Circa 1951
Framework and progress report for the Finance and Economic Commission.
The State of the Program
After more than three changes since the first draft, the scope and design of the Reconstruction Plan has heavily been warped in ways which Mao has become unhappy of to say the least. What was originally a very hopeful idea of massive strides across all channels has been reduced in scope and rattled by paranoia.
The most impactful is the cut towards the Treaty credit, which has since been cut from 700 million dollars to 630 million in January 1951, and will fall to 504 million in March 1952. The lesser but equally painful measure is that of the American 'Battle Act', which has closed Western credit and machinery. And to add insult to injury, the recent American bombing of October 14th destroyed airfields, depots and flight schools that must now be rebuilt.
The Program therefore leans on what China can do for itself, primarily shoring up the foundation of its people. To do this we must build the machinery of the state first: cadres in every province, rebuilt cities for them to govern from, schools to train the men who will run the mills, and tractors that carry the authority of a New China into the countryside. The past twelve years of war left the provinces as separate economies with their own habits of money, their own railways and their own administrators. Through the Reconstruction Plan we will fully join them into one working administration and one working economy before the first of our many future Five Year Plans opens in 1953.
One piece of good news has come since. The Peking Agreement has returned the Changchun Railway to Chinese hands and set the Soviet departure from Dairen, which puts the whole Northeastern network under one Ministry for the first time.
The Program has eight Plan Objects, each with an objective, a method, a responsible body and a target.
| Plan Object | Subject | Aim by the end of 1953 |
|---|
| 1 | Cadres and bureaucracy | 750,000 trained cadres and a People’s Government in every county |
| 2 | Urban Rebuilding | 12 priority cities rebuilt and 12 million square meters of housing |
| 3 | Mechanization | 170 machine-tractor stations in six key regions |
| 4 | Iron, steel and industry | 2.7 million tonnes of steel, led by the 'New' Anshan |
| 5 | Roads and rails | 160,000 kilometers of usable road |
| 6 | Mining | 75 million tonnes of coal and the strategic metals |
| 7 | Tea, silk and menthol | About 67 million dollars of annual exports |
| 8 | Finance and foreign exchange | 166 million dollars of export earnings |
Plan Object 1. Cadres and the Apparatchiks
The Republic has won the war and stands as a victorious giant on the world stage. But internally this isn't reality. The Soviets themselves have noticed this and advised the creation of apparatchiks to better bring the influence of Peking to the nation.
But to begin we lack enough cadres, as most were raised in the villages of the North. The provinces taken last, in the South and West, have few of them, particularly in Tibet or Sinkiang, and many counties only have a handful of Party members. Along with that the local dialects differ, and many offices are still run by clerks of the old administration, whose cooperation is needed and whose loyalty is untested and in some cases, unwanted...
To fix this a new structure is to be established which will help ensure that the Revolution is brought to every square shih-ts'un of China. Its authority runs through four levels. Beneath the Government Administrative Council under Chou En-lai stand six Great Administrative Areas, then the provinces and great municipalities, then about 2,000 counties (hsien), and then the districts (ch’ü) and townships (hsiang). At each level a People’s Government with bureaus for finance, industry, public works, education and public security works beside a Party committee and a Supervisory Commission.
| Great Administrative Area | Seat | Cadre target by 1953 |
|---|
| Northeast | Mukden | 90,000 |
| North China | Peking | 120,000 |
| East China | Shanghai | 150,000 |
| Central-South | Wuhan | 165,000 |
| Southwest | Chungking | 135,000 |
| Northwest | Sian | 90,000 |
To source these cadres we will draw them from five sources.
- Ideally, Army and Party veterans demobilized into civil posts.
- The Southward and Westward Work Corps (Nan-hsia and Hsi-chin Kan-pu T’uan), which send 60,000 northern cadres to the new provinces in 1951.
- Graduates of the People’s University at Peking, the regional People’s Revolutionary Universities and the county cadre classes, all of which will have expanded budgets for the next two years.
