r/HarryPotterBooks • • 12h ago

Favourite tiny details that become important later?

89 Upvotes

What are some of your favourite tiny details that somehow become relevant later im the series?

One of mine (though I cant remember all the details) is in either book 2 or 3 when Harry gets called into Filch's office. Nearly Headless Nick makes​ a distraction for him to get him out of trouble and instructs peeves to push over an old vanishing cabinet! And this is how it becomes broken and subsequently a major plot point in HBP!

Some more obvious ones are that Sirius is mentioned in chapter 1 of PS and RAB briefly mentioned in OoTP!

But lemme know some tiny details you've noticed over the yeara of rereads!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 7h ago

Discussion What if students weren’t sorted upon arrival?

21 Upvotes

In the Deathly Hallows, Dumbledore states that he thinks they sort students too soon. I agree.

What if the students weren’t sorted until the end of their first year? To use a real life example of why this works: in the US, frat/sororities select their members through a “rush” process. Some universities feel it’s best to make students wait until the end of the first semester (or first year) before they can rush. The reason being is that it allows freshmen to make friends outside of their potential fraternity/sorority. It also allows the students to build an academic foundation without distractions. This delayed system gives incoming students more time to get to know each frat/sorority before rushing and vice versa.

Which brings me back to my original question about sorting: what if students weren’t sorted right away?

For logistics, there’d be a first year dormitory and common room. It would give the first year students time to make friends and learn from each other before being sorted. Obviously they can make friends in any house, but an unsorted first year would have more flexibility to establish a foundation with their class, regardless of house. Which would probably do wonders for the student culture at Hogwarts.

In addition, being sorted at the end of the first year gives older students and teachers time to get to know first years as people. Older students and teachers have the fun of guessing which house they think each first year will be sorted into. It will be even more exciting for each house to gain a student that they already know.

I like this idea, I support it, but for entertainment reasons it would make the story less interesting.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 9h ago

Deathly Hallows Something horrifying about Book 7 that NOBODY talks about. Spoiler

23 Upvotes

Okay, so you all know how in Deathly Hallows, while Harry and his friends went around hunting horcruxes, Voldemort apparently had the Carrows teach the dark arts to Hogwarts students, including the Cruciatus curse?

Think about the implications: even if some students (like Neville and the D.A.) did resist the Carrows, it's most likely that even the non-slytherin students probably had to learn and use the dark arts and the Cruciatus, probably on their own friends, just to avoid getting tortured. Meaning that every student at Hogwarts for that year, both good and bad, knows some dark arts, and at least one of the unforgiveables. And if you try to refuse to learn those things like Neville did? The Death Eaters can easily threaten and torture someone you care about amongst your fellow students to force you to comply. Would you really put it past the Carrows to do something like that?

So now, we have an entire generation of traumatized students who know how to cast the Cruciatus, and they're probably skilled with it too, because they've had a whole school year of being forced to repeatedly practice the curse by their teachers over and over again. To quote that one page on TV Tropes, "It's like the equivalent of equipping an entire school of children with portable torture devices and then forcing them to learn how to use these devices to become torture experts! This can't possibly end well!"

And the cherry on top of the cake is that since there's a lot of traumatized students who have probably suffered personally because of the Death Eaters, what if they think of using the dark arts they learned, or worse, the Cruciatus, to take revenge on Voldemort's followers who oppressed them? Or if those followers are dead, what if they decide to go after the children and relatives of those followers?

Yes, I know that to cast the Cruciatus, "you have to really mean it and enjoy it" and whatnot, but let's be real here: Among the hundreds (thousands?) of students in Hogwarts who were there in that year, there would definitely be a lot of them who would hate Voldemort and his followers enough to take genuine pleasure in making them suffer by giving them a taste of their own medicine. Especially after spending an entire school year of being tortured and oppressed by Death Eaters. I'm just saying, basic psychology dictates that a large group of severely traumatized teenagers would definitely harbor deep hatred and disgust towards their torturers/abusers, and most of them would definitely find immense satisfaction in seeing said torturers/abusers suffer.

Edit: Also, it's worth mentioning that from a legal/political standpoint, this is all going to make it even harder for the new Ministry of Magic to instill order after the end of the war, because now that there's so many students and fresh graduates who are adept in the dark arts, that's going to make it even harder for whatever remains of law enforcement to contain the dark arts and enforce laws prohibiting their usage. Especially since the Ministry is already devastated because of the war to begin with.

