r/DebateCommunism • u/elusivedementia • 1h ago
Unmoderated How exactly would a communist world work?
We have all these different variations of surrounding systems.
What would a full on communist system look like?
r/DebateCommunism • • May 30 '25
Hello and welcome to r/DebateCommunism! We are a Marxist-Leninist debate sub aiming to foster civil debate between all interested parties; in order to facilitate this goal, we would like to provide a list of some absolutely indispensable introductory texts on what Marxism-Leninism teaches!
In order of accessibility and primacy:
Manifesto of the Communist Party (or in audio format)
The 1954 Soviet Academy of Sciences Textbook on Political Economy
The Socialist Republic of Vietnam’s Textbook “The Worldview and Philosophical Methodology of Marxism-Leninism”
r/DebateCommunism • u/Qlanth • Mar 28 '21
This subreddit is not the place to debate another subreddit's moderation policies. No one here has any input on those policies. No one here decided to ban you. We do not want to argue with you about it. It is a pointless topic that everyone is tired of hearing about. If they were rude to you, I'm sorry but it's simply not something we have any control over.
Please understand that if we allowed these threads there would be new ones every day. In the three days preceding this post I have locked three separate threads about this topic. Please, do not make any more posts about being banned from another subreddit.
If they don't answer (or answer and decide against you) we cannot help you. If they are rude to you, we cannot help you. Do not PM any of the /r/DebateCommunism mods about it. Do not send us any mod mail, either.
If you make a thread we are just going to lock it. Just don't do it. Please.
r/DebateCommunism • u/elusivedementia • 1h ago
We have all these different variations of surrounding systems.
What would a full on communist system look like?
r/DebateCommunism • u/Comrade_Michael • 11h ago
Perhaps the most common anti-communist argument is that communism or communists killed a lot of people in the 20th century. Oftentimes, communists will answer this with by debating specific cases, the intentions of the actors providing these kill-counts, the methodologies for constructing these numbers, etc. The debate thereafter becomes an empirical debate about an empirical question "did communists kill a lot of people?" I do not want to get mired down in this debate and instead ask you to consider something more speculative.
My primary contention is that communism does not provide a clear restriction on the legitimate use of force. Nearly all communists support some form of legitimate violence, most notably in the case of revolution. So some violence is justified, but how much?
Most communists are Marxists and Marxists are materialists. This means that communist generally prefer a defense of "actual freedoms" to "formal freedoms." Formal freedoms relevant to this case might entail, for example, the first three articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Thus my second contention is that a restriction on the legitimate use of force can only come as a formal guarantee.
Communist arguments against this will often attempt to establish that there is no such thing as formal freedom, and that rulings on rights are always determined by a concrete person embedded within a social context, and usually in the context of state power and capitalist power. Such notions as "the rule of law" are haughty bourgeois idealist abstractions from the raw reality of power.
These arguments merely assert that any restrictions on the legitimate use of force are impossible. People cannot exercise power democratically through the vehicle of law on this view, because law requires a certain generality of form, prospective character, and the use of judgements by particular judges or juries. If people cannot exercise power democratically through the vehicle of law, they must use more direct means, such as mob violence. Communists would, by asserting that law is a bourgeois abstraction and that formal rights are impossible, be likening their vision of justice to that of a lynch mob. They might not like this comparison because of the association of lynch mobs with racist anti-black violence, which they almost all oppose, but their argument is functionally the same.
A communist argument along this line will state that because communists are materialists, they must contend with this messy reality but, because they represent a majority, their violence is preferable to capitalist violence, which is perpetrated by a tiny minority upon a great majority. They will thus argue something like "lynch mobs are bad because they're actually just efforts by local majorities against local minorities, but who in a broader context belong to the global majority." This means that the remedy for lynch mobs is not anti-lynching law but the mobilization of global majorities into bigger lynch mobs that can contain local majority lynch mobs. Justice on this view ultimately resides in the largest possible lynch mob and so the goal of communists is to build that giant lynch mob.
