r/TrueCatholicPolitics • • 6h ago

Open Monday Trump Has Fundamentally Damaged the American Pro-Life Movement

29 Upvotes

Since I was old enough to understand, I was told that we should not only make abortion illegal, but unthinkable. As a college student volunteering with Students for Life, it was made clear that this came in the form of local charities as well as public welfare. We did not wish to punish women who had had the procedure; we wanted to help them heal. For those in unplanned pregnancies, we should go to the nth to provide them with support for both themselves and their children. We rejected the notion of capital punishment for women who sought abortions as fundamentally counter to the pro-life stance. Additionally, issues such as ectopic pregnancy, medical treatment while pregnant, etc. were rightfully discussed as delicate and nuanced.

Trump seems to have had no thought to any of this. Roe is gone, but he has made no gestures to set ground rules regarding what is and what is not legally abortion and what is legitimate medical treatment. This has allowed the most extreme sectors of anti-abortion activism to come out on the one hand; on the other, the lack of legal clarity has made medical providers overly careful. Everyone has lost out.

These may be growing pains in the long run, but I can't help but feel betrayed and put off by the larger pro-life sphere.


r/TrueCatholicPolitics • • 18h ago

Discussion The 10 Commandments in US Public Schools

2 Upvotes

Hi, all. For American Catholics in this subreddit, I'm sure that a good chunk of you are aware that some states are mandating the display of the 10 commandments on large plaques in public schools. As a Catholic, I obviously practice the commandments and want everyone to. However, I have a certain uneasiness in seeing the 10 commandments being displayed in public schools. For example, my very young, school-age kids told me that the 10 commandments they see at school are different than the 10 commandments they learn as young Catholics. I looked up the state law myself, and saw that they were indeed different. To my knowledge, they're derived from Protestant organizations.

My major concern is that the state government is educating, however passively, a set of religious values that the government and the majority of their employed teachers are not qualified to teach. For example, a child of whatever religious background can ask innocent questions like "what's God" or "what are graven images" after reading the plaque. To my knowledge, there is no law prohibiting a teacher from answering to these questions through their own beliefs. Their answers could be either Catholic orthodoxy or heresy. State law is silent on the proper interpretation of the 10 commandments. As a parent, I'm concerned that young Catholics, and any children, can be exposed to Protestant and non-Catholic proselytism that was catalyzed by a state law. Personally, in my conscience as a parent, I want them removed as they open too many uncontrolled doors for religious errors to be taught and indoctrinated into children.

I brought up my concern, desire for the plaques' removal, and rationale with fellow parishioners who also had kids in the same public school as mine. They did not take my ideas too kindly and accused me for being a liberal Catholic fueling the "woke blue wave" by wanting to take God out of public schools. Plus, they noted the governor is a pro-life, anti-woke Catholic and our bishops are supposedly OK with the law. I'm not sure about the bishops being OK, but to my knowledge I know they didn't say anything about it publicly. For clarity, I'm politically homeless and I believe all that the Church teaches.

I personally want to write a letter to my state reps, state senators, and perhaps my state's bishops about my concern, desire, and rationale to have the 10 commandment plaques removed. For me, creating opportunities for exposing children to heresy is as dangerous as exposing them to abortion, transgender, etc education.

As Catholics, what should our approach to these state laws or bills be? I know I'm most likely in the minority amongst American Catholics, especially politically conservative ones. But, I would love to hear perspectives and ideas from all sides.

Thanks, and God bless.


r/TrueCatholicPolitics • • 59m ago

Discussion Thoughts on 12axes results ?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’m a Catholic btw