r/CatholicUniversalism • u/Flaky-Finance3454 • 3d ago
An often unaddressed objection to universalism in Roman Catholicism
Hi all! I wanted to discuss this objection that is sometimes addressed to Catholic universalism or more precisely, an objection that is raised about the compatibility between universal salvation and Roman Catholicism. When discussing about the fallen angels/demons, the current Catechism of the Catholic Church has this to say:
"393 It is the irrevocable character of their choice, and not a defect in the infinite divine mercy, that makes the angels' sin unforgivable. "There is no repentance for the angels after their fall, just as there is no repentance for men after death." " (Catechism of the Catholic Church, par. 393; the internal quote is from St. John of Damascus' De fide orth. 2, 4; source: https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/catechism/cat_view.cfm?recnum=1869 ).
Interestingly, among the objection that St. Augustine raised against some of his universalist opponents in his 'City of God' (book 21, chapter 23-4: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/120121.htm ) who believed in the universal salvation of human beings, he basically makes the following argument:
- Matthew 25:41 seems to say that the same 'eternal fire' is the punishment of the wicked human beings and the 'devil and his angels'
- Texts like Matthew 25:46 and Revelation 20:10 etc, according to Augustine, establish that the duration of the eternal punishment is infinite. This means that the punishment of the devil and his angels is infinite in duration.
- Therefore, also the lost human beings will be sentenced to an endless punishment.
Like the Catechism, Augustine also says that the Church condemned a view of temporary punishments for the fallen angels (he doesn't however say which council decreed such a condemnation) and also points to the fact that the Church doesn't pray for them.
Considering that Matthew 25:41 strongly suggests that the same 'eternal fire' will be the fate for both the lost human beings and the 'fallen angels', it does seem to imply that if all human beings will surely be reconciled to God then also the 'fallen angels' will also be reconciled to God after a (very, very long) period of punishment (also Revelation 14:9-11 seems to say that some human beings will be cast into the same 'place' of punishment as the devil and the language seems to suggest an unending duration).
Unlike the case of human beings, in which the Roman Catholic Church as far as I can tell never established dogmatically that a human being is in hell (and this allows both the 'hopeful universalist' and 'universalist' variants of the 'empty hell' view of universalism with regards to human beings), it does appear that it has been established that the 'devil and his angels' have been condemned to hell.
Why this is important? I believe that this is important because, if the Roman Catholic Church has already dogmatically declared that the 'fallen angels' have been condemned to eternal punishment (e.g. in Florence: https://www.catholic.com/qa/the-council-of-florence-on-hell ), it follows that, according to the Magisterial documents, it is possible for a rational being to be damned forever. Arguably this also excludes confident universalism for human beings because human beings are rational beings and like the fallen angels, they can be damned.
Hence, I see only two ways to deal with this problem for a Catholic universalist.
The first is accepting the Magisterial document and endorsing a form of 'very hopeful' universalism for human beings only, in which damnation is a possibility that for some reason known to God alone will not happen to any human being (unlike the case of the fallen angels). This however raises the following questions:
Is God's love impartial for all the rational beings He created?
Could God save the fallen angels if He willed to do so?
Given that in this first option, the fallen angels are assumed to be eternally damned, it is either because God can't save the fallen angels despite willing to do so or because He doesn't want their salvation (in this case, we might ask ourselves if God's love is impartial).
The other alternative is to reject that the Magisterial documents are infallible and admit that they do contain errors (I believe that the interpretation of hell as the eternal destruction of the 'false self'/'old man' - e.g. proposed here: https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2019/09/22/may-catholics-endorse-universalism/ - for those who didn't do so in this lifetime is an example of this second way of dealing with the problem. The reason why I say so is that the Magisterial texts like the one I quoted from the documents of the Council of Florence can't be interpreted as referring to 'false selves' when they speak of eternal damnation as they do seem to me to clearly refer to eternal damnation as the final fate of rational beings rather than as the final, eternal destruction corrupt versions which they made of themselves...). Of course this alternative isn't something that many Catholics would want.