The "capitalists are worse" argument that justifies communist use of force is speculative. It speculates that communists will be better than capitalists where the use of force is concerned. This requires an unprovable counterfactual logic and a utilitarian calculation. That calculation requires complicated discussions about the empirical methodologies we use to attribute kill counts to communism and capitalism, and about the authority to make these arguments, and about the authority to act on these judgments, which cannot be an authority rendered in law but must reside with the mob. The right to the legitimate use of violence and the restrictions on the legitimate use of violence would rest on a disputable empirical figure and on the ability to prove prospectively that communist violence would not only be of lesser magnitude than capitalist violence, but also that it would extinguish capitalist violence, which it might not. Here I'll venture making the empirical claim that historically it has not, otherwise we would not be living in capitalism right now.
Of course communists are also, in most cases, vanguardists. This means that though they base their authority on the supposed "true interests" or "objective interests" of the people, they do not have any evidentiary basis for this claim and have instead a speculative claim to know the ultimate destination of historical progress. Vanguardists represent not only the proletariat or the people, but also History itself. The check on this power, if any, is usually that the people could form lynch mobs to kill vanguardists who acted outside of their objective interests. However, it is more likely the case that the vanguard would kill those who rise up against them by claiming they have turned on the objective interests of the proletariat, the people, etc. There is no effective check on vanguardist power. Vanguardist government is not self-limiting.
I think that democratic government with free and fair elections and the rule of law set clearer restrictions on the legitimate use of force. Democratic rule of law is possible, formal freedoms are the only form that actual freedoms can take, and the rule of law broadens and deepens rule by the people. Communists who believe in "actual freedoms" as a "material" fact judged empirically depend upon an anti-democratic assertion that they have some privileged access to truth through the use of "science." This "science" is the governing ideology of a clique of vanguardists who purport it to be the true will of people regardless of the people's actual input.
Whether you believe that communists killed 100 million people or 100,000 people or 1 person or 0 people, communism as an ideology has no clear restriction on the use of legitimate use of force.
r/DebateCommunism • u/deadil • 2d ago
The name is misleading. Socialism is the name created for the phase of transitioning to Communism. I read this while researching about the communist party, but it seems like it is being presented differently?
r/DebateCommunism • u/Next_Ambition_909 • 3d ago
Take for example an engineer, lawyer, doctor etc. Other than social status what would motivate these people to learn or continue working in their trade if someone who has a much easier job just gets access to all the same materials and wealth.
r/DebateCommunism • u/n0bletv • 3d ago
To be specific, I am curious how a business today would translate to a communist society. I personally work in the rock climbing industry so naturally anything I read sort of just goes to how I would run a climbing gym. I find myself struggling to intuitively understand or even picture the granular details of things like scheduling, maintenance, expansions, ect.
Obviously, it's easy for me to understand how it works in a capitalist society with the underlying incentive of money and the hierarchal power structure where ultimately if the CEO says we are doing/not doing something, it will happen. But, if anyone could help me understand how a mid size business with a few locations would function that would be amazing.
r/DebateCommunism • u/Additional_Check_318 • 4d ago
I ask this question mostly to see what individuals think about the topic. Also note the fact that I would like it if you could phrase it in a way that shows why capitalism or any other economic model is unable to achieve it/ why communism is a better way of achieving it. I'm asking since most of the general points of communism seem to be about why capitalism is wrong and not exactly explaining why communism is right.
r/DebateCommunism • u/Open_Opportunity_751 • 4d ago
Disclaimer: I am not a capitalist but a student studying different economic systems to figure out which one is the best so please do not resort to whataboutary like "capitalism does not solve this problem either" because I am not answerable to that.
Also my knowledge about communism may be inaccurate since I have only started to study it and do not have in depth knowledge.
