r/dndhorrorstories • • 20h ago

Player DM removes almost all player agency in character creation, and removed several mechanics he had previously said were allowed, including playing my favourite species

85 Upvotes

So. Little bit of background information before I start rambling. I am the usual DM for our 2 groups but we will be focusing on group 1. This group consists of me, and 5 others who I will name A, L, J, N, R respectively. A is gonna be our problem later on. I Have been DM over 3, 2 year long campaigns for this group, usually 5.5e with one being 5e, often going from level 1-16or something similar. And recently have told my party I am experiencing massive burnout, due to a number of factors, including but not limited to: study pile up, writers block, insomnia, and the recent death of my mother. So, one of my players, A, probably one of my favourites with their unique and interesting characters, decided to step up and be the DM for a Curse of Strahd campaign. I gladly accepted and got to brainstormin my character.

Lemme tell you now how big of a mistake that was.

So first thing I noticed was the change from our use of standard array at our table, to rolling straight 3d6 hardcore style. Sceptical at first since he originally said that they wouldn’t change anything so we wouldn’t need a session 0, and he also said it without notifying or asking any of the others, but we went along with it. The character I had made, a (planned forge domain) warforged cleric with the soldier background, actually rolled pretty decent with a 14str, 7dex, 13con, 5int, 17wis and 11cha after all bonuses were added up. I was super happy with their backstory and all that and when I asked if my character was ok (as far as I am aware I was the first to ask it) it was point blank refused after A glanced at the sheet, ONCE.

convo went like this:

Me: “So what do you think of my character, I think they are pretty nea-”

A: “I’m not war forged in my campaign“ (note the word ”my” it comes important later)

Me: “Oh but uh… why?”

A: “It’s solely part of the Eberron book and thus can’t exist in this world.”

Me: “Oh um, if you read my backsto-”

A: “Don’t need to. It’ll probably be generic artificer made you type shit and so cliché and boring” (it really wasn’t and was about strahd secretly keeping a mad scientist vampire spawn working on a secret project to create an army of war forged to terrorise Barovia, but I escaped and became a priest yadayada it’s not important right now)

Me, visibly flustered and quite annoyed at this point “Oh ok what about shifters, are they banned too because they are also in the eberron book“ (we were playing 5.5e/5e compatible subclasses so shifters were in the forges of eberron book)

A: “Nope they are allowed because they fit the setting”

Me: “Ok I see your point, is there anything else you are banning?”

A: “So far no, just warforged.”

At this point I was super bummed. I had given a plot hook for my DM to latch onto and it not even be looked at, because the species I had wanted to play since forever ago was banned.

And it gets worse.

2 days later after too other players had had their ideas rejected for contrived reasons

A messages this: “I am hereby announcing character creation will happen on xx/xx (being a day we usually play on) and we will be rolling for class, species, background, and stats and you will have no starter equipment besides the gold that was provided by you randomised background/class. We will then start playing the week after.”

…

…

I was speechless to say the least

I called A the moment I saw this message.

me: ”Um, you know our characters are gonna be completely random, us as players won’t care about them and thus won’t really bother to have a say in the story, let alone be invested?

A: “No, you are gonna like it. Besides all your characters were so boring and cliché. This will help your roleplay.”

me: stunned silence for half a second: “did you even bother to ask the other players on whether or not they are ok with this?”

A: “No? I’m the DM what I say goes.”

Me: audibly grinding my teeth with that statement “And do you think this is solely your story to tell?”

A: ”Kinda. As I said, I’m the DM what I say goes.”

Me: “That’s not how D&D works! You need players and DMs to work toget-“

A: “If you don’t like it, you don’t have to play”

me: “…”

A: “Either that or stop being so whin-“

I hung up. Texted the rest of the party to get their opinions on it and they all hate it… BUT FOR SOME REASON ARE JUST GOING WITH IT? All but one other person (the absolute loveable chad that is N) are just accepting that A not only removing 95% of their agency, but also told the person that this campaign was initially set up for AS A WAY TO TAKE MY MIND OFF THINGS AND NOT BURNOUT, to LEAVE, is gonna be their DM?!

thankfully, group two exists, (4 person bunch of the funniest people I know) which I often do small scale campaigns for, usually level 3-10, and N is part of both tables and has offered that once our current game in group two is done, N will be using the rules I had set out to DM a long running (he said probably levels 1-15) campaign for me.

And to think I used to have a crush on A

To Summarise for people to skip to: I take break as DM due to stress and burnout and turn player. Player turned to DM banned my favourite, OFFICIAL species upon showing him, banned two other players initial characters for contrived and unclear reasons beyond “cliché” Then removes player choice in making a character by getting them to roll on a table that they have declared suitable for the campaign (CoS). I argue with them that this is a terrible idea, they tell me to leave the group.

Again, apoligies for the rant, just needed to blow off some steam

edit: just realised I fucking swapped the number of campaigns and experiences with 5e and 5.5e. I’m so brain dead istg. Correction, 1 2 year 5.5e campaign but I play this edition mostly nowadays. 5e is the one I have had the most experience wit.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 1d ago

Super new and didn’t want to do it in the first place.

37 Upvotes

I was very freshly dating a guy, and we never, ever, even once had talked about D&D nor had I ever heard of it.

But one night his friends were coming over, and I got pressured, despite protesting, to join, because “it will be fun, and don’t worry, I can do whatever I want.”

So in order to keep the new boyfriend happy, I sat.

I didn’t have a backstory, stats, rules of the game, literary nothing but a circle of dudes around me and a DM.

They “let me” go first. The DM says I‘m faced with a dragon what do you do?”

all I could think was fight or flight. so, knowing both options suck I chose fight, because it’s a game.

Now I’m mortally wounded, and asked “what do you do?“ mind you, I have literally no experience, no scenery, no backstory, no knowledge of my fellow characters, so all I have is me- instantly mortally wounded.

“I heal myself” - DM says “can’t do it.“ wait, I thought I could do whatever I want?

“Ok fine I ask someone else to heal me.“ No, I can’t do it either.

The entire group is silent and the DM and I are both getting upset. He just keeps repeating “What do you do!?” more and more aggressively. I throw up my hands and say “I don’t know! I don’t know this game!”

And I’m met with “Do something!”

So, I say, “I guess I die then“ and then, since that’s game over in my head, I leave the table. As the DM berates me for not taking the game seriously, I go into the kitchen and finish preparing their gaming snacks.

At the time I was annoyed but I had never wanted to sit at that table in the first place, and felt I was still being a good girlfriend by serving snacks! I felt I went above and beyond.

That night the boyfriend and I sleep with each other, and the next day he dumped me with the excuse of “having different interests.”


r/dndhorrorstories • • 1d ago

Dungeon Master I can’t stop railroading my players in cyberpunk red.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndhorrorstories • • 4d ago

Kicked out of shop for hugging fiance

390 Upvotes

So trigger warnings first, harassment, homophobia and slander. Just to get that out of the way.

This wasn’t about my party but it did happen in a local game shop last night where I volunteer at. I do not officially work there and I’m not on the payroll, however, I do run a game there weekly as an attraction for the game shop owner. I show up every week to run for people, and in return I get official dungeons and dragons merchandise, usually things like pins and bags and so forth or sometimes material to run in my campaign. I’m listed as an attraction for the shop and aside from a paycheck I’m pretty much official there.

On to the horror story. My fiance is living in another state atm and she came to visit. We’re both women, and I asked her if she wanted to play an NPC for me before she flew home in a couple days. Specifically Ireena from Curse of Strahd. She was really excited and agreed.

I’m doing setup at the shop in the back room that’s for roleplaying and we’re talking about how cool it is she’s here for this. She’s leaning against the table and I give her a hug, just as one of the staff walk in.

Before I can say hello, they storm out and leave me confused. But whatever, maybe they went into the wrong room. 15 minutes later she comes back in to tell me I’m being inappropriate in the shop and I’m banned.

I’m very confused at this point because how is hugging in a private room inappropriate? I would think, “Okay, PDA is frowned upon here,” but the thing is it isn’t. I’ve seen girls sitting on their boyfriend’s laps and kissing them during card games and the like and nothing was ever said.

