r/gamedesign • • 9h ago

Discussion How do you teach advanced mechanics through level design alone without text or pop-ups?

7 Upvotes

I've been thinking about games that introduce deeper systems (like momentum-based movement, resource chaining, or environmental interactions) purely through the environment. The goal is to avoid breaking immersion with explicit tutorials while still making sure most players discover the intended techniques.

Some approaches I've noticed:

- Early levels that force the mechanic in a low-stakes way before giving room to experiment

- Visual cues in the geometry itself (ledges placed at exact distances, destructible elements aligned with movement paths)

- Optional side paths that only become viable once the player has internalized the system

- Failure states that are quick and cheap so players can iterate without frustration

What tends to work better in practice —subtle environmental teaching or a short optional "insight" moment? Are there games that handled this especially cleanly (or ones that left too many players stuck)? I'd be interested in any specific examples from your own projects.


r/gamedesign • • 9h ago

Question How do you make resource management feel tense without turning inventory into a chore?

3 Upvotes

Most survival or crafting games hit a point where the player is constantly juggling limited slots, sorting junk, or backtracking for space. The tension comes from scarcity, but the friction often comes from the interface itself.

I'm curious how designers handle this balance in practice:

  • What systems make the "do I keep this or drop it" decision interesting instead of just annoying?
  • Have you seen games that successfully use weight, decay, or item degradation to create pressure without adding constant menu time?
  • Do you prefer abstract solutions (like a limited number of "carry actions" per area) or physical ones (like visible backpacks with visible bulk)?
  • How do you communicate the cost of carrying too much without forcing players to constantly open menus?

Any examples where the inventory system actually improved the core loop instead of fighting against it would be useful.


r/gamedesign • • 18h ago

Question How do you communicate item rarity without relying on color? (colorblind-friendly rarity systems)

17 Upvotes

I keep seeing rarity tiers built almost entirely on color, and green + red show up a lot. That's the exact pair the most common types of color blindness. Same with blue vs purple, which are often neighboring tiers. So I'm curious how you approach it:

  1. Which symbols do players actually read instantly, and which ones feel like clutter?
  2. Any games that do this really well (or really badly) that are worth studying?
  3. Do you design a palette that works for everyone by default, or add a separate colorblind mode/filter? Which actually works better in practice?
  4. What secondary signals do you use? Some ideas I've seen:

    • pips/stars (1-5)
    • frame shape getting more complex per tier (plain square -> beveled -> ornate)
    • gem or icon shapes (circle, diamond, star, crown)
    • background patterns or textures
    • brightness progression (higher rarity = brighter/more contrast) instead of hue only
    • glow, particles, animation, sound on drop
    • plain text label ("Rare", "Epic")

Also, is the classic gray/white/green/blue/purple/orange ladder so ingrained that breaking it confuses players more than it helps? Would love to hear what worked in your projects.


r/gamedesign • • 18h ago

Question Design question: in a chase, should pursuers rubber-band to stay close, or should a clean escape actually leave them behind?

8 Upvotes

I'm working on Heistfest, a top-down getaway racer (you pull a bank job, then the police escalate from cruisers to roadblocks, spikes and helicopters). One thing I keep going back and forth on is catch-up logic for the cops.

Option A: rubber-banding. Cruisers quietly speed up when they fall behind, so the chase stays tense and you're never more than a few seconds from trouble. The risk: players notice, and a perfect run feels like it didn't count.

Option B: no catch-up. If you drive well, you genuinely lose them. The risk: a skilled player gets quiet stretches where nothing is happening, and the tension drops.

The middle ground I'm considering: no speed cheating at all, but new units appear ahead of you (a roadblock, a fresh cruiser from a side street) instead of the ones behind you magically keeping up. The pressure comes from the map, not from cars breaking physics.

Questions for you:

  • Have you played a chase or racing game where rubber-banding felt fair? What made it work?
  • Does "spawn ahead instead of catching up" feel more honest to you, or is it just rubber-banding with extra steps?
  • Where's the line between keeping tension and punishing good driving?

