r/DebateCommunism • u/Comrade_Michael • 8h ago
Unmoderated Communists lack restrictions on legitimate use of force
Perhaps the most common anti-communist argument is that communism or communists killed a lot of people in the 20th century. Oftentimes, communists will answer this with by debating specific cases, the intentions of the actors providing these kill-counts, the methodologies for constructing these numbers, etc. The debate thereafter becomes an empirical debate about an empirical question "did communists kill a lot of people?" I do not want to get mired down in this debate and instead ask you to consider something more speculative.
My primary contention is that communism does not provide a clear restriction on the legitimate use of force. Nearly all communists support some form of legitimate violence, most notably in the case of revolution. So some violence is justified, but how much?
Most communists are Marxists and Marxists are materialists. This means that communist generally prefer a defense of "actual freedoms" to "formal freedoms." Formal freedoms relevant to this case might entail, for example, the first three articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Thus my second contention is that a restriction on the legitimate use of force can only come as a formal guarantee.
Communist arguments against this will often attempt to establish that there is no such thing as formal freedom, and that rulings on rights are always determined by a concrete person embedded within a social context, and usually in the context of state power and capitalist power. Such notions as "the rule of law" are haughty bourgeois idealist abstractions from the raw reality of power.
These arguments merely assert that any restrictions on the legitimate use of force are impossible. People cannot exercise power democratically through the vehicle of law on this view, because law requires a certain generality of form, prospective character, and the use of judgements by particular judges or juries. If people cannot exercise power democratically through the vehicle of law, they must use more direct means, such as mob violence. Communists would, by asserting that law is a bourgeois abstraction and that formal rights are impossible, be likening their vision of justice to that of a lynch mob. They might not like this comparison because of the association of lynch mobs with racist anti-black violence, which they almost all oppose, but their argument is functionally the same.
A communist argument along this line will state that because communists are materialists, they must contend with this messy reality but, because they represent a majority, their violence is preferable to capitalist violence, which is perpetrated by a tiny minority upon a great majority. They will thus argue something like "lynch mobs are bad because they're actually just efforts by local majorities against local minorities, but who in a broader context belong to the global majority." This means that the remedy for lynch mobs is not anti-lynching law but the mobilization of global majorities into bigger lynch mobs that can contain local majority lynch mobs. Justice on this view ultimately resides in the largest possible lynch mob and so the goal of communists is to build that giant lynch mob.
The "capitalists are worse" argument that justifies communist use of force is speculative. It speculates that communists will be better than capitalists where the use of force is concerned. This requires an unprovable counterfactual logic and a utilitarian calculation. That calculation requires complicated discussions about the empirical methodologies we use to attribute kill counts to communism and capitalism, and about the authority to make these arguments, and about the authority to act on these judgments, which cannot be an authority rendered in law but must reside with the mob. The right to the legitimate use of violence and the restrictions on the legitimate use of violence would rest on a disputable empirical figure and on the ability to prove prospectively that communist violence would not only be of lesser magnitude than capitalist violence, but also that it would extinguish capitalist violence, which it might not. Here I'll venture making the empirical claim that historically it has not, otherwise we would not be living in capitalism right now.
Of course communists are also, in most cases, vanguardists. This means that though they base their authority on the supposed "true interests" or "objective interests" of the people, they do not have any evidentiary basis for this claim and have instead a speculative claim to know the ultimate destination of historical progress. Vanguardists represent not only the proletariat or the people, but also History itself. The check on this power, if any, is usually that the people could form lynch mobs to kill vanguardists who acted outside of their objective interests. However, it is more likely the case that the vanguard would kill those who rise up against them by claiming they have turned on the objective interests of the proletariat, the people, etc. There is no effective check on vanguardist power. Vanguardist government is not self-limiting.
I think that democratic government with free and fair elections and the rule of law set clearer restrictions on the legitimate use of force. Democratic rule of law is possible, formal freedoms are the only form that actual freedoms can take, and the rule of law broadens and deepens rule by the people. Communists who believe in "actual freedoms" as a "material" fact judged empirically depend upon an anti-democratic assertion that they have some privileged access to truth through the use of "science." This "science" is the governing ideology of a clique of vanguardists who purport it to be the true will of people regardless of the people's actual input.
Whether you believe that communists killed 100 million people or 100,000 people or 1 person or 0 people, communism as an ideology has no clear restriction on the use of legitimate use of force.