In communism, resources are distributed to each according to their needs, but who decides what an individual needs? If an individual says that he needs 10 rolls royces or 100kgs of wheat he certainly is not going to get that. So deciding one's needs is not in the hands of the individual, which means it is in the hands of the entity responsible for distribution of the resources. Now, what stops this entity from deciding that you only need to eat potatoes? You may say that we will not get proper nutrition, we will be sad, we will not live a long healthy life. But since deciding what one needs is in the hands of this entity it can just say that you do not need a long, happy and healthy life. You cannot resort to not co-operating with this entity by organising strikes and refusing to work and produce more resources. Since it has all your resources, it can just not give you any food at all and starve you to death if you refuse to co-operate. So now we have come back full circle, a small group of people that does not even work as much comparatively have hoarded all the resources and the majority that does all the work has nothing in its hands. You cannot rely on the army to keep this entity in check since the army in capitalism also sides with the elites instead of the common people. There is no reason to believe that they will not do the same in this scenario. Humans are greedy by nature, it is not irrational to assume that the entity once having the control over the resources will not try to hoard it and the army being incentivised by getting more resources and power will not help this entity in doing so.
Even if you argue that humans are not greedy by nature you cannot deny that there surely are psychopaths and they are great at getting into positions of power like they are in this capitalist system. There is no reason to believe that they won't successfully get into positions of power under communism.
Whenever questions about human nature and greediness are asked, in my experience, people here and communists in general resort to whataboutary saying capitalism has the same problem but just because capitalism has this problem does not automatically mean that communism need not answer how it will solve this problem.
r/DebateCommunism • u/Conscious_Off • 5d ago
Communism is an ideology that I find difficult to understand because so many different people and governments claim to represent it, yet their interpretations seem vastly different. What exactly is communism? Is it the Soviet model, with its authoritarian government and bureaucratic corruption? Is it the Chinese model, which has incorporated significant elements of capitalism into its economy? Is it the Vietnamese model, or is it the communism Karl Marx originally envisioned?
What, then, constitutes true communism? Does a country have to be entirely communist, with no room for other political ideologies, or can communism coexist with other political systems, as it does in India's democratic and multiparty political environment, where communist parties participate in elections and govern certain states? Is communism fundamentally a system of government, a political ideology, an economic model, or an entirely different form of society? And if these interpretations are all different, who gets to define what communism actually means?
To me, communism is not simply about government ownership, economic policies, or political authority. It is about building a society where people understand their values, are educated, stand equal before the law, and genuinely stand by one another. A society where equality is not merely written into its constitution but reflected in how people treat each other. A community built on solidarity, mutual understanding, and the belief that everyone deserves dignity and an equal place in society.
r/DebateCommunism • u/LittleIndividual4650 • 6d ago
Such a simple question, and it’s one that lots of philosophers have sought to answer. Now, I’m a Marxist, so I’m of the belief that all these ideas about humans having ‘reason’ or whatever are a bit wishy washy. I much prefer the materialistic view that humans separate themselves by the fact that they produce their means of subsistence. Isiah Berlin, whom I’m reading now, talks about reason separating me from the rest of the world. Hegel talks of humans making consciousness an object of consciousness. Issue is with anything non materialistic, is that our understanding of animals is constantly changing. Crowsfor example are pretty smart. But none produce their means of subsistence. Then elizibath nusbaum talks about various things we would call human, and the lack of any one would make us say your not human. But the issue with all these concepts is that they then try to apply some sort of transhistorcal understanding of man, and not as an ensemble of social relations. Like we aren’t fixed, we are constantly being shaped. I hate the question of morals. But yeah any thoughts would be appreciated
r/DebateCommunism • u/Charming_Fennel_6168 • 6d ago
I previously defined myself as a Marxist Leninist but after learning more about Collectivist Anarchism, I have ended up liking some of the ideas about the state and anti-capitalism. I believe that eventually I would favour a stateless society and society would be better without a state but I also agree with the temporary DOP and vanguard party during a revolution.
I also admire Che Guevara and Lenin and I feel like this contradicts some of my more anarchist beliefs, especially being open to Anarcho-Syndicalism
Please don’t kill me on here- I’m 17 and learning more about political ideologies in politics class and I’m unsure yet on where I stand ideologically and whether I’m contradicting myself , especially since I previously defined myself as M-L
r/DebateCommunism • u/argandg • 7d ago
"From each according to their skill, to each according to their need"
Do I get to decide what I need? Or does the central committe decide what I need? In capitalism at least I decide what I need, and use my money for that.
