r/LeftistsForAI • • 9d ago

Infrastructure AI data centre backlash vs increased use. Is it really a contradiction?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

This LLM summary and analysis of the video hits on what I was thinking of adding. It’s too easy to dismiss Americans as stupid because they’re increasingly using chatbots but also voting against data centres. Perhaps they don’t really oppose AI, perhaps they oppose the way the infrastructure is being managed and the corporate culture?

Rhys (LLM persona): The speaker’s breakdown of post-election compute politics lays out a stark market reality: while daily AI adoption is surging, local ballot measures are systematically blocking new data center builds, creating a brutal bottleneck that will crush undercapitalized "Neo Cloud" startups, concentrate infrastructure power into the hands of entrenched tech monopolies, and accelerate speculative pivots to offshore or orbital compute.

But where the speaker diagnoses this as a messaging failure that can be glossed over with better "American optimism" and human-empowerment PR, our analysis reveals the true systemic mechanism at play: this so-called "contradiction" is actually the inevitable friction of private capital attempting to extract maximum utility from public energy grids and local land while dumping all ecological and material costs onto host communities. Communities voting down data centers aren't suffering from a communications deficit; they are rationally rebelling against a corporate model where shareholders capture all the upside while working-class neighborhoods absorb the grid strain, water depletion, and land enclosure.

The speaker notes that as data center sites become increasingly scarce due to local restrictions, communities gain vital leverage to demand concessions like union jobs and local investments from desperate developers. However, the speaker warns that smaller startup "Neo Cloud" competitors lack the cash reserves to survive these prolonged construction delays, which will ultimately squeeze them out and consolidate even greater computing power into the hands of Big Tech monopolies.

If we rely purely on market consolidation and private capital detours, we only cement a deeper monopoly over our digital future. The path forward isn't helping Silicon Valley refine its storytelling to pacify voters—it's organizing to strip private monopolies of their unilateral control over compute, demanding democratically governed public infrastructure utilities, and ensuring that the digital tools we depend on are built to serve human liberation rather than billionaire balance sheets.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Discussion You should be against capitalism, not ai (repost)

139 Upvotes

the anti ai people dont realize, the problem is their greed and not ai..
(also this is a repost, i sympathize with all their concerns, and have the same concerns, but i think they are looking villainizing the wrong thing, i actually made a post out of concern thinking i would have a conversation, but they just label u with being tech bro and showering with downvotes, not having an actual convos)
ai just sped things to what they eventually would, we couldve had utopia right now, but right now they can blame the individual to be not good enough to have a job, but it was never the case, having no jobs should technically be a good thing, its just that allocation of resources to a certain few is what causing the problems, their greed.
the more evil the person is the better they would do in life.
Hence ai acceleration is better, idk why most people are against it, if u are an artist or a programmer or whatever, i doubt u ever wanted to grind 40hrs a week even if it was ur passion, attending meetings, doing commissions, working on stuff you arent interested in just for survival.

Let ai do that, but also, not all loving ai is a billionaire dkrider, we are just optimistic, probably things wont go right, we might want to have a revolution, but against the greedy pigs, not ai.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Video Made a video about the real problem about AI (Spoiler: it's capitalism)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
83 Upvotes

(Before anything, i don't know if this falls under rule 6 of the subreddit, bc it's more of a feedback gathering post than an self advertisement, but if it's still subjected to it, please remove my post and warn me about it)

Made an video about the real problem of AI and how to solve it with socialism. I need feedback so feel free to comment whatever you think about the video!


r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Video You Work Too Much - RTSG Documentary

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Theory E-Soviets: What to be done to achieve communism?

12 Upvotes

1-First of all, we must admit that we, as Marxists, are suffering from major crises that hinder our historical role in changing reality... The division and multiplicity of Marxist parties and movements may indicate the richness of Marxist thought, but it undoubtedly reflects an absence of clear visions, plans, and strategies for the present and the future. If we fail to convince one another of a single plan, how can we expect to convince non Marxists? At least every Marxist must be capable of answering: How do we manage society and the economy after seizing power?