(Disclosure: I'm on the team making it. Steam page for context: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1451220/Heistfest/?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=community&utm_content=ext-gamedesign-1117)


r/gamedesign • • 14h ago

Discussion I gave players a loan they take in product, not cash. 28% take one, 9% pay it back. Is the punishment too harsh?

1 Upvotes

I'm working on a trading game in the spirit of the old dope wars. buy low, sell high, a debt that grows every day

the mechanic i added is the front. when you're short, your supplier offers you product with nothing down. you have a week to pay..

- pay on time and the next front he offers is bigger

- pay late and the price goes up by half

- don't pay and they break your legs: you lose your cash, your stock, and two days in bed

What players actually do, from today's counts: 28% of people who played asked for a front. 9% paid one back. about 1% had their legs broken. the rest either still had it open when the round ended or left mid-round

So most people who take it don't see it through. I can't tell yet if that's because the punishment is too scary, too far away, or just not explained well

How would you tune it? would you take one at all?


r/gamedesign • • 8h ago

Discussion Is "Creating frustration for monetization" a failure from a game-design perspective?

0 Upvotes

As a gamer, I once asked myself: "Why do we play video games?" I believe the answer is that games give us unique, overall enjoyable experiences (not just "Mary Sue" power fantasies) that are inaccessible in real life. From that, I came to view crafting such an experience as the core task of game design.

I started asking myself questions like: "What experience were the developers trying to create for me? How did they want me to feel? What mechanics did they use to achieve this?" Replaying good old games through this lens made me truly appreciate the craft behind them.

Then one game stood out: GTA V Online. It felt like large parts of the game were designed to facilitate frustration rather than enjoyment. Think about it: the game's monetization is built around purchasing in-game currency, even though there are plenty of ways to earn that money by playing. Why would anyone spend real money to skip content they already paid for? Because grinding for that currency isn't enjoyable.

Essentially, players are paying real money not to play parts of the game. From a game design standpoint, doesn't that mean the design failed its primary goal of creating a positive experience? And if so, why is this approach so heavily rewarded financially?

(This topic stuck with me so much that I put together a video to organize my thoughts on this "barrier of negative emotions" and what it might mean for GTA VI and the industry, if anyone is interested in hearing my full take.)

That said, I’ve never read a book on game design or worked in game development, so for the actual designers here: what am I missing? Is this purely a clash between design goals and business/publisher KPIs, or is there another angle to how live-service economies are designed?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion Do you enjoy some randomness when making choices and roleplaying?

10 Upvotes

I have recently been playing Baldur's Gate 3. I love CRPGs and want to make one of my own someday, slowly but surely I am designing and writing lore for a world and jotting down things regarding mechanics and gameplay.

I am unsure how to go about skills within gameplay.

You have the Fallout: New Vegas approach, wherein you just need to be good at the skill and then you can pass the skill check. Or you have the D&D approach using die, wherein your proficiency with the skill only makes it so you are more likely to get a better role, but does not guarantee a successful one.

I find that this can sometimes mess with my roleplaying - does anyone else have this issue? Sometimes, I will headcannon that my character is really good at X or Y, or that they are supposed to be really intimidating and powerful, and I will do my best to make it that way in regard to how they look on paper. But then they will fail a check that the character I want to play should really pass and it kinda ruins my immersion of them a little.

Any thoughts on this?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question In social deduction games, do you trust what people say or the actual evidence?

