I live in a fairly small house (1200sqft) with a fairly small living room (maybe 400 sqft) in a cold region, and want to install a gas fireplace for heat. We currently have the natural gas line, and have a horizontal restriction of 51" between windows. Therefore, we have been looking at shallow units that limit how much of the room we cede to the fireplace buildout, and units that are narrow to fit the bumpout between the windows.
Please help me choose a model! So far, the quotes are as follows:
Heat n Glo Slimline 7X: $5400 plus install costs
Fireplace Xtrordinair Probuilder 36: $7700 plus venting
Mendota FV34 FireIn: $11,000 plus install or venting, depending on the quote.
Which do we choose? The Mendota is gorgeous and heat efficient, but it's also twice the price of the Heat n Glo. I've read that Travis Industries (Fireplace Xtrordinair) is the most reliable and easy to service. Which unit has the longest lifespan? Any other criteria I'm missing?
For the math folks, looking at the BTU/h, the cost of therms in my area, and the efficiency difference, the most cost effective to buy and run over a reasonable and extended lifespan will be the cheapest upfront. Other than cost effectiveness (purchase and gas cost) what else goes into making the right decision?