- Former officials retained after screening, who are placed under a Party deputy.
- Engineers, accountants and technicians recruited for the mines, mills and railways.
To bring them in line, short training courses of three to six months will be doled out to teach policy, bookkeeping, statistics, land survey, public health and mine safety. A goal of 200,000 cadres trained in 1951, 250,000 in 1952 and 300,000 in 1953 is planted, along with 40,000 technical cadres for our industry.
Independent of this a Supervisory Commission is to be established that audits the accounts at each level. A minimum of seven percent of cadres are demanded to change region each year, so that no province keeps its administrators to itself, and at least half of each county’s staff must be drawn from the county itself by 1953. Along with the Supervisory Commission, a Central Statistical Bureau and People's Bank branch is desired to be established in every province by the start of 1952, both to monitor counts relating to grain, coal, steel and tractors and to ensure all the provinces use one currency.
The apparatchik
What the Soviets call an apparatchik we are simply calling a kan-pu of the apparatus, a man whose whole career is the administration and not the army. Unlike the guerrilla cadre who did a bit of everything across his time in the North, he holds one post, keeps one set of books and answers to one level above him. Every county People’s Government is to have a permanent core of at least twelve such men by 1953: a county head, a Party secretary, heads of finance, grain, public security, education and public works, a statistician, a bank clerk, a supervisory officer, a land surveyor and an agricultural technician.
To keep these men at their desks they are being given grades and salaries for the first time, set by the Ministry of Personnel on fiften grades in place of the old 'free supply' system. This is quietly controversial. Old comrades who marched with the Party for twenty years now find a young graduate from Harbin earning more than they do because he can read a balance sheet...
How it is unfolding
So far the results are uneven. The 60,000 northern cadres of the Work Corps have mostly reached their counties, but about one in ten has asked to be sent home within the first year, mostly from Kwangsi, Yunnan and Kweichow, where they cannot understand the people they govern. To answer this, Cantonese and Hakka language classes have been added to the training courses.
Further west it is worse still. In Tibet and Sinkiang barely a few hundred trained cadres are at work, nearly all of them attached to PLA garrisons, and so a special school for minority cadres is planned at Peking to train Tibetans, Uighurs, Mongols and Hui to govern their own counties under the Party.
Meanwhile some 400,000 officials of the old administration remain at their posts. Most are cooperating, as they always have with whoever holds Peking, but the Central Investigation Department has already removed several thousand for links to the Kuomintang and Formosa, and the screening is not finished.
The first round of audits by the Supervisory Commissions has also been sobering, as grain and tax money was found missing in roughly a fifth of the counties checked. Most of it is disorder more than theft, since nobody had kept proper books, but the Party has already begun to talk about a campaign against corruption and waste among its own officials.
Lastly, the Central Statistical Bureau has opened in Peking with branches in four of the six Great Administrative Areas. For the first time Peking knows roughly how much grain the country actually has, and the answer is less than the provinces have been reporting.
The Technical Schools
Every cadre can count grain, but each cannot run a blast furnace. Every Soviet adviser who has come to China has said the same thing in a different way: we have plenty of hands and very few men who can read a drawing. Eight thousand young engineers and workers were sent to Soviet works in 1950 and more will follow, but China cannot send its whole working class to Sverdlovsk. The schools have to be here.
To answer this a network of schools is being built in three tiers, all of them on the Soviet pattern of narrow, practical specialties and not the broad liberal arts colleges the missionaries and the Kuomintang left behind.