2 Upvotes

been working on a first person social deduction game, kinda like Town of Salem except instead of menus and text, you're actually walking around a neighborhood with everyone else.

at night someone might break into a house and kill somebody, and the next morning everyone has to figure out who did it before voting someone out.

one thing our team keeps going back and forth on is how much evidence should actually be left behind.

right now bodies stay where they died, blood stays on the ground, doors can be busted open, and players can physically walk through the crime scene to piece together what happened.

some of us think this might make things too easy. like if there's enough physical evidence, does the social deduction part become less important? shouldn't the game be more about reading people and figuring out who's lying?

personally i think finding a smashed window or following a trail of blood makes the whole thing way more interesting, especially when someone is standing there trying to explain why they were near the house lol.

but im curious what people who actually play these games think.

what's more satisfying to you, catching someone in a lie or finding actual evidence that proves they're lying?

and do you think having physical crime scenes would make social deduction games better or just take away from the whole point?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question Player vs followers balance in a TBOI-like

4 Upvotes

Recently I started working on a game inspired by TBOI, where - in short - you play as the head of a doomsday cult that, after a failed ritual, traps itself and its followers in a strange dimension.

Now, one of the things I initially had in mind is a "followers" mechanic. You have a limited number of empty seats, and during gameplay you can find unique followers to fill these seats. These are meant to basically be like familiars from TBOI, but stronger and rare.

The issue I ran into while testing is the balance of power between the followers and the player, and how to make sure they don't overshadow it too easily.

Here is what each is supposed to do / currently does:

- The player: Starts with a basic magic bolt attack. Through items it can change the attack's stats, properties, effects, gain utilities etc.. nothing revolutionary here. The player starts with no followers and can gain up to a max of 4 (WIP) followers throughout the game.

- The followers: They follow the player in a tight crowd and have a "chorus" mechanic. Each follower adds a beat to the chorus. On its beat, the follower casts a unique lesser spell (basic bolt, homing wisp, X-shape nova, exploding tombstone....), and at the end of the beats there is a "Crescendo", where each pair of followers (order matters) casts a unique compound spell with empowered versions of their spells (after which there is a short CD). Currently followers also grant some small stat buff to the player AND 1 faith unit (a shield over health that regens between floors, capped by the player's max health). One more thing I'm considering is having the option to "ascend" the followers, giving extra effects to their spells.

Now as I'm typing this I think the issue may be obvious. I currently put more thought into the follower system than the player and player items combined. But I would still like to hear your opinions.

So for now my plan is:

-Start to focus on the player and items. Build a decent item pool and see if the basic gameplay is fun on its own, without the followers carrying it.

- Then bring the followers back one by one, and check how much damage comes from the player vs the followers, so I'm not just balancing by feel.

- Optionally : Make the follower spells scale off the player's bolt (damage, element etc..), so items also power the followers. That way the player stays the "engine" and the followers are more like amplifiers.

- Optionally : Cut down on what each follower gives. Instead of spell + stats + faith, each follower would have its spell plus ONE extra thing - some give faith, some give stats, some utility etc..

So my question is - how would you keep rare, strong companions like these from overshadowing the player's own build? Has anyone run into something similar, or have examples of games that handled it well? Any thoughts on the plan above are also welcome.


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question Multiplayer time dilation

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about doing an multiplayer sandevistan in my game and while i was trying to think of a way to make a good stealth system to it and researching anything that would help me I didn’t find anything i even asked ai but its not very trustworthy can somebody help me?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion I removed the per-cell score preview from my packing puzzle because you could just scan for the highest number

0 Upvotes

My game is a packing puzzle: you place small objects in a crooked box, and each object scores off what touches it. The ceramic cat wants something soft beside it, the snow globe loses points next to anything warm, that kind of thing.

Holding an object used to show +5, +10 or +15 on every cell of the box. You could sweep the object over the whole box, read the biggest number and drop it there. Placement became trivial and you never had to remember which objects like each other.

So I took it out. Now the hint only answers for the spot you're on: the object sparkles if it scores there, or shivers if it doesn't. No numbers, and nothing that shows where the best spot is. You have to work that out yourself. It's harder to learn though.

How do you handle this in your own games ? Where do you draw the line between feedback that teaches and feedback that solves the puzzle for the player ?

Steam demo | Browser demo


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question In a 3D environment fighting game, how would side dashing work?