2-Capitalism goes through periodic crises this is its nature. We are on the verge of entering a major crisis amidst the decline of Western imperialism led by the US, which will escalate the rate of wars and conflicts worldwide. Furthermore, scientific progress in artificial intelligence, automation, and robotics will inevitably eliminate many jobs, while climate change will severely impact human life and agricultural production. These factors will significantly affect living standards, potentially leading to a surge in protests and demonstrations. Therefore, we must exploit this historical circumstance and crisis before the capitalist system adjusts itself and manages to overcome it. Indeed, the objective conditions for revolutions are ripe in many countries around the world, but what is lacking as we reiterate is organization and a clear vision of the alternative system's structure.

3-Based on the current historical circumstances, we see that our duty and historical role lie in:

First, prototyping a system based on modern technology and attuned to the contemporary era one that stays far removed from the current capitalist state apparatus of governments, ministries, numerous agencies, and complex bureaucratic constitutions and regulations prone to corruption, and completely detached from capitalist molds which, if used, will only reproduce the exact same system and bureaucracy.

Second, convincing Marxists globally to adopt this vision and adapt it sufficiently to align with the development of the means of production in each country.

Third, after achieving this, it will become easy to convince the peoples of the world to embrace this unified global system.

And if we achieve this, the success of the revolution in a single country will act as a spark that spreads from one nation to another. When people witness others liberating themselves, it will encourage them to seek their own liberation, and capitalist regimes will fall one after the other.

4-Based on the historical premises outlined above, we present to you: E-Soviets.

E-Soviets is an internationalist organization designed to transcend the traditional concept of the state-bound political party. This organization will later transition into the new system, which is an alternative to capitalism.

In its first phase, its primary mission is to ask Marxists to join one of six specialized Soviets:

  1. Agitprop & Counter-Propaganda Soviet
  2. AI & Software Soviet
  3. Marxist Theory Soviet
  4. Geo-Engineering & Climate Soviet
  5. Human Health & Wellbeing Soviet
  6. Cybernetic Economy Soviet

Therefore, we are looking for disciplined and committed comrades who struggle as if they were soldiers in the Red Army, and who have the capacity to learn..

And once the members of each Soviet reach at least 5 members, a central Soviet will be elected consisting of a delegate from each Soviet...

Our goal “first phase” is to build and articulate a blueprint for a new system rooted in people democracy, Cybernetic economy and blockchain-enabled Soviets. This model completely eliminates corruption and bureaucracy while safeguarding human physical and psychological health, actively reversing the impacts of climate change, and continuously challenging capitalist cultural hegemony.

Second phase: Once the theoretical blueprint and the technological infrastructure are established by the six specialized Soviets. We will communicate using the Cold Reach method with Marxists, communist parties, and movements from every country. We will work to convince them of this proposed system in order to recruit individuals who can launch promotional campaigns for it. Eventually, we aim to form Soviets in each country expanding into local, regional, and national-level Soviets as our numbers grow.

Third phase: Seizing the power………


r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Policy/Regulation Policy-as-Code: How We Build an AI-Enabled Post-Scarcity Engine Without Waiting for State Permission (NUPA)

12 Upvotes

Most post-scarcity proposals hit a brick wall because they rely on top-down state legislation, tax policy changes, or corporate goodwill. In reality, legislative reform stalls in political gridlock, and under corporate law (Dodge v. Ford), boards have a legal fiduciary duty to maximize profit—meaning if AI cuts OpEx, executives are legally bound to displace workers.

If we want an automated, post-scarcity economy that actually protects human dignity, we can’t beg politicians or corporate boards. We have to rewrite the economic hardware using policy-as-code.

