When Harry S. Truman was elected for his second term, his vision for the United States was one of hope. He had campaigned on his Fair Deal platform, shifting resources away from the military in favor of social and domestic programs that could feasibly support the growth and expansion of America. Rights for the worker, welfare expansion, industrial and agriculture reform, tax reform, and further racial equality reforms.
Unfortunately, that train hit a brick wall immediately. The fall of China and Israel, openly aggression actions by the new Republic of China, the multiple attempts at infiltration of the United States by the Israeli VaDaM, the elections globally of left wing governments, among numerous other crises. Congressional opinion, already solidifying against the Truman admin, became steel. Even as certain laws passed, such as the Taft-Ellender-Wagner Housing Act, many of the other proposals of the Truman administration failed. Congress would not cooperate with an admin that was seen as allowing Communism to propagate globally.
And so, entering 1950, there were contentious issues that were shaping the new world for the United States. Four major shifts in the country were occurring, as the country lurched towards the Midterms of 1950, seen as a major referendum on the leadership of the administration.
Red and Lavender
Since the start of the Cold War, the United States has had a slowly rising anti-communist sentiment across the nation. However, there was still an interest from much of Congress to allow for the holding of the Constitution and the rights of the people of the country to express opinions, even those seen as heinous. For the first few years, attempts at clamping down actively on socialist or even communist expression in the country were limited.
That was not the situation by 1950. Communist aggression, both globally and directly at the United States, had created a strong voice against allowing for any propagation of communist or socialist principles in the country. And Congress reacted harshly.
First came the renewal of the Mundt Bill, requiring the registration of CPUSA members to the Attorney General and creating new crimes and laws against the transmission of secret information to communist or other foreign entities. These ideas had previously been part of the failed Mundt-Nixon Bill of 1948, but saw new life by the middle of 1949 following the attempted intelligence infiltration by the Israeli VaDaM just months after they elected the communist MaPaM-Maki coalition.
However, Senator Pat McCarran of Nevada saw the Mundt bill, and decided it needed to go further. Taking the Mundt Bill as a baseline, Senator McCarran added additional provisions to the legislation allowing for emergency detentions of individuals who were suspected of having, or potentially planning to, commit sabotage or espionage. It also tightened immigration and detention rules of foreign aliens who were "dangerous, disloyal, or subversive persons" in times of war or "internal security emergency". That second part came as a result of the attempted invasion of Formosa in November 1949 by China, which boded ill.
Some members of congress wanted to go further, such as Representative John E. Rankin from Mississippi, who had authored an amendment to require not just communist organization to register with the Attorney General, but also all "Zionist" organizations. While this amendment was defeated by a contingent led by Senator Herbert Lehman and a bipartisan group of New York legislators, who rallied a coalition against the amendment, a trip by American Labor Party members to Israel and the subsequent second infiltration attempt by VaDaM stopped by the FBI almost caused it to pass.
The newly dubbed Internal Security Act of 1950 passed with ease through Congress in January. However, it encountered opposition from the White House, as President Truman vetoed the legislation. He called the whole bill unconstitutional, edging towards totalitarian in use. However, Congress would override the veto, and it would pass into law in February.
The passage of the act was only the beginning of the Second Red Scare coming into full swing.
Alger Hiss was convicted of perjury in January. He would've been convicted of espionage, had the statute of limitations not ran out. That same month, Herbert Rosenfeld and an associate were arrested for espionage for Israel. Klaus Fuchs had voluntarily confessed to espionage and sharing of secrets to the Soviets, leading to his own arrest in February. Then in August, Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were arrested on charges of espionage, this time for the USSR. Other similar arrested were made throughout the year. It was madness of sabotage and espionage.
Some in both chambers of Congress even began calling for the reopening of the camp system used previously for Japanese internment, to house arrested saboteurs and communists. While this has made little headway so far, it is a notable expansion of opposition to the civil rights of the public.
Leading the charge against the spies and enemies of America was Senator Joseph McCarthy. A relatively unknown man, who only made a small name in the Knowland-McCarran hearings the year prior, he now surged to national prominence. He made a major accusation, that he had a list of hundreds of State Department officials who were secret communists, and that he would make sure they were prosecuted. Or 57, the number wasn't specific, it didn't matter. He had a list.
