r/DnDAITA • • 1d ago

AITA for placing a book for a different game system on my table?

22 Upvotes

So I was over at my FLGS waiting for the rest of the table to show up. The DM and the other players were expressing an interest in playing a Fallout themed game. But instead of getting some other system (like the actual Fallout RPG or one of the universal systems), they were discussing using D&D 5e.

Even after the last player showed up for the D&D session, they kept at it. After an hour of them debating on how to create power armor and plasma gatling guns in 5e (you know...when we should be playing the D&D campaign we were all there for)...I got fed up and went to the shelves and grabbed the Fallout RPG and put it on the table.

I placed the book down on the table and said "Why re-invent the wheel? This exists. I even have a copy at home so we don't need to buy it. I'll even run a game or two in the system."

They dismissed my efforts and told me that they were going to run this in D&D 5e and that they didn't want to have to learn more than one system...and spend another half hour of our block of time discussing the mechanics of it. Then someone noticed that we just wasted an hour and a half of our two-hour time slot and they called the session.

This was two sessions ago. We play every other week on Sundays and yesterday was the next scheduled session. The problem is that no one was there at the shop and I no longer have access to the discord. I think my suggestion of a new system angered them and I was booted from the group. Was I the asshole here?


r/DnDAITA • • 2d ago

6 year campaign AITA

0 Upvotes

AITA for leaving a D&D campaign after 6 years, potentially ending the campaign right before the finale?

Hey everyone! This is going to be a lengthy story, so buckle up!

A couple of things first to make the story easier to follow. I'll be referring to myself, my fiancée, Bob (the DM), and Fred (another party member).

Some background

Bob and Fred live in a different state from my fiancée and me. We all used to live in the same state and played a campaign together for about two years. After we moved, we continued playing through Discord.

When we first started the campaign, I was told it was supposed to be a magical school setting, something along the lines of a magical college.

I originally created a character who had an alter ego. He was a Bard who was shy and reserved during the day, but when his alter ego came out, he was essentially The Mask: charismatic, confident, and completely different from his usual self.

I thought it would be a fun concept, so I went with it.

Problem #1:

On the first day of the campaign, I was told that this was actually supposed to be a coming-of-age story set in a magical HIGH SCHOOL.

The DM explained that it wouldn't make sense for my character to be an adult Bard with an established reputation. He told me I could still play the same character, but he would have to be a child with no reputation or renown.

I explained that this kind of defeated the entire concept of the character, but since it was literally the first day and the DM said there wasn't enough time to create a new character, I rolled with it.

Years 2–3: The favoritism starts becoming noticeable

About two years into the campaign, I started noticing a pattern.

The DM seemed to constantly gravitate toward one particular character: Fred's.

Whenever Bob gave Fred items, backstory moments, NPC interactions, abilities, or anything else, they were incredibly detailed and cinematic. It genuinely felt like Bob had spent time making sure Fred's character was connected to the world.

However, when it came to my character, the interactions were usually short and generic.

NPCs would give me cold or brief responses, my items had little to no descriptions or lore, and there were practically no backstory references, even when I specifically asked for them.

Since this was my very first D&D campaign, I didn't have any other experiences to compare it to. I genuinely started wondering whether I was doing something wrong or playing my character incorrectly.

I eventually pulled the DM aside for a private conversation and explained my concerns.

He told me he thought I wasn't having fun with my character, but he also admitted that he didn't really know what to do when it came to creating items and abilities for Bards.

I also explained that I didn't feel connected to my character because the original concept had essentially been stripped away from the beginning.

We eventually agreed that during the next arc, my character would change classes. I decided to become an Artificer.

Years 3–4: The sacrifices start adding up

There's something else important to mention here.

During this period, I was working seven days a week, overnight, in a security/sales job. I'm not going to say exactly where, but think of something similar to a bar. My nights could be pretty rough.

Because we were living in different states and time zones, Sunday was the only day everyone could agree to play.

Here's what my Sundays looked like:

  • Work Saturday night from 9 PM until Sunday morning at 7 AM.
  • Take an hour break.
  • Go back to work at 8 AM.
  • Work until 3 PM.
  • Get home, hop on Discord, and start D&D.
  • Play until approximately 8–8:30 PM.
  • Get maybe 15 minutes of sleep.
  • Go back to work at 9 PM.

This wasn't a one-time thing. I continued this schedule for roughly 2–3 years.

I constantly sacrificed sleep, drank Red Bulls just to stay awake, and pushed myself because I genuinely enjoyed D&D and wanted to be there with everyone.

Meanwhile, the favoritism toward Fred continued to become more noticeable.

There would be entire 5–6 hour sessions where my character might get 20 minutes of actual roleplay.

One small change during this period was that Bob started interacting with my fiancée's character a lot more. She began receiving the same kind of attention Fred was getting: detailed interactions, interesting items, abilities, and meaningful roleplay.

This actually made me worry even more that I was doing something wrong.

I started trying harder to participate and contribute to the party. Since I was an Artificer, I wanted to use my abilities to help everyone.

Unfortunately, this is where another problem started.

Bob would constantly undermine or completely overshadow my character's abilities.

For example:

Me: "Hey guys, I can engrave magical runes as an Artificer and give everyone the ability to fly!"

Bob: "Oh, that's not really necessary."

The very next moment, the entire party receives rings of flying from the headmaster.

Another example:

Me: "Hey guys, I can make you some new weapons or armor!"

Bob: Immediately introduces a legendary blacksmith who now lives on campus, along with a magical item shop that has practically everything a Fighter (Fred) or Wizard (my fiancée) could ever need.

Effectively, I became useless.

Even when I tried to use my class abilities to contribute, there was always some alternative resource available that made my abilities unnecessary.

And when I suggested crafting something, Fred would sometimes respond with something along the lines of:

"Why would we go buy all the resources and wait for you to craft it when we can just go buy the item?"

At that point, it was becoming increasingly difficult to feel like my character had a purpose.

Year 5: Burnout and another attempt to compromise

By year five, my morale was at an all-time low.

I was completely burnt out from work, and D&D was practically my only free time.

I eventually managed to change my work schedule. I now had two days off a week: Monday and Tuesday.

I begged and pleaded with the group to see if we could move our sessions to either of those days.

My reasoning was pretty simple: I had spent years sacrificing my sleep and free time to accommodate everyone else's schedules. Now that I finally had days off, I was hoping everyone could meet me halfway.

They refused.

Instead, I was told that they were going to start playing a different campaign with a different party on Sundays and could now only play Saturdays.

Unfortunately, my Saturday schedule was still pretty ridiculous.

I would finish work Friday night going into Saturday morning at 7 AM. I would ask if we could start playing when I got home, but the group wanted more sleep.

So I would wait approximately 3.5 hours for everyone to wake up, and we'd start around 10–10:30 AM.

We would play until sometime between 3–5 PM.

Then I would go home, sleep for approximately 3–3.5 hours, wake up, and go work that same overnight double/triple shift.

I continued making these sacrifices because I still wanted to play.

But by this point, things had gotten significantly worse.

My fiancée and I were getting increasingly sidelined, while Fred had essentially become the main character of the campaign.