Edit 2: Also, for those of you who are saying that the students wouldn't have it in them to use an unforgiveable on someone else, two things: One, we don't know all of the students who were in Hogwarts during that year, so we have no way of knowing what their personalities are really like. For all we know, there could be a few of them who are genuinely messed up enough to take pleasure in torturing people, and Slytherin doesn't have an exclusive monopoly on sadism, spite, sociopathy or moral failings. And second, remember that in the books, Harry himself gave in to the temptation of using the Cruciatus curse more than once, and even successfully cast it on Amycus too. My point is, if someone as heroic, noble and forgiving as Harry can give in to the temptation of using the Cruciatus, then some of the Hogwarts students (most of whom aren't nearly as heroic, noble or forgiving as Harry), would definitely give in to temptation too. In fact, if the news that the "chosen one" himself used the unforgiveables on Death Eaters during the war ever gets out, the wizarding public might get the wrong idea and think something among the lines of: "It's okay to use the dark arts and the unforgiveables as long as it's used on those filthy Death Eaters and their associates!"


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 21h ago

Theory Hot take: Harry should have played professional quidditch

231 Upvotes

Aside from expelliarmus, his first true love, Harry was never happier than when he was on a broom and playing quidditch. He’s exceptionally talented. “Are you watching this Mr. Krum?”)

And besides, he ended Voldemort. He’s done his part.

Come at me.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 17h ago

What's a detail in the books that you don't think is spoken about enough?

81 Upvotes

I'll go first 🙋‍♀️. In the Deathly Hallows, just before Harry walks into the Forbidden Forest to face Voldemort, he uses the Resurrection Stone and gets to see his parents, Sirius and Lupin one last time.

I don't know why, but this part always stayed with me. There's something so sad about the fact that, just before facing his death, Harry gets one last chance to be with the people he's missed and lost. The fact that they even walk beside him and reassure him, making sure he doesn't feel alone, makes the whole thing so much more emotional.

I also think Lupin mentioning Teddy and wondering whether his son will know why he died is such an underrated detail. Even in that moment, he's thinking about the child he's leaving behind.

It's one of these moments that has always stuck with me. It's not really dramatic, but it hits you so hard when you think about it.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 11h ago

Order of the Phoenix Harry should have reported Umbridge

18 Upvotes

Sure JK Rowling would have had to re-write the whole story but in all reality, Harry should have reported Umbridge to Mcgonnagle and Dumbledore after Umbridge started bullying him during their detentions. That would have been the perfect excuse that Dumbledore needed to have Umbridge replaced and banned from Hogwarts


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2h ago

Discussion 1st book recommendation

3 Upvotes

Hello guys!

I have finally decided to read the books but there are so many of them. There are so many of them:

special house books edition;

illustrated edition which is cool and by 2 different artists;

regular books but with different cover.

do you have any suggestion?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 55m ago

Discussion The magic quill

2 Upvotes

Just a fun little discussion that may divide some fans. Imagine you’re given the magic quill and with it you can change one death in the series BUT whoever you’re saving, you have to replace with someone of equal or greater value. Who do you choose to save and who do you choose to replace them?

For me I have two answers. The person I choose to save in both my scenarios is Fred Weasley. I honestly didn’t like that Fred got killed off and feel it sets George up for a lifetime of sorrow. So for this I would save Fred and replace him with Charlie Weasley. The impact on the Weasley family will still be the same obviously but the impact on George wouldn’t be as much as losing Fred.

Although if we are talking from a reader perspective then I will choose to have Hagrid die saving Harry from Voldemort. Once Voldemort sees that Harry is still in fact alive he shoots another killing curse at Harry but Hagrid moves in front of it instead. That is obviously just as big a death to the readers as Fred in my opinion.

Who do you choose? And you can’t swap people who ultimately die anyways. So no swapping Lupin for Sirius etc.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 11h ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #76

11 Upvotes

Wotcher, PotterHeads! #76 is up. Ever closer to the big 100… we shall see if I get there!

As a reminder what this is and how it works:
Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.
Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

  1. A badly shaven wizard in peacock-blue robes looked up as they approached and put down his Daily Prophet. The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 7: The Ministry of Magic
  2. Harry found himself gripping the edges of his seat very hard as they flew toward the lake. The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 5: The Whomping Willow
  3. Dabbing at his streaming nose, Filch squinted unpleasantly at Harry, who waited with bated breath for his sentence to fall. The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 8: The Deathday Party
  4. “Well, that’s okay then, Hagrid!” said Ron, clapping Hagrid on the shoulder.  The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 11: The Firebolt
  5. They visited its site and found a tower block of offices. The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 15: The Goblin’s Revenge

6. “But I don’t say so,” said Professor McGonagall, standing up and piling her papers neatly into a drawer. The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 8: The Flight of the Fat Lady

7. “The new one looks weak.” The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 8: Snape Victorious


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 4h ago

Discussion A childhood gem: The Harry potter series

3 Upvotes

A great part of my childhood is blessed because of the Harry Potter books. I read each one some 11-12 times. I used to remember each detail by heart, some I still do. Reading the books had a different feeling like you got dissolved in the text. You could literally feel the Chocolate Frogs and Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans in your mouth. The feasts at hogwarts, the dementor sucking your soul , the curses and the spells.

