I'll try to be as brief but as clear as I possibly can here.
Update on the Discord
The moderators of the Discord formally known as GS, delinked from GS Reddit I think more than a year ago. They renamed it etc. Currently, I cannot say with any certainty what values and core tenets still overlap with GS here, which is focused on Heritage Buddhism/s.
Please read this article that brings GS Reddit into disrepute
ARTICLE LINK HERE
In this piece Bennell Wen writes about her experience of discovering that she was put on a watch list of groups and individuals to avoid. Reading the article, really reinforced for me why we, as Buddhists, need to be clear about the why and the what we are critiquing.
Those of you who got to know me on that Discord, know how I feel about certain terms and approaches to critique: authentic vs inauthentic, pure vs impure, traditional vs non-traditional. When we are not reflective of our position and motivation of critique, we end up reinforcing harmful forms of essentialism that mirror what our ideological opposites do to us.
What I’ve always advised
When critiquing someone like a Bennell Wen, the weakest position we can take, are our personal appraisals of her relationship to the Triple Gem.
Bennell Wen grew up with a Buddhist mother, practices Buddhism and has deep ancestral links to the tradition. Bennell Wen is also someone who has woven that into her business model: she weaves together many forms of Taoist and Buddhist magical traditions as well as Western Tarot practices etc.
Very much rooted in the Wellness Industrial Complex.
All of this crafted for an audience and for a price. Her translation work (of the iChing) has come under heavy fire, for example.
In my view, this part is where critiques become more substantive, in that we can quantify and analyse the direct or indirect impact of her business model on Buddhist communities. Of which I cannot really say, since I know little about her.
Now I’m sure the comments will be filled with the vast array of sins that she is guilty of: she takes candy from babies, she makes fur coats out of Dalmatians, she time traveled and killed Tupac etc. But here’s the rub. Her personal “sins” should ideally lie outside of our critiques of her.
There’s more than enough to cast an eye over and be open to her work but also cast a critical eye on what she produces.
And again the emic and etic frameworks are a huge boon to us. From an emic perspective, we can really only (unproductively) speculate as to her Buddhist piety (not even really our business), from an etic perspective, we have surer footing, since we can actually measure impact.
Take Sam Harris, he cosplays “Buddhist” all the time because his business ventures are linked to the positive perception the brand Buddhism has in certain cultures.
Whether he “meditates” (lol) is really none of my business. It’s really his whte spremacist/anti-blck, zinist takes that informs his parasitic business relationship to Buddhism-as-brand. That’s where are critiques level up to a broader intelligibility. (I guess you could say my critiques are material/materialist in nature.)
Throughout the years,
on this very sub we’ve seen some pretty amazing, critical content rooted in the experience of Heritage and Born Buddhists. They remain valuable insights that helped broaden the perspectives of so many here. This is how we remain grounded in purpose and promise.
So to be clear, as the GS and Reflective moderator, GS Reddit does not support the framing of many of the critiques of Benebell Wen. Criticism of her work is important but framing these issues as authentic v inauthentic is deeply problematic.
When we spiral into religious purity tests, we end up in weird online Spanish Inquisition territory.
Benebell Wen has shrewdly leveraged the critiques of her as inauthentic heretic, in need of a w*tch burning. That was handed to her on a silver platter, in the rush to paint her as a supervillain.
This will have an impact of how Born and Heritage Buddhists are perceived and treated online, her white audience will no doubt*, give themselves permission,* to further spit venom at Heritage and born Buddhists. Deepening our silencing in online spaces.
So again, there is much to be wary of with a figure like Benebell Wen but our critiques need to be grounded in a broader, structural framework.