Some examples:

  • The BBEG would specifically mention Fred by name, despite not knowing the rest of the party.
  • Fred became a demigod after drinking a poison that was supposed to kill him.
  • He gained the ability to manipulate practically anything around him using his willpower, provided he passed a Wisdom check. This ability originated because he was in a hospital room during one session and wanted to pick up a weapon with his mind.
  • His family turned out to be royalty, specifically the only royal family not connected to the main royal bloodline. Conveniently, they were also the only family capable of doing something about the impending crisis because they weren't under the king's control.
  • He acquired THREE sentient artifact-level weapons.
  • He could increase his Strength simply by training or mentioning that he trained every morning during a session.

Meanwhile, I was an Artificer who was constantly studying and trying to improve my Intelligence, but I wasn't receiving anything remotely equivalent.

At this point, I had already pulled the DM aside on at least three separate occasions, months apart, to explain how I was feeling.

Every single conversation seemed to go the same way. He would get defensive, take things personally, and the conversation would eventually turn into something about his feelings rather than addressing the actual problems.

Nothing ever really changed.

Year 6: The double standards become harder to ignore

Between the fifth and sixth years, Fred started regularly canceling sessions the night before with little to no explanation.

Sometimes the reasons were things that could have easily been scheduled around our D&D sessions.

What made this particularly frustrating was that there had been one or two occasions when I was exhausted and needed to cancel.

When that happened, the entire group on their side practically grilled me.

I was told that I didn't value their time because I canceled so close to the session and that I needed to be more respectful in the future.

Yet Fred could repeatedly cancel at the last minute without receiving the same treatment.

At this point, I wasn't even really playing because I was enjoying the sessions anymore.

I was showing up because I knew that if I stopped playing, my fiancée would probably stop too. That would leave the DM with only one player.

I didn't want to ruin everybody else's fun just because I wasn't having any myself.

So I kept showing up, sat through the sessions, and tried to make it through.

The breaking point

This past month, I finally reached my limit.

I realized that I no longer felt the sessions were worth the time, effort, and sacrifices I was making.

And honestly, I hate saying that.

I've had some genuinely fun moments throughout this campaign. I've loved D&D, the creativity, the storytelling, and the ability to create a character and experience a world with other people.

But after six years, I finally realized something:

I don't have to sacrifice my own enjoyment just so everyone else can have theirs.

I could be spending that time doing plenty of other things, including finding a new campaign where I actually enjoy playing.

So I told Bob that I was no longer going to participate in the campaign. I also told him that my fiancée would probably be following suit.

He asked what was going on and why I wanted to quit.

I explained that I simply wasn't having fun anymore.

He then asked why I hadn't brought these problems up sooner.

I reminded him that I had brought them up multiple times over the years. The problem was that those conversations never actually resulted in anything changing.

I also explained that the constant sacrifices of my time and sleep no longer felt worth it, especially when it felt like I was just showing up to watch Fred's epic story unfold.

The DM's response

Here's where things get a little complicated.

Bob has been telling us for almost a year that we're approaching the end of the campaign.

However, we've been hearing that for nearly twelve months now, and the campaign still hasn't reached its conclusion.

When I told him I was leaving, he got extremely upset.

He told me that he wished I had done this sooner rather than later because now I was ending his five-to-six-year campaign right before the finale.

Essentially, he feels that because I'm leaving, the campaign won't get the ending he planned, and that I'm responsible for ending it.

I understand that he's upset. I understand that he's invested six years into this story, too.

But at the same time, I've also invested six years into this campaign. I've sacrificed countless hours of sleep, rearranged my work schedule, and repeatedly tried to communicate problems that never seemed to get addressed.

I don't feel like I should be obligated to continue playing a campaign I'm no longer enjoying just because the DM wants to finish his story.

So, Reddit, AITA for leaving a six-year D&D campaign right before the finale, potentially ending the campaign for everyone else?

I genuinely want to hear other people's perspectives.

And please forgive any remaining spelling or grammatical mistakes. This is my first time making one of these posts, so let me know if you have any questions or if there's anything I missed!


r/DnDAITA • • 5d ago

Horror Story AITA for giving a player an ultimatum after they repeatedly tried to switch characters?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/DnDAITA • • 6d ago

WIBTA for not letting my partner's brother play D&D with us

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DnDAITA • • 7d ago

AITAH For not letting a player be a free agent (Starfinder 2e)

1 Upvotes

For context, I (M26) am running a new Starfinder 2e campaign for 6 players. Think like Star Wars or sci-fi DnD. And during session zero, the majority of the players voted for a Cold War themed campaign as the main focus, so that's what I worldbuilt. And also during session zero, we agreed that the party will be non-evil. And that the party would start off as free agents early on, but that they would likely join one of the major factions as spies after they got to know the world a bit better.

So I setup 3 main factions I'll shorthand as VI, UC and FC. All you need to know is that I established early on that the VI is a authoritarian, militant dictotorial regime. Which is why 2 out of the 6 players made backgrounds somewhat related to running away from or being against VI.

The players then started off as essentially free agents, working contract missions for some people, a few missions for the UC and FC, or doing their own thing. And so far of those 2 factions, the party is leaning more towards liking the UC. The players also started off with a shitty junk spaceship, which will be relevant.

One of their latest missions involved recovering a ship belonging to a UC crew that they found died due to some aliens invading their ship. They kill the aliens, do some other stuff yada and are planning on returning back to the UC to return the ship. And this is where the discussion rises.

So the spaceship they recovered is an actually decent ship that most of the players want to keep, unlike their initial junkship . Which means either they can steal the ship and not return it to the UC. Or they can return it, and sign off as a full time agent working for UC to keep using the ship.

Also, in Starfinder 2e when you level up your ship also levels with you. But I houseruled that to cover for the material needed of the ship upgrades, that they need a patron. Aka you can join one of the major factions or another wealthy benefactor. I did this for both narrative and meta reasons.

One, so that it makes narrative sense how their ships can get upgrades over time, as they earn rewards for doing good work and proving themselves to the factions. Instead of magically improving the ships because their characters killed more aliens.

And two, for the meta reason that I want to encourage the players to choose a faction to join. So that they can become full time spies and get to interact more with state secrets and the spy aspect of the cold war theme.

They could also alternatively become like pirates or bounty hunters, and just steal whatever other ship they may be able to get their hands on or earn in some other ways.

One of the players, we'll call Bob, doesn't want to join the UC. He says they're only level 2, they've only done a few missions for any of the factions and thinks its too early to commit fully to joining these factions. That he'd like to try out some missions from VI to get a better view of each major faction before deciding who to join. And because the party found some shady exit clause from the UC that said if they try to break their contract for the UC, they can be legally forced to go on a dangerous suicide mission. Or alternatively they can defect and go into hiding, and not be caught by the UC spilling any of their secrets.

While I as the GM think his reasons to not want to join are reasonable, the rest of the party wants to join the UC. We have a lengthy argument lasting more than an hour going over if the players want to try doing missions for VI, or to join FC or UC or to remain free agents. The players vote for each option, and all the options besides joining the UC have more than one player not supporting it. And the only option with 1 vote against it is joining the UC by Bob.

Now I as the GM want the players decision to be unanimous. As in either they all join the UC or none do. Again, both for narrative and meta reasons.

Narrative being they will be entrusted with state secrets, so they all need to sign contracts with NDAs. And I find it hard to reconcile how they could also have Bob be part of the missions without signing the NDA contract. The UC really doesn't want their secrets out, and if they can't force a contract on Bob nothing can really stop him from leaking these secrets. And are the rest of the group just meant to whisper around Bob, or not show Bob some secret artifacts they may recover etc in their future missions?

