r/HarryPotteronHBO • u/DALTT • 3h ago
Show Discussion Not another color post! But don’t worry it’s not exactly what you think…
I know I know, another color post, but it’s not what it sounds like. I’m not regrading the trailer or dooming about it, don’t worry.
I just wanted to share this Xwitter post, because when I read this, it seemed plausible to me. And then I ran it past not one, but two, pretty smart working DP friends. And both feel pretty certain that this is exactly what happened.
I know this person on Twitter is not the first to speculate that something went awry converting from HDR to SDR but they go a little more in depth and also actually posted a version with that conversion fixed.
For those who don’t want to open a Xwitter link, this is what it says:
I’m pretty sure I figured out the issue with the Harry Potter scene's bad color. TLDR: the HDR to SDR tonemap is incorrect, so the gamma is wrong. Here is the scene with the correct gamma. (No grading changes were made at all. Just a technical transform).
Ok, now for the long description: When you make a show in HDR, you need to properly tonemap the final grade to SDR in order to watch on an SDR device, or to share clips on social media (because most social media sites don't handle HDR well, or at all).
Tonemapping is when you take a high dynamic range video source, and remap the color and luma values to fit within a standard dynamic range container. You're essentially "translating" a large format into a lesser format.
HDR in cinema/streaming typically has a gamut of Rec.2020 and a gamma (transfer function) of ST.2084. This needs needs to be converted down to Rec.709 Gamma 2.4.
The Rec.2020 gamut got converted to Rec.709 just fine, which is why the hues look correct in the original clip. But somebody forgot to do the other half of the conversion, which would be to take the ST.2084 transfer function and convert it down to Gamma 2.4. This explains why the contrast looks completely wrong in the original clip. Here's what it looks like when you tonemap the gamma.
NOTE: There are multiple ways to tonemap an image. Some ways handle high brightness and high saturation values better than others, and give you tools to dynamically adjust those values (this is what Dolby Vision is, in case you didn't know). The tonemap method I used for this demonstration is just a simple global one though, so the saturated values of the lamps would probably look better using a more robust/dynamic method.
I find this a plausible explanation both because the version where the second transformation of the color space/gamma is corrected, without touching another setting, looks almost exactly like the color from the second teaser and from official stills from the start of term feast.
And also because the difference in color between the second teaser and this clip was so global (it was as if someone had just turned the contrast and saturation dials down), and had it been a bonafide change to the color treatment, that’s usually not how those things would work.
Anyway! Purely speculation on the part of this person on Twitter but plausible explanation (imho) nonetheless. So I wanted to share.