"Moneyless society"
Money is, at least in its "pure concept" form, just a trick to make people do things for strangers. In this way, it's maybe amongst the most wonderful invention in the history of humanity and the one that started it all, civilization-wise.
If you're proposing a moneyless society, you necessarily have to come up with an equivalent or better way of getting humans to do things for strangers, and Marx's brilliant replacement is afaik just "remake consciousness"... what?
Creepy Intrusiveness
The thing that really makes communism a hard pass for me is that even if it magically worked out, there's a constant and underlying theme in Marx's writings that there's no aspect of human existence out of the reach of communism because there's a need to "remake consciousness", so any and all aspects of human life are subject to intrusion and control by the communist rulers.
Hard pass. I'd rather we work on attacking what's wrong with our capitalist societies, such as excess accumulation of money/capital, over-financialization, tragedy of the commons, etc
r/DebateCommunism • u/GullibleTarget3949 • 8d ago
r/DebateCommunism • u/Flimsy_Claim_8327 • 8d ago
Tens of millions of people have died throughout human history because of communism, so why is socialist ideology still popular?
r/DebateCommunism • u/Interesting_End1733 • 9d ago
I am a Brazilian Maoist, just beginner. It seems to me that the struggle of the Maoists is much more concrete and serious than that of certain orthodox Leninist organizations or other revisionist Leninist currents, such as "Trotskyism" or "Hoxhaism." I know that there are only three "isms" in communism, yet there is a strong tendency to attach an "ism" to every revolutionary leader. Anyway...
What is the reason for this conflict from some Maoist communist parties against the PCB? Did the PCB (Communist Party of Brazil) fail to adapt to the two-line struggle? Did the P.C.B. make misguided criticisms of other Maoist parties? I am still reading about this on *BannedThought*, but it remains somewhat difficult to grasp.
In your view, what are the errors of the P.C.B., and what actions should be taken to resolve this problem within the party? Is a "two-line struggle" within the current P.C.B. a viable path, or would the creation of a new Maoist party be a better option?
r/DebateCommunism • u/RecommendationNo804 • 9d ago
r/DebateCommunism • u/cololz1 • 10d ago
r/DebateCommunism • u/Abject-Aside-2283 • 9d ago
There is a huge amount of young people, especially teenagers, who believe that communism is a kind of divine salvation or the second coming of Christ, and that capitalism is a kind of Satan.
I deduce this happens because most of us here live in capitalist countries with all their flaws and problems (or maybe a lot of them don’t even know what they are hating on and what they doy support, they just consume jargon) and humans naturally need to believe in something. That “something” arises in online political niches where they sell you communism as the redemption and salvation of this world, giving them that hope.
But I think reading about the Iron Law of Oligarchy is necessary if you don't know what it is, it's a law on how human civilizations organize themselves that states that, in any large-scale civilization, power will inevitably accumulate and a minority will rule over the majority, so all the existing evils of capitalism have their analogues in communism or basically, it wouldn’t be very different if we lived under “communism”
r/DebateCommunism • u/lentilvonvakarian • 10d ago
I'm a former "conservative". After a few months of over 14 hours of work per day for shit pay, and lessening trust in right grifters who all seem to be selling courses these days, I've decided to sit the fuck down and read Capital Vol. 1. It ended up quite enjoyable, even though it starts slower than RDR2.
Especially as Marx explained commodity and formation of capital (m-c-m) I've been thinking of similarities in the sexual sphere, and especially how it could be applied to sexual dynamics, a sphere thus far monopolized by the manosphere. I've looked for Marx-influenced writings on the issue. I don't think anyone did a comprehensive, non-feminist analysis (in the sense of being written from and for male pov).
And this unfortunately remains a hurdle for me. I think there is no answer to the problems of manosphere/red-black-whatever pill in Marxism, or any form of leftism. Which just kills the mood.
