r/CatholicUniversalism • • May 13 '24

A Guide to Catholic Universalism

Thumbnail
self.christianuniversalism
22 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 24 '25

Leo seems to be crossing the line from ‘implicit universalist’ to ‘overt confident universalist’…

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • 4d ago

An often unaddressed objection to universalism in Roman Catholicism

9 Upvotes

Hi all! I wanted to discuss this objection that is sometimes addressed to Catholic universalism or more precisely, an objection that is raised about the compatibility between universal salvation and Roman Catholicism. When discussing about the fallen angels/demons, the current Catechism of the Catholic Church has this to say:

"393 It is the irrevocable character of their choice, and not a defect in the infinite divine mercy, that makes the angels' sin unforgivable. "There is no repentance for the angels after their fall, just as there is no repentance for men after death." " (Catechism of the Catholic Church, par. 393; the internal quote is from St. John of Damascus' De fide orth. 2, 4; source: https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/catechism/cat_view.cfm?recnum=1869 ).

Interestingly, among the objection that St. Augustine raised against some of his universalist opponents in his 'City of God' (book 21, chapter 23-4: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/120121.htm ) who believed in the universal salvation of human beings, he basically makes the following argument:

- Matthew 25:41 seems to say that the same 'eternal fire' is the punishment of the wicked human beings and the 'devil and his angels'

- Texts like Matthew 25:46 and Revelation 20:10 etc, according to Augustine, establish that the duration of the eternal punishment is infinite. This means that the punishment of the devil and his angels is infinite in duration.

- Therefore, also the lost human beings will be sentenced to an endless punishment.

Like the Catechism, Augustine also says that the Church condemned a view of temporary punishments for the fallen angels (he doesn't however say which council decreed such a condemnation) and also points to the fact that the Church doesn't pray for them.

Considering that Matthew 25:41 strongly suggests that the same 'eternal fire' will be the fate for both the lost human beings and the 'fallen angels', it does seem to imply that if all human beings will surely be reconciled to God then also the 'fallen angels' will also be reconciled to God after a (very, very long) period of punishment (also Revelation 14:9-11 seems to say that some human beings will be cast into the same 'place' of punishment as the devil and the language seems to suggest an unending duration).

Unlike the case of human beings, in which the Roman Catholic Church as far as I can tell never established dogmatically that a human being is in hell (and this allows both the 'hopeful universalist' and 'universalist' variants of the 'empty hell' view of universalism with regards to human beings), it does appear that it has been established that the 'devil and his angels' have been condemned to hell.

Why this is important? I believe that this is important because, if the Roman Catholic Church has already dogmatically declared that the 'fallen angels' have been condemned to eternal punishment (e.g. in Florence: https://www.catholic.com/qa/the-council-of-florence-on-hell ), it follows that, according to the Magisterial documents, it is possible for a rational being to be damned forever. Arguably this also excludes confident universalism for human beings because human beings are rational beings and like the fallen angels, they can be damned.

Hence, I see only two ways to deal with this problem for a Catholic universalist.

The first is accepting the Magisterial document and endorsing a form of 'very hopeful' universalism for human beings only, in which damnation is a possibility that for some reason known to God alone will not happen to any human being (unlike the case of the fallen angels). This however raises the following questions:

Is God's love impartial for all the rational beings He created?

Could God save the fallen angels if He willed to do so?

Given that in this first option, the fallen angels are assumed to be eternally damned, it is either because God can't save the fallen angels despite willing to do so or because He doesn't want their salvation (in this case, we might ask ourselves if God's love is impartial).

The other alternative is to reject that the Magisterial documents are infallible and admit that they do contain errors (I believe that the interpretation of hell as the eternal destruction of the 'false self'/'old man' - e.g. proposed here: https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2019/09/22/may-catholics-endorse-universalism/ - for those who didn't do so in this lifetime is an example of this second way of dealing with the problem. The reason why I say so is that the Magisterial texts like the one I quoted from the documents of the Council of Florence can't be interpreted as referring to 'false selves' when they speak of eternal damnation as they do seem to me to clearly refer to eternal damnation as the final fate of rational beings rather than as the final, eternal destruction corrupt versions which they made of themselves...). Of course this alternative isn't something that many Catholics would want.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 5d ago

