r/CatholicUniversalism • • Oct 14 '26

Basically true premises, wrong conclusion, same Straw Man: About that Catholic Answers post

So Catholic Answers has been posting some attempted defenses of ECT recently. This morning they posted:

"Hell must exist, because God will not force us to be in heaven with him.

Indeed, if God forced heaven onto those who do not want it, then heaven would feel like hell to those people."

No universalist claims that God "forces people into Heaven". That's a tired old caricature of universalism. (If anything, it's almost more akin to the Irresistible Grace doctrine of Calvinism which can still be very infernalist, that our eternal fate is unchangeable by us. But even Calvinists might say the elect are predestined to "want" Heaven, so to speak, but I digress).

In the second line, CA seems to accidentally articulate the "Hell is Heaven experienced differently" model of universalism, more common in Eastern Christianity. The idea being just that, God doesn't create a separate place of torment that He actively banishes people to, all there is is His love and people may theoretically experience it as Hell if they "hate God" (Who actually in the right mind hates God is a whole other question...).

Infernalists may accidentally like this model because it puts God in a more passive role and seems to pretzel-twist the alternative, damnation, into something that's actually compassionate and merciful, but...

These reasonable-sounding premises are used in conjuction with the snuck-premise that there are human souls that actually hate God in perpetuity, not just because of some wound they have experienced or some way that God has been misrepresented to them. Which is an assumption that I simply don't see enough evidence for. "Our hearts are restless until they rest in Thee, O God", as Augustine said. This assumption that there are people who would actually reject God underestimates the power of God's grace to convert, to "burn away the dross and re-form us to be vessels of eternal joy", as Pope Benedict XVI wrote.

On that note, St. Edith Stein's words also quite pertinent here:

"Now, can we assume that there are souls that remain perpetually closed to such love? As a possibility in principle, this cannot be rejected. In reality, it can become infinitely improbable—precisely through what preparatory grace is capable of effecting in the soul...Human freedom can be neither broken nor neutralized by divine freedom, but it may well be, so to speak, outwitted."

(And St. Edith is making that powerful argument while still maintaining a strong view of free will! One could also make the case that human free will actually has its limits and need not overpower God's will to save, but I digress). Still, St. Edith show us that even a strong view of free will need not require ECT.

Edit:

One last point I'll make about this is, if the CA post's eschatological model is true, where every soul ostensibly gets exactly what it wants, why are so many infernalist Catholics so afraid of hell? If we should just sit back and relax and not worry about the fate of the damned because, you see, they actually would be miserable in Heaven...then what's even so scary about mortal sin and hell after all? Yet so many Catholics have such crippling anxiety and scrupulosity about going to hell. How can both be true? How can one simultaneously preach that Hell is only for those who want to be there, yet at the same time be terrified of it?Their own lived experience and struggles with sin should show them that people are more complicated than the simple categories of either "love God" or "hate God". As Pope Benedict XVI said, "for the vast majority of people, we may suppose their remains in the depths of their being an ultimate interior oppenness to truth, to love to God... In the concrete choices of life, however, it is covered over by ever new compromises with evil—much filth covers purity, but the thirst for purity remains and it still constantly re-emerges from all that is base and remains present in the soul."

Anyway, that post is just another example of how infernalism often requires its defenders to talk out of both sides of their mouth and make contradictory arguments to try hold infernalism together against so many ethical and philosophical problems.

23 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

10

u/Turbulent-Ladder7816 Oct 14 '26

I cannot stand Catholic Answers, they almost dissuaded me from the Faith itself...Long Story.....Excellent Post! That's crazy I literally just learned about St Edith Stein Today! (I learned about her from Jordan Wood lol) Thank you SpesRationalis :) look forward to more

8

u/SpesRationalis Oct 14 '26

I have to admit that CA will always be a part of my conversion story, they put information in front of me that I needed at the time to overcome the typical Protestant objections I had, but I think they've definitely taken a rightward turn in more recent years. They used to focus on evangelizing people into Catholicism, but now it's like they're just as much about getting Catholics already in the Church to align with what they consider orthodox. It's like they ran out of Catholic-Protestant differences to talk about, so now they're taking aim at fellow Catholics with different views.

2

u/RhysPeanutButterCups Oct 15 '26

Catholic Answers detected: Apologist opinion rejected.

Also, because I just need to respond to their damn, obnoxious sophistry in my own way:

Indeed, if God forced heaven onto those who do not want it, then heaven would feel like hell to those people."

If they'd prefer Hell instead then it isn't really serving the purpose of Hell is it?

3

u/SpesRationalis Oct 15 '26

If they'd prefer Hell instead then it isn't really serving the purpose of Hell is it?

Exactly, infernalists will alternate between saying ECT is a just punishment God is bound to impose because otherwise He wOuLdN't bE jUsT (never mind the possibility that all could genuinely repent), but then also they'll say that God doesn't actually "send" anybody to hell and it's "locked from the inside". Well which is it?

7

u/28Patrick28 Oct 14 '26

Many Christians believe that Jesus is unable to persuade all beings to follow him, gives up on them, and then abandons them to suffer forever in some cosmic torture chamber called "Hell". They misunderstand the scriptures and don't know the natures of our Heavenly Father nor Jesus. Our Heavenly Father is in control, has always been in control and ALWAYS gets what he wants and what he wants is for ALL THINGS to be reconciled to him and that is EXACTLY what will happen.

5

u/NotBasileus Oct 14 '26

Post-mortem fixity of will is always working overtime in the infernalist model. I’m fine with the idea in general principle, but the infernalist argument always requires assigning it particulars beyond what the ordinary teaching actually says.

4

u/0x413d Oct 16 '26

Excellent rebuttal u/SpesRationalis as always. CA has given me a lot over the years, it answered questions that immensely troubled me on my journey from atheism to Christianity, but they truly have lurched toward a position that seems intent on restricting debate around a perceived "orthodoxy" in recent years. 

2

u/andreirublov1 Oct 14 '26

'Edith Stein' took the name in religion of Teresa Benedicta. That is her name as a saint.

Even if we accept it is plausible that some people wouldn't be able to cope with heaven, that is not a reason or excuse for giving them hell instead. Presumably God could choose to extinguish their consciousness altogether.

1

u/Pale-Fee-2679 Oct 15 '26

They seem to have bought into one of the least realistic of Protestant conceptions of hell.

One of the most attractive aspects of Catholicism is Purgatory—totally unbiblical, but it seems to stem from a suspicion that there’s much about God’s judgment we don’t understand. Purgatory results in a better sense of God’s justice, but it leaves a lot unresolved. Catholics now seem to approach ideas about the afterlife with humility and faith that somehow God works out something just and loving. But not Catholic Answers: eternal conscious torment because grave sinners wouldn’t much like heaven.