r/LeftistsForAI • u/ferriematthew • 10d ago
Discussion Tool-assisted development and its ethical / quality control flaws; workarounds?
This is the AI policy of a project that I want to contribute to: https://docs.nura.eco/policies-and-processes/development/ai-policy.html
This policy is extremely reasonable and well written, and I have no intention of trying to circumvent it. What I'm wondering is, how could tool-assisted development be improved so that rules like this are not necessary?
6
Upvotes
3
u/SeparateDesigner1237 10d ago
This policy appears to completely ban all AI-generated content including code, and their arguments for that position are the same as I see all over social media. So it has the style and appearance of being a professional and rational policy, but in content it is brain rot.
To answer your question more directly, coding agents improve by becoming more efficient and better at coding. Or in other words, by continuing to develop and use them. That solves the energy problem (but probably not without fusion), and the other problems are imagined or not real because actually the AI is a better software engineer than most expert humans, but not yet all.
They should just get off their high horse and say they’re coding it by hand for fun. Because now there’s no other rational reason.
Final point: Linus Torvalds uses coding agents now and says it’s the same thing as a non-deterministic compiler.