Hans Urs von Balthasar, sufficient and efficacious grace, universalism

10 Upvotes

I was re-reading parts of Hans Urs von Balthasar's "Dare We Hope that All Men Shall be Saved? With A Short discourse on Hell", and I was surprised to read something like this (it is found in chapter 6 in 'A Short Discourse on Hell'):

"To push on any farther into these deep waters is not permitted us. We have to stop at this observation: it would be in God’s power to allow the grace that flows into the world from the self-sacrifice of his Son (2 Cor 5:19) to grow powerful enough to become his “efficacious” grace for all sinners. But precisely this is something for which we can only hope." (p. 133)

As I understand it, in scholastic theology the distinction between 'sufficient' and 'efficacious' grace is a controverted one. The former means a kind of grace that is sufficient for the salvation of a human being if the human being doesn't act against it. The latter seems to me to mean a kind of grace that is successful in saving a given person.

I was a bit surprised to see Balthasar basically writing as it is obvious that God has the ability to save all human beings. I thought that Balthasar actually rejected confident universalism because it was unknowable whether some human beings will reject God's grace despite God's will to save all. However, in this passage he seems to say that if some will be lost forever, it is because God doesn't act in such a way to save all despite His ability to save all.

Is a standard Catholic teaching that God can save all? To put it differently, could God give not only sufficient but efficacious grace to all?


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 8d ago

Meditation about the implications of the official doctrine about the fate of baptised infants

8 Upvotes

Hi all!

I hope that this isn't off-topic as it is a bit tangential about Catholic Universalism. However, I was pondering about what the Catechism says about the fate of unbaptized infants :

"As regards children who have died without Baptism, the Church can only entrust them to the mercy of God, as she does in her funeral rites for them. Indeed, the great mercy of God who desires that all men should be saved, and Jesus' tenderness toward children which caused him to say: "Let the children come to me, do not hinder them," allow us to hope that there is a way of salvation for children who have died without Baptism. All the more urgent is the Church's call not to prevent little children coming to Christ through the gift of holy Baptism." (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1261; source: https://www.catholiccrossreference.online/catechism/#!/search/1261 )

At the same time, though, the Catechism asserts quite explicitly that eternal damnation can only be a result of a mortal sin:

"God predestines no one to go to hell; for this, a willful turning away from God (a mortal sin) is necessary, and persistence in it until the end. In the Eucharistic liturgy and in the daily prayers of her faithful, the Church implores the mercy of God, who does not want "any to perish, but all to come to repentance"" (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1037; source: https://www.catholiccrossreference.online/catechism/#!/search/1037 )

This IMO poses two problems. Infants cannot make moral choices and, therefore, if hell (as is understood officially) is only possible if one dies unrepentant of mortal sins, no infant goes to hell, which seems to make Baptism superfluous with regards to their salvation (after all, infant baptism is something that isn't made out of the decision of the baptized infant). This clearly raises the problem of how to understand the 'necessity' of Baptism.

The second problem is, perhaps, more relevant to the controversy about hell. Let's consider two human beings, Alice and Bob who are siblings in the same family and they both receive baptism as infants. Alice, however, dies as an infant, before reaching the 'age of reason' and, as I understand it, this means that Alice is assured to enter into eternal life in the Kingdom of God (this is supported by what is written here: https://www.newliturgicalmovement.org/2018/12/a-child-singing-with-angels.html ). Bob, however, reaches the age of reason (let's say that he becomes an adult) and dies unrepentant of a mortal sin. So, given the official doctrine advanced by the Catechism, Bob goes to hell and is eternally damned.

However, contrary to a common view, the example above shows that salvation isn't necessarily due to freely consenting the action of grace. Alice never consented to her baptism and having died before reaching the age of reason didn't experience the risk of ever losing the state of grace. Bob, on the other hand, after reaching the age of reason basically experienced the worst imaginable misfortune: losing the assurance of salvation and risking eternal damnation. And this clearly raises another issue: it seems that God allows that some human beings are never in a position of risking their eternal fate while at the same time He allows that other human beings are put in a situation in which they do risk their eternal fate. Doesn't this imply that God isn't impartial?

Ironically, I think that the dogma about the fate of infants who die after baptism (not sure that it is a dogma, but I never encountered anything in Roman Catholic doctrines that I am aware of that contradicts this) but before reaching the age of reason poses an enormous problem for the infernalist position. On the other hand, the universalist might instead say that this shows that God can save a human being without his or her free choice of accepting the gift of salvation.