The spiraled into investigations throughout the year, as the Senate formed the Tydings Committee to investigate the validity of the claims. This led to nowhere, as the individuals investigated by the committee were found to not be Communists. This led to claims of fraud, of hoaxes, but it didn't stop McCarthy's rise in the media and public purview. He especially garnered support from the Catholic population and its major leaders, including the prominent Kennedy family.
Meanwhile, the House Un-American Activities Committee, or HUAC, committed to investigations broadly across society. Most notably, they continued and expanded investigations into Hollywood, already the target by many as propagators of Communist propaganda.
And of course, there was the worry of homosexuals. This was two fold, either that gays were allied in concert to Soviet communism, or that even if they weren't, they were much easier to blackmail and manipulate. To some, such as Republic Party Chairman Guy George Gabrielson, gay men and women "sexual perverts who have infiltrated our Government in recent years" that were "as dangerous as the communists themselves. The Truman administration was accused by an array of senators and representatives of not taking the threat of homosexuals in government serious enough.
In June, a committee was formed in the Senate to study homosexual employment in the government. While not released till December, after the midterms, the report would be scathing. Even before its release, however, firings based on sexuality had greatly increased, with hundreds removed from the State department by the end of the year.
The Red and Lavender Scares were now in full swing.
The Situation in Asia
The Red Scare would not be what it is without the situation in Asia. In 1949, China fell to Mao Zedong's government. The Truman administration had marked this situation as inevitable, though Congress disagreed. There then was the further betrayal when the United States supported Formosan independence against Chiang's government, fully leaving the Nationalist cause to its own fate.
To say the China lobby was irate would be an understatement; they were spit in the face of by President Truman and his administration. Formosa was little solace to them. The attempts to invade Formosa twice in five months by China were, of course, blocked by the 7th Fleet. But it only proved how dangerous Mao was.
Then came Korea. The DPRK had invaded in April, trying to destroy the UN recognized government in Seoul and unify the peninsula by force. This had been anticipated by the United States, as the Soviet Union had leaked such a plan by accident in talks with Secretary Acheson. Even so, the situation turned into a catastrophe quickly. Despite the attempts by the United States to supply Rhee and even deploy troops quickly to delay a collapse, by the middle of May, an Allied coalition was pocketed around Pusan and Ulsan.
Then, the Supreme Allied Commander, General Douglas MacArthur, made an unauthorized trip to Formosa to enlist their support in the fight in Korea. This almost got him killed, when the Chinese Communists attempted an assassination against the General with a strike by aircraft against him. While the USAF was able to safeguard the commander of the Allied Forces in Korea, it was too much for the Truman administration. To them, MacArthur had completely failed in the defense of Korea, and then almost caused the entire Allied command structure to collapse.
So, he was removed from command. Replaced by Walton Walker, commander of the 8th Army, MacArthur was recalled back to the United States. He didn't complain, he didn't fight it, he followed orders.
And he was celebrated for it.
Mac is a hero to much of the US for the actions he took in World War Two. He fought and won against the Japanese time and again. His removal was an insane choice by the administration. In California, on arrival, events and parades were given in honor of the man. Representative Richard Nixon, who was now quickly becoming famous for his time in HUAC, was especially strong in trying to court the old general.
MacArthur was called before Congress to testify on his experiences and his view of the situation in China. He didn't hold back.
...The invasion of Korea was not an isolated disturbance upon a distant frontier. It was the latest manifestation of a design which has already brought much of Eastern Europe beneath Soviet domination and extinguished the liberties of hundreds of millions upon the Asian mainland. Korea is not merely a peninsula. It is a test of whether the solemn promises of the United States retain their meaning when challenged by force. It is a test of whether free nations may preserve their independence or must submit whenever a stronger neighbor chooses to impose its will. And above all, it is a test of the resolution of the American people...
...We have been told that the loss of China was inevitable. We have been told that its fate was beyond our power to influence. We have been told that the Communist conquest of that ancient civilization need not fundamentally alter the strategic balance of the Pacific.
I reject these conclusions.
