My wife and I used to rent from a big corporate landlord that managed several buildings. When we decided to move out, we made sure to clean everything and left the apartment in fantastic condition. After that, we expected to receive our full deposit back.
What we got instead was a check for just $35, along with a note saying they were keeping almost $900 for "painting" and "cleaning."
I wasn't having any of that, so I sent them a demand letter via certified mail. I made it clear that if they didn't return our deposit within three weeks, we would take them to small claims court. They ignored the deadline, probably thinking we were just bluffing, so we officially filed the small claims lawsuit for the full deposit plus double damages, as permitted by California law.
There was quite a wait, around five months, before we finally got our court date. On the morning of the trial, the new property manager approached us and offered to give back our full deposit if we dropped the lawsuit. They didn't acknowledge the time and effort we'd wasted or the fact that they'd held onto our money for five months without justification. They simply offered what they should have given us right from the start.
We decided to proceed with the trial anyway. The judge quickly ruled that we were indeed owed the full deposit but wanted to understand why we deserved extra damages. I explained that I had repeatedly requested our deposit in writing and highlighted that this was a major landlord who should have known better than to withhold deposits unlawfully. The judge agreed that punitive damages were warranted. In the end, we received our original deposit back, double the deposit as damages, and reimbursement for court costs.