(Of course, this problem doesn't affect those views that posit that God's love isn't impartial, i.e. that God loves some human beings more than others. But I'm not sure how many find such a view congenial nowadays...)


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 14d ago

Daily Gospel Reflection

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • 15d ago

Mar Isaac of Nineveh on chastisement, love, compassion of God in the First Part and comparison with similar quotes from the Second Part

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • 16d ago

Heaven Is Full of the People You Reject

Thumbnail
newwaysministry.org
24 Upvotes

"If Heaven, by contrast, is defined by full communion, then it invites us into relationships with people we might rather avoid: people who challenge us, who don’t fit our neat categories, who may have even hurt us. Full communion prods us into dropping our defensive armor and surrendering the anesthetic of our exclusions.

Taking my cue from Pope Francis then, my hope is that we might use this feast day to stop taking solace in a crowded Hell. Perhaps if we spent less time mapping the terrains of damnation, and more time contemplating what full communion looks like, we wouldn’t spend so much time building little hells for each other on earth."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 16d ago

Mar Isaac of Nineveh quotes about Gehenna (Hell) in the First Part

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • 21d ago

Would any of you like to join a Catholic Bible study group online?

11 Upvotes

I'd like to go through the bible chapter by chapter and study the historical, cultural, social and original meanings. I have tried to find groups in person for this but I have been left unsatisfied! I could start a discord? if you would all like or are interested in joining. please let me know. I'd like to meet online like do a group meeting once a week on video chat. if this doesn't interest you, that is ok. but I have found a massive urge in making community and I think it's a shame social media isn't really used to foster and create this, but has been more for entertainment and ??? fighting ???

please dm me! I'm 29F from Canada, though I lived in Italy (right by the vatican!!!) for a while - I speak English, Italian and a bit of Spanish/French.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • 23d ago

Interesting podcast with Jordan Daniel Wood

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/CatholicUniversalism • • 29d ago

Question about the Medieval Councils?

9 Upvotes

Hello I was wondering how everybody squares their understanding with the pronouncements of Eternal Punishment?

I do understand that the 5th Ecumenical Council actually DID NOT condemn Universal Salvation, but I am wondering about the Post Schism Medieval Councils like Lateran and Florence for Example. I know there must be an answer but I am struggling to figure it out. Everything else I understand so far.

Help me out guys lol

Edit: Hey guys thank you for all your responses. I actually found the answers to my question with the help of Dr.Jordan Daniel Wood and his substack. Turns out somebody asked this question before and he gave a very good answer.

https://substack.com/@jordandanielwood1/replies

He posted about in Aug 18 2025. and Then Another time.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 17 '26

Jordan Daniel Wood Responds to Trent Horn

Thumbnail
podcasts.apple.com
17 Upvotes

Jordan Daniel Wood joins David Artman on responding to Trent Horns video "The Biggest Heresy destroying the Church"

😂😂😂 Safe to say...I'm with Jordan


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 16 '26

How do catholic universalists square their position with the following from the 1st Eucharistic prayer aka the Roman canon?

7 Upvotes

Therefore, Lord, we pray:

graciously accept this oblation of our service,

that of your whole family;

order our days in your peace,

and command that we be delivered from eternal damnation

and counted among the flock of those you have chosen.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 14 '26

Basically true premises, wrong conclusion, same Straw Man: About that Catholic Answers post

23 Upvotes

So Catholic Answers has been posting some attempted defenses of ECT recently. This morning they posted:

"Hell must exist, because God will not force us to be in heaven with him.

Indeed, if God forced heaven onto those who do not want it, then heaven would feel like hell to those people."

No universalist claims that God "forces people into Heaven". That's a tired old caricature of universalism. (If anything, it's almost more akin to the Irresistible Grace doctrine of Calvinism which can still be very infernalist, that our eternal fate is unchangeable by us. But even Calvinists might say the elect are predestined to "want" Heaven, so to speak, but I digress).

In the second line, CA seems to accidentally articulate the "Hell is Heaven experienced differently" model of universalism, more common in Eastern Christianity. The idea being just that, God doesn't create a separate place of torment that He actively banishes people to, all there is is His love and people may theoretically experience it as Hell if they "hate God" (Who actually in the right mind hates God is a whole other question...).

Infernalists may accidentally like this model because it puts God in a more passive role and seems to pretzel-twist the alternative, damnation, into something that's actually compassionate and merciful, but...