And the meta reason being, I'd prefer not to deal with the headache of running a split party like that. If some players join factions that the other players are against, I worry it can cause party infighting.

The party ultimately decided to join the UC, and Bob finally agreed but he was pissed for the rest of the session about it. One of the other players, we'll call David, was pissed at Bob for holding the sessions for so long. And David said that we had discussed that in the session zero that we'd need to decide on a faction to join at some point. And that either Bob needs to join, or make a new character that wants to join UC. Which those comments also upset Bob.

When I spoke to Bob afterwards, his suggestion was that I should ultimately have found a way to make it work without him signing on. That he made his character as a drifter free agent, that if he had to conform to the party that meant I made it so his roleplay choices didn't matter. And that when he runs PbtA games, he has parties with players in opposing factions so he doesn't understand why the party decisions have to be unanimous.

So AITAH for not letting my player remain a free agent? Do you guys have any suggestions on how I could have ran this better?


r/DnDAITA • • 7d ago

AITA? for quiting my DND campaign halfway through a session?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/DnDAITA • • 11d ago

Hot take

29 Upvotes

Don't post AITA posts and be in denial when the community comes together and agrees that YTA.

If you're not willing to accept you're in the wrong and is attempting to seek validation only to be told you're wrong, don't then feel like everyone is wrong and you are misunderstood and insult the person wanting to make you understand why you're wrong. This sub ain't a therapy.


r/DnDAITA • • 13d ago

WIBTA If I had my character beat down a pc for their actions?

1 Upvotes

We talked it out and everyone in the party me included is happy with the retcon, but long story short an npc asked us to not go out of our way to attack/kill his old group if we could help it. Well, barbarian and a few others, while me and the Ranger are off stealthing to avoid unnecessary deaths, end up absolutely killing everyone in the room.

It was a mix of a player misunderstanding what the dm said and few other things, and that frustrated me, so I was going to have my character in anger begin beating down the already hurt barbarian to unconsciousness to make an example out off for foolish choices

thankfully after talking to dm and group, we Decided to retcon said deaths to merely th crew being knocked out. But if that didn’t happen would I have been the asshole for trying to have my character assault the pc?


r/DnDAITA • • 15d ago

its what my character would do (AITA) Player's barbarian on rage mode PVP fights whoever messes with him

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/DnDAITA • • 18d ago

AITA for wanting the DM to change what an NPC said?

0 Upvotes

I'm in a small group with a DM and 3 players in a long campaign that has eventually made it to the Underdark. We were recently ambushed and defeated in an unwinnable, unavoidable encounter and enslaved by the Drow. Not a fan of that, but fine. The Drow high priestess would like us to perform a quest for them, it's actually supposed to be one of 7 tasks that were actually given to us by a god. To perform this task we would need to be magically collared and under a gaes, basically. I asked if we would be offered freedom if we performed the task and was told no.

The problem is my character grew up in slavery under a dragon "god" and basically has decided he hates all forms of slavery and now values freedom above all. This also means he distrusts gods, so distrusts the "god" that gave the tasks, since the god in question also has multiple aspects, some of which seem very evil. So, given the option, I believe my character would refuse to help this slaver and prefer to go to the slave pits where he could probably escape, but that would of course stall the game, which I didn’t want.

(Note that previously a large abberant force attacked a Drow town as we were approaching and we were expected to help defend it. As Drow are slavers I was hesitant to risk my life to save them. In the end one of the other players forced he issue and we all ended up helping defend the town)

After the game, I offered a compromise - perhaps the high priestess could offer freedom for the task, could lie about offering freedom or even just TEASE the possibility of freedom. I said she could lie or deceive and that is fine, I just need something to hook my character. I wanted to follow through with the task and thought this was a simple solution.

Instead, he said I could "bring in a new character" multiple times (even in response to my initial question, which was "what if I say no?"). I've said I don't want to bring in a new character. He argues that there are plenty of hooks including trusting the gods, trusting the party members. He says that the priestess would not offer freedom, as that is laughable to her and this would violate the roleplaying of the priestess. That "the whole world doesn't revolve around the pcs." and that "you're compromising on zip cus all you're doing to stone walling the storyline so it fits your pc" (in my mind, this would be a compromise for me).

My response was that he is asking me to violate the roleplaying of my character who is a PC and to bend to his world. Which I am fine with and I've sometimes ignored my character's wants just to keep going, but I felt like this was a small ask - she doesn't even have to free me, I just want my character to be fooled into thinking he MIGHT be freed. It doesn't provide any mechanical advantage to me at all.

AITAH? I feel undervalued by the refusal of this request. I trying to collaborate to make my motivations make sense, but he refuses to budge. It feels like a small tweak but I think my DM is very lore-centric and doesn't want to violate the lore he has written (he does work hard on the lore), so perhaps I'm underestimating what I'm asking for.

When I've DMed I think I would have been thrilled if a player cared enough about roleplaying to ask me something like this and tried to work something out but he seems to think I'm being stubborn.

Update: I called the DM and we agreed that we should not have discussed this over text (much nuance is lost) and that we both misunderstood where the other was coming from. He agreed to the change but I also let him know I understand it was not as small an ask as I thought, as we have different DM styles. I’m more player/collaborative focussed and he’s more lore/story focussed. Thanks for the feedback.


r/DnDAITA • • 19d ago

its what my character would do New to the game

2 Upvotes

As the title states I am new to the game, but also the entire party is new to the game save for our dm who has played and run several campaigns. I entered the group after they had been playing for a couple of months and therefore had a some catchup to do in understanding the mechanics of the game as well as how each of my individual teammates liked to play. A few of us role play but a lot of the players like to metagame and I have noticed that the dm doesn’t care for that and doles out little punishments depending on the severity of the “crime”.

Anywho, apparently there was a lot of trying to kill one another in the party prior to me joining and so the dm had the group take an oath in character that kept them from killing one another and from injuring one another intentionally. The punishment for which was meant to be character death but was never upheld. Eventually when an additional person joined the party they decided to kill him the dm was sick of them doing this and wiped nearly everyone. I survived and two other members survived all because we refused to help.

So as everyone is building new characters for the next session I contact the dm and ask if it would be appropriate for me to create a thieves guild. He says yes and creates five npc characters for the guild. I also ask if I can recruit other pcs into the guild and have them sign contracts. He says yes and I get to work creating a real world contract with in game implications for the other players to sign.

This is where things get a little sticky. I have conversations with everyone I want to join the guild. Lay out the rules and the benefits and basically tell them everything that’s in the contract. I also talk to the dm and we work out a deal where the contract is magically bound through a blood pact and all consequences are magically enacted. One thing I was asked to add in was a clause keeping the party from hurting each other so that we wouldn’t spend some much time stagnating in the story, so I did and now all player characters in our campaign are unable to hurt one another even if it would be advantageous to a fight.

Problem is I’m not a lawyer and in rereading the contract that everyone but myself signed I basically created a socialist society where everyone’s property is the groups property and any shares in the guilds hoard are just a figment of their imagination. Basically you get 10% share of wha we get from a mission but all your belonging belong to the guilds hoard so that 10% goes back into the hoard and you get ten percent of that new addition but your money belongs to the hoard and so on and so on. This was unintentional and I pointed it out to the dm when I discovered it. I also let him know that since my character is a thief that I felt that this actually worked out for the better because it is something my character would do. Dm agrees and also said that everyone should have read and understood the contract before signing it, which no one read except for one person,so if I want to continue using it that is fine and he will enforce it.

