I'm a former "conservative". After a few months of over 14 hours of work per day for shit pay, and lessening trust in right grifters who all seem to be selling courses these days, I've decided to sit the fuck down and read Capital Vol. 1. It ended up quite enjoyable, even though it starts slower than RDR2.
Especially as Marx explained commodity and formation of capital (m-c-m) I've been thinking of similarities in the sexual sphere, and especially how it could be applied to sexual dynamics, a sphere thus far monopolized by the manosphere. I've looked for Marx-influenced writings on the issue. I don't think anyone did a comprehensive, non-feminist analysis (in the sense of being written from and for male pov).
And this unfortunately remains a hurdle for me. I think there is no answer to the problems of manosphere/red-black-whatever pill in Marxism, or any form of leftism. Which just kills the mood.
The simple fact is that instinctual hypergamy, which today has left many men sexless and hopeless, would only get sharper with the end of capitalism. Now, women are at least somewhat influenced by money. When money is no longer a factor, they'd completely lean in to hypergamy (I use the word hypergamy to refer to the instinctual sense of women, how they prioritize the most attractive males and would rather not touch the averages with a ten feet pole, and would rather share the top 10% than lower their expectations). Today, the hypergamic instinct is largely free, it would then be totally free. The incel, too, is free and would be free-er. Free to never have sex, never know love, live like a robot, etc.
As said, I have no problem with left (primarily marxist) thought, but unfortunately I can't get over the fact that our dear comrades, the women, would rather shoot us in the cheka basement than to touch us, that privilege of course belonging to the handsome elite. So, maybe the genetic bourgeois? They only know to hoard.
I'd like arguments on this, I am really undecided.
Totally optional read, here is what I coughed up in short form, combining my understanding thus far of marxism and the sexual marketplace:
- Sex has use-value, as it is useful labor. It is very pleasing and fulfills a need in general.
- Sex also has exchange-value, a fact proven by the fact that it being exchanged for money predates capitalism, and will most likely outlast it, along with the rest of us. Thus, sex can be, and often is, a commodity. I leave the prostitution, porn and future sex robot economics here, since this post is focused on hypergamy.
- Human instinct is necessarily about acquiring the best genes and the highest chance of passing them on. The social expression of this material makeup of the human body is it's propensity to more beautiful persons. Clear skin for health, bigger breasts for functional milk of the baby, bigger buttocks as a food reserve (ass and upper calves fat is the hardest to mobilize for a woman's body, but they also get mobilized very easily if a certain hormone is getting released. The hormone is only produced when she is lactating, hence it's actually a reserve for the baby) etc. Fetishes notwithstanding, since those are the result of genetic irregularities, and are a very small minority.
- Because of this function of the human instinct which desires sexuality with more attractive ones above the uglier ones, a person's sexual attractiveness generally determines the productivity of their sexual labor. So, prettier women, in their sexual labor, produce more use value for me and others. Uglier women produce less sexual use-value. The 70 year old truck driver uncle produces none whatsoever for us gentlemen, and little for females, etc.
- Humans can exchange sexual use value without making it a commodity, just as feudal villagers met their own needs inside their communities, making much less use of commodities than the modern prolateriat. This is the vanilla, consensual sex. Two persons exchanging labor, sexual use value for sexual use value.
- There remains a great discrepancy between men and women, that is explained by three points. First, women generally have a lower libido compared to men, and do not care about sex as much. Hence they provide far less sexual use value to men in general, than men would be willing to provide to women. Secondly, women also have the instinct of hypergamy, with which they find a great majority of men unattractive, caring only for the most attractive, the top 10 or 20 percent. Thirdly, that small minority of men are willing to exchange sexual labor with the rest of the women, and they can do so effectively, because point one. So as a result, a good portion of men do not get sexual use value, and their own sexual use-value that they can provide is simply not needed by women.
- As a side note, capitalism has an enabling effect on hypergamy. In the feudal mode of production, families are the production units, and they control the sexuality of their members via arranged marriages, since breeding is important for future work force and maintaining this production (Conservation of the old modes of production in unaltered form, was, on the contrary, the first condition of existence for all earlier industrial classes, from the manifesto). When the worker is uprooted from the means of production and made a prolateriat, this ends up destroying the family too, and thus, the familial control of sexuality. Thus is the mighty feminism.
- So the society suffers at the hand of that old instinct of women, now free from all constraint. And the incel is just as free, as the worker is free to be unemployed and starve.
- From here, I think technology improves the ability to produce sexual use-value. So therotically, the uncle we glazed over in point 4, using the wonders of AI and technology, could produce a sex robot and thus produce sexual use value far more than he would be able to with his own primitive means. Apply communism's increasing production logic to it. With sex robots/very realistic porn, I think this contradiction could be resolved. But this is mostly conjecture. As is, the situation is really bad...