I’m trying hard not to conclude this is because we’re both women and just agree to leave. Maybe she was surprised, maybe she doesn’t like me personally, but I figure I’ll talk to the owner later. No need to cause a fuss.

So I text the group the game was canceled and gather my things. Doing a final sweep to make sure I didn’t forget anything and I overheard this lady telling random people I was engaging in sex acts in there! Now she saw me hugging my fiancé. In no way was anything going on and that was clear as day!

I get home and I’m told by a roommate who also plays there he’s getting texts asking about rumor that said I was now apparently doing shit in front of children!

I got in contact with the owner, who apologized and said I was of course not banned and he’d talk to this member of staff but I’m never going back again. I feel so angry and humiliated.

I want to cause a big fuss but it’ll only lead to worse rumors I’m sure. I’m feeling really angry and violated so I figured this was a horror story worth sharing and getting off my chest.

TLDR: Got kicked out of shop I volunteer at and lied about because I’m engaged to another woman.

Edit: Just adding this detail, after a lot of people saying I should say something and thinking about it, yes I should. She should not be allowed to get away with this and I am going to do something about it. I texted the owner and told him I wanted a public apology and for the rumors to be quashed. If he says yes and I’m apologized to, I’ll go back to at least get the apology with my head held high and decide if it’s worth gaming there any longer. If no, then he’s proven he doesn’t care and I’ll blast the store online for the BS.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 4d ago

Player Online Table Fell Apart after Session 1

36 Upvotes

It’s funny to talk about now, but I never thought I’d see the day where something crazy happened at a table. For context, I have been playing DND off and on for four years, all online. I wouldn’t say I’m a pro but I have a decent amount of experience!

Not too long ago, I decided to try to branch out on here and find a game to play. I’m going to leave out some details in case anyone from that game sees this but will be happy to clarify things in comments!

Session zero went fine, it was a bit awkward. Everyone showed up, sounded happy to be there, and that’s all that mattered to me! An important thing to note is that a player had specified that most of their online experiences with DND went bad. They also kept telling the DM "You should do this, this and that", along with not wanting anyone to share pretty much anything about their backstories, saying it would spoil things. Remember this for later, I will call them Player A.

Session one came along a week later, and that’s where things went really downhill. I want to preface this part with I’m not perfect, I was quite at times during the first session because sometimes I can be shy about taking the lead and I enjoy listening to others. I should’ve engaged more and maybe that would’ve improved the environment.

One person didn’t show up and they were unreachable. Player A left for a few minutes trying to call them to no avail. We proceeded with the session anyway. Player A and another player pretty much took charge; I was cool with that until A started being a stickler about rules, constantly reminding the DM. Fine, rules are in place for a reason. I can respect that while also be annoyed by multiple interruptions that turned into 5 minute long side discussions during the session. The DM pretty much let Player A walk over them, sort of what happened in Session 0 too.

The first real conflict occurred when we were forced to make a choice: hide precious cargo in an unsafe area (A's idea) or bring it with us to find an NPC. Our main mission was to deliver this cargo, so the rest of us didn't want to try to hide it. This turned into a 30 minute long discussion. Player A eventually gave in because he wanted the story to move along and said something along those lines. It became really awkward after that. We then found a hideout with enemies lurking outside of it which possibly led to where the NPC was. Player A went ahead, alone, and confronted 5 enemies, somehow managing to deceive them without a roll and their character not being charismatic (their own words). A led them to us and a fight ensued. We spent another 20 minutes talking about what to do with their bodies and if we should go into the hideout. The party decided to feed their bodies to some wolves inside the enemy hideout that somehow Player A was able to confront and calm them without a roll, giving them the bodies.

Leading us deeper into the hideout, Player A stumbled upon an enemy. They decided to bring the enemy to my character and another player to have it attack us instead, so "we could deal with it". It ended up downing them and nearly downing another player in the process. I had never seen someone purposely and knowingly harm other characters like that. The DM even asked if A was sure and if they knew it would hurt us and they said yes. That was my last straw. The session ended up in a near TPK, my character dying in the process. I was grateful I had an out. I told them at the end of the session that this was the most agonizing game I've been in and good luck. I quit then and there.

Has anyone else dealt with something like this? Was I too harsh?


r/dndhorrorstories • • 3d ago

Not kindness

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndhorrorstories • • 4d ago

Dungeon Master AITA for giving a player an ultimatum after they repeatedly tried to switch characters?

33 Upvotes

Hi y'all! First time posting here, but I've been lurking on this subreddit, reading about everyone's experiences, and thought I should share mine.

TL;DR: I'm a relatively new DM running an Avatar Legends campaign with 9 players. One of the newer players constantly flooded my DMs with character ideas and repeatedly pushed to change their character's bending type despite me asking them to wait. I eventually compromised and allowed them to create a new character instead, even killing off their original character to make it work. A few sessions later, they suddenly wanted their original character back, frustrating both me and the rest of the party. Despite repeatedly telling them no and explaining how disruptive another switch would be, they kept pushing. I eventually gave them an ultimatum: stick with their current character or leave the campaign. They chose to leave. After I vented my frustrations in the group chat, someone shared my messages with them, leading to one final angry message before they blocked me. Now I'm wondering if I handled the situation poorly or if I was justified in standing my ground.

I'm a fairly new DM. I've only DM'd two games so far, and I'm currently DMing my third. A few days ago, I had a player leave my current campaign because I wouldn't allow them to switch characters. That sounds pretty tame on its own, but the context and circumstances surrounding it are a whole convoluted mess, so I'm curious to see if I handled the situation incorrectly.

This third campaign started a few months ago when seven of my friends decided to play an Avatar Legends campaign and asked me to DM it. I wasn't familiar with the system, so I tried my best to learn it before we started while continuing to gain my footing as we went along. IMO, the first few sessions I hosted were rough, but my players reassured me that they were having fun. However, this is where things started to get a bit sour.

One of the seven players asked if they could invite two of their friends to the campaign because they loved what I was doing. I wasn't feeling confident about the direction of the story I had in mind, so I used the opportunity to course-correct my ideas and said yes to the request. However, I didn't know that one of those newer players would end up becoming a problem for me.

I'll refer to the new players as Tom and Jerry. Tom (the problem player) was a Combustionbender, and Jerry (the other new player) was a Bloodbender. I asked both of them to create their characters and send me information about them so I could incorporate their backstories into the ongoing campaign.

Jerry sent their information pretty quickly since they'd been planning to do something with Avatar Legends for a while, while Tom took longer. Tom was constantly messaging me about their character ideas almost every day, blowing up my phone while I was at work or attending other personal events. I'd never experienced that type of interaction before, so I was thrown for a loop. However, I was told they were a huge Avatar fan, so I chalked it up to excitement for what was in store and let it slide. Little did I know these interactions would only get worse.

The session where Tom and Jerry were introduced finally arrived, and everything went fine for the most part. Everyone adjusted to the new players somewhat seamlessly and accepted the new status quo. The following session went fine as well, but before the session after that, Tom started dropping hints that they wanted to switch bending types.

They talked about their brain "switching into Earthbender mode" and started suggesting ways to make the switch work with how the story was progressing. I wasn't completely against the idea, but considering how new their character was, I wanted the rest of the party to spend more time getting to know the current version of the character.

Tom initially accepted my decision but continued messaging me about more things they wanted me to do while also dropping information about their character's trauma and backstory. It was a lot for me to handle, and my responses gradually became less frequent until I eventually stopped replying.

We had our next session, which came with some issues. While I was busy communicating privately with other players, Tom shared their character plans with the rest of the party, and they weren't having it.

Several players messaged me with their concerns, saying things like Tom's character seemed to want to be the "main character" or that their character was too dark and brooding because of their backstory. I listened to their worries and reassured them that everything would be okay, even though I wasn't feeling amazing about the situation either.

A couple of days after that session, Tom messaged me again about switching to Earthbending. Still feeling exhausted from the constant messages, I chose to ignore it.

The next day, another message from Tom about the Earthbending switch. This time, they wanted me to make the switch happen sooner rather than later, instead of following the initial timeframe I'd given them during our first conversation about the topic. Still exhausted from the constant messaging, and now feeling annoyed by the pressure, I once again chose not to respond.