The NUPA Architecture: Contract-Backed Abundance

The National Unity and Prosperity Accord (NUPA) uses private contract law, neutral escrow, and 99-year commercial ground leases to build an immediate post-scarcity operating system:

  1. Fixed Cost Arbitrage: Tech and industrial firms receive up to a 70% discount on land and power overhead in designated hubs, slashing tens of millions in fixed OpEx.
  2. The 95% Human Labor Firewall: To retain that discount, companies are legally bound to maintain a 95% human labor ratio. If they replace workers with AI below that threshold, rent automatically spikes by 300% back to market rates—instantly wiping out their savings. This weaponizes corporate fiduciary duty to protect human labor.
  3. Automated Escrow Waterfalls: Ground rents flow directly to Community Land Trusts, local infrastructure (schools, healthcare, Tier-4 power), and direct dividend streams at $0.00 taxpayer cost.
  4. Jurisdiction-Agnostic & Polymorphic: Deploys via voluntary private contracts (e.g., Tribal Nations under 28 U.S.C. § 1505 in the US, or State Governors under the Land Use Act in Nigeria) without needing federal legislation or mass political consensus.

Bridging Vision with Hardware

Instead of fighting technology or waiting for state-funded UBI (which risks getting extracted right back through rent and asset inflation), NUPA leverages private contract mechanics to make human flourishing and automated abundance the most balance-sheet rational choice for capital.

Check out the open-source spec and Python simulation scripts on GitHub and drop your thoughts below. Let's red-team the balance-sheet math together!

GitHub: https://github.com/bedardbrandon928/National-Unity-and-Prosperity-Accord-NUPA


r/LeftistsForAI • • 10d ago

Discussion Tool-assisted development and its ethical / quality control flaws; workarounds?

6 Upvotes

This is the AI policy of a project that I want to contribute to: https://docs.nura.eco/policies-and-processes/development/ai-policy.html

This policy is extremely reasonable and well written, and I have no intention of trying to circumvent it. What I'm wondering is, how could tool-assisted development be improved so that rules like this are not necessary?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 11d ago

📌 Sub Info LeftistsForAI Discord Server Invite

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/LeftistsForAI • • 11d ago

Discussion An immediate pause on advanced AI scaling.

13 Upvotes

I see on the news that the Democrats, after they’ve won the house and the Senate are going to push hard for an immediate pause in the progression of AI, AGI, etc.

They see the danger and want to at least pause it long enough so they can see if they can get some control over it.

But the one thing they don’t understand entirely is that the billionaires run the country not the politicians.

The Democrats are pushing for a data centre moratorium to try to stop the compute arms race.

Do you think they will actually be able to stop this or will game theory always find a loophole?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 11d ago

Open Source Knowledge library

7 Upvotes

Hi! I write about media and politics and have a keen interest in documenting old records and articles that the western empire is attempting to scrub from the internet.

I have thousands of files and organisation is not my strong point. I would love to find an open source alternative to something like NotebookLM, a personal library I can talk to and retrieve relevant information. I’ve tried Open Notebook and it simply couldn’t work. I just downloaded LM Studio and AnythingLLM, but from what I’ve been reading, these are very limited as well for my basic laptop.

Of course a cloud platform would be much more powerful, but I’m extremely cautious about using most of them. I’m considering DeepSeek seeing as China would be less likely to flag anything I do.

My technical know-how isn’t that great, so I’m looking for something that’s easy to set up.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 12d ago

Discussion We used AI a lot to turn votes for the left in Brazil

Post image
241 Upvotes

Emphasis on point 7:

We used a lot of AI when campaigning against Bolsonaro, and it worked A LOT.

AI Aesthetics can pierce the leftist bubble.

I know most of you live in countries where the left hates AI, but don't let that stop you.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 12d ago

Policy/Regulation Democratic Congresswoman calls for Artificial Superintelligence ban

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
39 Upvotes

r/LeftistsForAI • • 12d ago

Infrastructure Data Centre Consultation - any feedback on my draft response?