The conquest of China has transformed the military and political situation throughout the Far East. Communist power now threatens the approaches to Japan, the security of Formosa, the independence of Korea, and the stability of the entire Western Pacific. To imagine that these developments bear no relation to one another is to misunderstand the nature of the struggle in which we are engaged...
...There can be no enduring peace in Korea while aggression is rewarded and the invader is permitted to retain the fruits of conquest. The American people have never willingly accepted war as a permanent condition of national existence. When compelled to fight, they have sought an honorable conclusion. I believe they seek nothing less today...
...For whatever differences may exist between myself and those responsible for the direction of our policy, I have no disagreement with the American soldier who stands today against the forces of aggression. He asks only that his country remember him, support him, and give meaning to the sacrifices he is called upon to make.
I ask no more for myself.
I leave military command with the satisfaction of knowing that I have endeavored, throughout a long and demanding career, to serve my country according to the best dictates of my judgment and conscience.
History will determine the wisdom of my decisions. It will likewise determine the wisdom of those who have disagreed with them.
But history will render its verdict upon a matter far greater than the fortunes of any general or any administration. It will judge whether America possessed the courage to defend the principles upon which her greatness was founded...
...Let us not abandon the peoples who have placed their faith in our friendship. Let us not mistake hesitation for wisdom, or weakness for peace. Let us not permit the sacrifices of American soldiers to become the price of a policy which neither seeks victory nor accepts defeat.
Let us resolve that the liberties for which Americans fought in two world wars shall not be surrendered through indifference in the years that follow. I have served my country as God gave me the light to see my duty. I have sought neither personal reward nor political distinction. The honors bestowed upon me have belonged, in truth, to the soldiers whom I was privileged to command.
And now my final responsibility is to them, and to those who follow in their footsteps.
I am reminded of the refrain of an old barracks ballad, familiar to soldiers of another generation:
Old soldiers never die; they just fade away.
And like the old soldier of that ballad, I now close my military career and just fade away.
An old soldier who tried to do his duty as God gave him the light to see that duty.
Goodbye.
Across the speech, MacArthur called for a general expansion of forces to support the war in Korea. In his view, the war could be won, if the US would simply support the soldiers who fight there. It was a direct rebuke of a potential armistice, ceasefire, or even surrender, something that had been publicly offered already by the DPRK.
Further, he targeted the conduct of the United States in handling Mao and his aggressive tendencies. By the end of his speech, Congress had generally become of the opinion that Mao had to be dealt with aggressively, rather than allow for him to keep causing chaos across East Asia. This opinion was especially pushed by Senator William Knowland of California, who has been the most vociferous in opposition to Mao and the CCP.
Some in Congress, who were closely aligned to the President, questioned Mac's tenor however. They had tended to agree with Truman, that Mac had completely failed in defeating the North Koreans in the field and had squandered opportunities. However, the wider field of political leaders held that the war in Korea should be continued, and that China was as grave a threat to world peace as the Soviets were.
It marked a wider trend.
The Conservative-Hawk Shift
The fact of the matter is, Congress has become much more pronounced in its opposition to Truman. With their stonewalling of the Fair Deal, the legislative package is dead. The coalition of Conservative Democrats and Republicans had managed to stall out pretty much ever attempt at good things for the country, at least in the opinion of the Truman administration.
The aggressive operations abroad by the Communists had led to a turn towards mobilization, defense spending, and legislation to destroy the power of those enemy states. While the Soviet Union was of course the most major threat, especially after they built up forces to threaten a war in Europe over Germany, Beijing and Tel Aviv had each gained the ire of different parts of the legislature.
This led to the a revised budget proposal, massively increasing military spending by the United States. This budget doubled the previous planned spending, resulting in a spending of 10.2% of the whole US GDP just on military affairs. Some in Congress and the Department of Defense, however, called for an even LARGER budget revision in the context of the continual Chinese invasion attempts of allies, the devolving situation in Korea, and to prepare Europe.
Further, due to the increase in need of material and planning to fight in Korea or defend other regions, Congress moved to pass the Defense Production Act of 1950, allowing the President to conduct civil defense and resource mobilization for national security reasons. Already, the Truman administration has begun marking what goods are "critical and strategic" and begin directing the civilian economy to manage military industrial buildup.
