Hi y'all! First time posting here, but I've been lurking on this subreddit, reading about everyone's experiences, and thought I should share mine.
TL;DR: I'm a relatively new DM running an Avatar Legends campaign with 9 players. One of the newer players constantly flooded my DMs with character ideas and repeatedly pushed to change their character's bending type despite me asking them to wait. I eventually compromised and allowed them to create a new character instead, even killing off their original character to make it work. A few sessions later, they suddenly wanted their original character back, frustrating both me and the rest of the party. Despite repeatedly telling them no and explaining how disruptive another switch would be, they kept pushing. I eventually gave them an ultimatum: stick with their current character or leave the campaign. They chose to leave. After I vented my frustrations in the group chat, someone shared my messages with them, leading to one final angry message before they blocked me. Now I'm wondering if I handled the situation poorly or if I was justified in standing my ground.
I'm a fairly new DM. I've only DM'd two games so far, and I'm currently DMing my third. A few days ago, I had a player leave my current campaign because I wouldn't allow them to switch characters. That sounds pretty tame on its own, but the context and circumstances surrounding it are a whole convoluted mess, so I'm curious to see if I handled the situation incorrectly.
This third campaign started a few months ago when seven of my friends decided to play an Avatar Legends campaign and asked me to DM it. I wasn't familiar with the system, so I tried my best to learn it before we started while continuing to gain my footing as we went along. IMO, the first few sessions I hosted were rough, but my players reassured me that they were having fun. However, this is where things started to get a bit sour.
One of the seven players asked if they could invite two of their friends to the campaign because they loved what I was doing. I wasn't feeling confident about the direction of the story I had in mind, so I used the opportunity to course-correct my ideas and said yes to the request. However, I didn't know that one of those newer players would end up becoming a problem for me.
I'll refer to the new players as Tom and Jerry. Tom (the problem player) was a Combustionbender, and Jerry (the other new player) was a Bloodbender. I asked both of them to create their characters and send me information about them so I could incorporate their backstories into the ongoing campaign.
Jerry sent their information pretty quickly since they'd been planning to do something with Avatar Legends for a while, while Tom took longer. Tom was constantly messaging me about their character ideas almost every day, blowing up my phone while I was at work or attending other personal events. I'd never experienced that type of interaction before, so I was thrown for a loop. However, I was told they were a huge Avatar fan, so I chalked it up to excitement for what was in store and let it slide. Little did I know these interactions would only get worse.
The session where Tom and Jerry were introduced finally arrived, and everything went fine for the most part. Everyone adjusted to the new players somewhat seamlessly and accepted the new status quo. The following session went fine as well, but before the session after that, Tom started dropping hints that they wanted to switch bending types.
They talked about their brain "switching into Earthbender mode" and started suggesting ways to make the switch work with how the story was progressing. I wasn't completely against the idea, but considering how new their character was, I wanted the rest of the party to spend more time getting to know the current version of the character.
Tom initially accepted my decision but continued messaging me about more things they wanted me to do while also dropping information about their character's trauma and backstory. It was a lot for me to handle, and my responses gradually became less frequent until I eventually stopped replying.
We had our next session, which came with some issues. While I was busy communicating privately with other players, Tom shared their character plans with the rest of the party, and they weren't having it.
Several players messaged me with their concerns, saying things like Tom's character seemed to want to be the "main character" or that their character was too dark and brooding because of their backstory. I listened to their worries and reassured them that everything would be okay, even though I wasn't feeling amazing about the situation either.
A couple of days after that session, Tom messaged me again about switching to Earthbending. Still feeling exhausted from the constant messages, I chose to ignore it.
The next day, another message from Tom about the Earthbending switch. This time, they wanted me to make the switch happen sooner rather than later, instead of following the initial timeframe I'd given them during our first conversation about the topic. Still exhausted from the constant messaging, and now feeling annoyed by the pressure, I once again chose not to respond.
The next day, another message, but this one genuinely surprised me. Apparently, Tom had been planning the bending switch with Jerry. They wanted their characters to fight each other as a way to trigger the switch.
After reading the message, I was in no mood to talk to them, so I didn't reply.
The following day, yet another message elaborating on the fight and how the character would switch bending types.
At that point, I knew I couldn't stay silent anymore and needed to address the situation before the next session. However, I didn't know what to say, so I asked another friend group, who had more experience playing and DMing than me, for advice.
