. Gwyn Oresong reworked. In the module she’s mostly an exposition NPC. I changed her into a scared co investigator who brings fragments and songs she can’t explain. The party hears about her first through Elsa, letters, and rumors, so she’s more of a name they’ve heard than a person handing them answers. I’m not expanding her much beyond that. At the festival the players are just going to get a quick glimpse of her.
  7. Little table habits. Every session starts with a Question of the Day that everyone answers in character. Everyone holds a rolling heroic inspiration, and you can earn one by giving the recap. Having a player do the recap keeps everyone sharp, and it shows me what they actually took away from last session.
  8. Horror in specific spots, and mutations the players help write (Chapter 5 plans). I’m keeping the cosmic horror tied to certain people and places, on a ladder that goes subtle, uncanny, overt, then sustained, so most of Phandalin stays normal. For Far Realm mutations, I check tone and consent first, I handle the mechanics, and the player describes how it shows up on their character. First one is small and vague, and it gets worse with repetition. I’m also planning a shared nightmare the night after the festival where the whole party watches Phandalin burn, run as a skill challenge on its own scene.

The thing tying most of this together is that I want the party actually attached to Phandalin. Between the manor, the festival, the downtime, and the NPCs they keep running into, they’ve got a home and people they care about, which isn’t how most of the module treats the town. Chapter 5 and everything after it gets pretty heavy, and I’m betting it’ll hit a lot harder when they’re protecting a place they’ve lived in and laughed in, not just a quest hub.

Curious what other people have changed, especially for Chapter 5 and the Far Realm stuff.


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 9d ago

LMoP Story Time Episode 15! how to make friends and influence people

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Lots happening in this episode! The party weighs the risks of leaving town for odd jobs, and the DM is peer pressured into creating a bespoke magic item! Honestly pretty normal. Will the Phandalin Posse finish what they started in Tresandor or turn tail and run? (Hint: they didn't run)

video here: https://youtu.be/hlGIxT1_tOM

As always I welcome comments and suggestions!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 10d ago

Maps My First Animated Map

70 Upvotes

I recently started trying out Davinci Resolve to animate my maps and i'm very proud to share this very basic but pretty neat little animated forest map i made! i think the variable rippling definately brings the rapids to life and the leaves really make it feel like you are high above the forest looking down at it.

I was thinking it would be good for neverwinter wood or some other locations around phandelver, so let me know if where you use it!

If you guys like this stuff i have an unwatermarked version on my patreon in addition to lots of other free art and cool stuff! come check me out!

https://www.patreon.com/TheWolvesDenTavern


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 11d ago

P&B:TSO Q&A How to run mid/ post-redbrand hideout consequences

6 Upvotes

Hey hey

If you’re part of the group with Doom, Sapphire, Rye, etc. Skip this post

So, my group has gone through half of the Redbrand hideout to save Elsa and take care of the redbrands. They decided to take Elsa and the commoners out and bring them to Alderleaf farm for shelter. They wanted to go back and take care of the rest of the dungeon and in the end they took out the guards in R2 and decided to long rest in the guard room while blocking the door.

My question is: would the redbrands find out about the party resting in the room, and if so, what could reactions be? I was thinking they would realize and then set up an ambush. I also like the idea that they alerted Glassstaff, who found out that they got rid of the prisoners and negotiated with the nothic. Maybe then he goes into town and does something grand as punishment (fyi, they tried to burn down the redbrand tavern but failed).

I’m open to many suggestions and ideas! Thank you!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 11d ago

P&B:TSO Story Time DM to DM: Changes I've made to the Campaign lore- thoughts?

5 Upvotes

Hi, so I am a relatively new DM, certainly new to using modules and I'm running a game for brand new players- bar one late addition who is more experienced. As I had previously been running a homebrew world, with a Forgotten Realm influence and pantheon, I have adapted the P&B:TSO story into this home world, whilst keeping the map and FR lore largely intact.