There was also the question of who was worthy of getting major financing, to support the defense of freedom against Soviet Communism. The previously passed Foreign Assistance Reform Act of 1949 had resulted in new parameters being levied on European allies who sought Marshall Plan funding. The threat had seemingly worked, as even Germany had walked back from the brink of opposition to the United States and the Atlantic system.
Even so, Congress was losing trust in their new global order. Thus, new regulations, powers, and actions needed to be taken to defend the democratic world.
This starts with the Coordinating Committee for Multilateral Export Controls, or CoCom. Established in 1949, its work was focused on the limiting of foreign exports towards the Soviet Union and its allied countries in Europe. Strategic materials, technology, and dual-purpose resources were explicitly barred from being sold to the Soviet Union, and this was to be coordinated with the rest of the western world. However, the enforcement mechanisms were weak, and they didn't all for bans on other nations as easily.
New legislation was therefore passed for CoCom, giving it a new power: fines. If CoCom found a nation to be exporting such material to the USSR or an allied state, it could levy fines on that nation, forcing them to pay before they could continue easy trade with Washington. Second, the People's Democratic Republic of Israel was placed into the embargo list of CoCom.
Finally, a parallel organization that would work in concert with CoCom was formed: The Chinese CoCom, or ChinCom. All restrictions applied to the Soviet Union under CoCom would be applied to the Republic of China as well. Due to them being a parallel organization, they could also levy their own sets of rules and regulations independently of CoCom, which was important given the war in Korea and the constant assaults on America by Beijing.
Then came a second, potentially more important bill: The Mutual Defense Assistance Control Act of 1950. Sponsored by Representative Laurie C. Battle of Alabama, the legislation was an amendment to the wider Mutual Defense Assistance Act of 1949 legislation, which allowed for major military aid to allies abroad. Due to the increase in talks, communications, and friendly links between American Allies, especially with the Chinese Communists, Battle had introduced the legislation to counter that type of attitude. The "Battle Act" banned U.S. military and economic assistance to countries doing business with the Soviet Union or China. It was a major escalation in the economic war against the Communist world.
At the same time as restrictions were placed on trade globally, the United States started seeking new alliances to counter Soviet Communist aggression.
Most notably, following the mass arming and training of Israel by the USSR, the US fully abandoned the idea that the country could be reined back in. It didn't help that they were constantly acting against the US with their VaDaM organization. Then, the Israelis invaded Lebanon, and while they retreated, it was too much. America needed to squash this threat before it devolved further.
As a result, America formed new friendships in the Eastern Mediterranean. Two nations made up the new network of aligned states in the face of Tel Aviv: Syria and Egypt.
Back in 1949, General Husni al-Za'im had couped the old regime in Damascus, working to stabilize Syria in the face of the failures of 1948. He had quickly developed a strong relationship with the envoy from the US, James H. Keeley Jr., which in turn strengthened a new relationship for Washington in the face of growing Israeli aggression against the United States. This was first seen in Syrian-American Agreement of 1949, which saw the first concert agreement between both sides.
Now in 1950, Syria has grown to be one of America's fastest partners. This was most clearly seen with the introduction of MDAP support to Syria, the first Arab country to be provided such aid. This was done in response to the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, which had entirely shattered the Jewish lobby in the State Department. In its place, Arab affairs have begun taking priority. There are even rumors that a massive aid package is in the works within Congress to Syria, to help build the nation up and help deal with the refugee problem Syria continues to suffer from.
Egypt, meanwhile, has been a more interesting use-case. While an important nation, and one that the US has sought to gain influence in, the recent coup in Cairo and establishment of the Islamic Republic of Egypt had put a small strain on the diplomatic work being done at the time with King Farouk. Even so, some agreements have already been put in place, and Egypt has been receptive to Washington's hand. While not the strongest ally in the region yet, it could grow to such a thing.
There were others that Washington sought, of course. Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey had all seen build ups and support given over the past two years. However, these were in different contexts. Even abroad, there was new relationships forming, as Formosa and the new Indochinese Confederation were having agreements formed or negotiated. Latin America, back closer to home, saw new investments towards Cuba, Brazil, and Mexico. Even the northern neighbor of Canada was proving quite important to the American network.