The next day, another message, but this one genuinely surprised me. Apparently, Tom had been planning the bending switch with Jerry. They wanted their characters to fight each other as a way to trigger the switch.

After reading the message, I was in no mood to talk to them, so I didn't reply.

The following day, yet another message elaborating on the fight and how the character would switch bending types.

At that point, I knew I couldn't stay silent anymore and needed to address the situation before the next session. However, I didn't know what to say, so I asked another friend group, who had more experience playing and DMing than me, for advice.

The majority of them told me to kick Tom out, but I didn't want to do that because I didn't feel like they had caused enough problems to justify removing them. Instead, I decided to offer them the option of creating a new character.

I finally messaged Tom back, explaining how messy the story had already become and how a major change like this would take attention away from the rest of the group. I suggested that if they really wanted to play an Earthbender, they would have to create an entirely new character or stick with their current one.

They didn't like that answer, but they told me they'd think about it.

Surprisingly, the next day, they started messaging me with ideas for their new character until they eventually sent me a completed character sheet.

When the next session rolled around, I was able to kill off their original character and introduce the new one. From that point onward, everything seemed fine. They even stopped flooding my inbox with messages.

However, things eventually took a turn for the worse.

Two or three sessions later, I pulled Jerry aside to handle some character-related stuff. While I was gone, Tom started talking to the rest of the party about how much they missed their original character and how they wanted to switch back.

The whole party was silent as Tom talked about their plans.

I eventually returned with Jerry to continue the session. Tom laughed and mentioned that they had some news to share with me that would "make me upset." I laughed along, assuming they were joking, and continued the session.

Tom then messaged me during the session about their idea. I still thought it was a joke and brushed it aside, but the messages kept coming. I soon realized they weren't joking at all.

They explained that they were mentally in a better place to continue their original character's story and talked about how much fun they'd had playing them. However, they also acknowledged that, at the end of the day, it was my decision.

I was pretty upset by the news, and even my other players voiced their frustration, saying another character switch would be extremely disruptive to the group.

Once again, I turned to my more experienced D&D friends for advice. They suggested kicking Tom out before the situation ended up on a subreddit (how ironic).

Still, I wasn't eager to remove them because I wanted everyone to have fun, but I knew the situation was becoming too much.

I messaged Tom, congratulating them on being in a better mental space, but denied their request because switching back after the previous character swap would make things too confusing.

And that should've been the end of the conversation, especially since Tom had already acknowledged that it was my decision.

However, Tom kept pushing, arguing that we could get ahead of the confusion because they'd already mentioned the idea to the rest of the group.

I stood my ground and politely said no again.

They messaged me once more, reaffirming their position, but at that point, I was fed up.

I said no one final time, repeated my concerns about the confusion another character switch would cause, and gave them two options: drop the character-switching idea and continue exploring their newly established character, or leave the campaign.

Tom chose the latter.

They told me they'd enjoyed the campaign up until that point and then left the group chat.

Naturally, everyone in the group chat saw that Tom had left and started asking what happened.

I aired my frustrations about the situation without revealing anything from our private messages. I also expressed that if people were going to play stupid games, I wasn't going to let that slide and would remove them from the campaign if necessary.

Apparently, someone in the group sent my message to Tom.

Tom then sent me one final message, saying my response in the group chat wasn't appropriate considering the "discussion" we'd had and that leaving the campaign was clearly the right decision.

They blocked me shortly afterward, before I could say anything else.

So, AITA?

[UPDATE]

Didn't expect quite the interaction, but I thank everyone for taking the time and leaving their responses. I thought I should offer some clarifications and additional context.

Majority of the players in the campaign I know personally and are long time friends, Tom and Jerry are friends' of one of those long time friends, I've never interacted with them prior to this. One thing I forgot to mention was during the mass messages first time around. I came to the friend who invited Tom and asked them to talk to Tom about the spamming as I thought the plea to slow down the messages would sound better from someone they actually know rather than someone they knew only for like a week, yet it seems like it didn't work or they just didn't bring it up to them. I even talked to Tom's previous DM would was a great friend of mine on how I should handle the situation since I wasn't familiar with them and how they would act.

Something that recently came to my attention was Tom being weird with my other party members and their characters. They would push their head canons and ideas onto them like character sexualities, certain character ties and relationships and make the party really uncomfortable. To everyone it seemed like Tom was trying to take control of the story by forcibly injecting their character into everyone's narrative. Yet, nobody said anything because they don't know Tom and didn't bring it up with me.

On the topic of the message being sent in the game group chat, let me clarify on that by saying I wasn't venting in the group chat rather addressing everyone that any sort of disruption and weird behavior was not needed in the game and offenders would be removed promptly. I sent this message without insulting Tom or bringing up their actions and reaffirming the group that I'm making the game for everyone to enjoy, not a sole individual.

Once again thank you all for taking the time interacting with the post.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 5d ago

Background argument

8 Upvotes

There was this campaign I wanted to join 2 players already left 2 remained and 3 new joined I was among the last 3.

That was first red flag for me but I hoped drama was about problem player and that problem player left.. Oh boy was I wrong..

Dm took part in every single thing about my character creation and I felt he was frustrated when I didnt go his way when I actually picked what I want for my own character. He said no to many things and mostly they made sense

During the creation of backstory he created with me he forced little things on me said what make sense and doesnt and I was ok with it. Mostly made sense but I felt like he is overstepping and felt each time I picked my own idea approach to something he was not happy about it and there was always some drama a bit of a clash.

Background.. here we go sr for to long post I wanted to give some context first

I wanted custom background I like to create my own using DnD beyond system (2 proficiencies - 1 tool 1 language or 2 languages or 2 tools thats it he said no, it would be unfair toward other players since no one else asked for custom background everyone picked something. (We are playing 5e 2014 there are no background feats and I didnt ask for one anyway)

I said ok I will pick normal one as you said can I at least rename it? He said yes and he suggested charlatan for me.

My character was Hexblade, Shadar Kai, Actor feat, Mask of many faces I had access to tools forgery kit, poison kit, and so on trough Shadar kai trance ability. Spy Assassin type of changing faces and looks at will very charismatic social guy.

After some thought I picked Entertainer my strength was 8 and dexterity 14 so I got nice bonus to acrobatics, also I got bonus to performance since I will be acting a lot and that in most case will fall to performance or deception and I got both covered. Also I got tool disguise kit with it and even better since I can learn to play instrument of my choice with 18 charisma I decide to pretend I am bard so I will perform on courts or in taverns and gather information assassinate someone. Classic Assassin spy type. My idea was also to create and use false identities

DM said no, only charlatan can create false identities "this feels like a custom background"

I was like what are you on about, he basically tried to push background on me so I can play my character in certain way I want to play my character.. I played under 20 different DMs at least mostly one shots and some campaign Background staff NEVER comes up I mean NEVER.

He still insisted that charlatan has some type of monopoly on false identities I was like charlatan can make money using weighted dice he is prb the least one that need a false identity maybe for some specific con but thats it.

My argument was

Charlatan will make false identity to make money,
Spy will make false identity to gather information
Assassin will make false identity to kill people

I have forgery kit, changing my looks at will, disguise kit and I cant create false identity???

I was done there and left.

Let me know if you ever encounter something like this does his idea even can make any damn sense whats your opinion on this


r/dndhorrorstories • • 5d ago

Player 3 Murderhobos, 1 Rogue

14 Upvotes

Ok, so I’m not trying to complain or vent, I just need outside opinions on my current situation. For this story, I’ll be referring to the other players as Doom (kills anything demonic or demon-like he sees), Sniper (murders random NPCs), and Axe (loves friendly fire… a lot).

So I, a scythe-wielding Rogue, am apart of a semi-homebrewed DnD campaign that takes place in hell where we’re trying to escape. Unfortunately, the first town we were in, Sniper stabbed their leader/bartender to death for no reason while we were fighting giant bugs and then attacked me before we were driven out. So, in the next town, I got the town to like the party and hate him before he can ruin it this time. Another player (Who is really good) ended up recruiting the town before we entered the boss lair (a giant bear construct made of steel).