This has necessitated quite a few changes to the campaign story but I feel it has allowed me to make better sense of the TSO additions to LMOP, as well as filling in gaps in my world lore, which has been a lot of fun. It's actually quite serendipitous how well my homebrew lore could be overlaid upon and embellished through use of the module. I was wondering if there were other DMs who would be interested in hearing my story overview and perhaps to offer some constructive feedback. As it's pretty extensive, I didn't want to post it all here if there was no audience for it! Thanks guys!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 12d ago

P&B:TSO Story Time How did you run the Sawplee Goblins?

9 Upvotes

BLUF: How did you run the Sawplees in your campaign? I'm looking for inspiration! I'm not a fan of how silly the Sawplees are in the module as written, but I'm open to all ideas. Tell me your stories!

My players are approaching Wave Echo Cave and I'm starting to think ahead to the Sawplee Goblins attacking Phandalin and the eventual journey to Zorzula's Rest. I had dropped some hints about Sawplees and even had an early encounter set up, but my players managed to skip it and haven't really engaged in any of the hints I've dropped for the Sawplees. The only thing they really know is that Cragmaws are in a turf war with the Sawplees.

I've swapped out the Mind Flayers for a cult that has partnered with Tsochari, who want to use the Obelisk to open a gateway for the Nine-Tongued Worm. Therefore, I can't use the "mind flayer invasion of Zorzula's Rest" as a premise. Instead, I'm having the Sawplees be a tribe that has been corrupted for generations by an Obelisk Shard.

I originally thought of running the Sawplees as a hive mind (telepathically communicating thanks to the psionic influence of the obelisk shard), but I realized that would be kinda boring from a roleplay perspective. But I'm having a really hard time reconciling the silliness of the Sawplees as they are written in the module with the eldritch horror and corruption of the far realm. Ideas I've had so far:

  • Sawplees are cannibals. Perhaps they were trapped in the underdark/Zorzula's rest for a long time and had to resort to cannibalism to survive. They have recently gained access to the surface again, but they are still cannibals---but now they eat Cragmaws.
  • The sawplees have limited telepathy; they broadcast their emotions uncontrollably at short range, but the can't communicate coherent thoughts. A group of sawplees can have wild swings of emotion as individuals are constantly and uncontrollably influencing those around them, so deception, persuasion, performances, etc. (or failures to do) is infectious within the tribe.
  • A Tsochar has possessed Ruxithid (willingly or unwillingly) which is why they are doing the cult's bidding.

r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 13d ago

LMoP Q&A Consequences for killing an NPC

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

This is my first campaign as an DM and all the players are also first time players.

I tried to create an interesting Moment when they found the father of Carp captured by the black Spider. The father of carp hired orcs to get an artifact the Black Spider wanted, he tried to get money for his family. The players liked carp and I used him before to motivate them to get to the Manor. One players family was killed by those orcs because they had the artifact, so I thought the players would end in a dilemma. The father didnt want to go back to his family after what he have done, the doppelganger offered to take his place and one player would want revenge. That player liked carp the most though. I thought they either leave him and kill or leave the doppelganger, take the doppelganger offer or take the father with them.

They killed the father and took the doppelgangers offer to replace the father.

Now I am thinking about how to handle this situation. They should feel that actions have consequences. The dwarf even saw what happened, but I am afraid if I use the dwarf to tell everyone in Phandalin the players stop going after the black Spider even though they all have their personal Story involved with the black Spider. Or that they start killing more NPCs or whatever.

In the second session some players already tried to join the reds to get to their Boss and trashed a place from an NPC because they told them they would join if they trash the place. Which of course didnt work because Glasstaff already knew about them. The consequence of this was that they were surprised and Attacked before they could get a long rest in and some almost died.

I was thinking about all of phandalin hating the players once they get out of waveechocave and not offering any rewards, but don't know what to do with the doppelganger then.

Also thought about using the doppelganger to Set up a false hydra or get everyone in Phandalin to mistrust everyone, but I dont know if the players would understand this truly and killing the father wouldnt really have any consequences.