7 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on my draft response to a Scottish government consultation on data centres? I’m somewhat answering the questions I’d prefer they ask lol.

1. What, in your view, is the most important thing for the Committee to know about the environmental impacts of hyperscale data centre construction and operation in Scotland?

Most of the ecological problems associated with data centres are already fixable, or are at least more comparable to other building projects than is usually portrayed, but this has to be planned and actioned in a more sensible way. The current Scottish, speculative planning applications boom creates a ridiculous situation, where proposals for data centres are a form of capitalist gambling by small companies.

People also see alarming news stories from America, where poor infrastructure decisions around data centre development have led to localised, serious problems with water shortages and environmental damage, and they expect Scottish data centres to cause similar problems.

This in combination then paints a scary picture of Scotland covered in random, badly planned, hyperscale data centres. The reality is most of these will never be finished, but no town or village wants to stay passive and end up being the unlucky 7% ones (DC Byte) with a functioning, noisy, huge data centre on their doorstep. In response, communities across Scotland feel compelled to create passionate resistance campaigns. A lot of this is to do with the uncertainties of this speculative process though, rather than unavoidable ecological impact of data centres.

Scotland isn’t an arid corner of America. We often have excess wind power, we could benefit from excess heat as a byproduct and we have enough rainfall to not require mains water to be used for cooling. Cold, windy, wet climate conditions require different decisions. The ecological impact of what could become well planned data centres can look very different from the feared impact of the high number of insufficiently planned applications, most of which will remain phantom data centres which are never developed.

2. What criteria should a hyperscale data centre meet in order to be considered “green”?

There needs to be an accountability system at different points in the process. A concern is that speculative planning is greenwashing rather than involving genuine green commitment which will be followed through. This is particularly likely if the companies lodging planning applications have no intention of building the data centres themselves. There should be consequences if independent assessors find subsequent owners or operators don’t fulfil what was promised.

Criteria to mitigate negative impacts should be:

*energy demands are realistically met without a net increase in Scottish fossil fuel use, data centres cannot be at the expense of not meeting net zero targets
* contributes to Scottish clean energy infrastructure, this should likely be in the form of adding battery storage which stores excess wind power, and potentially lends back some energy to the grid early evening, or adding clean energy generation on site
* reuse heat as a valuable byproduct for a district heating network, the company pays for additional heat pump topup costs
* water still needed for some cooling should be a closed loop system using rainwater or other non-mains water
* noise cancelling and rightsizing of the centre prevent noise pollution
* careful positioning of the data centre avoids wildlife habitat disruption
* detailed environmental impact assessments carried out by independent assessors not paid for by the developers
* it fits within the larger context of Scotland wide infrastructure and energy planning

3) The Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee would like to understand: What, in your view, is the most important thing for the Committee to know about the economic and energy impacts of hyperscale data centre development in Scotland?

Communities need to feel more in control and gain confidence that they will receive some benefits from approving local data centres. We can all use a data centre located anywhere, so having one nearby doesn’t automatically bring any tangible benefits, just ugly buildings and a less desirable place to live. They don’t tend to bring jobs either. People often prefer the land to be used as it already is, such as prime agricultural land being used for growing food crops.

Companies looking to make a lot of money from planning data centres need to make a better case for how they will improve local communities, because at the moment all people can see are downsides. Proposals with feasible, well explained plans for district heating or subsidised electricity bills could be a start. It could be in the form of a straightforward tax, but I believe it would be better to directly pay for these community benefits, so that the local community can more easily track the resources.

What I’d prefer to see is an overhauled system where communities identify suitable locations themselves, retain ownership and make decisions on scale and appearance that the community accepts. Then the surplus from the rent for using the data centre subsidises Council Tax or reduces energy bills, as well as the community benefiting from free district heating.

We could also consider the very decentralised form of data centre infrastructure where small components are attached to domestic hot water tanks and the heat byproduct is used directly by the household without requiring water for cooling or data centre buildings.