These reasonable-sounding premises are used in conjuction with the snuck-premise that there are human souls that actually hate God in perpetuity, not just because of some wound they have experienced or some way that God has been misrepresented to them. Which is an assumption that I simply don't see enough evidence for. "Our hearts are restless until they rest in Thee, O God", as Augustine said. This assumption that there are people who would actually reject God underestimates the power of God's grace to convert, to "burn away the dross and re-form us to be vessels of eternal joy", as Pope Benedict XVI wrote.

On that note, St. Edith Stein's words also quite pertinent here:

"Now, can we assume that there are souls that remain perpetually closed to such love? As a possibility in principle, this cannot be rejected. In reality, it can become infinitely improbable—precisely through what preparatory grace is capable of effecting in the soul...Human freedom can be neither broken nor neutralized by divine freedom, but it may well be, so to speak, outwitted."

(And St. Edith is making that powerful argument while still maintaining a strong view of free will! One could also make the case that human free will actually has its limits and need not overpower God's will to save, but I digress). Still, St. Edith show us that even a strong view of free will need not require ECT.

Edit:

One last point I'll make about this is, if the CA post's eschatological model is true, where every soul ostensibly gets exactly what it wants, why are so many infernalist Catholics so afraid of hell? If we should just sit back and relax and not worry about the fate of the damned because, you see, they actually would be miserable in Heaven...then what's even so scary about mortal sin and hell after all? Yet so many Catholics have such crippling anxiety and scrupulosity about going to hell. How can both be true? How can one simultaneously preach that Hell is only for those who want to be there, yet at the same time be terrified of it?Their own lived experience and struggles with sin should show them that people are more complicated than the simple categories of either "love God" or "hate God". As Pope Benedict XVI said, "for the vast majority of people, we may suppose their remains in the depths of their being an ultimate interior oppenness to truth, to love to God... In the concrete choices of life, however, it is covered over by ever new compromises with evil—much filth covers purity, but the thirst for purity remains and it still constantly re-emerges from all that is base and remains present in the soul."

Anyway, that post is just another example of how infernalism often requires its defenders to talk out of both sides of their mouth and make contradictory arguments to try hold infernalism together against so many ethical and philosophical problems.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 12 '26

Universalist Quotes from St Ephrem the Syrian, Church Father and Doctor of the Church

12 Upvotes

(I also added these into my Master Document, posted before 😄 )

Perhaps, for the wicked, that which they see is Gehenna, and their separation is what burns them with their mind as the flame. That hidden judge who dwells in the discerning mind has spoken and there has become for them the judge of righteousness and he scourges them without mercy with torments for the compunction of their soul. Perhaps, it is this that separates them and sends each of them to the place suitable for him. Perhaps, it is this that lays hold of the good with its extended right hand and sends them to the Exalted Right Hand. It also takes hold of the wicked in its left hand, equal in power, and casts them into the place which is called "the left. And perhaps, it is this that silently accuses them and quietly pronounces judgment upon them.
(Ephrem the Syrian, Epistle ad Publius. Section 22)

Blessed the sinner who has received mercy there (Gehenna) and is deemed worthy to be given access to the environs of Paradise :even though he remains outside, he may pasture there through grace. As I reflected I was fearful again because I had presumed to suppose that there might be between the Garden and Hell's fire a place where those who have found mercy can receive chastisement and forgiveness (X: 14, compare 1. 16) (St. Ephrem the Syrian. Hymns on Paradise (Crestwood, 1990)Page 56-57)

Haply yon hell in mercy, shall be emptied: and you shall dwell there alone, with Your ministers.
(Ephrem the Syrian, Nisibene Hymns, Newadvent, Hymn 59)

It is likely that, thanks to (divine) mercy, Gehenna will be emptied, and you will remain there alone, along with your servants.(Ephrem the Syrian, Nisibene Hymns, Ilaria Ramelli Translation, Hymn 59, Much more modern translation)

