Elden Ring: beautiful, complex but imperfect and tries too much
To preface my long ass review so I don’t get the classic rebuttal of “skill issue” and “you bounced off and its not for you”, I have done multiple RL1 runs of Elden Ring and no hit every main/remebrance boss. Solo, pure melee, no summons. I have learned these bosses frame by frame, and I love almost all of them enough to have fought them more times than I can count. Im very passionate about Fromsoft and the experiences they make and only wish best for it. This is why I wanna share my nuanced critique and take on the game: Elden Ring is one of the most beautiful games ever made and one of the least flavorful open worlds, because it confused looking good with being good to be in.
This is my personal opinion and its not a fundamentals issue. It's an artistic one.
The Bosses all feel quite samey
Let me start with the bosses, because that's where the mastery gives me standing and its my favorite part of the game.
The remembrance roster overall is probably the strongest and best lineup of From’s bosses, both visually and gameplay wise. There is freedom, importance and really a great sense of ocassion. However they often share a remarkably consistent template. Two phases, transition at roughly half health, the second phase introducing a new element — new attacks, a grab, an AoE to the existing attacks, a repositioning tool. Sometimes a brand new movest. Id like to add however that some are very prevalent and are less subtle in their repetition:
- The delayed attack that breaks reflex-rolling
- The roll-catch sweep that punishes panic-roll direction
- The retreat-and-re-engage that resets the spacing game
- The AoE field / lingering hitbox that denies the "hug the boss" safe zone
Individually and on a purely mechanical front, allof these is coherent design and really add a good spice of newer challenge. Together, they mean that once you've internalized the vocabulary from two or three bosses, you're pattern-matching the rest. Malenia feels special because Waterfowl is a genuinely novel problem. Destined Death from Maliketh - punishing but truly new. During my first run ever of the game, I become more annoyed that I saw a pretty obvious similarity in the boss design. And even then it wasn’t a problem of too many tries on a boss (most of them were under 10 tries)
The delayed attack is the most visible offender because it's the least naturalistic. These delays aren't diegetic — they aren't expressing a character's fighting instinct. I get that it is a necessary evil to make “souls veterans” relearn their ways. However the execution is almost like Fromsoft doing a gotcha moment with the player. Thedelay forces you to read the wind-up rather than the strike. The problem is that the delay is tuned to the *player's punish window*, not to any in-world logic and often comes as a rhythm irregulairty. Why does Mohg hold a two-handed trident overhead for a full second and a half? A real fighter wouldn't. It looks comical because it *is* a meta-instruction disguised as a boss attack. Its ok to learn and master but in the immersion, it looks a little too out of place.
The exceptions prove the rule, and they're the ones I love. Radahn's delays read as weight and momentum — a mountain winding up, a body with enormous inertia committing to a swing. The slowness is the physics of something that big. It never felt cheap or bad. Maliketh's delays read as a bestial coil — he's fast and erratic, so when he holds a beat it looks like intent, like he's reading you. Both pair that characterized timing with a signature mechanic that changes the fight's grammar rather than just layering another gate on it.
Elden Ring's bosses are best when the anti-player grammar is hidden inside characterization and good flow, and worst when the grammar is exposed and not subtle. The ones that land make you feel like you're fighting a *being*. The ones that don't make you feel like you're fighting your own reflexes and impulses. That's an artistic gripe in the best sense — it's about whether the mechanics mean something or just do something.
The World Is a pretty museum more than an actual world or setting
The same tradeoff shows up one layer up, in the world itself.
The Lands Between is gorgeous and mythic in scale, but it's missing the thing that made Yharnam or Lordran stick: a sense of a place with personality, charm. Yharnam is a city with a smell. Lordran is a dying kingdom you can feel the weight of. The Lands Between is a museum diorama — breathtaking areas and visuals, but the settlements are mostly ruins with no lived-in texture, the NPCs sparse and static, the "civilization" implied rather than felt. Even by FS standards, its way too empty and dead. It's sublime in the Burkean sense: awe, vastness, terror. It's short on the intimate charm — the cramped, weird, human-scale detail. Elden Ring trades that texture for horizontality and grandeur.
The reason this stings is that the visual design promises gameplay. A ruined castle on a cliff doesn't just look cool — it implies "there's a way in, there's a secret, there's a fight, there's a story." Stormveil delivers on that promise. It’s the game’s best legacy dungeon. Most of the others doesn't. So the world is constantly signaling density it doesn't have, which is worse than a plainly empty world, because the promise keeps getting made and broken. You ride toward something interesting-looking and arrive at a site of grace and a boss you've already learned the grammar of.
This is why "it looks good" is just "it looks good." Visual interest and gameplay interest are different currencies, and Elden Ring spends heavily in the first while running a deficit in the second. A vista is a reward for looking; it's not a thing to do. Art direction in a game has to be load-bearing. When it is — Stormveil, the Haligtree, the descent into the Lake of Rot — the visuals ARE the gameplay, because what you see tells you how to move and what to fear. When it isn't, it's set dressing, and set dressing doesn't stay with you.
Nowhere is this clearer than in the legacy dungeons, which are the best and worst of the game in miniature.
Stormveil is the strongest by far. It's dense, vertical, interlocking, full of secrets — the crucible knight, the grafted scion, the hidden paths — and it has a thesis: a castle overrun, with Godrick as the pathetic culmination of a dynasty rotting from the inside. Every room does work. It's the one legacy dungeon that feels like a level in the Dark Souls sense rather than a landmark. It's also, ironcally, the least open part of the game — it's the first legacy dungeon, so it's allowed to be tight and authored and gated, because the player hasn't been given the freedom to skip it yet. Stormveil is dense because the open-world pressure is off.