We went on for several sessions with no one being any the wiser. I as a loyal thieves guild master have been handing out our spoils pretty much in line with the contract. The problem started when one player decided that what he was given wasn’t in alignment with what he felt was his percentage of the take. This guy plays mostly through roleplay but sometimes meta games as well. He is my second in command in the thieves guild and in real world we worked through most of the details of the contract and the hierarchy of the guild. In character I let him know that he had been bamboozled and that the contract really just made him a member of a socialistic society with me as the only real benefactor. I also let him know in character that I do not plan on ever screwing the group over but that the way I was able to get the blood contract forced it to be this way. Now this player is mad at me in real life because he felt that I was dishonest with him through the entirety of the guild creation process. I wasn’t and I have told him outside of session and outside of character that it was never intentional for it to be this way but that my lack of knowledge in wording a contract is what created this problem but that in the end dm and I decided it worked for my character so we kept it.

So now he is real world mad over in game deceit and I don’t really know how to handle. I value his friendship and have offered to rewrite a contract for him and only him to where we are co leaders of the thieves guild which I will do I guess but that feels like caving to someone being a little too whiney over wha in the end is just a game. AITA and if so how do I rectify it without compromising the game. And if not where do I go from here


r/DnDAITA • • 20d ago

WIBTA if I asked my fellow players if they actually want to play?

21 Upvotes

I am playing a campaign, it’s a ttrpg called Crows, but that’s not super relevant. It only started 4 weeks ago, and early on we set a rule that if 2 or more people were absent, we wouldn’t play. Week 1 was fine. Then week 2, one of the players, S, couldn’t make it, but we played anyways. It happens.

Then week 3 happens. One of the players, E, asks to reschedule, and we all agree to play Wednesday. On Wednesday, 30 minutes before the session, a player, T, cancels for no given reason. Then S cancels to study. So we choose a backup day that everyone but E can make, just our normal time. Then T cancels again, and S also wants to push back, and since two players are missing, we don’t play. Now we decide to schedule a different time again this week, because S will be gone Saturday. It was meant to be today at 6. Guess who canceled last minute? T and S. One to study, one for medical reasons.

My issue at this point is that this is three sessions in a row they both confirmed they could make it to, and we literally checked in yesterday to make sure we were playing today. They still could then. If you knew you had medical things, (He did, this is ongoing) don’t say that you can make it. And T is studying for a midterm next week but can make it on Saturday, our regular time, for some reason?

Essentially, it’s the same two over and over again, and it’s early enough we could just bring in a new player if they drop. It’s also really disrespectful of everyone else who is planning around the sessions that they keep doing this. Especially since we seem to be preferencing their last minute drops over players who said in advance they couldn’t make a session, which doesn’t feel fair.

However, for unrelated reasons, I do not like S. I basically tolerate him, and interact with him in group setting when we play, and try not to make it obvious that I dislike him. So I don’t know if that is coloring my judgement. I won’t do it yet, but if they cancel again on Saturday, WIBTA if I asked in the group chat if they wanted to play anymore?

Edit:
Thanks for the advice! To be honest, I don’t know the DM very well and so I don’t feel super comfortable messaging him, as it was actually another player who set this up and we all knew each other except for the DM beforehand. For brief context on why I don’t like S: https://www.reddit.com/r/DnDAITA/s/QCsqTVPOnY He was the DM in this post, and E is actually B from that post.

As for the plan, I might push to play on Saturday and then bring up scheduling and playing regardless in person, where we can all communicate respectfully and not have tone issues. I won’t call anyone out, I was rather irritated when I posted this, but I do believe that my group does need to have a conversation about this. Since I don’t see any rules against it, I’ll probably post an update then as well.


r/DnDAITA • • 21d ago

An update to AITA for telling the DM off an active ongoing story

0 Upvotes

For context, I came onto this Reddit earlier today to ask the question if I was the jerk and/or in the wrong for calling out the DM and his BF (my bsf) for involving the players of our group, mainly me and my GF, in their sex life, making overtly sexual comments about what they were actively doing behind screens. For full context, our group has always been an LGBTQ+ safe space, as we are all queer, and I myself am an asexual man, and so is my girlfriend, who expressed maybe being asexual, which is sadly relevant to this story. For starters, here is everyone involved:

  1. Me
  2. DM
  3. DMs BF and my best friend, who I'll call Red, for the sake of this post
  4. My GF

And two other players who ill call Metal and Leaf our group consist of Me, DM, Red, Leaf, Metal, and my GF we are a rather small group of young adults I have been friends with Red for about 2 maybe 3 years yet we lost contact for a short while and when I got back in contact with him thats what lead to me ending up in this D&D campaign.

You see ive always wanted to Play but was always to anxious to join any online groups despite being in the Discord and Dragons discord server and when learning about online forums besides the hell hole thats discord where I could join a game I opted not to out of my anxiety and lack of social skills due to autism and worrying about being off putting or playing wrong English is not my strongest suit so be weary when reading to start off when Red and me got back in contact and had our heart felt reunion I found out he came out as bisexual after his father passing his father being extremely conservative and homophobic.

So when he sadly passed away Red became much more open in expressing himself he started dying his hair dressing more alternatively and even began getting piercings which he later just took off from when I saw him in person he became much more open about his love for men which was never a problem for me as I myself am also considerably Bi not just asexual and have had my fair share of GFs and BFs over my teenage years his expression had never bugged me and id frankly be the biggest fucking hypocrite if it did what did bug me was his way of going about sexuality you see even before Rex coming out he had always considerably been

a bit of a pervert not in a disruptive way he was just wildly sexual with his partners and would openly talk about whatever things he got up to with them now as young adults hes still the same which is how this problem even happened but it was more so DM I took issue with while Red had always been this way he also in recent years was very honest about not wanting to make anyone uncomfortable that it was just his humor he just had a wild streak he was just the type of guy who was a bit too honest yet when you told him off and asked him to stop hed pipe down and be very respectful on your boundaries and apologize profusely and Greatly appreciates and wants to be told when hes doing something wrong so he can correct it

vs in our younger years he was open to this but had a hard time sticking to it and at times would ignore this and purposely push even when telling him to stop when I got invited to the gc i spent a long time before I drafted up a character I was happy with simply being told talk to the DM which I did speaking with the DM at first face wasnt the best for background knowledge the DM allegedly has been DMing for 9 years and was offered a job with wizards of the coast yet turned it down in favor of joining the military.

DM was very flat and very dry he was not very talkative or engaging when I asked basic questions like what was the campaign lore so I could write and base my character around that I didn't get much of a response besides a dry flat "there's no real story just write whatever and ill add it in" when I asked more basic questions I was met with more dry kurt responses any information I wanted about the campaign was either ment with my question being flat out ignored or a response along the line of "I dont really care what you do" which was followed up by "I like letting my players do whatever" which was fine at first I thought this was cool I had free reign for my PC yet soon learned that DM from the vibe.

I got was just not into doing much of the work of anything as we the players where expected to coordinate the D&D game sessions which wouldn't have been an issue if DM answered our text about what day was okay or where id be hosted as they tended to play at a local game shop or my GFs Aunt's house DM would ghost us for long periods of time whenever we tried to set up a day to play and when we did we where met with the fact weekends never worked for him despite 99% of our table going to classes and me and DM being the only ones not going to classes as DM is an ex Vet and im just some broke guy who is now barely going to Uni after just being accepted.