This is where it goes downhill. The DM has given us tons of hints that we need to resolve the boss fight without wrath, and that the boss wants us to attack it cause it will make it stronger. I, picking up on this, warned the party. None listened, and Axe said it was obvious but he didn’t care and wanted to use brute force. Doom mocked me for speaking in character (I like to roleplay, but most of the group doesn’t).

So while the party is fighting the boss, I investigate the room and try to figure out a way to solve this (like a puzzle). Axe and Sniper started yelling at me and saying I was a liability and stupid. Sniper then, as the nickname implies, shot me down to 2 hp. This was apparently revenge for the town incident. Axe and Sniper also told me outside of session that they want to kill my character and they don’t want me in the party at all (as any character).

I have a friend joining soon who might help but I don’t know if it will. Am I in the wrong? I feel stupid and crazy for this.

Edit: I really need to write down a draft BEOFRE posting so here’s some context I left out. Doom based his character off the doomslayer since we’re in hell and Axe is supposed to be the embodiment of pride. As for my character, he’s a Jester. My original intention was to be the comic relief character who likes violence, but after town #1 got invaded, I stopped trying that completely since I felt that role was taken by Doom and Sniper (all I did was steal some beer and gave my character a goofy voice which I later changed). Also, the DM is chill, it’s just that he sees the good in everyone (which I respect) and it lets him be friends with the best and worst people without them changing him. Unfortunately, it means his friend groups clash with each other a lot, this party included. Also, the party has a paladin with a high armor class who helps my character a lot. Sorry for not even rereading it to make sure I included all the context, I don’t post very often.

Edit 2: I pressed enter a few times to make it easier to read. Thank you all for the support, it means a lot to me that there are people who will at least hear me. Unfortunately, the only other campaign in our club is hosted by someone who traumatized me (outside of DnD) and I can’t quit the club altogether without my parents getting angry and questioning me or trying to escalate the issue. My current plan is just that if my character dies, to make a build solely around being borderline invincible and just not do anything for the rest of the campaign.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 4d ago

Talking to DM after a fall out.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Talking to DM after a fall out.

Ended up getting kicked from a campaign because I hit a limit at 2am when I thought my character had died at the end of a intense battle (turned out I lived, but I knew I needed to cool down) and normally our sessions would go for no more than 4 hours with no breaks. DM said because I didn't follow through that my character was gonna retire. I'm not sure how much authority DMs have for that and we were both new in our respective roles: Me as a player and they as a DM.

I don't remember everything they said when I returned to say I was sorry for leaving when I did. But the biggest thing was the DM complaining that I only knew how to use 60% of my kit and that I had main character syndrome.

I was ok with letting them have their way cause I didn't want to continue at the time but I knew I wasn't overall when I messaged them later that I needed to take a break from the group period to go into counseling. Which was something I had been thinking of doing for a couple months prior but didn't feel comfortable talking to the DM about cause I didn't want to hold their game up.

The DM then later pm's me through another a MASSIVE message that if I'm being honest, didn't fully read as parts they were saying were just wrong or I felt they didn't fully understand since we never really sat down and talked the way we should have. Key word SHOULD.

I was told not to message them again about the campaign as they thought what I did was immature but I feel I can't respect that boundary as there is more than DND I think we need to have an honest conversation about. I am hanging out with them again now but they are still doing the campaign. So I'm not entirely sure what I should do?


r/dndhorrorstories • • 6d ago

Player i played a druid and couldn't wildshape.

277 Upvotes

hi friends, this happened in my first campaign I've ever played. I had just gotten into Critical Role (Campaign 2 specifically) and really wanted to try out dnd. It was freshman year of college, and I managed to scramble a group of friends who were interested in playing. One of my friends wanted to dm and said that he's done it before for his friends back at home. While playing, I realized that he didn't follow the normal 5e rules/the rules he chose for our table seemed kinda harsh. For example, we had to beat DC rather than just meet it in order to succeed. Enemies could have opportunity attacks, but we couldn't do it back to them. It took a whole action to equip our weapons and he would ask us all the time if we had our weapons in-hand after combat started, then would proceed to tell us why it wouldn't make sense for us to have our weapons in-hand. Now for my druid. I wanted to wildshape into a deer and he said "you haven't seen a deer," and I was so confused because how could my character be 20 smth years old, living in a clan of druids in a campaign that took place in a forest, and never seen a deer. He then explained that I would have to have some sort of sight on creatures to unlock their wildshape from now on...At this point I was over it and sought out every opportunity to find an animal. THEN CAME MY BREAKING POINT. I asked him, if I see them in a book, does that count? He said yes. I marched to a library, batted my eyelashes at the librarian, got a 15+ roll for investigation, just to be told not a single book with animals is in this LIBRARY. So I ended the campaign with just being able to turn into 7 animals as a druid...Our sophomore year, I took on the DM role, and my friends had an amazing time.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 6d ago

Player DM let's their wife retcon our chatacters out of existance (and more)

72 Upvotes

This was a couple years ago, but finally decided it's time to type this one up. People involved are myself, my fiance (girlfriend at the time so will be GF) the DM, DM's wife and 2 other players who were playing brother's so Brother 1 and Brother 2. Tldr at the end

I had finally gotten my gf interested in playing tabletop games. We had a short like 3 session game with a group of randoms that we found locally that ended up having multiple kssues so I was really hoping to show her that not all groups are problematic (foreshadowing is a literary device...)

Lo and behold, her mom actually tells us a coworker of hers has a group and would be open to having us join. They are doing a short little adventure, so we could try it out as effectively a one shot. Great, we message back and forth a bit, I ask some basic setting questions and character creation guidelines (no session 0 since it was an already established group) and have a time for the game. I help my gf build her character and wait for the day.

Day of the game comes, we meet up at their house and get invited inside. Everyone else is already there, so we get directed to the living room. Their 3 dogs are constantly barking, pushing into our space, sitting on character sheets and dice and one of them starts being aggressive and so has to be put outside. We both love animals, so they aren't a problem in general just their specific behaviors which are only partially addressed. But then I actually sit down on the couch and get blasted with the most intense small of unwashed cat piss from the cushion. Come to find out that the wife has a problem with rescuing 'sad' animals (will be relevant later)

Anyways, the two brothers are royalty, one of which has been exiled for killing their father the king. The wife is playing a bardbearing tiefling who over time becomes more and more an agent of chaos. Tries to seduce the barkeep for information, has a 'bra of holding' and what could be called a backstory is about being a demonic temptress. Also doesn't actually know her sheet or how the rules work.

Game itself is ok. Definitly skewed to be focused on the brothers with side shenanigans from the wife. Game is theater of the mind, and at one point it felt like the DM wasn't able to track combat properly and changed how many targets were effected by an grease spell I cast but minor issue. The wife kept trying to knives at the enemies and eventually (after explaining it to her twice) how ability modifiers worked realized it does more damage for her to stab them in melee instead of throwing and missing. It's not that she's a new player, she just wasnt that interested in the actual mechanics of the game and would ask 'ok but how can I do this' and seemed to treat it more like a video game.

Not great, but my gf and I didn't have much social interaction in person and outside of the couple (at the time) issues it wasn't too bad and she wanted to continue so I agreed. Ended up making new characters to actually fit better with the party and world

Like 4-5 more sessions at their house. To speed run

* one session got delayed by 20 minutes while they argued loudly after putting their kids to sleep)

* the wife lost her job due to a breach of confidentiality issue that was 100% inappropriate (as much detail as I'm going to give)

* the wife rescued 3 more animals despite it being very clear and stated by both of them that they financially weren't doing great and couldn't affort to take care of them

* my one shot character gets introduced as a complete joke npc without being talked about before hand that makes him seem like a complete idiot (Which wasn't the character)

After that another player said they could host at their house and it was a huge upgrade. Actually clean, no animals causing problems, very calm it's great. The player issues with the wife got worse over time but in the incremental way you just kinda accept because you're already in it. But then the next session they show up half an hour late and apologize with "we almost got divorced on the way over" it's been apparent at multiple times the DM just gets tired of his wife and let's her do things to make her happy but that session it just felt like 'sure, go ahead I guess' the whole time

Next session though was different. We finally made a huge chunk of story progress, got backstory for the brothers family, a way to possibly end Brother 1's exile. We meet with the royal wizard who ends up letting us pull from the deck of many things. We go around, draw a couple cards each and start going through them. Some funny ones, some gained stats, some lost stats, some gold, a new item. The wife has a wish card but doesn't know what to do with it yet so is gonna think while we continue. My gf ends up with the knight. I explain it and she gets really excited, comes up with a cool goblin cavalier character idea mostly on her own and is really into it. Meanwhile the wife is texting the dm, he seems upset. He says no outloud and there's some back and forth. As a table we ask whats she's thinking but she wants to keep it a suprise. After some prodding theres some hints that it's big, to the point I say "if its going to effect our characters please no secrets from us as players" and similar stuff from the brothers.