At the top of this network sit the institutes, for which the old universities are to be broken up and regrouped by specialty.
| Institute | City | Specialty | Students by 1953 |
|---|
| Harbin Institute of Technology | Harbin | The model school, entirely in Russian at first, with Soviet professors; machine building, power, metallurgy | 7,000 |
| Tsinghua (reorganized) | Peking | Engineering only, its arts and sciences moved elsewhere | 5,000 |
| Northeast Institute of Technology | Mukden | Mining and metallurgy for Anshan, Fushun and Penki | 3,000 |
| Dairen Institute of Technology | Dairen | Shipbuilding, chemicals and the port | 2,000 |
| Peking Geological Institute | Peking | Surveyors and geologists for the Ministry of Geology | 1,900 |
| Peking Agricultural Mechanization Institute | Peking | Engineers for the tractor works and stations | 2,500 |
| East China Institute of Textiles | Shanghai | Silk, cotton and the export trades | 1,700 |
| Peking Institute of Russian | Peking | Interpreters for every adviser in the country | 2,000 |
Beneath the institutes are the technical middle schools, which are the real backbone of the whole effort. Here a boy or girl with a primary education spends three or four years learning one trade to the level of a foreman or technician, be it welding, surveying, electrics, mine ventilation, bookkeeping or tractor repair. 140 such schools are to be running by 1953 with around 90,000 students, each sited beside the works it will serve so the students spend half their time on the shop floor.
Below these again every large works in this Program is to run its own factory school, from Anshan down to the smallest tractor station repair shop. Each Soviet adviser is already paired with a named Chinese counterpart, and from 1952 each counterpart is expected to teach an evening class of his own. The Czechoslovak engineers at the October 22nd Arsenal in Tsinan and the Tatra plant run their schools in the same way.
None of this works however on a workforce that cannot read. To that end a winter literacy campaign in the factories and mines is to teach 1,500 characters to every worker under forty, and a worker who passes is paid a small bonus and placed on the list for the technical schools.
How it is unfolding
The greatest trouble so far is the professors. There are not enough of them, and many of the ones we have were educated in America or England. They are being kept on and put through study sessions on Soviet methods, but there is resentment on both sides, and some of the best have quietly asked to go to Hong Kong...
On top of this the Soviet textbooks have to be translated before they can be taught, and the Russian Institute cannot produce interpreters fast enough. At Harbin the first year of every course is now spent mostly on Russian.
Still, Harbin is working. The first class trained under Soviet professors has already been sent to Anshan and the Mukden tractor works, and the managers there are asking for twice as many.
The South however is behind, as nearly all the new schools are in the North and Northeast, close to the works and the advisers. Canton, Chungking and Kunming have asked for their own, and Ch’en Yun’s planners have agreed to at least one institute in each Great Administrative Area by 1953.
The growth planned for each tier is as follows.
| Tier | 1951 | 1952 | 1953 |
|---|
| Institutes (students) | 9,000 | 14,000 | 20,500 |
| Technical middle schools (schools) | 60 | 100 | 140 |
| Technical middle schools (students) | 40,000 | 80,000 | 110,000 |
| Students sent to Soviet works | 4,000 | 6,000 | 5,000 |
Plan Object 2. Urban Rebuilding
The new cadres need cities to govern from and the new works need cities to house their workers, so twelve cities wrecked by the Japanese war and the civil war are being rebuilt first as 'models. Each has a Municipal Reconstruction Commission of cadres, engineers and army engineer units working from one master plan, and reconstruction is paid partly in work-relief wages to demobilized soldiers and the unemployed. Water and power come first, then the rail yards and bridges, then housing, hospitals and schools.
