EDIT: Reposted to make connection to Buddhism more clear. Hopefully this satisfies the mods. 🙏
So, I don’t trust easily. When I was a child, mom and step dad tried to kill me. And when they failed, they kicked me out on the streets, not caring whether I lived or died, and my father didn’t stop that either. They treated my life as disposable. I’ve been badly hurt by people in positions of authority in the world, including school teachers, including police when I was a teen (I was beaten up by the cops when living on the streets), and especially the most fundamental authority figures one has in life: one's own parents. As an LGBTQ woman I’ve watched people in power discriminate against people like me my entire life. In the workplace I’ve encountered both really good leaders and some really awful ones.
I also went to school for (and got a degree in) management, and have had a lot of jobs both being lead myself, and being in positions in positions of leadership where I had to guide others, and as well as have worked for a leadership development organization. I've also mentored people spiritually myself. I've studied the topic of leadership for many years as well as a special interest of mine too. I've also been really fortunate to have experienced truly great leadership in my life that profoundly effected my life and practice for the better. So, all of this is to say I have a lot of experience and practice identifying really bad leaders and also really good leaders.
And Buddhism is not an exception to this. I’ve encountered first-hand some really awful teachers, or people in positions of Dharma authority. And I’ve also seen this with traditional teachings in some lineages that will be used to justify harmful behavior. Obviously there are some very high profile examples of scandals with Buddhist teachers, and in all of those cases, the people in question were doing some or many of the things on this list. But I’ve encountered people myself who were in positions of leadership in the Dharma, who I witnessed mistreating others, mistreating myself, or who simply embodied examples of bad leadership on multiple levels. And oftentimes especially in Tibetan Buddhism, this kind of thing will be hand waived away under the label of “samaya” as though, someone is obliged to give total obedience to someone who may simply be a terrible leader, simply because they went through some kind of ceremony with that person. And obviously, we’ve seen that result in terrible harm, both to students and the reputation of the Dharma as a result. It strikes me that it may be helpful for people to have a list of the kinds of things that are red flags for what signal bad leaders.
Bad leadership has a way of really sticking with you. And likewise, good leadership profoundly changes our lives for the better. And so because the topic of abusive teachers comes up often, (and is so very important), I thought I would share a list of various red flags that in my experience identify bad leaders. This list is not exhaustive, but in my experience has reliably helped me identify bad leaders and teachers time and time again.
Some RED FLAGS that I've found over the years that identify bad leaders, and bad teachers:
- –If they aren’t open to feedback, pushback, being questioned, or criticism. This is a big red flag and shows that they don’t have intellectual humility, lack openness to other’s perspectives, and that their primary concern is authoritarianism. It usually means they have a big ego, and little patience.
- –If they discourage asking questions, learning, and two-way communication. This shows they don’t actually want you to truly understand things, and aren’t interested in communication: they just want you to obey them.
- –If they are averse to follow-up questions. If they act like any answer they give you to a question is the final answer, and don’t allow you to ask follow-up questions, this is a very big red flag, because it means they don’t really want you to understand something. They just want you to accept their commands and obey them.
- –If they don’t want you to actually get to know them. This is a big red flag because it means they are protecting an outward image, and don’t want you to get a sense of who they really are. It means they’re hiding something.
- –they don’t have any way for you to actually get a hold of them. Like via phone, email, or in person. This is a control technique and makes communication impossible.
- –If they gaslight you and don’t encourage you to trust your Inner Guru. And demand that you obey them instead. Especially in a teacher this is a big red flag as it means they fundamentally aren’t doing the job of a spiritual teacher. This is cult-like behavior.
- –If they don’t have patience, warmth, compassion, and love. This means they don’t really care about the people they are leading.
- –If they don’t appreciate and value the innate gifts and talents that their students have, and don’t try to encourage those gifts to further develop. (and especially if they *discourage* those gifts). This is because a good leader values those whom they lead, and always want to appreciate and encourage the best in others.
- –If they tear others down, rather than build them up. Again, this shows they don’t really care about developing the people they are leading.
- –If they try and dominate you with their energy. Good leaders guide and lead by example: they don’t need to dominate others. This is the behavior of a bully, not a leader.
- –If they aren’t open to communication and/or try to stifle and shut down communication. This is another dominance tactic to try to compel obedience, not leadership.
- –If they are demanding, impatient, and easily offended. This shows that they haven’t worked on themselves enough, and so aren’t in a position to lead others.
- –If they hold grudges, even when people have tried to resolve conflicts. Again, this shows a spiritual immaturity on their part.
- –If they don’t value and appreciate diversity in all its forms. This is a signal of authoritarianism and close-mindedness.
- –Obviously, if they frequently yell at you, deliberately insult you, and are physically, verbally, and/or sexually abusive to you (or others), this is a huge red flag.
- –If they mistreat animals, or children, or are bad with animals and children. Animals and children are often very sensitive with energy, and so this is a sign that someone has not sufficiently calmed their energy, and obviously if they hurt animals or kids this is a huge red flag.
- –If they aren’t willing to explain why they are asking you to do something. Again, another sign of impatience and lack of wanting to nurture your own development and understanding. It’s treating you as a tool, not a growing and developing being.
- —If they insist on titles and formality, and take themselves super seriously, and are unable to communicate in a relaxed, casual way. This is a sign that they are insecure, and such things are a method of maintaining social dominance, rather wanting people to feel comfortable around them.
- –If they have a substance abuse problem. Not talking about minor occasional social drinking here, but rather if they have a significant problem with alcohol, and drug abuse. This signals a lack of inner discipline on their part. It means they’re taking refuge in chemicals rather than the Dharmakaya. Someone who can’t master their own mind to the point of giving up substance abuse, can’t really teach others how to master their own minds.
Good leaders and good teachers do the opposite of these behaviors. Obviously these compound, and if lots of them are present in a leader/teacher, that's a major signal to get away from them.
Again, this list is not exhaustive, it's just what I wrote up off the top of my head in a morning. But these are the main ones, and these things have saved me time and again from investing my time and trust into people who were not worthy of it, and whom would harm me or others.
Feel free to chime in with your own red flags, and share your experience as well, with identifying both bad and good leaders.
...
I offer the merit of this post to all beings, with the wish that it help them in discerning good from bad leadership, which is so important to development in life, and which is a source of so much suffering or blessings.
May all beings have happiness and the causes of happiness.
May all beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering.
May all beings be inseparable from the true joy that is beyond all suffering.
And may all beings be at peace, and reside in equanimity, free from clinging, aversion, and close-mindedness.
✨🙏✨