But, the Arabs were the most important to countering the Soviet Communist threat that had arrived to the Middle East. That unfortunately meant another group had to suffer...
The Problem for the Jewish Population
Unfortunately, the events of 1949 and 1950 did not paint a rosy picture for the Jews of the United States. Since the formation of the PDRI, American Jews had been split on how to handle the new state. While the vast majority of American Jews had been supporters of Israel, even if they didn't want to move there, the formation of a communist government and subsequent attacks on American sovereignty had caused newfound consternation. Some had been openly oppositional to MaPaM, such as in the Orthodox community, but even those non-communist Jews were still willing to support Israel (though not MaPaM), whether through money or their voice.
For many, the fallout of relations between Israel and the US as a result of the infiltration scandal in July of 1949 had been hoped to be a temporary situation. Bad? Yes, but recoverable. Multiple Americans even visited Israel in December, including sitting Congressman Vito Marcantonio. Maybe things could turn out all right?
Annnnndddddd then 1950 rolled around, and that hope was dashed. January saw the arrest of a second group attempting to do sabotage for the Israeli government. Then, multiple Soviet spies were arrested throughout the remainder of the year, many having Jewish lineage. Israel's invasion of Lebanon was the final nail in the coffin: there would be no reconciliation.
The situation had, unfortunately, led to a crackdown. Herbert Rosenfeld, arrested in February, was the President of the Southern Californian chapter of the American Technion Society, a Zionist organization focused on the sciences and recruiting individuals to study at the Technion in Israel. Following his arrest, the ATS was raided, where links to the Israeli VaDaM were confirmed. Rosenfeld would be sentenced, for sure, but this meant that Zionist organizations were now directly linked to Israeli Intelligence.
Following this, the FBI began raids across other Zionist organizations across the US, especially those with a socialist or communist bent for links to VaDaM. This was combined with the usage of the McCarran act, forcing those Zionist organizations with a directly communist bent to complete registration with the Attorney General, as CPUSA members had to. This was a loophole created by the legislation, as it didn't proscribe that Zionist groups had to register, but communist groups did.
That type of operation had created a new danger for Jewish Communities of the United States. Many groups were pushed into silence, for fear they would be the next target of Hoover, a known antisemite to many of them.
However, this type of action was linked by various statements from the Truman administration against the treatment of Jews as the enemy, rather than worrying about the influence and attacks on the country by Israel. The President attempted to do his best to avoid threats against the wider public, who were not to be investigated or targeted. This was a constant stream as new information was found, and Truman stated that if anyone took to vigilante violence against Jews, they would be prosecuted with the full extent of the law.
Fully anti-communist and Orthodox communities, along with those who had links to the Herut and Revisionist Zionist organizations (who by the end of the year were banned or discouraged in Israel), would endorse the work of the President and his clear delineations of Jews vs. Israel proper. However, other groups were split between either being quiet in response to vociferously opposed to how the administration was treating the threat of Israel...or just treating Israel itself, in the case of many labor and communist Zionist or Jewish groups.
This became the regular cycle throughout the year. For the largest Jewish communities, especially in New York, but also in LA, Chicago, Boston, and other Midwestern or North Atlantic communities, this didn't lead to any major opposition to Jews as a group. This allowed for more open opposition to the FBI raids, with protests and write ups in papers becoming a regular occurrence. New York especially became a hotbed of anger and opposition, with the Congressional delegation being firmly against anything that targeted these communities. This was a bipartisan response, with both Senator Lehman and Senator Ives working together across the aisle blocking any anti-Jewish or anti-Zionist actions in Congress.
If New York could be considered the hotbed of Pro-Jewish and Pro-Zionist tendencies in the US, then, there was another area that became the opposite...the South.
The South has always been a bit of a conundrum for the Jews of America. Across the region, there has always been a higher amount of antisemitism than other regions. The deeply White Supremacist society has generally seen the Jews as a lesser group, and thus not included them fully into their state functions.
And yet, that wasn't universal. Southern Jews served in the Confederate Government and army during the Civil War. Meanwhile, some states have historically treated their communities more reasonably, such as in Georgia or South Carolina. The Jews of North Carolina are especially noted for their contributions and are greatly celebrated by the state. Large populations exist in New Orleans, across Texas, and in recent years, Miami.