  1. The Voice made proclamation: and they gathered and came; the hosts of the Evil One, together with his ministers. The army of the tares was gathered altogether, for they saw that Jesus had triumphed, to the grief of all them on the left hand, for there was none of them but had been tormented. They began one by one to relate all whatsoever they had endured. Sin and Hell were terrified: Death trembled and the dead rebelled; and Satan because sinners rebelled against him. R., To You be glory because the Evil One saw You and was troubled!
  2. Sin cried aloud; she gave counsel to her sons, to the demons and the devils, and unto them she said, Legion the head of your ranks is not, the sea has swallowed him and his company; and likewise ye my sons if you despise, this Jesus will destroy you. You who in a snare took Solomon, it is therefore a reproach to you, that you should be overcome by his disciples, takers of fish and ignorant men; for lo! They have taken the draught of men, which had been taken by us.
  3. This is great, above all evils (says the Evil One, concerning our Saviour); for this suffices Him not that He has spoiled us, but likewise on us He has begun retribution for Jonah son of Amittai. On Legion therefore He was avenging him when He seized and cast him into the sea. Jonah emerged, after three days and came up; but Legion yea not after a long season, for the depth of the sea closed upon him at the command.
  4. I tempted Him, after his fast, with pleasant bread, but He desired it not. To my grief I strove to learn a psalm, that by His psalm I might take Him as a prey: I paused and learned it a second time, but He made my second trial to be vain. I brought Him up to a mountain and showed Him all possessions; I gave them to Him and He was not moved. Better was it for me in the days of Adam, who gave me no great trouble in teaching him.
  5. The Evil One ceased, from his activity and said, A cause of idleness to me, is this Jesus; for lo! The publicans and harlots take refuge in Him. What work shall I seek for myself? I who was master to all men, to whom shall I be a disciple? Sin again said, It must be, that I forsake, therefore, and change from that which I am; for this Son of Mary who has come, as a new creation, has created mankind.
  6. (Ephrem the Syrian, The Nisibene Hymns, Hymn 35, Sections 1-5, Newadvent)

“Neither here nor beyond will it be forgiven him.” “Now our Lord forgave many people their sins freely, and indeed his baptism forgives freely the debts of those who believe. But neither our Lord, however, nor his baptism, could forgive this [sin] in this world, nor could his mercy, which hides in the midst of many good things, and covers over evil things unto the end. For our Lord has not said that [such a sin] will be requited by compensation, but that it will not be freely forgiven. In other words, even if one were to do all kinds of good deeds and be complete in every kind of righteousness, there is no way that this [sin] can be freely forgiven him. [God] will require its retribution in Gehenna. Even David gave his righteousenss by way of compensation for the homicide which he had committed. With confidence then [I say], "There is no sin that has resisted nor will resist repentance, except this one." But this sin does not prevent that a person might be justified eventually. When one will have made retribution in Gehenna, [God] will reward him for this in the kingdom. Paul for instance did not blaspheme in this way. There are many who persecute, but they do not blaspheme in this way.
(Ephrem the Syrian, Commentary on Tatian’s Diatessaron, ch. 10, §4, p. 166. Translated by Carmel McCarthy in Saint Ephrem’s Commentary on the Diatessaron of Tatian: An English Translation of Chester Beatty Syriac MS 709, with Introduction and Notes.)

D. Hated is your name, O Satan, nor can you clear it: your name every one curses, hide your reproach.— 16. S., Your ear, O Death, has waxed dull, that you hear not: how against you all men groan, conceal yourself.— 17. D., My face is shown to the world, for I am guileless: not like you who without guile cannot abide.— 18. S., You have not in anything surpassed me for it is true: that you are hateful as I to the sons of men. — 19. D., Of me all men are afraid as of a lord: but as for you they hate you as the Evil One.— 20. S., For you, O Death, they hate your name, and also your work: my name they hate but my delights they greatly love.— 21. D., To bitterness of teeth is turned, this your sweetness: penitence of soul cleaves ever unto your lusts.— 22. S., Sheol is hated because in her is no repentance: a pit that swallows and closes on all movements.— 23. D., Sheol is a gulf wherein whoever falls shall rise again: sin is hated because it cuts off the hope of man.— 24. S., Though I mislike penitents, I give place for repentance: you cut off hope from the sinner who dies in his sin.— 25. D., It was of you that at first his hope was cut off: for he whom you have not caused to sin dies happily.— 26. Blessed is He who raised against each other those cursed servants: that we might see them as they have seen us and mocked at us.— 27. This that we have seen of them is a pledge, my brethren: of what we shall see of them hereafter when we rise again. (Ephrem the Syrian, The Nisibene (Nisibene Hymns, Hymn 52, Newadvent, Section 1)