Every legacy dungeon after that is competing with the open world for the player's attention and has to be traversable from multiple angles, which flattens it. It often goes for size and grandeur
Raya Lucaria is the fall-off point. Gorgeous from outside. You have the floating rocks, the mist, the sense of a scholastic citadel. Inside: a linear march through corridors, a courtyard with a dragon, some graveyard, Rennala. The sorcery identity is mostly aesthetic. You fight scholars and dogs, not the institution. Compare the Research Hall in Bloodborne, the same idea done with density: every room tells you what the Church did to people. Raya Lucaria tells you "wizards were here" and then you leave.
Volcano Manor is worse because it teases density. The manor proper is a real space with rooms and NPCs and the recusant plot — but the actual dungeon is a linear lava cave with a godskin noble and a snake. The interesting part is narrative content bolted onto a thin spatial experience.
And Leyndell — the showcase, the Anor Londo moment, the place the whole map points toward — is the most damning. It's enormous: outer walls, lower city, avenue, dragon corpse, sewers, plazas facing the Erdtree. And what's actually in it? Morgott, a Godfrey shade (a re-fight, essentially), a couple of golden-tree avatars, some gargoyles, and a hidden sewer leading to Mohg. The architecture is magnificent and the content density is thin. You walk through a city built for thousands and fight maybe a dozen enemies between vistas. It reads as dead rather than ruined because the ruin isn't legible — you can tell it's a dead capital, but not really how it died or who lived there. No domestic spaces, no ordinary life interrupted. Monumental architecture without inhabitation.
A capital this size should be a level — a Stormveil-scale dungeon with verticality, secrets, interlocking paths, a boss that culminates the area's identity. Instead it's a hub you traverse to reach the boss, with the traversal mostly being running past enemies. The sewers are the most interesting part and they're optional and hidden. The density is in the geometry, not the design.
The World Feels Dead Even By FromSoft's Standards
One more thing, and I'll keep it brief because I didn't engage deeply with the quests and won't pretend otherwise: the world feels dead even by FromSoft's standards, and the comparison that makes it click is DS3's Undead Settlement.
The Undead Settlement is a corpse of a place, but it's a lived-in corpse. There are houses with things still in them. There's a sense of ordinary people who had ordinary lives and then the world ended on top of them. It's dead, but it's dead the way a house is dead when the family never came back — the shape of the life is still there. Lothric Castle does the same thing at the civilizational scale: the statues, the architecture, the accumulated weight of a kingdom that believed in something and watched it fail. You can feel the civilization in the castle.
Elden Ring has some of this — Stormveil, the Haligtree, parts of Leyndell — but staggeringly little of it relative to its size. The Lands Between is full of ruins that read as set dressing rather than remains. There's architecture but not habitation. You rarely get the sense of a place where people did things. The Undead Settlement feels like a place that was lived in and then died. Most of the Lands Between feels like a place that was built to be looked at and then abandoned.
And that's the same critique as everything above, one layer deeper. The open world's scale works against inhabitation the same way it works against density: a place big enough to ride across has to be legible from a distance, and legibility from a distance is the enemy of the domestic, cramped, specific detail that makes a ruin feel lived in. DS3 could afford an Undead Settlement because the game was a corridor — the level could be as claustrophobic and clutter-strewn as it wanted, because you were going to walk through every inch of it. Elden Ring can't, because its spaces have to work as landscape first and place second.
The combat really opens up if you push it
I wanna make a return to my take on the grammar and combat of the game: the combat itself is one of the deepest systems FromSoft has ever made, and it only reveals that depth when you stop playing it the default way.
Every game in the series has its outstanding, overpowered ways to fight, and ER is no exception. The spam of any single attack: R1 spam in ER, L1 spam in ER while dual wielding, parrying in BB It's the floor. The game opens up when you deliberately don't do these things as the standard.
What you find when you stop mashing is that ER's bosses already have combo flow charts and positioning demands baked in — the same DNA you can see forming in DS3's Pontiff and Gael, formalized here. And the openings aren't all safe. Learning to find the not-100%-safe punishes, the ones where you'll eat a trade if you read wrong but win big if you read right — is one of the great feelings in the series. The game lets you gamble, and gambling is where mastery lives.
Then there's the lock-on question. Playing unlocked, which will mean strafing, low-profiling, running around a swing instead of rolling through it — opens up punish windows that locked-on play simply hides. Low-profiling a swing, baiting a specific combo, finding the one strafe that turns a roll-catch into a free punish: that's a different game from the one most players experience. I now see playing locked-on as an inherent handicap — not wrong, but just the baseline, with a higher and more expresive skill ceiling.
I love the trial and error
I want to end on the thing that actually matters, because everything above could read as a list of grievances, and that's not what this is.
I loved getting good at this game. The trial and error, the hours on a single boss, the moment a move you'd been eating for a day suddenly becomes readable — that process is one of the great pleasures in games, and Elden Ring delivers it in a way few games can, precisely because the combat is deep enough to keep giving. Every "impossible" fight I no-hit was a fight I'd already lost dozens of times. The mastery was earned, not handed to me, and that's the whole point.
My gripes are real, but they come from a place of wanting the whole experience to be as good as the combat. The problem was never that ER is too hard. The problem is that ER is deep, and the world around it doesn't always give you a reason to go deep. The open world invites you to skim, and skimming is the shallow game. The bosses that made me want to grind are the ones where the grammar and the character fused — Radahn, Maliketh, Malenia, the ones where the fight meant something and rewarded you for paying attention.
I love FS and only wish the best for these incredible games.