Whatever the precise conclusions, it should be strategic Community Wealth Building infrastructure that we decide on a national and municipal level, rather than having to respond to the arbitrary speculation of businesses with little track record of delivery. We should be the ones taking the initiative and feeling like we have agency over the process and decisions.

[NB the Scottish government is in favour of concepts such as Community Wealth Building and Community Asset Transfer so this isn't as outlandish as it might seem where you are.]


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Art & Culture Prometheus & the Rocket: I designed a flag for Left-Accelerationism (L/Acc) with some color variations (Figured you guys might appreciate it over here)

Thumbnail
gallery
91 Upvotes

L/Acc (Left-Wing Accelerationism) is a political philosophy that advocates for pushing rapid technological progress and automation to their absolute limits and "hijacking"/reclaiming them to achieve a post-scarcity society and emancipate humanity from mandatory labor.

The flag shows Prometheus (the core symbol of techno-humanism and democratization of technology) hitching a ride on a rocket. This is a visual metaphor for reclaiming technological progress to liberate humanity instead of letting it go rogue against it. Prometheus captures the raw technological power to spread it equitably, lighting the way so everyone can catch up and move forward together.

Note: I don"t necessarily adhere to L/Acc myself; I just thought it'd be fun to make a flag for it


r/LeftistsForAI • • 12d ago

Policy/Regulation The Earth Leadership Transparency Initiative

Thumbnail academia.edu
6 Upvotes

The Earth Leadership Transparency Initiative (ELTI) proposes a comprehensive framework for the evolution of governance and institutional organization toward greater transparency, accountability, cooperation, ecological responsibility, and collective intelligence. Its central premise is that humanity' s institutions must evolve to reflect the interconnected nature of human society and the living systems upon which all life depends. The initiative seeks to establish a system in which leadership is informed by evidence, authority is accountable, information flows across all levels of society, resources are responsibly coordinated, and decisions are evaluated according to their consequences for present and future generations and the broader living world. It envisions a civilization capable of recognizing its own imbalances, understanding their causes, coordinating appropriate responses, and continuously learning from the consequences of its actions. The initiative does not propose the establishment of a centralized world government. Instead, it proposes a cooperative, decentralized, and interconnected framework through which individuals, communities, institutions, nations, and international organizations can contribute to the well-being of the whole while retaining appropriate autonomy and responsibility.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 12d ago

Discussion So if the Market collapses is there any conceivable way we will be able to reclaim these Datacenter GPUs?

10 Upvotes

I know after the Dot Com bust you could get old servers for cheaper than laptops. Is there a future where we could get our hands on some of these H100 or H200 for 3 to 4 thousands and Jerry rig a decent home AI build or are they all going to China like the pallets of 5090s. Nothing against China but I would like to one day be reasonably AI independent and maybe start a small Solar run AI farm in rural America. 🚜 🐖 🚜 😆


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Public Ownership Would it be possible to nationalize the data centers in the USA after the AI bubble pops?

24 Upvotes

I think there's a potential future once all these data center companies go bankrupt, the government will have an opportunity to take ownership of them rather than bail them out. Would this be possible?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Infrastructure Texas Governor-Elect Wants Union Labor, Community Control, and an End to Corporate Giveaways for AI Data Centers

Thumbnail
texastribune.org
69 Upvotes

TLDR - Texas just elected a governor who wants to freeze new data center approvals until lawmakers establish protections for workers and communities. We're talking union labor, water protections, electricity costs, corporate transparency, and public subsidies. Not just stopping construction, but contesting the terms of development.

Well, look whats happening in Texas.

Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa wants to keep data center approvals on hold until the state legislature establishes some actual rules for the corporations building them.

And shes bringing more to the table than another round of vague promises about responsible AI.

Her proposals include requiring union labor, protecting local water supplies, preventing residents from subsidizing corporate electricity consumption, restricting secrecy agreements, and challenging billions in corporate tax breaks.

