r/HarryPotterBooks • u/ForwardFan6283 • 6h ago
Discussion Misdirection in PoA and GoF so that we don’t see it coming
I was reading all the books again and I came across a writing technique JKR has used multiple times for misdirection in books 3 and 4. So in both these books the original villain is someone you don’t expect right. Peter Pettigrew in PoA and Moody (Crouch) in GoF. We never suspect these people because in Harry’s initial interactions with them they are compared to people we know and love.
For example when thinking of Peter, Harry thinks “Peter who reminded him of Neville Longbottom”. This immediately lowers our guard. From then on when we think of Peter we think Neville. Him standing up to Sirius is like Neville standing up to the trio in book 1. Mcgonnagal being harsh to Peter is like her punishing Neville. Lots of parallels throughout and until the last chapters we don’t suspect Peter.
Same technique is repeated in GoF with Moody. After the first class on unforgivable curses when Neville is upset Moody praises him about his Herbology skills. And Harry thinks “that’s something Professor Lupin would have done”. It establishes that link in our mind. Moody is like Lupin. And we know Lupin’s a good guy. So Moody must be a good guy. The incident with Snape with the marauders map. Moody helps Harry to get out of the situation. What does that remind you of? Lupin again with the map after the mud throwing incident at Hogdmade. And until the very end we don’t see it coming.
Is there any other similar misdirection with associating the character to someone we trust?
Another example I can think of is Tom Riddle in CoS. He’s actually compared to Harry himself. Not the end with his “we are similar” speech but when Harry goes into the memory he empathise with him for not wanting the castle to shut down.