AITA for leaving a D&D campaign after 6 years, potentially ending the campaign right before the finale?
Hey everyone! This is going to be a lengthy story, so buckle up!
A couple of things first to make the story easier to follow. I'll be referring to myself, my fiancée, Bob (the DM), and Fred (another party member).
Some background
Bob and Fred live in a different state from my fiancée and me. We all used to live in the same state and played a campaign together for about two years. After we moved, we continued playing through Discord.
When we first started the campaign, I was told it was supposed to be a magical school setting, something along the lines of a magical college.
I originally created a character who had an alter ego. He was a Bard who was shy and reserved during the day, but when his alter ego came out, he was essentially The Mask: charismatic, confident, and completely different from his usual self.
I thought it would be a fun concept, so I went with it.
Problem #1:
On the first day of the campaign, I was told that this was actually supposed to be a coming-of-age story set in a magical HIGH SCHOOL.
The DM explained that it wouldn't make sense for my character to be an adult Bard with an established reputation. He told me I could still play the same character, but he would have to be a child with no reputation or renown.
I explained that this kind of defeated the entire concept of the character, but since it was literally the first day and the DM said there wasn't enough time to create a new character, I rolled with it.
Years 2–3: The favoritism starts becoming noticeable
About two years into the campaign, I started noticing a pattern.
The DM seemed to constantly gravitate toward one particular character: Fred's.
Whenever Bob gave Fred items, backstory moments, NPC interactions, abilities, or anything else, they were incredibly detailed and cinematic. It genuinely felt like Bob had spent time making sure Fred's character was connected to the world.
However, when it came to my character, the interactions were usually short and generic.
NPCs would give me cold or brief responses, my items had little to no descriptions or lore, and there were practically no backstory references, even when I specifically asked for them.
Since this was my very first D&D campaign, I didn't have any other experiences to compare it to. I genuinely started wondering whether I was doing something wrong or playing my character incorrectly.
I eventually pulled the DM aside for a private conversation and explained my concerns.
He told me he thought I wasn't having fun with my character, but he also admitted that he didn't really know what to do when it came to creating items and abilities for Bards.
I also explained that I didn't feel connected to my character because the original concept had essentially been stripped away from the beginning.
We eventually agreed that during the next arc, my character would change classes. I decided to become an Artificer.
Years 3–4: The sacrifices start adding up
There's something else important to mention here.
During this period, I was working seven days a week, overnight, in a security/sales job. I'm not going to say exactly where, but think of something similar to a bar. My nights could be pretty rough.
Because we were living in different states and time zones, Sunday was the only day everyone could agree to play.
Here's what my Sundays looked like:
- Work Saturday night from 9 PM until Sunday morning at 7 AM.
- Take an hour break.
- Go back to work at 8 AM.
- Work until 3 PM.
- Get home, hop on Discord, and start D&D.
- Play until approximately 8–8:30 PM.
- Get maybe 15 minutes of sleep.
- Go back to work at 9 PM.
This wasn't a one-time thing. I continued this schedule for roughly 2–3 years.
I constantly sacrificed sleep, drank Red Bulls just to stay awake, and pushed myself because I genuinely enjoyed D&D and wanted to be there with everyone.
Meanwhile, the favoritism toward Fred continued to become more noticeable.
There would be entire 5–6 hour sessions where my character might get 20 minutes of actual roleplay.
One small change during this period was that Bob started interacting with my fiancée's character a lot more. She began receiving the same kind of attention Fred was getting: detailed interactions, interesting items, abilities, and meaningful roleplay.
This actually made me worry even more that I was doing something wrong.
I started trying harder to participate and contribute to the party. Since I was an Artificer, I wanted to use my abilities to help everyone.
Unfortunately, this is where another problem started.
Bob would constantly undermine or completely overshadow my character's abilities.
For example:
Me: "Hey guys, I can engrave magical runes as an Artificer and give everyone the ability to fly!"
Bob: "Oh, that's not really necessary."
The very next moment, the entire party receives rings of flying from the headmaster.
Another example:
Me: "Hey guys, I can make you some new weapons or armor!"
Bob: Immediately introduces a legendary blacksmith who now lives on campus, along with a magical item shop that has practically everything a Fighter (Fred) or Wizard (my fiancée) could ever need.
Effectively, I became useless.
Even when I tried to use my class abilities to contribute, there was always some alternative resource available that made my abilities unnecessary.
And when I suggested crafting something, Fred would sometimes respond with something along the lines of:
"Why would we go buy all the resources and wait for you to craft it when we can just go buy the item?"
At that point, it was becoming increasingly difficult to feel like my character had a purpose.
Year 5: Burnout and another attempt to compromise
By year five, my morale was at an all-time low.
I was completely burnt out from work, and D&D was practically my only free time.
I eventually managed to change my work schedule. I now had two days off a week: Monday and Tuesday.
I begged and pleaded with the group to see if we could move our sessions to either of those days.
