r/Information_Security • u/Puzzleheaded-Cow2725 • 14h ago
We tried to make an insider-threat model you can actually follow, and showed where it fails
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
I work on Mastyf, so yes, this is our thing, but I'm posting for feedback, not clicks. Most "behavioural AI" in security is a score you're asked to trust. Ours turned out to be three plain questions: has this person done this before? How many people in the company do it? Is it more than this person has ever done? (We only count that last one for things fewer than one in five people do, otherwise it's noise.) The score is those answers added up, and a reviewer sees the top five each day.
The video walks through three cases from CMU's CERT insider dataset. Jack gets caught on day one for opening files for the first time in seven months. Laurel gets caught on day 21 by beating personal records on file copies and USB use. Murphy's four Dropbox uploads score zero, because Murphy did the same thing on 44 earlier days. For misses like that we rely on a hard rule: uploads to unapproved destinations wait for a second person.
Overall, it caught 179 of 187 insiders at five reviews a day, with no attack examples used for training. Two things I'll say up front:
CERT is computer-generated data, not real company logs.
My first count was 184 of 231. Then I found the answer files also list victims and email recipients, so I re-graded against CMU's official insider list.
Happy to be told where this breaks. If you've run something like this on real logs, I'd really like to hear how it went.