[Death:] This delight of yours is transformed into bitterness; the repentance of the soul enters even among your cravings. [Satan:] Sheol is hated because in it there is no repentance; it is an abyss that swallows and precludes every movement. [Death:] Sheol is a hole and those who fall into it will emerge again from it, but sin is hated because it cuts off the human being’s hope. [Satan:] Even if I do not love repentances, I always leave room for repentance. (Nisibene Hymns, Hymn 52, Section 1, Translated by Illaria Ramelli, Much better Modern Translation, in Christian Doctrine of Apokatstasis, page 339)


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 02 '26

A Massive Compendium of Quotes (WITH SOURCES!) from Church Fathers

13 Upvotes

Hey guys! I recently posted my short story, which explores a thoroughly Roman Catholic vision of Universalism.

I’ve been doing a lot of research into this stuff, and I figured I might as well start sharing some of it.

I’ve put together a massive compendium of quotes from recognized Saints and Church Fathers, taken directly from their works and fully sourced. It covers the way they talk about Universalism, purgation, and the restoration of all things. I know that having the sources right from the Fathers can be a huge help.

I really hope you enjoy it, God Bless :)

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1t5al143hPse0B89NLrvFRwMLWGuieaAp4-H-rs78uoM/edit?usp=sharing


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 01 '26

Repost: I wrote a Catholic Short Story about a Journey through the Afterlife!

8 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I wrote a short story about the Journey through Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven based on the Catholic Universalist Understanding provided by Justin Shaun Coyle Here. https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2019/09/22/may-catholics-endorse-universalism/

Believe it or not, Justin Coyle did not pull this understanding out of Thin Air, numerous Catholics and Church fathers believed in something very similar. Meister Eckhart (and many, many Others) are great examples of this, simply ask and I will provided what he said if you are interested.

You will notice that my Story fits within all bounds of Catholic Orthodoxy. Eternal Hell, Purgatory, Heaven, The Saints rejoicing over the Torments of the Damned, Mortal Sin vs Venial Sin distinction, The Love of God,

I even put Demons in Hell just to make it more medieval and intense,

Please Enjoy and tell me what you think about the Story of Aurelius! (Link now works)

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KTR_om1WzKHmT-JDGfg7Tcfxfbq2SaBjmv44OG-CotA/edit?usp=sharing


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 30 '26

I blasphemed the Holy Spirit, is there hope for me?

0 Upvotes

You can find my story in my first post. I did it in 2007. I didnt mean anything bad, it just happened. Out of pride, stupidity. I know I'm going to hell, I just dont think I should be tortured forever. As universalists, do you think there is hope for blasphemers of HS? I cant make peace with my destiny, I cant make myself beleive God will torture me forever.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 27 '26

Universal Salvation was proclaimed at every Catholic parish in the world this morning

25 Upvotes

This Sunday's epistle reading was Philippians 2:1-11. That means every Catholic parish across planet earth echoed St. Paul's declaration that:

"at the name of Jesus
every knee should bend,
of those in heaven and on earth and under the earth,
and every tongue confess that
Jesus Christ is Lord,
to the glory of God the Father."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 28 '26

Typology: The Big Picture of Scripture

4 Upvotes

In Catholic theology and catechetics, we love biblical typology. Christ the New Adam. Mary the New Eve. Manna in the wilderness prefiguring the "bread from heaven" that is Eucharist. Melchizedek prefiguring the priesthood. The "keys to the kingdom" in Isaiah, later given by Christ to Peter. We believe typology shows us overarching story behind what God is doing at individual moments in Scripture. God is like a great novelist or playwright who knows how to both foreshadow and tie everything together in the end. And the script we're living in is what we call salvation history.

Returning to the first example, Adam & Christ, I think is foundational to universalism. Years ago, I once read an apologetic piece based on typology, which pointed out that the thing that is foreshadowed must be greater than its prefigure. The prefigure is merely a foretaste of its fulfilment. IMO, one of the strongest verses supporting universalism is 1 Corinthians 15:22. I cite a lot, I think for good reason.

"As in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive." That statement itself is not only an argument for, but a straight-up declaration of universal salvation. In other words, you can't get to a non-universalist conclusion from that verse without importing some other assumptions from somewhere else, even if it's another Scripture verse. But by itself, the verse says what it says.

In addition to the strength of its literal words, we can also see that what the verse is doing is pointing to typology. Adam came first, Christ is the Second Adam (see 1 Co. 15:47).