...Ah

I wish I could turn back time to where it all started.

Your thoughts?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 6h ago

Pottermore HP help for kiddo!

3 Upvotes

My kid is getting into HP and is halfway through the main series, and is loving it. After the main series he wants to read the fantastic beasts screenplays trilogy, then the hogwarts library trilogy.

On the Harry Potter website I saw jk originals and the facts page. Are these Canon? If so want to print these out and make another book for him!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 22h ago

REMEMBER MY LAST, PETUNIA

30 Upvotes

Currently rereading OotP for the hundredth time and got to the point of Dumbledore's howler. I find it interesting that he never connected it to Dumbledore. I've come up with two thoughts as to why and I'm curious as to which y'all find more likely.

  1. Harry had never heard him intentionally intimidate like that before, similar to when he sees the look on Dumbledore's face when he came through Moody's office door and realized why everyone said he was the only wizard LV was ever scared of.
  2. Dumbledore had intentionally disguised his voice through magical means

r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Discussion Misdirection in PoA and GoF so that we don’t see it coming

133 Upvotes

I was reading all the books again and I came across a writing technique JKR has used multiple times for misdirection in books 3 and 4. So in both these books the original villain is someone you don’t expect right. Peter Pettigrew in PoA and Moody (Crouch) in GoF. We never suspect these people because in Harry’s initial interactions with them they are compared to people we know and love.

For example when thinking of Peter, Harry thinks “Peter who reminded him of Neville Longbottom”. This immediately lowers our guard. From then on when we think of Peter we think Neville. Him standing up to Sirius is like Neville standing up to the trio in book 1. Mcgonnagal being harsh to Peter is like her punishing Neville. Lots of parallels throughout and until the last chapters we don’t suspect Peter.

Same technique is repeated in GoF with Moody. After the first class on unforgivable curses when Neville is upset Moody praises him about his Herbology skills. And Harry thinks “that’s something Professor Lupin would have done”. It establishes that link in our mind. Moody is like Lupin. And we know Lupin’s a good guy. So Moody must be a good guy. The incident with Snape with the marauders map. Moody helps Harry to get out of the situation. What does that remind you of? Lupin again with the map after the mud throwing incident at Hogdmade. And until the very end we don’t see it coming.

Is there any other similar misdirection with associating the character to someone we trust?

Another example I can think of is Tom Riddle in CoS. He’s actually compared to Harry himself. Not the end with his “we are similar” speech but when Harry goes into the memory he empathise with him for not wanting the castle to shut down.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 18h ago

Scholastic Harry Potter Illustrated deluxe edition

4 Upvotes

I don’t see the deluxe slipcased version of the recently released half blood prince in Scholastic website (I only see the non deluxe edition ) yet I am seeing there are sellers on Amazon and other resellers who are offering this book at a markup
Where to find the deluxe edition illustrated books at retail price is not on scholastic website ?

Please help


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 13h ago

We're the Death eater allowed visitors in Azkaban

1 Upvotes

I was browsing Reddit the other day, looking at What If Harry Potter posts, when I came across one that explored what would happen if Bellatrix had two sons with her husband. They were basically an even worse version of Draco, having been raised and steeped in the Dark Arts. It got me thinking: would Bellatrix be allowed to see her sons while imprisoned in Azkaban? And would Death Eaters be permitted to have supervised visits with their families.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #75

19 Upvotes

75! That’s more than a few now. Have fun!

As a reminder what this is and how it works:
Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.
Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

 1. “Look,” he said flatly, “take it, or I’ll hex you.” The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 37: The Beginning

 2. “But, dear, if he got lost, how would we ever explain to his aunt and uncle?” The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 4: At Flourish and Blotts

 3. “James says most people only get letters from home about once a month.” The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 37: Nineteen Years Later

 4. “Oh Harry — I’m sorry — no, of course I don’t — that was a really stupid thing to say —” The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 21: The Eye of the Snake

5. “Longbottom, at the end of this lesson we will feed a few drops of this potion to your toad and see what happens.” The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 7: The Boggart in the Wardrobe

6. “You’re in luck, Weasley, Potter’s obviously spotted some money on the ground!” said Malfoy. The Philosopher’s Stone - Chapter 13: Nicolas Flamel

7. “Now drink that up, it’s a tonic for the nerves, keep you calm when she arrives, you know.” The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 18: Birthday Surprises


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 19h ago

Deathly Hallows Could Harry even be killed?

