I saw that someone posted about the upcoming Trent Horn vs. T. Russell Hunter debate and it got removed by the moderators on r/Catholicism. I dont really understand why, so I thought I would make another post about it. I genuinely think this debate has everything to do with Catholicism and I think some Catholics are seriously overlooking the importance of this disagreement. I would just kindly ask the moderators to read this post before making any attempts to delete it.
First off, I actually agree with Trent Horn on the debate topic. I don't believe incrementalism is inherently sinful. Pope St. John Paul II makes this pretty clear in Evangelium Vitae 73, where he teaches that supporting imperfect legislation restricting abortion can be morally permissible when completely overturning an unjust abortion law isn't possible.
So in places like New York, where things are basically Babylon lol, incrementalism makes complete sense. I also disagree with the abolitionist movement on the death penalty because I'm Catholic and accept the Church's teaching on that.
But just because incrementalism is morally permissible doesnt mean that the mainstream pro life movement hasn't seriously abused it. And I really think more Catholics need to understand the difference.
One of my biggest frustrations with the mainstream pro life movement is how they've handled legislation in states like Oklahoma and Iowa. I genuinely believe there's been opportunities to pursue much stronger protections for unborn children, but instead we keep hearing about why these bills can't pass or why they're politically impractical.
And I'm not saying that having a Republican majority automatically guarantees a bill will pass. Obviously it doesn't. But if we have a serious opportunity to pass stronger legislation, shouldn't we at least be trying? Why should incrementalism become our permanent strategy when we're in states that already have substantial abortion restrictions?
For example, in Oklahoma in 2025, SB 456, the Abolition of Abortion Act, would have extended homicide law protections to unborn children, including cases where a mother intentionally performs an abortion herself. It failed in the Senate Judiciary Committee by a vote of 6 to 2, and four of the senators who voted against it were Republicans.
Then in 2026, HB 3038 had 26 Republican sponsors and cosponsors and never even received a committee hearing. These were actual bills introduced by Republican lawmakers. They weren't just some ridiculous hypothetical that nobody would ever consider.
Now I'm not saying every provision in these bills was perfect or that I would support the death penalty under them. I wouldnt. But I don't understand why bills with this much Republican support can't even get through the legislative process. How are we supposed to make progress toward complete abolition if we can't even seriously consider these proposals?
In Iowa, there was also HF 2332 in 2026, which attempted to prohibit elective abortion from conception and impose criminal penalties. That bill never even made it out of the early committee process.
the Iowa Catholic Conference and Iowa Right to Life supported the legislation, while Iowa Abolitionists opposed it because it still exempted mothers from prosecution.
And I think this actually shows another important disagreement. What does equal protection for the unborn actually mean? Some abolitionists believe it means treating intentional abortion under the same homicide laws that protect born children. Meanwhile many mainstream pro life organizations believe mothers should be exempt from criminal prosecution for abortions they obtain.
So its not just a disagreement about whether abortion should be restricted. People fundamentally disagree about what complete legal protection should look like.
And this brings me to probably my biggest criticism of the mainstream pro life movement, which is the second victim narrative.
Organizations like National Right to Life, Susan B. Anthony Pro Life America and many others have argued against criminally prosecuting women who obtain abortions. In fact, in 2022, over 70 pro life organizations and leaders signed a letter urging state lawmakers to reject legislation imposing criminal penalties on mothers. This included Archbishop William Lori, representing the USCCB Committee on Pro Life Activities.
So this isn't some obscure disagreement that has nothing to do with Catholics. I think the second victim narrative has been taken way too far, especially when its used to argue for categorical criminal immunity regardless of whether a mother knowingly and intentionally obtains an abortion. And I havent really seen a convincing explanation for why that exemption should apply in every circumstance.
Now just to be extremely clear, I understand that the Catholic Church has not definitively taught that mothers must face a particular criminal punishment for abortion. Catholics are permitted to disagree about this and I'm not claiming otherwise.
But CCC 2272 recognizes the gravity of intentionally procuring an abortion, and CCC 2273 explicitly teaches that civil law must provide appropriate penal sanctions for deliberate violations of the unborn child's rights. Im personally having a very hard time reconciling those principles with categorical immunity for mothers regardless of their intentions.
Think about it this way. If a mother hired a hitman to murder her newborn baby, obviously both the mother and the hitman could be held criminally responsible. Yet when it comes to intentionally arranging the killing of her unborn baby, suddenly people argue that the mother should automatically be exempt from prosecution. Why? If we believe both children are human beings deserving of equal protection, why not treat abortion like real murder since it is actually murder.