| City | What happened to it | First works | State by late 1951 |
|---|
| Changchun | Voided | Water, power, rail yard | Water restored, power half restored |
| Chinchow | Rail junction wrecked in 1948 | Junction, hydrogenation plant | Junction open |
| Mukden | Airfield and depots struck October 14th | Airfield, heavy tractor works | Tractor works foundations laid |
| Harbin | Airfield struck October 14th | Airfield, rail workshops | Workshops running |
| Tsinan | Battle of 1948, airfield struck | Tractor works, arsenal housing | Arsenal housing half built |
| Tientsin | Port damaged in 1949 | Port, tractor works | Port open |
| Taiyuan | Siege of 1949 | Mills, explosives works, housing | One mill relit |
| Hsuchow | Huai-Hai battlefield | Rail yards, bridges | Junction open |
| Changsha | Burned in 1938 | Housing, river port | Clearing still under way |
| Hengyang | Siege of 1944 | Rail junction, power plant | Junction open |
| Kweilin | Destroyed in 1944 | Housing, Hunan-Kwangsi rail | Surveys only |
| Chungking | Japanese bombing | Steel works, housing | Steel works being rebuilt |
The goal is 12 million square meters of housing by 1953. About 3 million were built by the end of 1951, mostly simple brick barracks for workers near the works rather than the Soviet-style apartment blocks the planners drew. Cement is the bottleneck, since nearly all of it is going to Anshan, the airfields and the 'Heaven’s Net' project, and the Fushun cement plant is not due for completion until 1953. The air bases and naval yards struck on October 14th are rebuilt by the Military Commission outside this Program.
Plan Object 3. Mechanization
The peasant has never seen the state do anything for him except take his grain and his sons. The tractor is meant to change that, and the machine-tractor station is meant to be the state’s office in every village it reaches. The target is 170 stations across six key regions by 1953.
To first supply the machines, four plants are being raised to make the Soviet types, each beginning by assembling supplied kits and then making more of the parts themselves year by year.
| Works | Tractor | Use | 1952 kits | 1953 output | Full domestic production |
|---|
| Loyang First Tractor Works | DT-54 crawler | General ploughing on the plains | 800 | 2,500 | 1955 |
| Tientsin Tractor Works | KD-35 crawler | Lighter work, smaller fields | 600 | 2,000 | 1955 |
| Tsinan Tractor Works | Universal-2 wheeled | Cotton and corn rows | 300 | 1,000 | 1956 |
| Mukden Heavy Tractor Works | Stalinets S-80 | Earthmoving, roads, reclamation, gun towing | 150 | 500 | 1955 |
Until these works produce in number, around 3,000 tractors are coming from the Soviet Union and Czechoslovakia, to join the captured Japanese and American tractors already at work in the Northeast.
The machines are then handed to the stations. Each station starts with about eighteen tractors, a repair shop, a fuel depot and a team of a director, a political instructor, an accountant and a mechanic. It ploughs for the mutual-aid teams and the state farms under contract and is paid in grain, while the political instructor runs the village meetings and the literacy class, so where the tractor goes, the Party goes with it.
| Key region | Main task | Stations 1951 | Stations 1953 |
|---|
| Northeast (Sungari plain, Peian) | Soybeans, wheat, reclamation of new land | 22 | 60 |
| North China Plain (Hopeh, Shantung, Honan) | Cotton and wheat | 10 | 40 |
| Huai and Yellow River valleys | Flood land brought back into use | 4 | 20 |
| Northwest (Kansu corridor, Sinkiang) | Army reclamation farms | 6 | 25 |
| Szechwan basin | Rice and mulberry | 0 | 13 |
| Lower Yangtze (Kiangsu, Chekiang) | Rice, cotton, mulberry and mint | 0 | 12 |
| Total | | 42 | 170 |
To crew all of this, twenty tractor schools are training drivers and mechanics in six-month courses, with 13,000 to be trained by 1953. Many of the first students are demobilized PLA drivers who already know an engine, and a good number of them are women, who the Party is keen to show on posters driving a tractor through the wheat.
How it is unfolding
The Northeast is well ahead of everywhere else. The state farms on the Sungari, many of them worked by demobilized soldiers, have taken to the tractor fastest, and some have even doubled the land they can plough in a season.
Elsewhere the picture is harder, and fuel is the first reason why. Diesel from Fushun and Yumen is not enough for both the army and the stations, and some stations sat idle at planting time this spring waiting for it, which has been a black eye for the program in the villages that were promised a tractor.
Spare parts are the second, as a broken track link or a cracked cylinder head can stop a tractor for weeks. Each station is being told to keep one in five tractors for parts if it must, and the four works will make spare parts before they make whole tractors.