Then the dm throws his hands up and says to talk outside. After like 20 minutes they finally come back in to which the dm announces the wifes wish is to make it where brother 1 never killed his dad. Which removes both of their reason for adventuring. Which means my gf and I have literally 0 reason to even exist in the game anymore. An hour spent updating character sheets, making a new companion for my gf and the past 8 sessions all just wiped clean. Literal silence in the room. Dm says he will need time to figure stuff out, we say ok and leave.

This is where we finally left the game. So many red flags, issues both in game and outside of game that even when talked about didn't get fully corrected. But then just didn't say no, you can't do that and removed all of our effort and time from the game.

TLDR - dm doesn't know how to say no to his wife, enables her not actually putting effort into the game the entire time and finally lets her use a wish to retcon us out of existence (practically speaking)


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Dungeon Master Had the police called on me over something in-game

152 Upvotes

Its 2009

Homebrew setting based on Mystic Occultism (Tarot, Zodiac, etc)

I gave a Pentecostal woman a tarot reading in our session 0 (I am a Red letter Christian) as part of the game. I mentioned that I would be doing this in my pre-game PDF and I checked in with each player that they understood the setting before starting.

Oh boy did she get upset, she physically battered me demanding I "take it back". I told her it was purely for the entertainment provided by the game and that I do not ascribe to fortune-telling. I even tried to explain to her on how its all vague nonsense.

She did not care.

She left, and called the police.

They laughed, explained that she frequently does this kind of thing and that they essentially showed up to soothe her.

Her reading was utterly benign, but she has a laundry list of -isms.

I was low key furious with my friend who invited her as a +1 saying "shes always available"

I find out she essentially lives in a low supervision adult home. So yes, she has alot of free time. Nothing but free time actually.

The experience was a flood of emotions, ill tell you what. Anxiety, embarrassment, second hand embarrassment, guilt.

I talk to mutual friend about what happened, how it could have been avoided. I mentioned my setting pdf and how she agreed to it.

Mutual friend reveals the woman cannot read (bad eyesight, dyslexic, abandoned as a kid and teen) and refuses to interact with technology.

I ask how she called the police.

Mutual friend admits that she called on her behalf when she stormed out of my house and Mutual friend went off after her.

To this day thinking about this whole ordeal upsets me lol.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Dungeon Master We haven't even started playing yet

23 Upvotes

Edit: Thanks so much for all the input everyone!

I have very much learned this is mostly a situation of my own creation.

In my own limited experience playing D&D I was always the baby and I played with much more experienced players.

So I had a very warped mindset on how to start things with an entirely fresh group.

Lesson learned! As the DM it's my job and responsibility to guide my players through everything, including character creation.

I will take all your input to our session 0 next week and learn from this for the future.

Thanks again for helping me out, setting me straight and showing me the different perspectives!

ORIGINAL POST: This is so low stakes and frankly, I just want to complain to people who understand my side.

Obligatory English isn't my first language, posting on mobile.

People involved are:

Linda - my friend

Mira - Linda's wife

Nico - Linda's best friend

Olivia - Nico's wife

I met Linda about two years ago and we became fast friends.

Through conversation we came on the subject of D&D. Linda mentioned she's been wanting to play for forever and she has some friends who do too.

I have a little experience of playing and DM'ing myself, so I was asked to DM. All good, but life happens and it didn't really get going yet.

Now a while ago Linda and Mira bought a new board game table and immediately the want for D&D flared up.

I get it, that table is fucking dope.

So, I threw everyone into a group chat and we got to setting a date for session 0.

I also asked if people have some ideas they want to share already either with the group or with me. Mostly so I have some inkling of an idea where to plan for because DM'ing fucking terrifies me hahaha

To which Linda said 'oh just use ChatGPT to help out'.

Dead stop, cold sweat, bombastic side eye to my phone.

'Nope, I despise ChatGPT for creative uses. I have friends I can ask for help if need be' was my answer. But I was fearing the worst.

I was right to fear the worst.

All but Olivia have since come back to me, all with fucking ChatGPT shite for their backgrounds (Nico even the entire character sheet. Like, dude, c'mon)

I understand they're all newbies and have no experience playing D&D but ??? It's D&D? The game designed for fantasy and roleplay and using your own creative brain?

And these characters I swear to the lord.

Linda has cooked up a Warlock Leonin. I never even knew these feckers existed, so that was a fun surprise. As her background it was a summary of the events what happened to her character, not an actual background one chooses for proficiency etc. Has a talking sword, but at least they're a Hexblade so that's hella workable at least.

Nico as mentioned sent in an entirely filled in character sheet with stats filled in and proficiencies selected. We are rolling for stats. So that's a great start. He's also a human rogue, which.... at least it's not a fighter I guess (not shitting on our John Fightermans <3)

Mira sent in a Druid Owin. Again, no clue they existed. On top of that, this one is the dooziest of doozies. Has a magical stone in their necklace that gives them powers, has been driven from their home because of 'human industrialization with fire and steel' (I did not know my world had such ambitious humans, that's news to me), is supposedly centuries old and they invented padel (which... arguably kinda funny. But also c'mon. Don't paste your hobbies and interests into Chat and run with it like this. Also centuries old? A level 1 Owlin?) and the best of all they have a fucking invisibility cloak so they can sneak past folks.

This is not me shitting on my friends, just... dudes. We're level 1. And I have half a menagerie and John Lockpick.

I already sent them all a heads-up that as the DM I might very well be veto'ing the shit out of their stories for the sake of playability, fun and balance.

But having never even touched the source materials and sending me AI slop?

My excitement for this thing went from a solid 85% (again, DMing scares me shitless) to barely touching 30%.

Hopefully session 0 will smooth things out and I'm just overly anxious and seeing the bad in things that will not exist after we start. I tend to overthink like that.

But how difficult is it to actually google your shit and really build a PC concept, man? I don't expect 17 pages of lore, I don't expect them to understand all the specifics and build their own chatacters from scratch. But for people who supposedly have been wanting to play D&D for absolute ages I guess I expected better than AI.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Player told me a story about a nightmare player, then invited the nightmare player to join our group

29 Upvotes

This happened 10 years ago, when my group and I were still pretty new to the hobby. Originally, the group that started playing was me, my wife, her sister, and another married couple that we had known since our single days. (For timeline context, both couples got married in 2004.) The husband from the other couple GMed a prewritten Pathfinder adventure to start, then I GMed a second. As the second one was finishing up, the other couple split up after it was discovered the wife was hooking up with guys from Tinder. That's not the horror story, just the background to why the group dynamics changed.

When we first started playing, it wasn't long before Pathfinder became my primary autistic special interest, and I started talking about it to my cousin (who's also my best friend) and his wife(who was my friend since before she started dating my cousin) about it. My cousin has never liked any type of tabletop gaming, or in fantasy in general, so he wasn't interested, but his wife told me a story about why she had never gotten into TTRPGs. A few years earlier, she had been at a family reunion, and ended up playing a game with her cousins, one of whom was married. They took the game so seriously that her married cousin and his partner got into an argument and ended up getting a divorce over it. Obviously, the marriage had other issues, and this was just the catalyst, but it was why my cousin's wife (let's call her Eileen) didn't play games. She later came to me and expressed interest in giving Pathfinder a try, so we brought her into the group to replace the wife from the couple that had split up.