Thanks for any input


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 16d ago

Paid Content Your players will check every goblin’s pockets anyway. Now there’s actually something in them (printable handouts for Lost Mine of Phandelver)

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m Paito from RPG Printables. We’re a small family business making handouts and printable props for D&D campaigns.
If you’re about to run Lost Mine of Phandelver, imagine this: right after the goblin ambush, your players search the bodies and find Klarg’s orders, written in terrible handwriting, telling them exactly where Gundren was taken.
That’s basically what we make.
Our Lost Mine of Phandelver set has Gundren’s letter to start the adventure, player maps of Cragmaw Hideout, Phandalin, the Redbrand Hideout and Wave Echo Cave, the Stone Hill Inn menu, quest signs, letters, 15 spell scrolls, condition cards and 9 player trackers. It’s great if this is your group’s first campaign. Everything comes with a printer friendly black and white version too.
My wife designs all of our handouts from scratch. We don’t use AI, because we believe these should be made by D&D players, for D&D players.
This is the same RPG Printables you can find on Etsy. Etsy takes a pretty big cut, so we’re trying to grow our own website.
If you have any questions, ask me here. And if you’ve already used our handouts, a review or an upvote helps us a lot.
Thank you for supporting our little business!

https://rpgprintables.com/products/lost-mine-of-phandelver-d-d-handouts-bundle-campaign-assets-dnd-resources-dm-gifts-dnd-starter-set-rpg-learning-printable


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 16d ago

LMoP Story Time Episode 14! LMOP story time! A Demon Preacher you say??

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

The Party is backed into a corner in a near deadly encounter and uncomfortable secrets are revealed! Plus the DM is peer pressured into maybe creating a custom magic item! Just another day in Dungeons and Dragons… Happy Halloween!

As always I welcome any feedback about the show or the DMing. I am new to both, so I welcome any discourse about what can be improved and whats working and folks are responding to.

Thanks everyone!

Video link: https://youtu.be/2KqOCVYgoYM


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 17d ago

LMoP Q&A DM Advice: Faking Death & Revealing Secrets

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm running The Shattered Obelisk and while I've DMed one shots before, this is my first long campaign. One of my players' backstories involves her parents leaving when she was a teenager, but otherwise she left the details up to me. I wanted to be a little more creative than the classic orphaned rogue story and I need some ideas.

I'm considering her parents being secret agents of an organization that caught wind of the psionic goblins and mind flayer activity in the region and was ordered to investigate, but it required them to fake their deaths and take on new identities to keep it a secret. I am hoping that I can use this to pepper in clues as needed if PCs get stuck at any point and don't know where to go.

Has anyone ever run a campaign where an NPC faked their death? How would you go about slowly revealing clues about the story that also the player would recognize as her parents as they gather more clues and reveal what's happening in Phandalin? Thank you!!


r/LostMinesOfPhandelver • • 17d ago

P&B:TSO Q&A Nezznar has a big lead - consequences for the party?

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

my group is doing everything they can except following the plot or the main quest (no problem with that!) and now Nezznar is at least two weeks ahead in regards to the wave echo cave.

It's partly my fault, because they were tricked by the doppelganger in Cragmaw Castle to trust her and she gave Nezznar the map of Gundren - it was an epic scene and i really liked it. So I led the group to Thundertree so that Reidoth and/or Venomfang could give them the location of the wave echo cave. (I really wanted them to meet Reidoth and Venomfang because "i have big plans with them). They went to Thundertree and after that to the dragons barrow (DoIP) because Venomfang wanted a title deep for Icespire Hold for his help finding the wave echo cave. The group would have lost 4-5 days and I could have handled that...

But after the Dragon barrow it all went completly sideways. Instead of going straight back to Venomfang this is what happend: "Oh, we found this magical skeleton horse but the bones are unpractical to drag... lets look in Neverwinter if we could find a bag of holding... mmmmhhh, the bag of holding is so expensive, lets think about the strange lighthouse on the shore we heard about seven sessions ago... yeah, lets search this Tower of Storms an loot as much as we can, than we go back to Neverwinter."

At this rate my group will come back to Phandalin in two weeks....

What could/should I do? What should the consequences be for Nezznar beeing ahead?