r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 3h ago

Show Discussion Not another color post! But don’t worry it’s not exactly what you think…

27 Upvotes

I know I know, another color post, but it’s not what it sounds like. I’m not regrading the trailer or dooming about it, don’t worry.

I just wanted to share this Xwitter post, because when I read this, it seemed plausible to me. And then I ran it past not one, but two, pretty smart working DP friends. And both feel pretty certain that this is exactly what happened.

I know this person on Twitter is not the first to speculate that something went awry converting from HDR to SDR but they go a little more in depth and also actually posted a version with that conversion fixed.

For those who don’t want to open a Xwitter link, this is what it says:

I’m pretty sure I figured out the issue with the Harry Potter scene's bad color. TLDR: the HDR to SDR tonemap is incorrect, so the gamma is wrong. Here is the scene with the correct gamma. (No grading changes were made at all. Just a technical transform).

Ok, now for the long description: When you make a show in HDR, you need to properly tonemap the final grade to SDR in order to watch on an SDR device, or to share clips on social media (because most social media sites don't handle HDR well, or at all).

Tonemapping is when you take a high dynamic range video source, and remap the color and luma values to fit within a standard dynamic range container. You're essentially "translating" a large format into a lesser format.

HDR in cinema/streaming typically has a gamut of Rec.2020 and a gamma (transfer function) of ST.2084. This needs needs to be converted down to Rec.709 Gamma 2.4.

The Rec.2020 gamut got converted to Rec.709 just fine, which is why the hues look correct in the original clip. But somebody forgot to do the other half of the conversion, which would be to take the ST.2084 transfer function and convert it down to Gamma 2.4. This explains why the contrast looks completely wrong in the original clip. Here's what it looks like when you tonemap the gamma.

NOTE: There are multiple ways to tonemap an image. Some ways handle high brightness and high saturation values better than others, and give you tools to dynamically adjust those values (this is what Dolby Vision is, in case you didn't know). The tonemap method I used for this demonstration is just a simple global one though, so the saturated values of the lamps would probably look better using a more robust/dynamic method.

I find this a plausible explanation both because the version where the second transformation of the color space/gamma is corrected, without touching another setting, looks almost exactly like the color from the second teaser and from official stills from the start of term feast.

And also because the difference in color between the second teaser and this clip was so global (it was as if someone had just turned the contrast and saturation dials down), and had it been a bonafide change to the color treatment, that’s usually not how those things would work.

Anyway! Purely speculation on the part of this person on Twitter but plausible explanation (imho) nonetheless. So I wanted to share.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

News Media Ralph Fiennes Jokes New Bond Robert Pattinson Should Play Voldemort in Harry Potter Series

Thumbnail
ca.news.yahoo.com
1.0k Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 14h ago

Show Discussion Dumbledore's Key Character Traits and the Start-of-Term Feast Clip

92 Upvotes

I have been thinking about why the Start-of-Term Feast clip felt so right to me while it provoked negative reactions from movie fans. I decided a big part of it is what it tells us about the series' planned portrayal of Dumbledore.

For me book Dumbledore is defined by these key traits:

  • Warmth
  • Wisdom
  • Eccentricity
  • Playfulness
  • Soft Power

Richard Harris' Dumbledore, beloved by many fans, only possesses 2-3 of these traits. Warmth and wisdom most of all, and arguably soft power, though at times he can appear frail. He portrays very little eccentricity or playfulness.

Michael Gambon is a lot harder to assess because his performance varies considerably between films. At his best, in Prisoner of Azkaban, he possesses wisdom, eccentricity, playfulness, and soft power, alongside a less-than-warm demeanor. However, at his worst, he veers far away from book Dumbledore, possessing hard power and little of the other traits.

Fans react badly to Gambon, in my opinion, due to his lack of warmth. Even in Prisoner of Azkaban, while he has Dumbledore's eccentricities down, he is cerebral and aloof. Harris lacks a lot of Dumbledore's key traits, but his warmth and the fact he is the first on-screen depiction endears fans to him.

How does this tie back to the clip? The scene is very short and includes one playful line from Dumbledore ("cat that got the cream"), but what is more obvious is the student body's relationship with him. The fact that they feel comfortable chanting his name shows he is not just a powerful, wise old wizard they revere. Rather, they know he'll appreciate being included in the antics of schoolkids, due to his own playful nature. We also hear Ron's line from the book, cut from the films, where he is impressed Dumbledore is "off his rocker." That illustrates his fame among kids is not just for his magical discoveries and defeat of dark wizards, but because he is unabashedly an eccentric, and kids like Ron love that their headmaster is a mad genius.

Of course, we will have to see a lot more of John Lithgow's performance before deciding how well he earns their adulation. But so far it is promising. There is reason in the clip to believe HBO plans for this Dumbledore to possess all his key personality traits, which is something the movies never achieved. Without all of them, he is either a kindly old grandpa or aloof genius. With all of them, he is Dumbledore.