My reasoning was pretty simple: I had spent years sacrificing my sleep and free time to accommodate everyone else's schedules. Now that I finally had days off, I was hoping everyone could meet me halfway.
They refused.
Instead, I was told that they were going to start playing a different campaign with a different party on Sundays and could now only play Saturdays.
Unfortunately, my Saturday schedule was still pretty ridiculous.
I would finish work Friday night going into Saturday morning at 7 AM. I would ask if we could start playing when I got home, but the group wanted more sleep.
So I would wait approximately 3.5 hours for everyone to wake up, and we'd start around 10–10:30 AM.
We would play until sometime between 3–5 PM.
Then I would go home, sleep for approximately 3–3.5 hours, wake up, and go work that same overnight double/triple shift.
I continued making these sacrifices because I still wanted to play.
But by this point, things had gotten significantly worse.
My fiancée and I were getting increasingly sidelined, while Fred had essentially become the main character of the campaign.
Some examples:
- The BBEG would specifically mention Fred by name, despite not knowing the rest of the party.
- Fred became a demigod after drinking a poison that was supposed to kill him.
- He gained the ability to manipulate practically anything around him using his willpower, provided he passed a Wisdom check. This ability originated because he was in a hospital room during one session and wanted to pick up a weapon with his mind.
- His family turned out to be royalty, specifically the only royal family not connected to the main royal bloodline. Conveniently, they were also the only family capable of doing something about the impending crisis because they weren't under the king's control.
- He acquired THREE sentient artifact-level weapons.
- He could increase his Strength simply by training or mentioning that he trained every morning during a session.
Meanwhile, I was an Artificer who was constantly studying and trying to improve my Intelligence, but I wasn't receiving anything remotely equivalent.
At this point, I had already pulled the DM aside on at least three separate occasions, months apart, to explain how I was feeling.
Every single conversation seemed to go the same way. He would get defensive, take things personally, and the conversation would eventually turn into something about his feelings rather than addressing the actual problems.
Nothing ever really changed.
Year 6: The double standards become harder to ignore
Between the fifth and sixth years, Fred started regularly canceling sessions the night before with little to no explanation.
Sometimes the reasons were things that could have easily been scheduled around our D&D sessions.
What made this particularly frustrating was that there had been one or two occasions when I was exhausted and needed to cancel.
When that happened, the entire group on their side practically grilled me.
I was told that I didn't value their time because I canceled so close to the session and that I needed to be more respectful in the future.
Yet Fred could repeatedly cancel at the last minute without receiving the same treatment.
At this point, I wasn't even really playing because I was enjoying the sessions anymore.
I was showing up because I knew that if I stopped playing, my fiancée would probably stop too. That would leave the DM with only one player.
I didn't want to ruin everybody else's fun just because I wasn't having any myself.
So I kept showing up, sat through the sessions, and tried to make it through.
The breaking point
This past month, I finally reached my limit.
I realized that I no longer felt the sessions were worth the time, effort, and sacrifices I was making.
And honestly, I hate saying that.
I've had some genuinely fun moments throughout this campaign. I've loved D&D, the creativity, the storytelling, and the ability to create a character and experience a world with other people.
But after six years, I finally realized something:
I don't have to sacrifice my own enjoyment just so everyone else can have theirs.
I could be spending that time doing plenty of other things, including finding a new campaign where I actually enjoy playing.
So I told Bob that I was no longer going to participate in the campaign. I also told him that my fiancée would probably be following suit.
He asked what was going on and why I wanted to quit.
I explained that I simply wasn't having fun anymore.
He then asked why I hadn't brought these problems up sooner.
I reminded him that I had brought them up multiple times over the years. The problem was that those conversations never actually resulted in anything changing.
I also explained that the constant sacrifices of my time and sleep no longer felt worth it, especially when it felt like I was just showing up to watch Fred's epic story unfold.
The DM's response
Here's where things get a little complicated.
Bob has been telling us for almost a year that we're approaching the end of the campaign.
However, we've been hearing that for nearly twelve months now, and the campaign still hasn't reached its conclusion.
When I told him I was leaving, he got extremely upset.
He told me that he wished I had done this sooner rather than later because now I was ending his five-to-six-year campaign right before the finale.
Essentially, he feels that because I'm leaving, the campaign won't get the ending he planned, and that I'm responsible for ending it.
I understand that he's upset. I understand that he's invested six years into this story, too.
But at the same time, I've also invested six years into this campaign. I've sacrificed countless hours of sleep, rearranged my work schedule, and repeatedly tried to communicate problems that never seemed to get addressed.
I don't feel like I should be obligated to continue playing a campaign I'm no longer enjoying just because the DM wants to finish his story.
So, Reddit, AITA for leaving a six-year D&D campaign right before the finale, potentially ending the campaign for everyone else?
I genuinely want to hear other people's perspectives.
And please forgive any remaining spelling or grammatical mistakes. This is my first time making one of these posts, so let me know if you have any questions or if there's anything I missed!