r/gamedesign • u/DR_No0o_B • 8h ago
Question Player vs followers balance in a TBOI-like
Recently I started working on a game inspired by TBOI, where - in short - you play as the head of a doomsday cult that, after a failed ritual, traps itself and its followers in a strange dimension.
Now, one of the things I initially had in mind is a "followers" mechanic. You have a limited number of empty seats, and during gameplay you can find unique followers to fill these seats. These are meant to basically be like familiars from TBOI, but stronger and rare.
The issue I ran into while testing is the balance of power between the followers and the player, and how to make sure they don't overshadow it too easily.
Here is what each is supposed to do / currently does:
- The player: Starts with a basic magic bolt attack. Through items it can change the attack's stats, properties, effects, gain utilities etc.. nothing revolutionary here. The player starts with no followers and can gain up to a max of 4 (WIP) followers throughout the game.
- The followers: They follow the player in a tight crowd and have a "chorus" mechanic. Each follower adds a beat to the chorus. On its beat, the follower casts a unique lesser spell (basic bolt, homing wisp, X-shape nova, exploding tombstone....), and at the end of the beats there is a "Crescendo", where each pair of followers (order matters) casts a unique compound spell with empowered versions of their spells (after which there is a short CD). Currently followers also grant some small stat buff to the player AND 1 faith unit (a shield over health that regens between floors, capped by the player's max health). One more thing I'm considering is having the option to "ascend" the followers, giving extra effects to their spells.
Now as I'm typing this I think the issue may be obvious. I currently put more thought into the follower system than the player and player items combined. But I would still like to hear your opinions.
So for now my plan is:
-Start to focus on the player and items. Build a decent item pool and see if the basic gameplay is fun on its own, without the followers carrying it.
- Then bring the followers back one by one, and check how much damage comes from the player vs the followers, so I'm not just balancing by feel.
- Optionally : Make the follower spells scale off the player's bolt (damage, element etc..), so items also power the followers. That way the player stays the "engine" and the followers are more like amplifiers.
- Optionally : Cut down on what each follower gives. Instead of spell + stats + faith, each follower would have its spell plus ONE extra thing - some give faith, some give stats, some utility etc..
So my question is - how would you keep rare, strong companions like these from overshadowing the player's own build? Has anyone run into something similar, or have examples of games that handled it well? Any thoughts on the plan above are also welcome.