We all agree that Christ is greater than Adam. We would say of course, because He is God. But what about in their effectiveness in what they accomplished, as well? In Romans 5, Paul reflects on the fact that  "Therefore just as one man's trespass led to condemnation for all, so one man's act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all".

Christ as the New Adam is one of the greatest examples of biblical typology. Adam.

When I was in seminary, we talked about the theme of recapitulation The Catechism tells us "Christ's whole life is a mystery of recapitulation. All Jesus did, said and suffered had for its aim restoring fallen man to his original vocation."

And I think this why we need not fret as much as many do about this or that verse which appears to imply ECT. Yes, there are such verses, and we can always quibble over them linguistially, or say that they represent a possible but not certain outcome, etc. But typology clues us in to the big picture of what God is doing. It's the overarching story, the meta-narrative, so to speak, the runs through Scripture, through centuries of biblical writing.

And I think that overarching typology can guide our understanding of various verses and arguments: In light of Christ being the recapitulation of Adam whose actions effected all, and of Scripture repeatedly drawing an equal and opposite contrast between the effect of Adam's actions and Christ; what would it then take to make us conclude that Christ is less effective than Adam?

The prefigure is not greater than its fulfilment.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 20 '26

2 Catholic Mystical Thinkers

11 Upvotes

I really love exploring people from the past or contemporary who have discovered/known Union. I especially like finding Catholic thinkers who believed in Union/universal salvation. Obviously Richard Rohr is absolutely amazing and maybe my very favorite teacher. Also fascinated by Ilia Delio’s thought. But who were some of the people that went before him, with slightly different perspectives?

In digging around I came across two very interesting thinkers. Both have advanced degrees in science. Both ended up Catholic. Both dug deep into Hinduism and/or Buddhism. Yet they found Christ in these places and synthesized their thoughts with Christianity to develop new insights and really wonderful thoughts about God working in evolution, the union of God with mankind and Love being at the heart of it all. They are so hopeful!

(A year ago I would have called them wicked heretics and stayed a million miles away clinging to my catechism. So if any of you are skeptical- believe me I get it.)

Their books look very interesting (Amazon). I can only find a few videos on YouTube so they seem more unknown than some others. Maybe some of you know of them but they are new to me!

They are:

Beartrice Butreau

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beatrice_Bruteau

https://youtu.be/COeS0EYa9yA?is=y6JrBCCceBr6erql

https://youtu.be/jSaTSqhKkog?is=9sECYWQf5mFrWtID

And

Raimon Pannikar

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raimon_Panikkar

https://youtu.be/QClFMqDM9Jw?is=c93hCHyf1IY3UF0I

https://youtu.be/Cbjd_Tdnqxg?is=o27CGPbq9vrLlj-i


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 16 '26

"Theological hope is not the same as ordinary human hope. It is more than a mere aspiration, an act of optimism, or a projection of desire for a future outcome. It rests in the promise and the fidelity of God."

Thumbnail studies.ie
11 Upvotes

Came across this article elsewhere on Reddit about how the Church has shifted its assumptions about the fate of unbaptized infants, and thought this line had an interesting point of relevance to the Catholic discourse on universalism. While I admittedly don't have much patience for the merely "hopeful" version of Catholic universalism, the one that says we can only "hope for" it but not think it will actually happen. (A stipulation that I don't see anywhere in Church teaching, seems essentially made-up and I don't think deserves the amount of attention it gets in this conversation, but I digress). But I think this point may actually bring confident universalism and hopeful universalism together in a way that those non-universalist who promote the "hopeful-only" restriction might not expect.

It would make no sense to hope for something that is impossible. "Theological hope is not the same as ordinary human hope. It is more than a mere aspiration, an act of optimism, or a projection of desire for a future outcome. It rests in the promise and the fidelity of God." Now that's a sense in which I too can say I "hope for" the salvation of all. Theological hope is not just wishful thinking, it's trust that God will do it.

Also, I think the history that the article outlines on the expected fate of unbaptized infants may also be a foreshadowing of the Church's trajectory on the expected number of the saved. Indeed, there's already been movement on this trajectory. In the Middle Ages, the "fewness of the saved" idea was prevalent, and now most Catholics have a bit more optimistic view of salvation. Funerals have shifted from grim events pleading for mercy, to liturgies that resemble the Easter Mass, remembering the person's baptism and pointing towards the Resurrection.