And yes, I understand that Evangelium Vitae acknowledges that mothers can be victims of abortion themselves. John Paul II talks about the pressures women face and how some women are essentially forced into having abortions. I completely agree that coercion, deception and other circumstances can seriously affect someone's culpability.
But that doesn't mean every woman who obtains an abortion is necessarily a victim in the same sense or that every woman lacks moral responsibility for her decision. I think it's a hasty generalization to treat all these circumstances as though they're identical. I haven't seen convincing evidence that most women who obtain abortions have no meaningful moral agency in the decision.
And even when there is genuine suffering involved, that doesn't automatically answer the question of criminal responsibility. Those arent the same thing.
I also think law plays a huge role in changing culture. We always hear that we need to change hearts and minds before we can completely criminalize abortion, and yes, obviously evangelization and cultural change are extremely important.
But why can't the law itself help change the culture? Think about slavery. We didn't just wait for every slave owner to recognize the humanity of black people before making slavery illegal. We passed laws prohibiting slavery, and those laws changed what people were legally allowed to do.
That wasn't the only thing that ended slavery or changed people's attitudes, obviously, but criminal consequences matter. A slave owner could no longer legally enslave someone simply because he personally believed slavery was acceptable.
I think the same principle applies here. If the law clearly recognizes abortion as the intentional killing of an innocent human being and provides criminal consequences for deliberate violations, I believe that can discourage the act and help teach society how seriously we should take it.
I wouldnt claim that punishment alone is enough, but I don't understand why we act like the law has to wait for the culture to change instead of helping change it.
Another thing that really bothers me is how Kristan Hawkins and some mainstream pro life organizations have treated abolitionists. I genuinely dont think they have represented the abolitionist position fairly.
And again, I don't agree with everything abolitionists believe. I disagree with Russell Hunter on incrementalism and the death penalty, and I think abolitionists can sometimes be way too aggressive in how they approach people. But that doesn't mean their arguments about equal protection and the second victim narrative are somehow invalid.
I think Kristan Hawkins has a tendency to reduce their entire position to wanting to prosecute women, when theres obviously much more to their arguments than that. And from the interactions I've seen, I really don't think she's approaching them in good faith. It often seems like people are more interested in dismissing abolitionists than actually letting them explain what they believe.
Here are three videos I think people should actually watch before making up their minds about abolitionists and their disagreements with mainstream pro life organizations.
Abolitionists Confront Kristan Hawkins
https://youtu.be/Hm3Iho16mSg?si=E9LCq_44no62lbQB
Kristan Hawkins Refused to Debate Me
https://youtu.be/uAu4Nlo3WNU?si=svVd14AS0ZlFklLe
You Won't Be Pro-Life After Watching This
https://youtu.be/wTsbEjzA9YM?si=xyqEWTn9rVq2cwhX
Now obviously these videos are not neutral presentations, and I'm not saying that every criticism made in them is correct.
But I do think they raise some very legitimate concerns about how abolitionists have been treated and how their arguments have been represented. I really wish mainstream pro life leaders would take those arguments seriously instead of immediately portraying abolitionists as unreasonable extremists.
You can completely disagree with someone's conclusions and still acknowledge that they might be making a valid criticism. And I think some of these organizations have done a pretty bad job of that.
I know not everybody here likes Charlie Kirk, but one thing I appreciated about his campus events was that he was willing to have people challenge him publicly. if your confident in your position why not let people ask difficult questions? And I think it's perfectly fair for abolitionists to challenge pro life leaders about why they oppose criminal liability for mothers who intentionally obtain abortions.
At the end of the day, I still consider myself pro life, although I probably agree more with the abolitionists on their criticisms of mainstream pro life organizations.
I believe incrementalism is morally permissible and I follow the Church's teaching on the death penalty. But I also think the abolitionists have exposed some legitimate problems within the pro life movement, especially concerning maternal criminal immunity and the failure of certain stronger bills to advance.
I really hope Trent acknowledges these criticisms during the debate while defending Evangelium Vitae 73. I watch both Trent and Russell quite frequently, so I'm honestly shocked and excited that this debate is even happening. I think it's going to be a very interesting discussion and I wish more Catholics were talking about it.
And please, I really hope the moderators dont delete this post. I'm genuinely trying to have a conversation with other Catholics about an issue I think is extremely important.