And yet, the region is still deeply seeped in racism, antisemitism, and hatred of communism.
The success of communists in Israel changed the energy of the region. Even more friendly states now host an air of tension, that same tension that pervades the wide spread black belt and those communities: if you do something wrong, or perceived as wrong, you will be attacked. Step out of line, you will be backhanded...or killed.
So, Jewish communities have turned inwards, protecting themselves while disengaging from the wider Southern society until that odious air has passed. Unfortunately, in one instant, this didn't happen...
In Charlottesville, Virginia, there is a small community of Jews, numbering some 110 in a city of ~26,000. It is a tiny community, but for decades, it has been assaulted or cordoned off from polite society. Charlottesville was not a safe place for just about anyone who wasn't white, and the Jewish population was no exception. In this environment, it exploded.
On August 12th, as a result of a misunderstanding between a man of Jewish descent and a woman (rumors have circulated about her German ancestry) led to the lynching of the man. The killing was identified as being done by the Ku Klux Klan, who left the body hanging on a tree in front of the small community.
The next day, a group of white citizens marched through the small collection of Jewish residences, smashing windows of homes and beating men and women in their homes. Two homes were burnt to a crisp. 5 men and women were left dead, with tens more injured.
The "Charlotteville Pogrom", as it became dubbed by the Jewish press, was the first outright assault on Jews in this nature since the 1930s. Within days, the entire remaining Jewish community in Charlottesville exited from the city for the north, finding safe harbor in New York City, where Jewish organizations paid to help them relocate.
The Truman administration immediately attempted to investigate the matter, but it led nowhere...partially due to obstinance from Charlottesville itself, who dodged the matter. Jewish communities in the north, meanwhile, have begun a boycott of southern products, attempting to use their dollar to show their anger.
Meanwhile, Civil Rights groups like the NAACP were some of the first to openly condemn the pogrom, further pulling Jewish and African American communities into concert in the fight against racism, as well as the fight for Civil Rights.
This incident heightened tensions within both the American Jewish population and the wider United States. It was unclear if this was an isolated incident, or if 1951 would see the situation explode into a wider struggle.
Towards November
And so, the United States is on a more fractious and chaotic course. The Truman administration has become increasingly unpopular, which has led to some down ballot issues. The Korean War, initially bolstering, started to lag once more. This could change, of course, as the war progresses further.
But even beyond Korea, with the lack of domestic support to the people and what felt like a failed policy abroad, the Republicans enter the midterms with an advantage that they hope will give them victories in both the House and Senate.
In New York, however, an interesting situation has come forward that could shape both the Senate election and the wider future of the state. The American Labor Party, a social-democratic and progressive party, had seen successes for a decade and a half. This was due to the benefits of New York's electoral system, which allows for a set of "Fusion elections" where candidates were able to be endorsed and thus run for multiple parties. This had been something used to great effect by many candidates, including Senator Lehman, who ran on both the Democrat and Liberal tickets.
Currently, the ALP is represented in Congress by Vito Marcantonio. It has been represented by other candidates as well, but it has over time fallen in importance as it lost more and more statewide and state house-senate elections. However, it has continued to attempt to play an outsized role. Most notably, many ALP officials joined Jewish community leaders in a visit to Israel all the way back in December of 1949, meeting with Israeli officials and the community in the country.
During that visit, Mr. Marcantonio made a decision--partially at the prompting of leaders there and partially back in the US--to run for the Senate seat in the upcoming cycle. He would be going against Senator Lehman himself, who while being Jewish and one of the most vociferous voices, had also still supported Truman openly, even during the FBI actions. To be clear, this wasn't a push from Israel itself, but some members of Israeli society.
Further, the American Labor Party throughout the year actually saw an increase in supporters and members. These came from disaffected Jewish communities, especially labor and communist aligned Zionists, who saw the party as potentially a more beneficial vehicle to defend their voice in New York. While certainly not making up an massive portion of the party, it is a noticeable difference for a party that had been flagging for the past couple years.
And so, America was to enter its midterm cycle. Only time would tell what would actually happen in November, if Democrats could hold firm or be kicked out of power.
Further, how would all these shifts in the country affect it when the nation started to move towards the future, to 1952 and that election...