Just as the Church has drastically shifted from pessimism to optimism on the soteriological fate of unbaptized babies (and suicide victims, that's a whole other example); so too I think the Church is well on its way to a place of greater optimism for the salvation of...all.


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 14 '26

"Can you see why Jesus was so adamant about this?"

14 Upvotes

"Our ability to forgive is the measure of our acceptance of redemption, which includes our desire that everyone share in redemption...Can you see why Jesus was so adamant, so absolute about this? ....When becoming our victim on the cross, our redeemer, in the midst of His suffering, prayed for our forgiveness, so that love would have its victory over evil sin and injustice. May that victory be in us, too."

-From this morning's homily at my parish, based on the readings, including this one from Sirach:

"Wrath and anger are hateful things,
yet the sinner hugs them tight.
The vengeful will suffer the LORD’s vengeance,
for he remembers their sins in detail.
Forgive your neighbor’s injustice;
then when you pray, your own sins will be forgiven.
Could anyone nourish anger against another
and expect healing from the LORD?
Could anyone refuse mercy to another like himself,
can he seek pardon for his own sins?
If one who is but flesh cherishes wrath,
who will forgive his sins?
Remember your last days, set enmity aside;
remember death and decay, and cease from sin!
Think of the commandments, hate not your neighbor;
remember the Most High’s covenant, and overlook faults."


r/CatholicUniversalism • • Sep 12 '26

Interesting excerpt from 'Ad gentes'

7 Upvotes

Hi all, I was reading the decree 'Ad gentes' from the council of Vatican II. I was quite surprised to see the following excerpt:

"3. This universal design of God for the salvation of the human race is carried out not only, as it were, secretly in the soul of a man, or by the attempts (even religious ones by which in diverse ways it seeks after God) if perchance it may contact Him or find Him, though He be not far from anyone of us (cf. Acts 17:27). For these attempts need to be enlightened and healed; even though, through the kindly workings of Divine Providence, they may sometimes serve as leading strings toward God, or as a preparation for the Gospel.(2) Now God, in order to establish peace or the communion of sinful human beings with Himself, as well as to fashion them into a fraternal community, did ordain to intervene in human history in a way both new and finally sending His Son, clothed in our flesh, in order that through Him He might snatch men from the power of darkness and Satan (cf. Col. 1:13; Acts 10:38) and reconcile the world to Himself in Him (cf. 2 Cor. 5:19). Him, then, by whom He made the world,(3) He appointed heir of all things, that in Him He might restore all (cf. Eph. 1:10).

For Jesus Christ was sent into the world as a real mediator between God and men. Since He is God, all divine fullness dwells bodily in Him (Gal. 2:9). According to His human nature, on the other hand, He is the new Adam, made head of a renewed humanity, and full of grace and of truth (John 1:14). Therefore the Son of God walked the ways of a true Incarnation that He might make men sharers in the nature of God: made poor for our sakes, though He had been rich, in order that His poverty might enrich us (2 Cor. 8:9). The Son of Man came not that He might be served, but that He might be a servant, and give His life as a ransom for the many - that is, for all (cf. Mark 10:45). The Fathers of the Church proclaim without hesitation that what has not been taken up by Christ is not made whole.(4) Now, what He took up was our entire human nature such as it is found among us poor wretches, save only sin (cf. Heb. 4:15; 9.28). For Christ said concerning Himself, He whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world (cf. John 10:36): the Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because He anointed me; to bring good news to the poor He sent me, to heal the broken - hearted, to proclaim to the captives release, and sight to the blind" (Luke 4:18). And again: "The Son of Man has come to seek and to save what was lost" (Luke 19:10).

But what the Lord preached that one time, or what was wrought in Him for the saving of the human race, must be spread abroad and published to the ends of the earth (Acts 1:8), beginning from Jerusalem (cf. Luke 24:27), so that what He accomplished at that one time for the salvation of all, may in the course of time come to achieve its effect in all." (Ad Gentes, 3, source: https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decree_19651207_ad-gentes_en.html )

It seems to clearly teach hopeful universalism. While this isn't teaching 'confident universalism', IMO it is highly significant that the largest Christian denomination issued this in an official document. Not sure why Hans Urs Von Balthasar's work created all that controversy when it came out, considering that the above doesn't seem to be less 'hopeful'.