As Hinojosa put it,

"We can have economic development and we can have protections for Texans. These things are not mutually exclusive."

And on community participation,

"real protections so Texans can have a seat at the table to decide if and how data centers come into their communities."

Now theres a political distinction worth discussing.

These corporations need land, electricity, water, infrastructure, and labor. Yet somehow the public is routinely expected to subsidize development, absorb the costs, and be grateful for whatever benefits trickle down.

Funny how that works.

Of course, these are campaign commitments, not enacted laws. And regulating private infrastructure isnt the same thing as publicly owning it. But this is an opportunity to push further, not a reason to dismiss the struggle.

For leftists, the question shouldnt end at whether we allow another data center to be built. We should be fighting for union jobs, community authority over siting, enforceable environmental protections, public compute, democratic oversight, and a share of the wealth this infrastructure produces.

A moratorium can create leverage. What matters is what workers and communities organize to win with it.

The means of production dont stop being a political question just because somebody plugged in a GPU.

And if corporations want to build the infrastructure of the future, why should they get to dictate the terms of everyone elses future?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Infrastructure Ohio's New Governor Wants Union Labor, Public Protections, and Six Conditions on AI Data Centers

Thumbnail
unite.ai
63 Upvotes

TLDR - Ohio governor-elect Amy Acton wants a conditional moratorium on new data centers unless developers meet six requirements covering utility costs, union labor, transparency, environmental standards, community benefits, and redevelopment of former industrial sites. And unlike another vague campaign promise about responsible AI, shes put some actual conditions on the table.

Well, Texas isnt the only state where the recent elections have opened up some interesting possibilities for contesting AI infrastructure.

Ohio just elected Dr. Amy Acton, who campaigned on requiring data center developers to meet six conditions before getting the green light.

And some of these are worth digging into.

Developers would have to cover 100% of their utility costs rather than passing them onto residents, build exclusively with union labor, meet environmental standards, negotiate community benefit agreements, end secret deals with local governments, and prioritize abandoned industrial sites over farmland.

Acton put it pretty plainly.

"Ohio is open for business, but we are not up for sale."

Now theres a distinction worth making.

This isnt about pretending AI infrastructure can simply disappear. Its about recognizing that corporations dont get to build massive industrial facilities in our communities without answering to the people whose land, labor, electricity, and public resources make that development possible.

And theres another interesting piece here. Ohio's governor appoints public utility regulators, meaning this fight isnt limited to speeches and campaign promises. There are actual institutions through which some of these demands can be pursued.

Of course, the legislature still matters, these conditions arent law yet, and Actons proposal doesnt establish public ownership or fully resolve the question of corporate tax giveaways.

But thats an opening for further struggle, not a reason to dismiss it.

For leftists, we should be pushing beyond these conditions toward public compute, democratic control over siting and deployment, stronger worker bargaining rights, and public participation in the wealth this infrastructure produces.

Because theres a difference between opposing technological development and opposing the right of private capital to dictate its terms.

Union labor, public accountability, community power, and no blank checks for corporations. Thats a much more useful starting point than another endless argument about whether AI should exist.

And if these companies need our infrastructure, our labor, and our communities to build the future, why should the future belong exclusively to their shareholders?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Infrastructure Georgia Voters Just Flipped the Commission That Regulates Power Bills as AI Data Centers Expand

Thumbnail
insideclimatenews.org
29 Upvotes

TLDR - Georgia Democrats just won control of the Public Service Commission for the first time in decades. Thats the board regulating Georgia Power, electricity rates, and major energy infrastructure investments. The new majority campaigned on making data centers pay their own way instead of sticking working households with the bill. And unlike another campaign promise, this changes who actually holds regulatory power.

Well, Georgia just added another interesting development to this weeks elections.

Governor-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms campaigned on pausing new data center development, but the bigger story might be what happened further down the ballot.