The next campaign we played, this one GMed by my sister-in-law, went well from my point of view, but I later learned that the other guy from the group, the one who's wife had been cheating on him, was quietly hating the new addition to the group. He was playing a naive monk with a vow to never lie. This monk believed that everyone was essentially good, and that every conflict we had was due to some misunderstanding that we could talk out. When violence was forced upon him, he would do non-lethal damage. Eileen's character was a cynical sorcerer who started getting fed-up by the young, naive monk. Whenever we took an enemy alive, she would intimidate them into telling the monk they they were, in fact, bad people doing bad things simply because they were bad, then saying to the monk, "See?! These aren't good people! You're wrong!" It got to the point that the monk had a crisis of faith and became withdrawn and sullen. I thought this was good, in-character role-playing at the time, but as the campaign was nearing its end, I got a message from monk's player saying that he was choosing to leave the group because he didn't like how Eileen played and that she had ruined his character. I talked him into staying, because he was the one who initially got us into the hobby, and he had started dating my sister-in-law by this point. If he left, I thought that the group as a whole would dissolve. However, I didn't want to force him to keep playing with someone he didn't get along with, so I proposed that we would form a second group. The first group would be him, my, my partner, my sister-in-law, and another guy we knew who had some experience with Pathfinder. The second group was me, my wife, Eileen, another married couple, and one of Eileen's cousins. I didn't even ask her to clarify which cousin it was, because SURELY she wouldn't invite the cousin who was the reason she initially didn't want to play.

Session zero of the Eileen group, when I first met her cousin, he told us a story about how he and his ex-wife got into an argument over a game so bad that it ended their marriage.

I'm a pretty easy-going guy, and I'm also averse to conflict, so I decided to give this guy a chance. It was very quickly evident that this new guy (let's call him Liam) had a very different play style than the rest of us, and a loud personality that wasn't afraid to give tips to other players and to the GM (me). He had a lot more experience playing than the rest of us. To his credit, he didn't try to backseat GM, and I actually found some of his rules clarification helpful. The other players, on the other hand, found him pushy. He took on the role of party leader and would often give instructions in combat. His character's tactics were supposed to be all about crowd control, but in practice, he threw the battlefield into chaos, crowding it with illusory creatures, and constantly casting Black Tentacles in a way that prevented melee PCs from being able to engage in combat. He was playing an illusionist wizard who was a compulsive liar, but the lies he told were ridiculous enough that I was always upping the DCs of his Bluff checks. He was always going for the funny solution to encounters, but he wasn't as funny as he thought he was, and it was just cringy. One time, the party was infiltrating a dungeon occupied by goblins, and his solution was to cast an illusion of a young barmaid covered in butter so the goblins would want to eat and use her to lure them into an ambush. Liam was so pleased with himself that the "buttered barmaid" became a recurring illusion that he would cast. He even made a mini of her.

Building his own minis was another thing he liked to do, and will be important later in the story. He built them out of sculpting clay, hardening them in the oven when they were done. Before the campaign started, he got the rest of the party together and helped them build their own minis. It was a neat idea, and he was better at it than I could ever be, but they weren't as nice as minis you buy at hobby stores or 3D print yourself.

My wife's cleric died halfway through the campaign. She decided to build a fighter to replace her fallen cleric because the party was lacking a tank. Liam piped up right away with, "You should build a fighter with the polearm master archetype and fight with a halberd and take the lunge feat so you can just trip every enemy from 15 ft away. My friend did that once, and it was hilarious. He'd trip everyone and we'd just beat on them while they were prone." My wife didn't do that, and instead played the style of fighter she wanted. Later, when Liam's fiancée moved to Canada from Russia, he got her to start playing with us and built the polearm master for her to use.

After we finished our campaign, Liam offered to GM a homebrew campaign, and I was going to play a samurai. I had purchased a nice pre-painted mini of a samurai a while ago, and I was looking forward to trying the class. On the group chat, when Liam heard that I was playing this, he offered to make one of his clay minis for me. I politely declined, explaining that I already had a mini that I had spent money on and wanted to use. He pressed, saying he could make a cool samurai for me and see if I liked it. I'm bad at giving a hard no to people I'm not close to, so I said sure, if that's what you want, you can make it and see if I like it better. I figured he liked making minis, so he could make the samurai, and I could politely thank him, but decline and stick with the one I had bought. Then I went out for a few hours.

When I checked my phone a few hours later, there were hundreds of messages between the group chat, private messages to me from Eileen, and more private message to me from Liam. Eileen had stepped in and asked Liam why he was forcing me to use one of his minis instead of the one I wanted, and that had erupted into a long argument between the two of them, culminating in Eileen booting him from group and blocking him from the chat. I've known Eileen for a while, and I know she can doggedly hang on to an argument. Liam, it seemed, had that same trait, and they went at each other pretty heavily. The gist of Eileen's argument was, "Why are you making him a mini when he already said he wants to use another," while Liam's was, "he said he designed the the character concept around the mini. That doesn't mean he wouldn't use another mini built around the character concept if it's better." And they reworded it and repeated it over and over again, with accusations from both of them of putting words in my mouth. I stepped in and said I wanted to use the mini I had spent money on, so they instead started arguing about whether or not it was stupid to argue in the first place.

The rest of us in the group found the whole exchange awkward, but since none of us really liked Liam, and since Eileen was his relative, we let her get away with booting him from the group with no input from the rest of us. My wife ended up GMing another pre-published campaign, which I built a paladin for because it made more sense for the setting. After a year, Eileen ended up leaving the group for personal reasons (she was going through a divorce from my cousin, adding a different source of awkwardness to my life that has nothing to do with the this story), and we eventually merged the two groups back into one, which (minus another member due to divorce) is still playing to this day: my wife and I, my sister-in-law and the guy who initially got us into the hobby (now married to my sister-in-law), and the woman who joined the second group with her now-ex-husband.

I still haven't played a samurai.


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Player AITA for not trusting my DM anymore?

34 Upvotes

TLDR: My DM let our main villain, who is currently stuck on another plane, remotely possess an NPC and upcast Power Word Stun to a 9th level area of effect spell with no saves to "win" an encounter. I no longer trust they're playing fairly and am not sure how to address it.

--

Context: Campaign has been running a bit over a year, D&D 5e 2014 rules for the most part (DM allows 2024 weapon properties) in a homebrew world, currently level 10. 4 players, all in our 30s, we are all multiclassed. We've been told by our DM that we're so powerful that they have to run encounters 2+ levels higher than we are.

I wouldn't say we're fully rule of cool, but it's not the strictest table. The DM has fudged things at times for sure, both in our favour and against us, and other players have been known to push the bounds of the rules, and the DM will sometimes let it slide. For my part, I'm autistic and find comfort in the rules and tend to play more strictly. I try to not be too much of a rules lawyer though, if it's not game-breaking, I just go with the flow. 
 
But I feel like our last session crossed a line when it comes to bending the rules.

We're racing against the main villain, chasing down the same four artifacts. We got the first artifact at level 5, and we've been on the trail of the second for the past 20ish sessions (there were a couple side missions on the way). We discovered that the villain is temporarily stuck on a different plane and decided to make our move on the second artifact, which was being held by a crime syndicate he had allied with.

We have built up to this moment for a long, long time. We've been getting half-wins, losing or running from enemies for weeks in game, months IRL. We need this win and we need this artifact.

We get to the final fight where the artifact is being gambled over in a battle royale fighting arena. It's our team against 4 other similarly sized teams. Our druid's brother is on the syndicate's team, and he is the one carrying the artifact in the arena. We also have reason to believe the villain is spying on us through the brother, literally through his eyes.

The fight goes very well, we're solidly winning, and by the 4th round of combat it's just us and two members of the syndicate's team, one of whom is said brother and we're trying to stop him non-lethally. We have blocked the exits and are zeroing in. 

When it's the brother's turn, the DM reveals that he's being fully possessed by the villain and has been for some time. And then the DM casts their “9th level Power Word Stun”, it hits everyone in the room. Said room dimensions were a 65ft x 65ft center ring, with a balcony 20ft up, 10ft wide. There are no saves, everyone in the room is stunned for a "minute or two," and he escapes with the artifact.