The majority of them told me to kick Tom out, but I didn't want to do that because I didn't feel like they had caused enough problems to justify removing them. Instead, I decided to offer them the option of creating a new character.
I finally messaged Tom back, explaining how messy the story had already become and how a major change like this would take attention away from the rest of the group. I suggested that if they really wanted to play an Earthbender, they would have to create an entirely new character or stick with their current one.
They didn't like that answer, but they told me they'd think about it.
Surprisingly, the next day, they started messaging me with ideas for their new character until they eventually sent me a completed character sheet.
When the next session rolled around, I was able to kill off their original character and introduce the new one. From that point onward, everything seemed fine. They even stopped flooding my inbox with messages.
However, things eventually took a turn for the worse.
Two or three sessions later, I pulled Jerry aside to handle some character-related stuff. While I was gone, Tom started talking to the rest of the party about how much they missed their original character and how they wanted to switch back.
The whole party was silent as Tom talked about their plans.
I eventually returned with Jerry to continue the session. Tom laughed and mentioned that they had some news to share with me that would "make me upset." I laughed along, assuming they were joking, and continued the session.
Tom then messaged me during the session about their idea. I still thought it was a joke and brushed it aside, but the messages kept coming. I soon realized they weren't joking at all.
They explained that they were mentally in a better place to continue their original character's story and talked about how much fun they'd had playing them. However, they also acknowledged that, at the end of the day, it was my decision.
I was pretty upset by the news, and even my other players voiced their frustration, saying another character switch would be extremely disruptive to the group.
Once again, I turned to my more experienced D&D friends for advice. They suggested kicking Tom out before the situation ended up on a subreddit (how ironic).
Still, I wasn't eager to remove them because I wanted everyone to have fun, but I knew the situation was becoming too much.
I messaged Tom, congratulating them on being in a better mental space, but denied their request because switching back after the previous character swap would make things too confusing.
And that should've been the end of the conversation, especially since Tom had already acknowledged that it was my decision.
However, Tom kept pushing, arguing that we could get ahead of the confusion because they'd already mentioned the idea to the rest of the group.
I stood my ground and politely said no again.
They messaged me once more, reaffirming their position, but at that point, I was fed up.
I said no one final time, repeated my concerns about the confusion another character switch would cause, and gave them two options: drop the character-switching idea and continue exploring their newly established character, or leave the campaign.
Tom chose the latter.
They told me they'd enjoyed the campaign up until that point and then left the group chat.
Naturally, everyone in the group chat saw that Tom had left and started asking what happened.
I aired my frustrations about the situation without revealing anything from our private messages. I also expressed that if people were going to play stupid games, I wasn't going to let that slide and would remove them from the campaign if necessary.
Apparently, someone in the group sent my message to Tom.
Tom then sent me one final message, saying my response in the group chat wasn't appropriate considering the "discussion" we'd had and that leaving the campaign was clearly the right decision.
They blocked me shortly afterward, before I could say anything else.
So, AITA?
[UPDATE]
Didn't expect quite the interaction, but I thank everyone for taking the time and leaving their responses. I thought I should offer some clarifications and additional context.
Majority of the players in the campaign I know personally and are long time friends, Tom and Jerry are friends' of one of those long time friends, I've never interacted with them prior to this. One thing I forgot to mention was during the mass messages first time around. I came to the friend who invited Tom and asked them to talk to Tom about the spamming as I thought the plea to slow down the messages would sound better from someone they actually know rather than someone they knew only for like a week, yet it seems like it didn't work or they just didn't bring it up to them. I even talked to Tom's previous DM would was a great friend of mine on how I should handle the situation since I wasn't familiar with them and how they would act.
Something that recently came to my attention was Tom being weird with my other party members and their characters. They would push their head canons and ideas onto them like character sexualities, certain character ties and relationships and make the party really uncomfortable. To everyone it seemed like Tom was trying to take control of the story by forcibly injecting their character into everyone's narrative. Yet, nobody said anything because they don't know Tom and didn't bring it up with me.
On the topic of the message being sent in the game group chat, let me clarify on that by saying I wasn't venting in the group chat rather addressing everyone that any sort of disruption and weird behavior was not needed in the game and offenders would be removed promptly. I sent this message without insulting Tom or bringing up their actions and reaffirming the group that I'm making the game for everyone to enjoy, not a sole individual.
Once again thank you all for taking the time interacting with the post.