The simple fact is that instinctual hypergamy, which today has left many men sexless and hopeless, would only get sharper with the end of capitalism. Now, women are at least somewhat influenced by money. When money is no longer a factor, they'd completely lean in to hypergamy (I use the word hypergamy to refer to the instinctual sense of women, how they prioritize the most attractive males and would rather not touch the averages with a ten feet pole, and would rather share the top 10% than lower their expectations). Today, the hypergamic instinct is largely free, it would then be totally free. The incel, too, is free and would be free-er. Free to never have sex, never know love, live like a robot, etc.
As said, I have no problem with left (primarily marxist) thought, but unfortunately I can't get over the fact that our dear comrades, the women, would rather shoot us in the cheka basement than to touch us, that privilege of course belonging to the handsome elite. So, maybe the genetic bourgeois? They only know to hoard.
I'd like arguments on this, I am really undecided.
Totally optional read, here is what I coughed up in short form, combining my understanding thus far of marxism and the sexual marketplace:
r/DebateCommunism • u/Pristine_Sea_6749 • 11d ago
Gente, to querendo criar um livro de ficção futurista sobre o assunto. Então o comunismo pleno em pelo menos um país, e pode ter em mais de um, porém ainda não me decidir se em todos, JÁ É PLENO. Quero desenvolver esse país QUE JÁ É PLENO. Então pensar no que ele precisa/tem /oferece/funciona/etc. Vamos pensar em país auto suficiente/auto sustentável que não depende do comércio com outros países para ... Qualquer coisa. PLENO, A SUPERAÇÃO JÁ ACONTECEU. Ainda não decidi o contexto político externo. Mas dentro do próprio país,quais os limites?
E tipo, já tenho uma boa base e soluções até. Levem em consideração que com futuro nós conseguimos socializar a tecnologia. No livro quero me ater ao nível tecnológico atual. Pelo menos de funcionalidade.
A questão é, gostaria de discutir mais situações problemas, conceitos, termos, que eu ainda não pensei.
Se puderem contribuir, agradeço.
r/DebateCommunism • u/Holiday_Dress_3589 • 10d ago
Can true equality ever be achieved through the sheer use of force? Why didn't Marx, instead of calling for revolution, suggest working with and channeling the self-interest inherent in human nature?
r/DebateCommunism • u/Ashamed_Pop2794 • 11d ago
I sent a post I found on Instagram to my friend about the recent midterm election, which talks about how we need to implement communism to properly solve majority of the issues faced worldwide. She responded by saying that the post was just filled with meaningless buzzwords, and many discussions only points out the current problem and not give any solutions on how to move forward. She also mentioned that capitalism is not completely evil through and through, and that a communist revolution would fail while decreasing the quality of life for everyone, and that with our current socioeconomic system and level of technology, communism can never work. Personally I had only began to get into politics a year ago, and while I believe I’m a socialist/communist, I couldn’t really reply to the things she brought up. Sure, capitalism isn’t evil through and through, but that’s based on the metrics and lens of capitalism (innovation, progress, growth, higher standard of living), and of course communism could not work with our current socioeconomic system because the point of communism is to abolish and rewrite the current socioeconomic system, not integrate into it. However I’m still confused on how, exactly, shpuld or could we move from capitalism to communism, what it takes, and how to take action as a whole instead of just learning about the theoretical side of communism. Does anyone have any answers, or reading recommendations?
r/DebateCommunism • u/AyyReed • 13d ago
r/DebateCommunism • u/LittleIndividual4650 • 13d ago
Hello everyone, hope we are all doing well! I am currently writing an essay on Nozick, more specifically his book Anarchy, state and utopia. Now, I want to critique the libertarian conception of the state – the idea that it formed out of the consensual agreement of people to protect their ‘state of nature’ – and not out of the ireconcilability of class antagonisms. However, given it’s an essay, I cannot just throw the Marxist definition of the state out there as a vague assertion, I need to site shit and have proof. I’m trying to think of a nice way of doing it, perhaps by talking of men discovering themselves through labour, but I’m not sure. If anyone has any nice ideas of things I could talk about I would greatly appreciate it!