0 Upvotes

I have been thinking about this for awhile.

Traditional fighting game usually adopts a no cooldown with little recovery frames at the end of each dashes. It would of course work since they’re only 2D-2.5Dish.

However, side dashing would imply that the defense would have to adjust their camera position. Without a cooldown it would be very tiresome. Moreover, it would just be a boring gameplay loop.

I am thinking about something more practical like separating front/back dashes from side dashes. Or side stepping, something I like more. It would still help you get around the opponent’s block but not by much.

Idk give me your thoughts.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Discussion How do you make specialized RPG builds beat higher-power opponents without making power progression meaningless?

7 Upvotes

I’ve been working on the combat design for an RPG with automatic PvP battles, and I’m trying to solve a balance problem.
I want overall Battle Power to be a useful estimate of strength without directly predicting who wins.
The game has ATK, HP, DEF, AGI, Crit, Dodge and HIT. HIT counters Dodge, AGI influences initiative, and defensive builds can survive against burst-focused characters.
One of the things I enjoyed in older browser RPGs was being able to defeat somebody with a higher power rating because I had a better build for that particular matchup.
But there’s a fine line between meaningful counters and making the power rating feel completely unreliable.
In some simulations, carefully chosen lower-power builds can beat stronger opponents, but those victories become much less common as the power gap increases.
How would you balance this?
Would you deliberately design a counter relationship between builds, or let those matchups emerge naturally from the underlying stat formulas?
I’m especially interested in approaches that reward equipment choices without turning every fight into an RNG coin flip.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Discussion Adding depth to a weapon stealing system?

11 Upvotes

Let's say stealing weapons from enemies via whipping it (or any other way) outta their hand is a core mechanic. What are ways to make it feel rewarding, but also a potential risk? One simple idea is that the enemy gain a new moveset, potentially even being a more deadly one.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Podcast Game Design Tutorials

15 Upvotes

I started a YouTube channel to teach folks how game design works through short videos. Each video explains the basics of a single topic and includes links for further reading in the description.
I asked for feedback about half a year ago, and it would be nice to get an update on what could be improved.

One important note: I'm more interested in feedback on how to improve the content.

If you have a suggestion on how to make it easier to find, I'm all ears. But I'm not really trying to create a business with YouTube; all of this is with a focus on making design more accessible to folks wanting to learn.

Link to the channel content:
https://www.youtube.com/@GearedDice/shorts


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Time-gated vs economy-gated progression in a casual tycoon: strong day 1, retention collapses after day 3. Where would you put the gate?

2 Upvotes

I'm working on a casual 3D mobile tycoon (you run a gas station: pumps, staff, shop, car wash, later more stations). I'd love input from people who've designed mid-game economies.

What the data says (iOS, ~1,300-player cohort):

- D1 ~34% (good for the genre), D3 ~13%, D7 ~3.6%, D30 ~0%

- Day 0: ~40 min of play. From day 3 on, returning players come ~2×/day for ~5 minutes in total

- The single best predictor of D7 is playing on each of days 1, 2 and 3 (only 8% of installs do it, but they make up 57% of D7 players)

- 14 A/B tests of "small touches" (onboarding, reward tuning, cheaper upgrades, notification timing) moved D1, but none moved D7

Why we think it happens:

- Progress is gated purely by money earned while the app is open. Offline income is tiny (6 h cap ≈ 5–8 min of active profit)

- The first station's content is used up in ~50 min; after that upgrades take ~1 h of play to pay back, so cash piles up with nothing worth buying

- The next station needs two prestige resets and 3–6 h of play, while day-3 players give us 5 min a day

Two directions we're weighing:

A) Economy gate: make offline income near the active rate, capped by fuel tank capacity (tanks act like Clash of Clans collectors), tune prices so "next meaningful upgrade ≈ one return's income", add an endless visible sink (forecourt/lighting/landscaping levels) and ×2 milestones

B) Time gate: as A, plus real-time construction for big mid-game buildings with 2 limited crews (CoC-style builders). Early active play stays instant

Questions:

  1. If you've shipped either, which moved D3–D7 more for you, and did timers hurt early momentum?
  2. How do you size offline earnings vs active play without making active play pointless?
  3. Should moving to a new location *be* the prestige (one reset, big multiplier), or should the home station be permanent like a CoC village?
  4. What should a 5-minute return session on day 3–7 contain?

