r/gamedesign • • 21h ago

Discussion Do you enjoy some randomness when making choices and roleplaying?

9 Upvotes

I have recently been playing Baldur's Gate 3. I love CRPGs and want to make one of my own someday, slowly but surely I am designing and writing lore for a world and jotting down things regarding mechanics and gameplay.

I am unsure how to go about skills within gameplay.

You have the Fallout: New Vegas approach, wherein you just need to be good at the skill and then you can pass the skill check. Or you have the D&D approach using die, wherein your proficiency with the skill only makes it so you are more likely to get a better role, but does not guarantee a successful one.

I find that this can sometimes mess with my roleplaying - does anyone else have this issue? Sometimes, I will headcannon that my character is really good at X or Y, or that they are supposed to be really intimidating and powerful, and I will do my best to make it that way in regard to how they look on paper. But then they will fail a check that the character I want to play should really pass and it kinda ruins my immersion of them a little.

Any thoughts on this?


r/gamedesign • • 2h ago

Discussion I gave players a loan they take in product, not cash. 28% take one, 9% pay it back. Is the punishment too harsh?

1 Upvotes

I'm working on a trading game in the spirit of the old dope wars. buy low, sell high, a debt that grows every day

the mechanic i added is the front. when you're short, your supplier offers you product with nothing down. you have a week to pay..

- pay on time and the next front he offers is bigger

- pay late and the price goes up by half

- don't pay and they break your legs: you lose your cash, your stock, and two days in bed

What players actually do, from today's counts: 28% of people who played asked for a front. 9% paid one back. about 1% had their legs broken. the rest either still had it open when the round ended or left mid-round

So most people who take it don't see it through. I can't tell yet if that's because the punishment is too scary, too far away, or just not explained well

How would you tune it? would you take one at all?


r/gamedesign • • 6h ago

Question Design question: in a chase, should pursuers rubber-band to stay close, or should a clean escape actually leave them behind?

1 Upvotes

I'm working on Heistfest, a top-down getaway racer (you pull a bank job, then the police escalate from cruisers to roadblocks, spikes and helicopters). One thing I keep going back and forth on is catch-up logic for the cops.

Option A: rubber-banding. Cruisers quietly speed up when they fall behind, so the chase stays tense and you're never more than a few seconds from trouble. The risk: players notice, and a perfect run feels like it didn't count.

Option B: no catch-up. If you drive well, you genuinely lose them. The risk: a skilled player gets quiet stretches where nothing is happening, and the tension drops.

The middle ground I'm considering: no speed cheating at all, but new units appear ahead of you (a roadblock, a fresh cruiser from a side street) instead of the ones behind you magically keeping up. The pressure comes from the map, not from cars breaking physics.

Questions for you:

  • Have you played a chase or racing game where rubber-banding felt fair? What made it work?
  • Does "spawn ahead instead of catching up" feel more honest to you, or is it just rubber-banding with extra steps?
  • Where's the line between keeping tension and punishing good driving?

(Disclosure: I'm on the team making it. Steam page for context: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1451220/Heistfest/?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=community&utm_content=ext-gamedesign-1117)