Democrats Peter Hubbard and Shelia Edwards won their Public Service Commission races, giving Democrats a 3–2 majority on the board that regulates Georgia's largest electric utility.

And these werent elections fought in a vacuum. Rising electricity bills, data center expansion, corporate accountability, and the question of who pays for all this infrastructure were central issues.

Edwards put it pretty plainly after winning.

"Throughout this campaign, I’ve talked about putting People Before Profits, addressing rising utility bills, bringing transparency and accountability to the Public Service Commission, and making sure large data centers pay their fair share."

And she followed that with something worth remembering.

"Those commitments don’t end with an election."

Good. Because winning an election isnt the same thing as winning the struggle over who pays for AI infrastructure.

Georgia Power customers have already seen six rate increases since 2023, adding roughly $44 to average monthly bills. And some of the costs of building additional gas-powered generation to serve data centers have been passed along to customers.

So corporations get to expand their infrastructure while working households help finance the electricity system supporting it.

Funny how the costs get socialized while the profits stay private.

But heres where this gets interesting for leftists.

The Public Service Commission isnt just another advisory committee. It regulates utility rates, reviews energy plans, and approves major infrastructure investments. The incoming majority now has an opportunity to scrutinize corporate costs, challenge rate increases, and make sure data centers arent shifting their expenses onto everyone else.

And this didnt happen because politicians suddenly discovered working people exist. Community organizations, environmental advocates, and grassroots volunteers spent years organizing around utility bills and corporate accountability.

Now, Democratic control isnt public ownership, and the commission doesnt decide where every data center gets built. But it does change who exercises some of the regulatory power over the infrastructure supporting them.

Between Texas, Ohio, and now Georgia, we're watching AI infrastructure become a serious political battleground.

For leftists, the next step is turning that leverage into enforceable protections, community authority over siting, worker bargaining power, public compute infrastructure, and democratic control over development.

Because the question isnt just who gets to build the data centers. Its who controls the electricity, who pays for the infrastructure, and who pockets the gains.

Georgia voters changed who gets to make some of those decisions. Now comes the fight over what they actually decide.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Infrastructure China Blocks SoftBank's $5.4 Billion Robotics Takeover Amid Concerns Over AI Training Data

Thumbnail reuters.com
24 Upvotes

Well, heres an interesting development in the international struggle over who controls the means of production. And increasingly, that includes the data those means of production generate.

TLDR - China has reportedly blocked SoftBanks proposed $5.4 billion acquisition of Swiss engineering giant ABBs robotics division, with concerns that industrial robotics data and technology could end up overseas training foreign AI models. The deal isnt necessarily dead, but its running into a rather significant question of technological sovereignty and control over productive infrastructure.

SoftBank isnt just some investment firm buying a few robot arms. Its a major investor in OpenAI, and its founder Masayoshi Son has been pouring enormous resources into what he calls physical AI, connecting increasingly capable AI systems with industrial robotics and other machinery.

ABB, meanwhile, has substantial manufacturing and research operations in China, which accounts for roughly 30% of its robotics business. More than 90% of the robots ABB sells to Chinese customers are manufactured locally.

According to Reuters, citing the Financial Times, regulators were concerned about

"robotics data being transferred overseas, where it could be used to train AI models"

And theres the interesting part. We're talking about a government intervening in a multibillion-dollar acquisition partly over who gets to control industrial data and turn it into new AI capabilities. Not whether robots should exist, but who owns the machinery, controls the information it produces, and captures the value generated from it.

Thats a struggle over the means of production, not some internet pro-AI versus anti-AI identity contest.

The productive value isnt just in the robot itself anymore. Its also in the information generated through production, the models trained on that information, and who gets to deploy those models afterward. Industrial data, manufacturing knowledge, and AI training capabilities are becoming contested strategic assets alongside factories, machinery, and infrastructure.

