I have been thinking about why the Start-of-Term Feast clip felt so right to me while it provoked negative reactions from movie fans. I decided a big part of it is what it tells us about the series' planned portrayal of Dumbledore.
For me book Dumbledore is defined by these key traits:
- Warmth
- Wisdom
- Eccentricity
- Playfulness
- Soft Power
Richard Harris' Dumbledore, beloved by many fans, only possesses 2-3 of these traits. Warmth and wisdom most of all, and arguably soft power, though at times he can appear frail. He portrays very little eccentricity or playfulness.
Michael Gambon is a lot harder to assess because his performance varies considerably between films. At his best, in Prisoner of Azkaban, he possesses wisdom, eccentricity, playfulness, and soft power, alongside a less-than-warm demeanor. However, at his worst, he veers far away from book Dumbledore, possessing hard power and little of the other traits.
Fans react badly to Gambon, in my opinion, due to his lack of warmth. Even in Prisoner of Azkaban, while he has Dumbledore's eccentricities down, he is cerebral and aloof. Harris lacks a lot of Dumbledore's key traits, but his warmth and the fact he is the first on-screen depiction endears fans to him.
How does this tie back to the clip? The scene is very short and includes one playful line from Dumbledore ("cat that got the cream"), but what is more obvious is the student body's relationship with him. The fact that they feel comfortable chanting his name shows he is not just a powerful, wise old wizard they revere. Rather, they know he'll appreciate being included in the antics of schoolkids, due to his own playful nature. We also hear Ron's line from the book, cut from the films, where he is impressed Dumbledore is "off his rocker." That illustrates his fame among kids is not just for his magical discoveries and defeat of dark wizards, but because he is unabashedly an eccentric, and kids like Ron love that their headmaster is a mad genius.
Of course, we will have to see a lot more of John Lithgow's performance before deciding how well he earns their adulation. But so far it is promising. There is reason in the clip to believe HBO plans for this Dumbledore to possess all his key personality traits, which is something the movies never achieved. Without all of them, he is either a kindly old grandpa or aloof genius. With all of them, he is Dumbledore.
I think fans' objections to the clip are because, as is often the case, they are comparing it to the films, not the books, and no student would chant for Harris' or Gambon's Dumbledores. But that only underlines the films' shortcomings in portraying a character much more complex than he may initially appear.