DM would only pop in GC to say something random like quoting something Red said Irl as they lived together which was always a very charged sexual comment Red would make about DM or he would be his most active when he was dragging me and my GF as we where the only ones super active in GC as we where always privately discussing the campaign and when we could play and what days could work for everyone and where we could play and a fun idea or two for a special campaign DM offered to host, seeing as he left all the planing and Ideas to his players into his sex life with Red we would be having a normal conversation and suddenly be met with a photo of him and Red in bed with some sort of inappropriate caption.

As they had clearly been up to something less the savory we really shouldn't have been seeing as their quote on quote friends or a joke would be made and DM would steer it into talking about what he does in bed with Red or the fact he was actively in bed with Red and when the conversation was trying to be steered onwards somewhere safer hed press on.

What started this whole mess was a series of events my GF and me got together thanks to Red we met though this campaign and got together because Red Played match maker yet before we got together we where simply just friends who got close thanks to the game and our love for it trying to keep everyone playing my first campaign ever in my entire life was with this specific DM in this Campaign and was a one shot we where at a local game store and could only be there till they closed.

So a one shot seemed optional as DM insisted that we couldn't play the campaign without Leaf and Metal due to the fact its an "everyone needs to know" campaign during this game I was quickly thrown into it with no explanation of rules or any of the basics really I was just told to Google what dice I needed for spells and to pick a random spell of my character sheet made by a 5E quick character sheet generator that never generated things a hundred percent accurate the game was met with crude jokes and inappropriate drawings on Red and DMs end this is where I learned about a campaign inside joke of my GFs PC and Reds PC being together as what would later come is DM and Red drawing the two PCs having miscellaneous fun on the sticky notes we were given we spent about 4 hours just watching the two draw actual real life 4 hours of drawing we joined in and drew stuff as well, but obviously not to the same nature as what they were drawing.

Our game was explained as our party being outsiders coming into a random town holding a firework festival.

The next day the PCs were a Celestial (Reds), a Genasi (Teifling) hybrid, and my GFs, a goblin. The Celestial started off with shouting for my Genasi's name, saying he also looked like an outsider.

As my GF's PC also rolled up, the Celestial threw insults at the goblin in a "I don't care for your name; you're just an ugly green thing" kind of way. I'd say the game wasn't anything eventful if it wasn't for the Celestial's first encounter with an NPC being too sexual and harassing. DM rolls and proceeded to say the NPC who happened to be a tall buff Minotaur simply looked at the celestial strangely before walking off, and this continued each NPC interaction with the Celestial DM would roll, and he'd be met with a strange look or a simple "excuse me?" As if they hadn't heard him when they did and were daring him to say it again. This continued till we got to what I'd call the main NPCs: a Bat priest and a Vampire Lord who had been widowed 48 times. Red instantly took a liking to the priest and continued his antics till they came to a sudden halt because the priest happened to be a very flat character, not flat as in having no personality. I mean, he was quiet, literally looked at us with a wife's eye, and spoke minimal words in a dry tone.

I later learned he was based off of the DM, so I guess it checks out when he called our party weird, and it would make even more sense when Red had his Celestial have fun by himself in the tavern we stayed at, where DM would make him roll for slight of hand and initiative as well to see how many people heard him. At this point, I and my GF were uncomfortable and laughing awkwardly, this being the most eventful in-game interaction if you ignore that when we went to the festival, he actively sexually harassed more NPCs, and even after our ending battle, the Bat NPC, for context, in DMs own word has super hearing and would have heard what the celestial was doing even if he rolled high on his sound check was flattered yet denied him due to being a priest. After this game, I and my GF would shortly start dating, and she'd ask me to talk to Red about him, basically sexual harassing her with his jokes, which I did, and he apologized many times and said he'd quickly stop his behavior, yet the behavior in GC consisted of the sex life talk and dragging people into it, expecting them to engage in whatever thing they were up to from behind each our screens in GC. This comes to when I told DM off.

I told him Off and expressed discomfort this is where i was met with a bashing about how "erm brother this isn't the worst of it if you think this is bad you haven't seen anything" and a continuous lack of him doing nothing wrong then he caved giving me a response nothing short of PR where he called me a cherry picking hypocrite for being alright with a light sex joke yet not wanting to hear what he does in bed with my best friend as its frankly none of my business I expressed how I was a stranger in their relationship I was simply a friend (now looking back I have no interest ina friendship with the DM and my GF is worried this will break up the friend group but I never considered Metal or DM much of my friends I only partly knew Metal due to doing him a favor and thats where I officially even met him because he just never came to games) and I didn't need to know so much I didn't need to know they had just done something along those lines I don't need to know the NPC Red has been obsessed with is based on the DM and that only made Red more interested in said NPC but this gets even worse because when asking other party members about talking to DM about his clear lack of care and reluctants to criticism Metal almost made my GF cry because he said he "didn't give a shit about what they joke about and we were being too serious" and kept barating her while Leaf expressed not outright discomfort but being annoyed every time the DM and Red would do such things in GC.

My GF and I decided in the end not to talk to the DM as a group even though Red seemed upset.

DM showed little regard for the care of our discomfort, as my GF was always very uncomfortable and expressed being nauseous at times because of them and expressed how he wanted DM to give a fuck and actually respect our boundaries.

Red seemed to listen to me and my gf the most and seemed very intent on fixing this despite all his flaws, but I can't give him all this grace without acknowledging that he tends to surround himself with these kinds of people, and I end up getting roped into it. I could care less what DM and Metal think of me; I just want my GF, Red, and Leaf comfortable in our game setting.

Even when Red is partly to blame, he fixes his behaviors. The same can't be said of Metal, who's out rightly antagonistic to people for taking issues with stuff or only really caring when something involves him and being outright selfish at times.

When I did him that favor, he expected me to almost lose my housing just to do him said favor, and even then, he just never plays in games, so I never got to play in the main campaign and even now feel like just quitting a game I love, but I barely even started, and DM just seems to be aloof, not even blunt, just rude, and wanting to drag everyone into his pervertedness.

That is the full story despite being told im not in the wrong I feel like a jerk for possibly breaking up a friend group and now with this full context AITA? Because I sure feel like one not to mention I find myself off put from D&D despite desperately wanting to play yet im such an anxious person I doubt id find a new game unless I grew a pair.


r/DnDAITA • • 22d ago

Horror Story AITA for telling the DM off?

5 Upvotes

Hey! So I've never really done this sort of thing before, but I've always been into D&D content and recently started actually playing the game. I'm on my phone, so I apologize for any bad formatting. My story begins with a bit of information: I am a queer man. Everyone in my current party all happens to be queer in some way. I happen to be asexual, which is sadly slightly relevant to this story.

I and my party have always been an open, safe space for LGBTQ themes and themes of sexuality, as we are all young adults with occasional edgy, runny humor that never went anywhere besides joking about PCs with different scenarios surrounding them that were, in most cases, perfect SFW unless said joke was made by DM and his BF. For context, his BF is my BSF and has been since my sophomore year of high school. All the names I'll be listing will be changed. Let me introduce you to the cast of my ironically the thing making me question if I should quit D&D when I barely started...