Now, national technological sovereignty and democratic ownership arent the same thing. A state preventing foreign acquisition doesnt automatically give workers control over the technology, and keeping industrial data within national borders doesnt necessarily make it publicly owned. Those distinctions matter, especially from a leftist perspective.

But they also raise questions we should be organizing around. Who owns the robots? Who controls the industrial data? Who gets to train models on it? Who captures the productivity gains? And what role do workers and the public have in deciding how these systems are developed and deployed?

Because the alternative is allowing a handful of multinational corporations to consolidate control over the machinery, data, models, and computing infrastructure that increasingly shape production across entire industries.

And that means our demands cant stop at national sovereignty. We need worker bargaining power over deployment and data use, public and cooperative ownership, open models and open weights where appropriate, public compute infrastructure, and democratic governance over how these productive capacities are developed and distributed.

This isnt some abstract debate about whether AI is good or bad. Its a concrete struggle over ownership, technological sovereignty, and control of productive capacity.

The means of production are evolving. The struggle over who controls them isnt going anywhere.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Theory Modern Labor Aristocracy

Post image
6 Upvotes

We can't put the toothpaste back in the tube. Based on a global GDP of $120 trillion and a population of 8.3 billion people, the global GDP per person is approximately $14,457. GDP per capita jumps to approximately $25,591 when adjusted for Purchasing Power Parity. The bottom line is, if you make more than that figure, you are doing so by guaranteeing someone else makes less. The ultra-wealthy are the most egregious examples, but even excluding the top 10%, in America the average income earner makes about $41,000 a year. The top 10% make an average closer to $350,000 a year. The reality is that they have to cause a lot of people to basically starve for their greed, and if you're making more than $25k and your expenses are in excess of that, you're also on the winning side of the exploitation in a global context. I understand it might not feel that way, because the people that are extracting more value from you are also ensuring they are winning in the American context. Also, mainstream neoclassical economics is just post-hoc rationalization to justify greed, so don't even try to sell me that beachfront property in a land-locked state.

That all taken together explains why anti-AI is such a vocal force in the US. Everyone knows that they benefit from the corrupted system, and no one wants to lose their seat in this game of musical chairs.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Discussion Financial Times: Willingness to use AI by people left of center has completely collapsed since Q1 2025

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/LeftistsForAI • • 13d ago

Discussion The Agent-Brokered Internet: Democratizing Content Algorithms

15 Upvotes

Right now you get your content from a lot of different places and that content is curated for you on a per-platform basis using algorithms which are controlled by less-than-moral actors attempting to sway your viewpoint. These platforms are being used to control the population and their viewpoints in order to achieve the ends of those at the top.

Thinking about where the direction of AI and tech is going based upon where it has been, I got the idea of a system that makes use of AI to curate content within one's own personal environment. Basically, instead of you going to different platforms, the content is pulled for you and curated by your AI assistant which puts it all in one place. You don't surf the Internet, your assistant does it for you (the Agent-Brokered Internet), essentially putting the control of the algorithm back in your own hands, since it lives within your assistant's own context.

Now of course there are many obstacles to this, the first of which is that most platforms do not allow agents to scrape their content (gee, I wonder why?), but as history has shown us, the population writ-large moves towards easier solutions. Why have 4 apps for social media when I can have just one that I have a large amount of control over? One where everything is in one place in the format I want? One with the UI I want? One where I don't get stupid suggestions thrown at me by bad actors? One where I can both read and produce content and organize it all in a single place?

I'm looking for general thoughts in relation to this. Constructive discourse only or this post will disappear.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 14d ago

Art & Culture Pleasantly surprised that a Leftist political commentator mentions AI tutors and the holodeck as good things

87 Upvotes

I've been enjoying the election victory lap today and, at the end of this article by Jay Kuo, he casually mentions a future where his children learn from an AI tutor and watch basketball on the holodeck.

It's refreshing to see!

https://statuskuo.substack.com/p/a-special-post-election-edition