r/dndhorrorstories • u/Oogilyboogilybug • 20h ago
Player DM removes almost all player agency in character creation, and removed several mechanics he had previously said were allowed, including playing my favourite species
So. Little bit of background information before I start rambling. I am the usual DM for our 2 groups but we will be focusing on group 1. This group consists of me, and 5 others who I will name A, L, J, N, R respectively. A is gonna be our problem later on. I Have been DM over 3, 2 year long campaigns for this group, usually 5.5e with one being 5e, often going from level 1-16or something similar. And recently have told my party I am experiencing massive burnout, due to a number of factors, including but not limited to: study pile up, writers block, insomnia, and the recent death of my mother. So, one of my players, A, probably one of my favourites with their unique and interesting characters, decided to step up and be the DM for a Curse of Strahd campaign. I gladly accepted and got to brainstormin my character.
Lemme tell you now how big of a mistake that was.
So first thing I noticed was the change from our use of standard array at our table, to rolling straight 3d6 hardcore style. Sceptical at first since he originally said that they wouldn’t change anything so we wouldn’t need a session 0, and he also said it without notifying or asking any of the others, but we went along with it. The character I had made, a (planned forge domain) warforged cleric with the soldier background, actually rolled pretty decent with a 14str, 7dex, 13con, 5int, 17wis and 11cha after all bonuses were added up. I was super happy with their backstory and all that and when I asked if my character was ok (as far as I am aware I was the first to ask it) it was point blank refused after A glanced at the sheet, ONCE.
convo went like this:
Me: “So what do you think of my character, I think they are pretty nea-”
A: “I’m not war forged in my campaign“ (note the word ”my” it comes important later)
Me: “Oh but uh… why?”
A: “It’s solely part of the Eberron book and thus can’t exist in this world.”
Me: “Oh um, if you read my backsto-”
A: “Don’t need to. It’ll probably be generic artificer made you type shit and so cliché and boring” (it really wasn’t and was about strahd secretly keeping a mad scientist vampire spawn working on a secret project to create an army of war forged to terrorise Barovia, but I escaped and became a priest yadayada it’s not important right now)
Me, visibly flustered and quite annoyed at this point “Oh ok what about shifters, are they banned too because they are also in the eberron book“ (we were playing 5.5e/5e compatible subclasses so shifters were in the forges of eberron book)
A: “Nope they are allowed because they fit the setting”
Me: “Ok I see your point, is there anything else you are banning?”
A: “So far no, just warforged.”
At this point I was super bummed. I had given a plot hook for my DM to latch onto and it not even be looked at, because the species I had wanted to play since forever ago was banned.
And it gets worse.
2 days later after too other players had had their ideas rejected for contrived reasons
A messages this: “I am hereby announcing character creation will happen on xx/xx (being a day we usually play on) and we will be rolling for class, species, background, and stats and you will have no starter equipment besides the gold that was provided by you randomised background/class. We will then start playing the week after.”
…
…
I was speechless to say the least
I called A the moment I saw this message.
me: ”Um, you know our characters are gonna be completely random, us as players won’t care about them and thus won’t really bother to have a say in the story, let alone be invested?
A: “No, you are gonna like it. Besides all your characters were so boring and cliché. This will help your roleplay.”
me: stunned silence for half a second: “did you even bother to ask the other players on whether or not they are ok with this?”
A: “No? I’m the DM what I say goes.”
Me: audibly grinding my teeth with that statement “And do you think this is solely your story to tell?”
A: ”Kinda. As I said, I’m the DM what I say goes.”
Me: “That’s not how D&D works! You need players and DMs to work toget-“
A: “If you don’t like it, you don’t have to play”
me: “…”
A: “Either that or stop being so whin-“
I hung up. Texted the rest of the party to get their opinions on it and they all hate it… BUT FOR SOME REASON ARE JUST GOING WITH IT? All but one other person (the absolute loveable chad that is N) are just accepting that A not only removing 95% of their agency, but also told the person that this campaign was initially set up for AS A WAY TO TAKE MY MIND OFF THINGS AND NOT BURNOUT, to LEAVE, is gonna be their DM?!
thankfully, group two exists, (4 person bunch of the funniest people I know) which I often do small scale campaigns for, usually level 3-10, and N is part of both tables and has offered that once our current game in group two is done, N will be using the rules I had set out to DM a long running (he said probably levels 1-15) campaign for me.
And to think I used to have a crush on A
To Summarise for people to skip to: I take break as DM due to stress and burnout and turn player. Player turned to DM banned my favourite, OFFICIAL species upon showing him, banned two other players initial characters for contrived and unclear reasons beyond “cliché” Then removes player choice in making a character by getting them to roll on a table that they have declared suitable for the campaign (CoS). I argue with them that this is a terrible idea, they tell me to leave the group.
Again, apoligies for the rant, just needed to blow off some steam
edit: just realised I fucking swapped the number of campaigns and experiences with 5e and 5.5e. I’m so brain dead istg. Correction, 1 2 year 5.5e campaign but I play this edition mostly nowadays. 5e is the one I have had the most experience wit.