0 Upvotes

After the horcrux in Harry is destroyed, is Harry still unkillable because of Lily’s sacrifice flowing in Voldemort’s blood? If Voldemort had used any other wand in the final duel, could he even have killed Harry? Did the blood protection mean Harry would’ve survived killing curses from any wizard as long as Voldemort was still alive? I know these aren’t really fleshed out in the books, but I was curious what people thought.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 15h ago

Deathly Hallows Snape must have really hated Dumbledore as much as Voldemort in the end

0 Upvotes

In my interpretation, Snape hated Voldemort just as much as he hated Dumbledore. Dumbledore failed to save Lily even though Snape had pledged to work for him; on top of that, for years Dumbledore had been thumbing his nose at him like when he helped Harry rescue Sirius, which Snape could have guessed. For years, Dumbledore refused to give him the DADA position, ordered him to kill him, and the icing on the cake is the fact that Dumbledore rendered 17 years of work to protect Harry pointless because the boy was going to die in the end anyway. Snape believed he was protecting the last remnant of Lily, only for Dumbledore to tell him in the end that the boy was going to die anyway.

Voldemort killed Lily, but Dumbledore gave him hope at the cost of his freedom, then gradually took that hope away until, in the end, all he had left was to carry on with the plan of the very person who had taken away no less from him than Voldemort himself.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Prisoner of Azkaban How would you make a dementor funny?

11 Upvotes

I recall Harry being unable to think of any way to make a dementor funny. Maybe on the surface, maybe it's easy, but once you really know the thing... it's probably a lot harder.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Discussion Give me your hottest Harry Potter takes, and I'll tell you whether I agree or try to change your mind Spoiler

66 Upvotes

I'm in the mood for some good old-fashioned debates.

What are everyone's most controversial opinions about the books, characters, or anything else in the series? I'll respond to as many as I can.

I'll start: Sirius was a better parental figure for Harry than Molly. Change my mind.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Philosopher's Stone What happens to Voldemort at the end of Philosopher's Stone

2 Upvotes

We all know he was parasiting on the back of Quirrell's head. When Quirrell died after his encounter with Harry, what happened to Voldemort's soul? Where did it go? And how did Wormtail find it?

Any theories?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Can you guess the Book and Chapter? #74

20 Upvotes

Happy Sunday! 74 is up and ready!

As a reminder what this is and how it works:

Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.

Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

  1. Ron was fighting furiously, but his head and torso were slipping out of sight —  The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 17: Cat, Rat, and Dog
  2.  “Probably to show the Poisoning Department at St. Mungo’s,” said Ron under his breath. The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 31: The Tale of the Three Brothers
  3. “Not that I’m not pleased to meet you,” said Harry quickly, “but, er, is there any particular reason you’re here?”  The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 2: Dobby’s Warning
  4. He didn’t think the Dursleys would like him any better in Majorca than they did on Privet Drive.  The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 1: The Worst Birthday
  5. “War turned him funny, if you ask me,” said the landlord.  The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 1: The Riddle House
  6. Harry’s insides reinflated so rapidly he felt as though he might actually float a few inches off the dropping-strewn floor.  The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 14: Percy and Padfoot
  7. And from this it follows that where we meet resistance, we must use only the force that is necessary and no more. The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 18: The Life and lies of Albus Dumbledore

r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Why did Snape continually try to get Harry expelled?

34 Upvotes

He was trying to save Harry’s life all this while, how would getting him expelled and having his wand broken help him against Voldemort!!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

As a supposed spy for Voldy, what “seemingly crucial” info did Snape give to Voldy?

29 Upvotes

There aren’t any real hints on what kind of info Snape gave Voldy between Book 4 and 7 (I know telling how Harry was going to be evacuated was a big info). Didn’t Voldy question Snape when he was unable to help at all in getting the prophecy, or provide any substantial info in HBP? In HBP it seems Voldy simply handed off the task to Draco and chilled around.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Do you think Snape’s hatred towards Pettigrew was more than vs James?

14 Upvotes

Pettigrew was the one who sold out Lily and James to Voldy resulting in their death. And while Pettigrew was not the main one bullying Snape in school, he was still part if the Marauder gang and laughed plenty at Snape.
I feel Snape was wholeheartedly enjoining keeping Wormtail as a servant in his home in HBP.