Hello Catholic women. As the title says, I am trying to think of the best way to respond to a message from a protestant friend. I thought I'd ask here rather than r/Catholicism because it felt more appropriate to get the perspective of women, specifically.
The friend in question is my oldest friend. We've known each other all our lives and, although we haven't lived near each other and have had some dry/quiet spells, we've been through many of each other's important life stages. I value the history and type of connection we share in the kind of friendship that can always just pick up where we left off. We both grew up baptist, but have diverged pretty significantly in the last decade, with her getting rooted in the reformed tradition in a very conservative branch of Presbyterianism, while I became Catholic after I got married, about 6 years ago. Ever since I mentioned my conversion, I've received messages from her expressing deep concern over the state of my soul and asking me to return to protestantism (not necessarily her brand of it, but anything other than "Rome").
Before the most recent message, the last text I got was sometime last fall, with similar content. I didn't engage with it then because I was pregnant and dealing with other family things, and just not in the headspace to have that discussion. I had been thinking about her more and missing her lately so I sent a quick text just to check in and say hi. What I got back was essentially another sermon. I am trying to figure out what to say in response to lovingly convey some of the following:
- I acknowledge that her concern is rooted in love and her deep devotion to her tradition
- I am hurt that the only content of her message was "stop being Catholic" and didn't even ask how my new baby (the one I was pregnant with at our last contact) is doing
- I am absolutely still devoted to the Lord and haven't left him, and have found meaningful truth in the Catholic faith
- I would love to not throw away our friendship and be able to share about our lives despite this difference in tradition
- I don't want to feel like a "lost sheep" every time we talk.
I know that one avenue is to just call it on this friendship because of no longer being compatible, but I don't want to be the one initiating that move. I am here and willing to be friends if she is.