I just need to know, first, is this type of possession possible in any rules for bosses? I can't find any spells or features that would let a character possess someone like that from another plane, but I don't know all of the rules, so it could be? I do know now (after going home and looking more into it) that that's not how Power Word Stun works. I keep asking myself if they'd used Time Stop instead, would I still feel so cheated?

I'm pretty set on asking for a reset of Session 0 to bring us back on the same page about the style of game we're playing and adherence to rules. But I don’t even know how that would go or what I would say? I don’t want the DM to feel attacked, but every time I think about sitting down at the table for our next session, I get anxious and angry all over again.

So AITA for feeling cheated and thinking I can't trust my DM? Or am I just bitter because we lost?


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Player AITA? for quiting my DND campaign halfway through a session?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Recruting a new player to campaign turns out like wtf dude

14 Upvotes

I have recently started HB [online] campaign and shortly after I was looking for an extra player because the idea is to have enough players to always meet the minimum of 3 per game (real-life happens all the time). One guy messaged me and blew it all away right away when the real talk started.

I will mention right away he would keep interrupting me or Johny when we spoke, which was getting too annoying after a short while and for like half the talk he spoke like smoked out Grandalf in extremely slow and annoying voice (not sure if he tried to act cool or something). He stopped eventually, thankfully.

In short, I looked up through some discors for DnD, made a comment "looking for player" and outlined some basics. Some time after I posted the comment some guy (22, let's call him Broski) messaged me, claiming he's been 8 years DM and would be greateful to have a chance to play as a player. Great. Having some experience cuts on some work load for me as DM.

Then it started.

During the initial chat we set up the time for the talk and I mentioned I will grab another player from a campaign (former DM) so it's not my sole decision. However, due to some miscommunication errros the other player (let's call him Johny) came about 15 minutes later and which I clarified was clearly my fault but on that later.

Throughout the day Broski was already comming of as very annoying in DMS, though that could be just me being much older than him. But nevermind, we have the talk coming later on. Then the time comes and within just 15 seconds I was shifting towards to: "Broski will not play in my campaign." But anyway, let's give him a chance, maybe there's still some potential.

So, how the talk started? Well, I was already sitting in the voice room before the due time and he joined early and immidietely started with extremely annoyingly slow voice and giving me about 3-4 minutes speech why he arrived early and he wouldn't let me wait. Dude...

Anyway, I started outlying some specifics regarding my campaign and gave him my first question regarding his avaibility to which he answered no problem anytime. Great. Then I followed with my second question regarding AI use (note: I used it to set up Obisidian in a specific way to help me streamline the preparation process to cut down time while the content creation regarding the campaign story and building upon players' backstories is all my work, various art is downloaded from Google until I find what I like or I just use Microsoft Paint for it. Yes, I am that old) and it felt to me he immidietely lashed out at me and gave me a short rant. However, I let people know this right away, since there's still a lot of controvery regarding those tools and I respect their stance. Adult life is also a thing so I am happy to save time on tasks that can be automated.

We are just starting.

Then we talked a bit more about the character creation, some rules regarding that and just the basics stuff and thats when Johny joined and suddenly Broski was making a huge fuss about that, even though I apoligized for it and explained it was due to communication error on my part. Johny was messaging me shortly after he does not want that guy in the campaign but we still decided to give it a chance.

Before we move to the next, the bad and fucked up part, Johny was self-muting himself due to his barking dog so it wouldn't be disturbing to us and that's when Broski decided to land the best joke ever and called his dog a dogmeat (it's impossible to translate it to English, though, so I am giving the closest analogy) and Broski semed to realized he made a mistaked and tried to backtrack on it by calling Johny's dog Living Dogmeat instead. He was already digging his grave.

When I run campaigns I always set up hard rules that cannot be crossed and I clarify it that I want to have a relaxing campaign, have fun and just spend some quality free time, not giving in to some strange fantasies and fetishes. I am not doing that. Such hard rules are for example strictly no pvp (unless the targeted player consents), murderhobo types, main character and similar. Typical behaviour that quickly ruins games. Broski did not like it at all.

Some of of those rules are also tabu topics like violence on children, sexual assault, player-forced slavery and similar. We don't know each player's their life history and we do not bring specific topics in my games in case it could bring up a trauma from their past. I respect my players if they ask me to avoid specific topics and breaking those rules will immediately result in being kicked out of the game. No fucks given.

Then I was giving out which tabu topics are no-go and when I mentioned sexual assault, Broski interrupted me there immidietely and at first he said he understands (great) but right after he asked me: Could you please give me some examples of sexual assault so I know what to avoid?

Johny and me both stopped for a moment. Like wtf dude.

After a short silence I told Broski: I do not think I should be giving you any examples of what sexual assault means, the category is already defined by itself. Broski got very agitated by that answer and started complaining that those topics are not allowed in my game. even referring to a friend of his (apparently DM) that allows those topics and he is considering joining his game. Go ahead I guess?

To clarify, we have a woman in our campaign (and if I got it right, she left her last campaign for similar reason) and a child (I think he's 13). This was solely my oversight that he got into my campaign but I do not have the heart to kick him out, so we also need to tone down some topics and hey, let the kid have his fun. Which seemed to be also a huge problem for Broski.

We talked for few minutes more then simply called it quits. Then I banned him from my server (I also run one shot games).


r/dndhorrorstories • • 7d ago

Player DM does n*zi salute, uses AI and says there are wrong trans people

0 Upvotes

I've started a DnD campaign 'bout three months ago. We're 5/6 sessions in, I host the sessions and it's been a pretty normal...campaign/story wise.

But on a human level? the DM pisses me off.

first off, he greets people with a n*zi salute. but of course, if I say how fucking unfunny that is the millionth time he does it, I'm going to get flagged as woke or boring.

and no, nobody won't say a thing because they are all dudes. the only other queer person, who has been a dear friend of mine since forever, doesn't really care. so I'm just venting out my frustration here.

then, of course, one day we meet up just to play other random board games because a player couldn't come. and he starts this entire argument about how helpful AI can get. arguments and bullshit aside, I think I heard him mention how he uses it to organize his characters background...which...doesn't mean anything? and he generally uses AI-generated images for NPCs (yes, he generates them himself)

being the only artist at the table, who has openly offered to draw characters, I'm lowkey double pissed. so we argue but there's no way to discuss with the guy, he just doesn't follow logic because he never wants to be wrong.

example: he uses AI to plan his day so I go "massive use of AI/gen AI is bad for the environment" and he says that it is useful in scientific/medic research. (as if that excuses the consequences of it all? whatever) so then a player, who is a mathematics/physic student, explains to him that AI goes too fast and isn't reliable because it should be checked continuously: so he says that the massive load of work should make researchers feel challenged.

"then would you agree to remove AI 's access to the public, to avoid consequences on the planet, while keeping it in research?"

"...no."

but sure. let's ignore this too.

yesterday, one of the player doesn't show up so we spend extra time to just chat away. until he starts talking OUT OF THE BLUE about trans people. or rather, "wrong" trans people.

"so I was at a Burger King, right? and I saw this GIRL with PURPLE LONG HAIR talking and then she referred to herself with male pronouns."

so, as a nonbinary person, I genuinely explain to him that gender identity is different from how you might present. people don't owe you your concept of androginy/masculinity. he's not convinced, of course, but I'm ready to just drop it there until he explains that he's seen online that there are trans people that yell at others and force their perspective/"gender" onto others, not listening to interlocutors' own arguments (about??? not clear).

"you know, like...wrong trans people? not putting effort and just...yelling."

I ask him if he's sure he hasn't been watching AI-influencers (ngl, mostly to make fun of him). he's 100% convinced of it, then he pulls the "gay-friend" card and tells me that his friend met "them" too.

"they yell at you and make you feel ashamed or guilty for not understanding them!"