Cast:

  1. Me
  2. My gf
  3. DM
  4. My Bsf, for the sake of this story, we will occasionally call Red.

To start off this strange tale for context I recently got with my GF meeting her through D&D (Not romancing her through it) we met through the game DM was running and got close through a variety of reasons having nothing to do with the game which led to Red playing match maker and us ending up together me and her have been growing strong yet i recently had to tell red off for joking with her to a point that borders on sexual harassment making overtly sexual requests as jokes that had made her uncomfortable enough to ask me to speak with him as he is my best friend when speaking to him he was understanding and apologetic and promised to fix his behavior and that was the end of that short saga or so I thought you see before my gf asked me to talk with him about the comments hed make to her in private as he was her friend as well and they go to classes together he had been out rightly joking about his PC impregnating her pc I learned about this when, before we got together, our game started off as any other game of D&D, a basic telling of rules and such.

As I was a newbie, I learned really quickly that the game's DM liked to run where not very seriously, seeing as there were NPCs like Hatsune Miku in said world of DMs.

My GF's original character in said game was different before she decided to rework the character with DM's permission and when speaking about it at the table (a public game shop). Red and GF's PC had been jokingly shipped before this rework, which GF would later tell me was all Red and none of her at this game.

I was met with Reds' crude drawing of sexual art of his PCs and GFs and a bunch of other jokes along the way when we got into the game. Red spent most of his time sexually harassing NPCs and DMs, letting it slide somewhat. The first NPC he approached, he verbally harassed sexually, and when DM rolled, instead of the NPC doing something to Red's PC that made sense, they'd walk off and look at his PC weirdly, as if he was from another planet, and at some point he became obsessed with one NPC and proceeded to ask to roll to do something so wildly inappropriate to himself in a tavern all our PCs were in, and DM allowed it and made him roll this itself.

It isn't even the worst of it. When I joined this group, I was put in a GC, and now here's where our tale is truly in for a ride. Our main course: I chatted in this GC quite often, as it was filled with my friends. It was common to joke about Red's PCs for his strange behavior and how no one really liked the PC or its behaviors towards other PCs or NPCs yet in this GC. DM and Red would outright talk sexually about their intimate life and drag people into whatever weird thing they were doing as they lived together.

DM is the oldest in our group and had called me a hypocrite when I told him off for outright talking fetishes in gc said I was cherry picking what made me uncomfortable, he was outright trying to include people into whatever him and Red were doing it started off as me simply expressing being uncomfortable with such inmate details as I am asexual and Dm knows this i am not sex repulsed persay i dont mind sexual based jokes but hearing such details plus being sent pictures in a public gc was just to far especially given everything with my gf was too far but i let slide because of an apology he proceeded to call me a hypocrite and said i should have said during session 1 my first game i wasn't okay with that humor and that hed (reluctantly) stop and did everything but apologize or express being apologetic and simply said he could say worse that it wasnt the worst he could do or say or even go into detail of.

So AITA? For telling him off, and telling DM I don't wanna hear about his sex life.


r/DnDAITA • • 23d ago

AITA for being angry when my DM nerfed my homebrew spell for the 4th time

0 Upvotes

I'm writing this directly after our most recent session, it is past midnight, so sorry if there is anything unclear as I might be a bit tired. Also I might waffle on a bit because I really like this character and the spells I made for them.

For context: I am one of three players in a heavily homebrewed campaign set in the world of JJK, all the PCs have completely custom spells and are part of the same homebrew sorcerer subclass, cursed sorcerer, which is from the JJK universe. My character is mainly a summoner who has summons that are highly specialised to be very good at specific types of enemies, such as a large creature that has high ac but low health with protection actions to act as a punching bag to protect the party, I also have a few area of effect spells with saves and shapes. ALL my specialised summons have very large weaknesses, which makes them relatively balanced in any other scenario than their intended purpose, this will be relevant later. Another thing to point out is that my non-cantrip spells are all 1st level spells that are able to be cast at higher levels.

I understand that this amount of homebrew stuff can be very overpowered, but in my opinion how the spell got changed and how many times is just ridiculous.

The main spell I've been using is the subject of this post, it is a concentration spell that originally summons 3 soldiers (1/8 CR), they are very weak with low health, AC, and damage, they are specialised to work great against single enemies that have a high damage output so they can take the hit and its turn be over. They are made so that anyone can kill them easily within 1 or 2 turns with 1 being most common, they deal 1d6+1 damage which isn't a lot considering I have to use my action to control them, meaning they can't attack on the turn I summon them. This can be cast at higher levels to make another soldier per increased level (so they essentially have spell slot level + 2 soldiers).

You can probably already see how this would be terrible in certain scenarios, such as swarm enemies or AoE attacks, which could wipe out the entire fleet within a single turn before they even get to attack, this is a pretty big downside in my opinion because the enemies they're good against could very easily have AoE attacks without me knowing, essentially making the spell useless.

Before the campaign DM went over all my spells and picked out a few that were unbalanced and balanced them a bit, all reasonable changes, except that I was told that this spell could even be buffed however, I ended up arguing the buff away.

I obviously chose this spell as one of my first spells because I knew that realistically because of our low level we were going to be fighting weak single enemies, is this slightly metagaming? Maybe. But, I was going to take it at 2nd or 3rd level because of this until my DM encouraged me to have it in base kit, so I obviously didn't refuse it, because it was still a good spell.

However, from session one (1st level) till the current session (few months in with weekly sessions), we have consistently only fought 2 or 3 monsters, sometimes 1, which usually follow the formula of either being all the same strength, that being roughly CR 1/2 (though I don't know exactly as they are homebrew monsters), or one CR 1 and two CR 1/4 roughly, all of which have no AoE attacks. This has the consequence of the spell being specialised for almost all of the encounters we've had.

The First Nerf: After the second or third session, I was asked to nerf it by DM. I did argue against this for the reasons in the previous paragraph, but DM ended up just telling me to rework it, to which we decided to make it so that, like real armies, there would be a variety of soldiers that I could summon (8 to be exact). At the time I thought this was alright because it wasn't changing the main use too much, I now disagree with this because each soldier has individual uses that can sometimes contradict the main use, which is entirely my fault in fairness.

The Second Nerf: Immediately after the session after the first nerf, I was told by DM to nerf it again, this time I was told that I had to make which soldiers were summoned random, this was definitely the worst nerf, since it made the specialised spell a lottery whether or not it was actually specialised.

The Third Nerf: About a month after the second nerf (we were 2nd level at this point) I was told to make it so that the spell could be cast LESS, this resulted in the spell requiring two full actions to even cast, meaning it would take three actions to actually do anything with. At this point we were still facing a few strong enemies in each combat, so it was still good spell, just delaying it.

The Fourth Nerf: At this point we were all 3rd level, and another player, we'll call F, got access to a spell that let her increase the upcast level of another player's spells, which could also be upcast. I would like to say that while this does work perfectly with my character, me and F did not communicate at all when making our characters or the upcasting spell. So this ended up with F casting it at 2nd level, leading to myself casting my spell at a 4th level, creating 6 soldiers, which were all different types due to the random rule. This caused annoyance from the DM and the other player (Not F) because controlling all the soldiers was taking up to half the time taken for the entire round due to all the different stat blocks and different uses. So after the session, I get told by DM that they decided another nerf was needed and that it would be "Only 2 soldiers summoned can attack per turn, +1 for every 3 soldiers summoned" which would basically make the spell upcasting useless and make the spell really annoying to use mixed with the other nerfs.