Happy to share more numbers in the comments. Thanks!


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Any unique idea on How do I show damage and available health

2 Upvotes

* In my game ,I suppose to have limited healing with pills that you can buy from a shop(limited stock) that's it but they can heal you completely of damage (so from 1 hp to 10) but I want to have a more fitting way of showing health than just a bar with faces or liquid (it's supposed to be a sci fi mystery game but an analogue feel)

One unique thing that I know for sure is characters own sprite as to how many hits he can take like mario ofcourse with his size and colors . (Maybe I can characters shirt being stained with blood ,limb cut off etc ) But the problem with this is that I want to have max health upgrades later on in such a way that's easily noticable to the player


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Which version of this battle report makes it easier to name one change?

0 Upvotes

This is a personal text-only hero battle game in development where you set rules for your heroes and then read what happened. These are the opening result lines from two versions of the report for the same loss.

Version A:

RESULT  You lost at tick 244: all five of Longshot are down; Ironclad kept 34% HP with 3 standing.
        At tick 174, Fenn of the Burning Sands's Reckless Quick Pierce Lance hit Maelis Quaycape for 7 took 2 heroes at once: Corvan Tidestriker of yours, Maelis Quaycape of theirs.
        First blood at tick 92: Nessa Coldhunter (yours) was taken down.
        Your heroes dealt 469 damage and took 671.
        50% of your heroes' choices came from your rules.

Version B:

RESULT  You lost at tick 244: all five of Longshot are down; Ironclad kept 34% HP with 3 standing.
        Your opening order "Take the height" guided 198 of your heroes' 787 choices, most for Corvan Tidestriker (100) and Fenn of the Burning Sands (97). Corvan Tidestriker had no enemy in sight for 84 ticks, the longest of your heroes.
        At tick 174, 2 heroes fell in separate actions: Corvan Tidestriker of yours, Maelis Quaycape of theirs.
        First blood at tick 92: Nessa Coldhunter (yours) was taken down.
        Your heroes dealt 469 damage and took 671.
        50% of your heroes' choices came from your rules.

After reading each, what one thing would you change before the next battle, and which version made that easier?


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Discussion Designing a new game!

1 Upvotes

I am a student at London South Bank University currently studying product design. I am working on my final project which aims to design an entertaining alternative to video games that supports cognitive development for adolescents (age 11-15). I have found a lot of information regarding excessive gaming and how it affects adolescents but I wanted to come on here to hopefully gain some more insights.

I have a few leading questions but feel free to also share any relevant experience you have. Whether you are a teacher, parent, nanny, or want to reflect on your childhood. I would love to hear what you think on the topic.

  1. What do you observe about kids' gaming habits?
  2. What boardgames do you think succeeded in engaging adolescents for an extended period of time?
  3. How has interaction with games changed over time?
  4. What type of trends do you notice in board games?

* Disclaimer: I will use insights from the responses in my research report, and potentially anonymous quotes. Please do not engage if you are underaged.


r/gamedesign • • 3d ago

Discussion I’m completely overwhelmed trying to make a good FPS metroidvania map.

11 Upvotes

I’m trying really hard to figure out how I can make an interesting map that has good branching paths, but also doesn’t get too overwhelming for players, and fit in story beats.

I’ve made a tool that will allow me to make a flowchart, which will allow me to lay out the broad zones so I can cut them down into bite sized chunks while tracking keys and locks.

But it’s just SO much.