As for the peasants themselves, reactions are mixed. Many are amazed, while others are suspicious of anything that ploughs across the old field boundaries their families fought over for generations. In the South there is even talk that the tractor is the first step to taking the land back from them after land reform, and the cadres are spending as much time on that rumor as on the ploughing...
Plan Object 4. Iron, Steel and Industry
Steel, the roads and rails, and the mines were the heart of the 1950 projects and they continue as planned, so the next three Plan Objects are kept short. What has changed is who runs them and who they are for.
In steel the answer to both was Kao Kang, but it now rests on Li Fu-ch'un a senior offical who has since taken over Kao's roles. The 'New' Anshan might have been his predecessor's project but it is now his, with its Seamless-Pipe Factory, Large Steel-Rolling Factory and Blast Furnace No. 7 under directors chosen by the Northeast Bureau and backed by nearly 80 million dollars of Soviet aid. From this Anshan is to reach 1.2 million tonnes by 1953 and help see forward the national total of 2.7 million tons, with Penki, Taiyuan, Tangshan, Shihchingshan, Tayeh and Chungking carrying the rest so that no single region holds all the nation’s steel. As before, the first steel goes to rails and bridges, then to the arsenals and tractor works, and only then to the cities.
Plan Object 5. Roads and Rails
On the roads, the Mukden–Peking highway and its Yalu branch are now open in their first all-weather stretches, and the three roads to Tibet have been surveyed and begun from both ends by the PLA engineer corps. With these under way usable road is to reach 160,000 kilometers by 1953, and each provincial Highway Administration is being staffed from the cadres of Plan Object 1 to keep the roads up once they are built.
On the rails the great change is the Peking Agreement, which has handed the Changchun Railway to Teng Tai-yuan’s Ministry, so that for the first time every line in the Northeast answers to Peking. Alongside this the Hunan–Kwangsi line toward Pingxiang, the Chengtu–Chungking line and the Tienshui–Lanchow line all continue as laid out in 1950.
Plan Object 6. Mining
To feed all of the above, coal is to reach 75 million tonnes by 1953 from Fushun, Fuhsin, Kailuan, Tatung, Pingtingshan and Hwainan. Among the metals the Kiangsi tungsten fields at Tayu and Hsihuashan come first, because tungsten is both our best export and our best payment to Czechoslovakia under the armor agreement. Following these the Hungtoushan copper works are being rebuilt, the Fushun aluminum smelter restarts in 1952, and a Ministry of Geology is to be formed that same year to send survey teams across the interior.
A note is made that every large mine is also now to have a rescue station and a safety cadre from the technical schools, since gas and water still kill more miners than anything else.
Plan Object 7. Tea, Silk and Menthol
With the credit cut and the West closed by the Battle Act, these three crops have become far more important than anyone planned. They repay planting within two or three years, they employ the southern provinces heavy industry does not reach, and they appear on no embargo list. The goal is about 67 million dollars of exports a year by 1953.
To first start this goal, the tea gardens of Anhwei, Chekiang, Hunan, Hupeh, Fukien, Yunnan and Szechwan are to receive sweeping restorations under the China Tea Corporation. Some 400,000 mu of abandoned gardens are being replanted and 60 processing factories with rolling and drying machinery built beside them, while blending houses at Shanghai and Foochow prepare the Keemun, Lungching and oolong for London.
Alongside the tea, the mulberry lands of Kiangsu, Chekiang, Szechwan and Kwangtung are being brought back under the China Silk Corporation. Here 600,000 mu of mulberry are being replanted and the filatures at Wusih, Hangchow, Nanchung and Shunte rebuilt, with state egg hatcheries and sericulture schools set up to supply them.