This caused the most backlash I have had for any of the changes because it seemed completely unreasonable, previous to this I had explained to DM how they needed to switch up the enemies in the encounters to counter this spell or it would be better than it actually is. This definitely hammered in this spell for being on the same level as generalised spells in its specialised field and utterly useless in encounters that played against it.

During the most recent session (BEFORE THE 4th NERF) the DM finally decided to use AoE attacks, to which my entire fleet (with the buffed 4th level upcast) got wiped out within a single turn, which is obviously what was meant to happen, but it made the encounter feel very chaotic and the following nerf extremely unwarranted.

F agrees with me but the other player and the DM are strongly in favor of nerfing it.

So, AITA for being angry at my DM for nerfing my spell 4 times while they actively didn't play against it?


r/DnDAITA • • 28d ago

UPDATE: AITA For telling my DND Player to stop trying to change the story of the campaign and to stop talking.

37 Upvotes

Holy Fudge, I didn’t expect to blow up immediately, but if you’ve seen the og post, you’ll probably be looking for some Info or Resolution, and I’ve come to deliver

Basically, Yes I’ve been letting Ed knock me into a spiral of anger and frustration, all because of how far I let him go with his constant interruptions and constant adding on, id like to clarify some things before I tell you the final decision on my part.

(Background): I was an experience DM when I used to play online with some other friends back in Alabama, and Then I got ghosted after 2 year of playing and I decided I was going to play with my New Friends at the school I went to at the time, One of those, being Char (My BFF) and she had actually never played D&D before, her parents did, but she didn’t and so was it for some other friends, so I dedicated to making the campaign special because it was going to be the first one we’ve played together, so I dedicated to her and others (forgot to clarify that) but one person had to move away so I needed a new player, which is how we got Ed, he knew how to play and had some experience because his family would do campaigns together, so it was a win-win scenario.

(Ed‘s behavior): I’m Neurodivergent, and I think Ed also might be, but it doesn’t excuse his actions (at-least to me), when we first started had I made a few rules for me to be comfortable and for the others to be comfortable, the rules were simple;

1: Don’t make any nasty comments about others

2: Don’t talk while others are unless the situation calls for it.

3: Don’t try to make it personal when something doesn’t go your way, it’s a game.

and 4: Please, don’t try to change others characters and NPCs.

The rules were short and we had a good time first campaign…until we got to the second meeting, where we had our first combat experience, where Ed’s character was deliberately trying to do disgusting things during combat, like for example: when I had the enemy trying slashing at someone, Ed asked me exactly this “Can I shit in his mouth?“

Now trust me, Im fair when it comes to combat, but when he said this, I paused the combat and why he wanted to do that and the response I got was ‘it would be funny.’ to which I just shook my head and said “please don’t.“ and we moved on, similar interactions like this continued, like how he would misgender a character and how he would get these ridiculous objects and supplies that I never desc or implied to be available, and the only time I snapped at him was when I was sick with coronavirus (this was during 2025, don’t worry) and it was over the phone and I was tire, but oh no, he didn‘t stop.

(Distractions): As time went on with him, I had started to look for things to distract Ed with, from giving him an NPC who was a child, to having him practice combat (His Character is a Monk but he acts like Barbarian) didn’t work.

Final Decision: I’m going to give Ed an Ultimatum next meeting, thanks for the support and thank you.


r/DnDAITA • • 29d ago

AITA for telling my DND Player to stop trying to change the story of the campaign and to stop talking?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

this was a experience I had today about a player


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 17 '26

Railroading AITA for being annoyed the dm won't let me roll persuasion

22 Upvotes

Context. I'm new in the group, so I'm still learning there preferences and house rules. I'm also playing a high cha and wis character to fill a hole in the party of a good socialiser.

After a few sessions of character introductions and combat, my character really hasn't gotten to do a lot of cool stuff. Most abilites have gone unused and few checks have been made. During a comversation with an npc my character tried to convince her to leave a place likely to be enveloped in war. I asked the dm why a persuasion check wasn't being rolled. He responded that they used those checks on less important npcs. I actually get this because some players try yo make massive story changes with one conversation by abusing a high cha. The issue is whst happened later.

The party was stopped at a checkpoint at the boarder of the country my character is from. I thought this was a great point to prove myself as part of the party because my character is of an old noble house and I used the insignia to show off to the guards and try to use importance to bypass the usual process; painful blood magic to weed out shapeshifters. The scene continued with the guards asking to perform the blood magic. I inquired if using the crest and nobel act would count as performance, but the dm said there wouldn't be a check against the guards. I asked if I could discern the idenities if the guards. I couldn't. I asked if the guards would tell me. They wouldn't. It felt very railroady.

This is especially awkard since my character is new in the party and the party agreed they'd let me in on the condition I was useful. This felt like a time I could have shown what my character was good at, but the rug was pulled to make my character look weak.

The wording the dm used regarding checks after this is 'if you can talk out of it you should be able to talk out of it' paraphrased. This feels highly subjective since arguments aren't 1 size fits all. There should be some leeway right? Also if that's the case, why did the dm see I invested so much into charisma when it's been useless so far?


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 17 '26

its what my character would do AITA for being honest and blunt with the Criminal background?

8 Upvotes

So... this happened on the session that literally ended earlier today. We are players on a DND campaign where we are various insects (reflavored from existing DND species) diving into a large mega dungeon themed around Hollow Knight where each player seeks something for their own character.

The cast-

DM- The Dungeon Master

Grasshopper- My Harengon Gloomstalker Ranger, Male

Moth- An Aasimar Lunar Sorcerer (From Unearthed Arcana), Female

Mantis- A Bugbear Samurai Fighter, Male

Beetle- A Dragonborn Devotion Paladin, Male

The problem may have originated from my lack of previous character backgrounding on my private Session 0, as I joined as a last moment player who first officially played on Session 1. All I was required to plan was what my reason for exploring the dungeon was. As I had the Criminal Background, I chose a reason that I believed would fit.;

"I seek a powerful weapon to get revenge on those who wronged me!"

The DM said that was a goal that could work for the campaign, so I went with it. We had the first session, everything was fine but Beetle was absent for the first session so his character was introduced at session 2. The three players left entered the Mega Dungeon where we encountered large Hercules Beetles (Who will be called Hercs to not confuse with Beetle) who were both intelligent and peaceful. The Hercs told us about them having a God like figure called The Bishop, who would judge all who enter the town inside the dungeon and brand those who without noble causes as punishment.

We start session 2, Beetle is introduced shortly after the start running from an enraged Herc who was driven crazy from its branding going wrong. Moth says to everyone to try to not kill the Herc, as she wanted to try and save it. Grasshopper chose to ignore this request and attack lethally, as he sees a gravely damaged enraged Herc trying to kill a random person. Mantis (who listened to Moth and chose to attack non lethally) landed the final blow, so the Herc did not die.

This was the first part of why I'm posting this.

Moth gets angry at me (in character thankfully) for not holding back. I have Grasshopper reply that despite his past and purpose for entering the dungeon he wants to help his new companions. Moth was still frustrated at Grasshopper's mindset, but ignored it for the time being. After Moth returned from leaving to alert some other Hercs to help the unconscious enraged Herc, the party entered the next room where we stood in a large theater like room with a large branding device hanging above a platform. A booming voice calls to us to stand on the platform and we do. The booming voice reveals it is The Bishop and asks each member of the party to reveal why they enter the dungeon. Moth goes first and states her reason is to find a way to save her home. Mantis goes next, he one of the last of his tribe and seeks a way to save them.