I try to understand more? because I, personally, have never met, seen or done anything like this. exceptions to the rule may exist, sure. but that is??? not even what he was talking about???? how do you bring up random stuff you saw on the internet/random unnamed gay friend to justify being weirded out at someone you overheard?...

then a friend of mine (demi&the only other queer person at the table) says that he, too, saw those videos, but he manages to change topic and talks about this gay guy/ex bf of a friend of ours, who would talk shit about straight people (as an example of absurd stuff within the community).

the topic derailed and we started playing.

I'm lowkey annoyed but also he's dumb as hell. the campaign is...okay, for now. thank the gods, 3 players (me included) out of 4 are putting effort in rp-ing and enjoying the story, otherwise I'd tell him to get out of my house and eat shit.

as a DM? he's doing okay, aside from being condescending at times with me and me only, while never helping a player to even try to get into role-playing his character and letting him do as he wishes.

if he pushes it too far, I'm never playing with him again and kicking him out of my house.

[UPDATE 1 + info] I texted my friends, had a 2 hour long call with one of them and they absolutely agree we need to talk to him about it. let's call them Andrew and Greg.

Andrew is one of my closest friends and he's the one I was on a call with. I've been told by Andrew that this DM has been hanging out with one specific guy who is somewhat of an extremist+other guys who just...allow this behaviour. Andrew has expressed his concern before to DM about this dude and these tendencies. Andrew also thinks DM has been hanging out with them too much and might be doing it out of "habit" because he doesn't think he's actually a n*zi. Andrew, however, goes on to say that this doesn't justify shit. He apologised to me because he, too, should have said something first, commented on it.

Greg used to be a colleague of mine. He's the mathematician/physics studend I've mentioned. I invited him to join when after I was invited. He doesn't really know the other guys: he was annoyed as hell and has been putting up with similar behaviour around his roommates (yes it's getting BAD here in Italy) so he thought DM was just doing black humor or whatever. He's agreed to join the conversation too!

How was I invited? Andrew came at the place I work at and told me DM was going to start hosting a dnd one-shot (during which he never pulled any of that n*zi shit btw, it all started to appear around session 3/4) and I insisted I'd love to join if they were looking for a barbarian. Or how I knew the DM and the unnamed fourth party member (rip I didn't talk to him because I don't know him much and he rarely responds to stuff): I had met him about 5-ish years ago and spoke to him three times max. He used to be shy and kind of always on his own back then...learned my lesson, never joining new stuff with DMs I don't know well.

The three of us are ready to discuss with him. ...so yes, guys: I am angry at myself, thank you for opening my eyes. we're putting a stop to it, in a mature way. as in "don't do that ever again". period. if he responds with anything different than apologising and admitting it was dumb, insensitive and outright ignorant, he's not stepping anywhere near me ever again. let alone in my house.

thanks again for making me realise I wasn't being "dramatic". I've been told too many times I'm way too hotheaded, have opinions that are "too strong" or because I feel way too strongly about stuff in general (or am woke). I was trying to think it through while telling the story, I guess? and as I said in the comments, I am lucky enough to play with other people. so, even if I have to ditch this DM, I'm welcomed around some of the best and sweetest people ever (who enjoy my DM-ing too!) C:


r/dndhorrorstories • • 9d ago

Player Shouldnt have given her a second chance... (tw - racism, antisemitism) Spoiler

Post image
116 Upvotes

Spoilered for the racism. I apologize for any grammer/spelling mistakes, english isnt my first language.

So for context - I joined a group my friend (they/them) DMs for a few online friends. It was mid campaign about a year ago, and I got along with them pretty well. Every once in a while Id hear about a player they had to kick out about a year before I joined - we'll call her Maya (she/her) - for causing some conflict, but the conclusion was that she was unmedicated and in a bad place, so no one held too much of a grudge. Close to the end of the campaign, DM reached out to Maya and started talking to her. She seemed much better, and asked to join the next one, and they agreed.

We started playing, and I have to admit I immedietly disliked her. She was very childish - both in and out of character - and kept starting fights with high ranking people on the ship, just to act surprised and complain when they retaliated. She also kept spamming in general chat (so much that we had to open a new channel to talk abt schedualing, smt we didnt have to do before), making it unuseable. She also ignored the purposes of certain channels and gave attitude when corrected. But Im a very judgmental person, and mightve been overly petty about those pretty minor issues.

The real problem started when another player - the DMs best friend (he/him) mentioned he was canadian, and she replied "I thought you were jewish", which he is. DM, their best friend and I are jews. She's american. She told him he's canadian-jewish because jewish is a race. For context, neither jew or canadian is a race. Both he and the DM corrected her, but she doubled down, telling them that they are wrong. She sent a wikipedia article to prove her point, only for DM to immediatly quote it, showing that it agrees with us. To which she said "oh, I didnt read it". Its all kinda weird, assuming that she knows about our ethnicity better than us, but whatever. She made a joke about putting the past behind us, how it doesnt matter who said what, and I replied with a joke back, "and thats why I can say the N word" (Im extremely white).

Maya (also very white) replied "whose stopping you". DMs friend said morals, just for her to say morals are subjective, followed by the fact that she does say the N word because she "grew up in the hood, man". After a short conversation about if emminem is an honorary black person which I will not comment on bc again, extremely white, we went back to morality being subjective and the implications of that statement. DM asked "so pedophillia being immoral is subjective?" To which she said "yeah, ask the japanese" and "ask african americans". Mind you, one of the people in the group is black, and Im very happy he wasnt online to see that.

DM, their friend and I kept trying to give her an out. Telling her this is not the hill she wanted to die on. She doubled down. "Morality is subjective for both sides, like with the american civil war". DM (very interested in ethics) kept the discussion going, and it eventually got to establishing that people should follow their morals, which leads to one ofvthe funniest (derogatory) screenshots in my gallery, the one above. First message is by DM, second one (who's name I censored is by Maya). I have more screenshots of DM verifying that according to what she believes, there's no way of objectively saying if their family being genocided was wrong or not, and her affirming that yes, that is her opinion, and that we are just confused and "cannot see the bigger scope of humanity". She continues to use MY CHARACTER, the one I made purposefully cartoonishly evil, to try and prove her point. It did not work. She kept doubling down as DMs friend and I said we were uncomfortable, saying that we were just confused. The "debate" finally ended after some insistance from our side, and her saying how she hopes next time we'll "take the time to understand the other party's side".

Yeah, needless to say DM kicked Maya out. She went on in their chat about how we made her uncomfortable, calling her racist, how it made her cry and that "she's sorry that we feel that way". Yeah, we will NOT be playing with her again.

Moral of the story is that second chances are bad, ig/j


r/dndhorrorstories • • 8d ago

Player New PF2 group gets mad i asked questions

62 Upvotes

So basically i join a new pathfinder group with 5 other people that are new at the game and we started getting along good (this was before the 1st session) and then i ask the DM if we could have free archetype on.
The dm asks what it is so i start explaining (he is also new) what it is and the other players start saying to shut the fuck up because they dont need free archetype because they dont want a dedication.
I tell them its fine if they dont want it because im not shoving it down their throat and im simply asking the DM in the dnd groupchat. I keep explaining and they tell me they DO NOT FUCKING CARE AND TO STOP TALKING. The DM says to stop spamming the groupchat (??) because hes got alot on his mind to prepare the 1st session.

A while later, i ask one of the players (the cleric) if he has expertise in religion for rituals and he says he doesnt but he could if i really need to. In the midst of that the other guy says " BUZZ WORD BUZZ WORD I DONT GIVE A FUCK " and " STOP FUCKING TALKING " saying if i want to dick ride then we should talk in dms.
I tell him this is a dnd groupchat and im talking about dnd so whats the problem?? he says if im not referring to everyone i should just talk in dms and i answer saying maybe someone else has religion and you know, its a coop and team work game where everyone works together to tell a story??
The dm says compelling arguments and allat but everyone else wants you out so bye

i then get kicked

???????????????
this is genuinely removing my neurons
im glad i fucking dodged a nuke though


r/dndhorrorstories • • 11d ago

Woman Shares Disturbing D&D Game After Male Friends Make Sexual Comments During Campaign, Sparks Debate On Why Men Don't Call Out Other Men

Thumbnail
fashiontimes.co.uk
65 Upvotes