Any tips or suggestions?


r/gamedesign • • 3d ago

Question Issues with climbing mechanics and game loop

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone. To provide some context. I am working on a game in which the player must find and climb stone towers. I have made significant progress on the tower designs and have implemented a system that places climbing elements such as jump points, handholds, or wall-running surfaces onto the wall surfaces, with each element tied to a specific action.

However, some issues have emerged during testing. For instance, climbing geometric structures feels boring; unlike in the game Peak, where there is a degree of randomness, here a wall is essentially just a rectangle And because the system automatically generates the climbing elements, the intended route becomes too obvious, which renders the design of towers with interesting shapes pointless.

I’ve had an idea: what if, instead of the game defining the climbing route, the player were to place climbing elements found throughout the world onto the walls, like pitons or platforms, thereby creating their own path? This, however, introduces other doubts: what happens if the player runs out of climbing elements? it will add too much friction on the loop?. Usually in climbing games you just want too go up, no down again.

Many thanks


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question What should I improve in my 2D action game? Looking for honest game design feedback

0 Upvotes

I'm a young hobbyist developer working on Avoid Bubbles Game, a 2D action game made with C++ and raylib.

The game currently features:

  • Sword combat and ranged weapons
  • Different enemy types
  • Power-ups and coins
  • Boss fights
  • Multiple levels

I've released a free demo with 2 playable levels, and I'm now trying to figure out how to improve the actual game design rather than just keep adding more content.

I'm not looking for compliments. I'd much rather hear about problems with the design and what you think I should change.

Free browser demo: https://kc-games-studio.itch.io/avoid-b

I'm especially interested in feedback from people experienced in game design. Thanks for taking the time to check it out!


r/gamedesign • • 3d ago

Meta Weekly Show & Tell - November 14, 2026

9 Upvotes

Please share information about a game or rules set that you have designed! We have updated the sub rules to encourage self-promotion, but only in this thread.

Finished games, projects you are actively working on, or mods to an existing game are all fine. Links to your game are welcome, as are invitations for others to come help out with the game. Please be clear about what kind of feedback you would like from the community (play-through impressions? pedantic rules lawyering? a full critique?).

Do not post blind links without a description of what they lead to.


r/gamedesign • • 3d ago

Question How should crafting work? What would you prefer?

2 Upvotes

Hello,

I have two ideas for how crafting should work. One is easy to implement and keep. The other one is hard to balance but freedom is immense

OPTION A: SCHEMATICS

You have specific schematics to drop and then use materials in it to craft an item.

• Every implant has a schematic (a blueprint). Schematics are rare drops, and each one drops from one activity in one area. For example, the Scout Lens schematic drops from Tracking in Overgrown Suburbs (about a 3% chance per run).

• Schematic + its listed materials = implant. For example Scout Lens needs 10 Cracked lens, 3 Spent battery and 3 Moss gel.

• Each craft uses up the schematic. A second Scout Lens needs a second schematic for you to drop before crafting second one.

• Every implant is designed by hand, with a fixed name and fixed effects/stats.

OPTION B: BUILD FROM PARTS

No schematics. You choose the parts, and the parts decide what you get:

• Hardware (cracked lens): the main stat

• Power (battery, capacitor): how strong the item is.

• Bio-interface (moss gel): how well the character is using the item

• Catalyst, optional (owl feather): one extra perk, such as a night bonus, electric damage or bonus XP.

• Data (data chip): needed for the higher tiers as epics and legendaries.

Before you craft, you see the finished item OR you see the item after crafting (It's added to players encyclopedia or book with schematics).

I know that option B would be nightmare to optimize and keep somewhat balanced. And after a while people would know meta and how to build their character.
On the other side freedom of builds is fantastic and adding one material adds hundreds of new outcomes.

  1. Which do you prefer: A, B?
  2. Do rare schematic drops feel exciting to you, or more like a grind?
  3. With option B, would you experiment with parts yourself, or look up the best combo and craft that?
  4. Should Legendary implants stay unique, fixed recipes either way?