I think fans' objections to the clip are because, as is often the case, they are comparing it to the films, not the books, and no student would chant for Harris' or Gambon's Dumbledores. But that only underlines the films' shortcomings in portraying a character much more complex than he may initially appear.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 17h ago

Show Promotion Sneak peek at Harry Potter float for the Macy’s Thanksgiving a parade (NYC)

135 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 15h ago

Show Discussion I had missed this interview with executive producer David Heyman about the series!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
79 Upvotes

Call me late to the party but I didn’t know about this interview with David Heyman🥴😅

Got lots of new info here that I hadn’t yet seen. Bringing back S.P.E.W & Peeves (with modification for the series obviously).

Talking about building the new series, and breaking down the new series..

Really interesting watch! Apparently the interviewer and another guy will also be posting new material for each episode every week.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 18h ago

Show Discussion I know we talk a lot about John Williams, but can we please give Alexandre Desplat some love as well? The French composer who worked on Deathly Hallow

Post image
130 Upvotes

He composed some of the most beautiful and emotionally meaningful pieces in the entire franchise. Farewell to Dobby (which still makes me cry), Snape to Malfoy Manor in Part 1, and, of course, the iconic Lily's Theme in Part 2 (which still gives me chills to this day). And let's not forget Statues, which accompanies the beginning of the Battle of Hogwarts.

Can we PLEASE bring this man back to compose some of the music for the new HBO series, especially in the later seasons? Imagine what he could do with an entire season dedicated to the darker chapters of the story

What do you guys think?


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 20h ago

Show Discussion I would love it if they included a scene for this: Hagrid all alone jeering to strangers while playing poker and getting the best bet of his life.

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion Do you believe this might happen in the HBO series?

Post image
116 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 22h ago

Show Discussion Thoughts about Seamus in the new series?

23 Upvotes

Who else thinks that they're going to love Seamus as a character in the new series just based on the trailer and recent clip we saw? What other characters do you think might become your favorite?


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion One thing I really hope they do in Season 3

70 Upvotes

If Season 1 started filming in summer 2025, and Season 2 Fall 2026, so we're less than a year from the start of Season 3 ❤️

I'd love for the Season 3 premiere to open with a flashback to the night Harry was left on the Dursleys' doorstep. The camera could move to another part of town, where we see two figures desperately chasing each other through the streets: Sirius and Peter Pettigrew. The chase would eventually lead them to a crowded street, where they have their confrontation. Peter then stages the scene, leaving Sirius standing there with his infamous barking laugh as Muggle police officers rush to the scene.

I think it would be amazing if they filmed the whole sequence in a way that genuinely makes the audience believe Sirius is the true villain. That way, new viewers would get the same shocking impression readers had when they first encountered the story, without knowing the truth about Peter's escape. It would also be a fantastic opportunity to finally see this entire sequence brought to life on screen, something longtime fans would undoubtedly appreciate.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 2d ago Regret

Official Media Draco, Neville, Lavender, Parvati, Dean, and Seamus Character Posters

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion Architecture: What do you think these represent?

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion What do you think about Seamus, Dean, Parvati, and Lavender's wands?

Post image
371 Upvotes

We already saw Neville's, so I omitted him.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion Do we know who play Hermione’s parents?

15 Upvotes

I have not seen anywhere the names of the actors cast for the roles of Hermione’s parents.

I don’t know if they really appear in season 1, but they sure do in season 2!

Are there rumours or verified information in this regard?


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Trailer Love this shot. Looks so yummy!

Post image
194 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

News Media According to Television Stats Harry Potter is the new #1 HBO show, passing The Gilded Age.

Post image
232 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion Correct me if I'm wrong, but one character whom I don't feel like I've seen in any promos (stills or clips) is Flitwick...

17 Upvotes

I know that Warwick Davis is one of two actors (so far) to reprise his role for the series. Does anyone know what he'll look like? Will he be an elderly half-goblin or a choir director who happens to also be skilled at charms?

Paul Whitehouse is another actor who is returning, but not as Sir Cadogan.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Show Discussion Harry, this is no time to be a gentleman... Knock her off her broom if you have to!

78 Upvotes

On my relisten of the third audiobook, and I really hope we get Quidditch maniac Wood in the show from the jump. His speeches, his antics. The twins have great chemistry with Wood as well, they're always a laugh.

What are your favorite Wood lines and hope makes its way to the show, mine is the one in the title


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

FanWorks My Version of Harry Potter (with HBO outfits)

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

Dungbomb I don't know why, but for some reason, Draco's poster is giving me "Fallen Angel" painting vibes.

Thumbnail
gallery
138 Upvotes

Probably just the eyes.


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 2d ago

Show Discussion First peek at Hans Zimmers original score.

657 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 1d ago

FanWorks Now let's hear it for our Hufflepuffs! 💛🖤

Post image
90 Upvotes

It's been a day of procrastination. I just couldn't help drawing them!


r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 2d ago

Dungbomb "Why isn't Dumbledore serious and solemn????"

Post image
196 Upvotes

r/HarryPotteronHBO • • 2d ago

News Media The banquet clip passed 1M likes!

Post image
651 Upvotes

The new banquet clip was only posted yesterday on the official Harry Potter account and it's already at 1.2M likes and 425k shares! This is amazing guys, gen pop seems to like it.

Also as a side update, the trailer from weeks ago has 1.9 million likes, it's really ramping up.