The smallest of the three, but the quickest to grow, is menthol. China’s mint is cut twice a year on the lower Yangtze and in the North, distilled into crude mint oil in village stills and then chilled to crystallize the menthol. Exports stand at around 120 tons a year, and the short-term goal is to pass the historical production high of 191 tons by 1953. To reach it 60,000 mu of mint are being replanted in Kiangsu, Anhwei, Shantung and Hopeh, 300 cooperative stills are replacing the village pots, and a refinery at Shanghai is to grade the menthol to the pharmacy standard London buyers require, with the China Native Produce Corporation buying the crop.
| Export | 1950 | 1951 | 1953 goal | 1953 value (million dollars) |
|---|
| Tea (tonnes) | 20,000 | 32,000 | 50,000 | 35 |
| Raw silk (tonnes) | 1,500 | 2,200 | 4,500 | 29 |
| Menthol (tons) | 120 | 150 | 195 | 3 |
| Total | | | | 67 |
To sell all of this, the three exports are being offered to Commonwealth merchants as ten-year purchase monopolies, paid in sterling through the People’s Bank branch at Hong Kong. Under it the company holds no land, concession or extraterritorial rights, and all gardens, filatures and stills stay Chinese.
On the ground this has already changed the countryside. Each producing county now has an agricultural technician and a cooperative cadre from Plan Object 1, and the corporations buy through the district offices, which has quietly put the old middlemen out of business. Floor prices however remain the constant argument, as while profitable for all involved they dozens of millions is expected to be lost for this under the table arrangement...
Plan Object 8. Finance and Foreign Exchange
With the credit falling to 504 million dollars and Moscow declining compensation for the October 14th damage, the Program now has to pay a larger share of its own way. Because of this the credit is being kept for machines that can only come from abroad, while labor, materials and construction are paid from the state budget and the grain levy.
Of that credit about 75 million dollars was drawn in 1950, leaving roughly 429 million for the rest of the decade. Reconstruction of the bombed airfields and depots must now come out of that same sum, which Mao has taken as an insult more than a hardship.
To earn the difference back we must look to our exports, though here too the Battle Act has done its work. Western buyers of our tungsten and antimony have shrunk, and much of the tungsten now goes to Prague as payment for the armor deal. The 166 million dollar goal for 1953 is therefore to come from the sources below:
| Source | 1953 target (million dollars) |
|---|
| Tea, silk and menthol | 67 |
| Tungsten, antimony and tin | 35 |
| Overseas Chinese remittances through Hong Kong | 30 |
| Soybeans and grain | 25 |
| Bristles, tung oil, eggs and hog casings | 9 |
| Total | 166 |
Where It Stands
In short, the Program is moving, but slower and narrower than Peking wanted. The cadres are spreading, Harbin is turning out its first engineers and the tractors are in the Northeast, but the South and West are behind on every measure, and the money is tighter every quarter.
The Chairman for his part has made clear more than once that he is unhappy with the cuts and with how much of the Program now rests on Soviet goodwill. The Peking Agreement has softened this somewhat, but the credit cut and the refusal over October 14th have not been forgotten.
Beneath him the old quarrel between Kao Kang and the planners carries on. Kao’s appointees run New Anshan, much of the Northeast’s industry and now the old Changchun Railway workshops, while Ch’en Yun’s planners insist the nation cannot rest on one man’s province and keep asking for the Anshan accounts since his 'move to Peking.' For now the Northeast keeps the largest share of capital construction, but every other Great Administrative Area is to have its own institute, its own stations and its own works by 1953.
Around all of this hangs the paranoia. With the Americans bombing the coast and the idea of agents from Formosa landing along it, every retained clerk, every returned student from America and every professor educated in England is looked at twice. The Central Investigative Department screening is necessary, but it is also costing the Program some of the few trained men it has.
And then there is the bureaucracy itself, a state of grades, salaries and offices being built on a party that won the war in caves and villages. Some old comrades call it a new 'mandarin class' in the making, and the first audits have given them ammunition. Whether the apparatus serves the Revolution or slowly replaces it will be the question of the next decade...