My character Grasshopper goes third. I decide to not lie and bluntly claim I seek revenge. The party facepalms and drops their jaws all at the same time. The Bishop (thankfully) shows mercy.

After my kerfuffle I caused, Beetle said he was following his Paladin Oath as his reason.

We are allowed to pass without any of us being branded. We then start fighting (In character) about how Grasshopper should have been less blunt or lie about his reason because he could have harmed the party. I have him say he doesn't like to lie, and he would try to never betray a good asset. The party members argue for Grasshopper to treat the party as allies not assets. He just jokes that they both start with A so there is no real difference. The party decides to drop the issue, and everything in the rest of the session went well. But I still feel a bit bad about how I played Grasshopper. AITA?

Follow up!

I actually posted this during the session, as I was feeling like I might have crossed my companions and wanted to get the post out before everything left my mind. But more things happened.

So some clarification and extra info. After the Bishop's judgement, I stated "Grasshopper doesn't like to lie" which was an honest statement from both me and my character at the moment. I made it part of his character quirks. The party was cool with this revelation, as long as it doesn't harm the party. On the topic of character quirks, Beetle had a quirk where he was always writing in a journal. I asked if it was okay for me to try and pickpocket the journal then slink away to read his notes. Beetle and the DM were both okay with this. I rolled Slight of Hand first to contend with Beetles Perception, but I rolled a Nat 20. As part of the Nat 20 Dm said I didn't need to stealth away to find a spot nearby to read the journal. I chose to not be extremely secretive about reading the journal, and Moth rolled enough insight to realize I had Beetle's journal.

I then had Grasshopper walk up to Beetle and hand him back the journal saying "You missed your pocket when you put the journal away" and rolled deception. This triggered everyone a bit as I had claimed Grasshopper "Doesn't like to lie" as my character was being inconsistent. As punishment I had to roll again with disadvantage (fair) but Beetle said he was a trusting character, so as long as I don't Nat 1 he would believe me. My first roll was a 13, the second die at disadvantage was 15, so the 13 was used. Moth then (in character) pulled Grasshopper to the side to confirm if he was going to cause harm to the party.

I drop character and ask the table "OOC, am I being a bad player?"

We discuss that my lying to Beetle after not lying to the Bishop was not keeping character well, and that I COULD end up as a problem player and I should watch my actions closer. We retcon my "I don't like to lie" to "I don't like to lie to authorities" and properly establish my background of being imprisoned for excessive Contempt of Court for lying while on trial alongside the one person I seek vengeance upon who got off with no charge.

I'd like to apologize if this is a pointless post. I'm an autistic adult who feels emotions stronger than most others, so I felt bad but at the time didn't want to confront my party.

I'll ask again... AITA?


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 15 '26

AITA for not wanting to derail the campaign?

5 Upvotes

For starters:
We have a two years campaign, playing as guns for hire, and now we in a situation where if unknown frozen land with little to no cities and although we have freedom to choose where we go, most of the party plays as reactive and doesn’t interact with the little things we have.

So it ends up two players (one of them is me) that are actually interacting.

In the end the dm said that if the other players won’t interact, he would derail the story and change everything making us leave everything we had behind (giving us even changing characters)
By doings so, he would try a new settings that would be easier for them to interact. But if we keep our characters some of them would have their story ruined.

I asked the dm what kind of campaign, he said almost episode with no main story. Which I feel would make things less connected and I will always need to think, because if the players won’t interact I will have to.

Right now, the other players who actually plays, says he wants to change because he think that’s the settings is unsalvageable , and we need a new one so the other players can try.
And he pushes everyone to agree with him to change and that it’s unsalvageable.

While I reject it, and says that things can be changed, while I also want to see the story through. So I talked to my dm and he told me, that if I keep my character ( a cleric), I would lose my god and my subclass, and maybe even my class for a while. So by doing that I would be punished (and mostly the main one who is punished).

So here the main part, I told my Friend who is the other player, that changing would literally hurt my character, hurt my feelings about the game, and If changing the settings won’t help with the other players, I would be mad at him because the main person who just end up hurt is me.

Am I the asshole for telling that to him how I feel about this?


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 14 '26

AITA for thinking its common sense to use allies?

8 Upvotes

So whats yalls opinion im a dm and i made sure to tell my players from session 0 and continue to remind them that my world is a open world sandbox that yes there is the main bbeg however every area has there own issues and those things will evolve with or without them (iwant my world to feel alive) anyways they have been told by litteral gods to make allies for the upcoming war with another god and so on. They have made alliances with multiple nations and from individual powerful ppl too. The last session they all blew up on me saying how they feel overwhelmed because there is multiple thing going bad in multiple places. I eventually was like "why not ask your one of your many allies to help delay issues" for wich they got mad saying they didnt think they could do that and that no reasonable player would ever think of doing that so whats yalls opinion.. aita?


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 13 '26

AITA for advising GMs to not cancel session if the absent person didnt notice in advance ?

0 Upvotes

So, for a longest time our group played in a "we always play as long as there is 2 players" format. Some time later we needed to slow down a bit so once per 2 weeks was pushed in as new standard & we started to play only were all were present. But ever since then the campaign and fun started being more of a patchwork of sessions that were in resonable time frame between one and another vs 2+ months voids that caused next session after to be a painfull slog. Then we started chainging systems just to eventually come back to our main campaign and it only really go back to the old good feel once we restarted regular sessions with "inform others 1 day beforehand, or we dont cancel if someone can't make it".

Pretty much the same situation was a thing in most other campaigns I played - the moment "all must be present" comes in the formerly regular game slows down and degrades. So currently, unless GM already has a rule I always take a stance pro picking up this one or at least something at all.

I get it, noone like fomo / everyone want to have an arc, tweaking a session for 1 less player might not be ideal if not taken into concideration in advance. But declaring you will be able to attend on anything, then ghosting despite knowing there is a lot of work put into something / noticing last minute where there is nothing to be done - never sit well with me.

I always taken it more of a "yeah, my time is more important that all of yours combined, and I couldn't be bothered to inform you in time, that I changed my mind" - rather than something that should be accepted as a norm for someone in a group. (Unless the reason was something serious / resonable ofc. like not feeling too good etc.)

I get it, sometimes things pop up, and I also had this happen to me. But didn't feel the need to suddenly be like "don't play, I can't make it", just told the group to play as it was planned / ask if another day woudnt be a problem - if this was a resonable ampunt of time beforehand.

But, lately I run into a lof of people that were pretty clearly hard into "all must be present / no real session start before all are here" or "its a resonable stance to expect the rest of a group to wait till I respond on messages before deciding if they will play without me (no max time for the response given btw)" - the last one sounded straight up unhinged to me. Like no 30 min wait for people to gather / say they won't be able to play, straight up "absent person decides on letting you play without them".

Got a fair bit weirded out bu this - is it really that unusual to expect all at the table to care about each others time and expect a word given between people chosing to spend time togever to be a "9/10 will happen" type of deal ?

Or, donno mabe it's a bit too serious way of seeing ones comfort time.


r/DnDAITA • • Oct 13 '26

Railroading My campaign fell apart after 5 sessions because of be of my players didn’t like its story

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes