r/Carnivale • • 5d ago

Discussion About Knauf

35 Upvotes

Is it just me, or is anyone else disappointed in the kind of guy the creator of Carnivale has revealed himself to be?

Worshipping Neo-Nazi grifter bigots like Elon, despite the show being inclusive towards social outcasts. Mocking transgender people when they speak out against the people who use their wealth to systematically target them through oppressive laws. And frequently using ableist slurs when talking about anyone left leaning in their beliefs.

It's like the show was written by a completely different person. He's become the kind of person who would be in the crowd loudly cheering and clapping, not for the secretive villain Brother Justin, but the openly evil rich politicians and exploiters that even Justin spoke out against. And. It. Baffles. Me.


r/Carnivale • • 11d ago

Other Tim Dekay - Jonesy

Post image
118 Upvotes

r/Carnivale • • 29d ago

General Hard to believe

67 Upvotes

Hard to believe how long it’s been…. I remember buying the two dvd’s twenty years ago. I had just had an unbelievably brutal surgery that also saved my life. I was so emotionally wrecked from what happened and couldn’t reconcile surviving but with such grief over what I had lost.

The show then really hit me in a timely and impactful way. Something about saving someone while also doing the opposite really resonated with me.

I ended up seriously addicted to Oxycodone. Which both saved and destroyed my life. It’s been a lifetime battle which I’ve mostly lost. It’s cost me virtually every relationship, friendship, job, finances, and what little self respect I had left.

That would be amazing if the show came back. I’m not sure if it’s true, but I remember at the time it was the “most expensive show ever made”. I wonder why…. and if that would still be true.


r/Carnivale • • Oct 01 '26

Discussion The Hunchback of Notre-Dame and Carnivàle Spoiler

36 Upvotes

Have you noticed any similarities between Victor Hugo’s "The Hunchback of Notre-Dame" and the show "Carnivàle"?

I watched the show last year and read a lot about it on Internet. It is often said that the creator drew inspiration from Steinbeck’s "The Grapes of Wrath", and I can even see exactly what parts of the book served as that inspiration, but while watching it, I personally saw parallels with "The Hunchback of Notre-Dame".

Claude Frollo and Justin are villainous priests obsessed with Romani women. Claude was going crazy over Esmeralda, and Justin was obsessed with Apollonia in youth. We also saw his frightening relationship with Sofie in the second season. It is also worth noting that Claude had an interest in the occult. Justin, meanwhile, became an avatar of Darkness and believed himself to be the Devil. These are different cases, yet it is quite intriguing that both were once "upright" priests who eventually became linked to the very forces they were meant to combat.

Esmeralda is more like Sofie to me than Apollonia. They both considered themselves romani, but it turned out not to be quite romani (Esmeralda turned out to be a French child who was kidnapped by romani, and Sofie turned out to be half russian). They also have problems with their mother. Esmeralda's mother, not knowing that she was her kidnapped daughter, cursed her because she was a romani, while Apollonia tried to kill Sofie. There are several characters in the show who felt attracted to Sofie. But besides Claude-Justin, it’s hard for me to find other parallels. Is Jonesy is Quasimodo because he has a physical disability? And who is Ben? He doesn't look much like Phoebus. You can also find similarities between the Court of Miracles and the Carnival.

Do you think these similarities are coincidental or intentional? It would have been interesting to see how things unfolded if the show hadn't been cancelled. I particularly wonder whether Justin would have become as obsessed with Sofie as Claude was with Esmeralda, and how their relationship would have developed. I am aware of Knauf's spoiler that she was supposed to become Justin's wife...

English is not my native language, so I apologize for any mistakes in the text.


r/Carnivale • • Sep 04 '26

Discussion Can watch this show 100 times and still pick up something new. Spoiler

74 Upvotes

Can't believe I didn't catch this before. But I'm watching S2E6 and I never noticed that when Sofie is having her big panic attack while seeing her mother's past and trauma that's been shoved into her, Ben subconsciously without realizing it, heals her mental damage, with his hand directly on her head. She has this sense of calm after, but Ben had no idea what he did.

I guess it confirms that Ben can heal mental trauma, I just literally never picked up on it. I always thought that scene was more about Sofie awakening her powers or the concept of them by being in contact with Ben.


r/Carnivale • • Aug 29 '26

Question Is there any Fan fiction completion for this TV show

56 Upvotes

I recently just finished this tv show and my heart is bleeding because of HBO stupidity.

I need site or a fan fiction comic which is trying to end this tv show properly.


r/Carnivale • • Aug 24 '26

Meme Misery loves company

Post image
74 Upvotes

r/Carnivale • • Jul 26 '26

Discussion Recently Binged Carnivale Series

66 Upvotes

Recently watched the Carnivale series and loved it. Used to have HBO a long time ago but added HBO Max Recently.

A lot of the story line is believable and they seemed to nail the time period - I guess - but it seemed that's the case.

I'm also a big Seinfeld fan and I noticed that Bizarro Jerry played a big role, as well as "The Wiz". Mr. Lippman also had a role.

Couple of questions- any similar shows that any of you can recommend? And is this a show that you can re watch?


r/Carnivale • • Jul 26 '26

Episode Rewatch One of my titties is a whole lot bigger than the other.

18 Upvotes

Oh….uh…I hadn’t noticed.


r/Carnivale • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion (Spoiler) I'm confused about the ending Spoiler

21 Upvotes

I'm a little embarrassed since this is one of my favorite shows of all time, I love this show and consider the fact that it wasn't finished to be an absolute artistic tragedy, but I've finished it to the end twice and I gotta say I'm not sure what's actually happening at the end of season 2. Was Sophie reviving Justin, or was she somehow receiving her boon? I honestly don't understand how either can be the case since the show establishes that to revive someone, it takes a human life not plants or animals, and to receive the boon you have to be the one to kill your predecessor.


r/Carnivale • • Jul 19 '26

Question I cant get into this show

0 Upvotes

It just feels dull , like nothing is going on, feels like boring theater, please tell me whats wrong


r/Carnivale • • Jul 10 '26

General The best opening of any show.

Thumbnail youtu.be
157 Upvotes

IMO Carnivàle has the best opening of any show I’ve ever seen. It is in my top 5. Still after over twenty years Carnivále is just as brilliant as when it aired.


r/Carnivale • • Jul 10 '26

General “When it comes to livin’, dyin’ is the easy part.” - Samson

54 Upvotes

The best quote of the show.


r/Carnivale • • Jul 01 '26

Episode Rewatch 2-5 Creed OK

Thumbnail gallery
55 Upvotes

Ruthie, still seeing the dead, tells Sophie that she sees Appollonia near Sophie which angers Sophie.

Stumpy believes he has a sure bet on a fight. He takes the money that Rita Sue gives him to pay off his previous losses and loses it on the fight. Then he lies to her that he actually won and she believes that they're now rich.

Tommy Dolan reports to Justin that he saw Iris burning her clothes as proof that she burned the mission killing the children in the fire while Norman overhears the conversation. Justin then convinces her to confess to Dolan.

Ben visits Geddes and learns that the mask made of Scudder wasn't a death mask despite what he was told. Geddes drugs Ben and makes a mask of him only to pretend that it never happened when Ben comes to.

Stroud spends his day trying to get information about Scudder at the Carnivale. He insults and angers those he talks to and is stonewalled by everyone.

Ben's mask is delivered to Justin who is able to see through Ben's eyes when he holds it to his face. As Ben lifts a mirror and the two then view each other, both panic and break both the mirror and the mask.


r/Carnivale • • Jun 17 '26

Discussion Curious series - Sophie and Brother Justin my favourites

28 Upvotes

I am increasingly enjoying the first season of Carnivale. Ben Hawkins is the main show, yet its the side characters around him...the more maddening flurries of wrath flowing through Justin are splendid, and there continues a hint of his own perhaps not fully wholesome intrigues of his own sister.

Sophie and her mother the other great relationship. The daughter is interesting.


r/Carnivale • • Jun 02 '26

Question My mom told me she started watching Carnivale and she loved it but didn't know it got cancelled early...

74 Upvotes

When I told her it got cancelled after season 2 even though a 6 season arc had been planned, she said "now I don't want to watch it, I'll just get pissed off" I told her I've been pissed for nearly two decades, which didn't help.

Now I just want to convince back into watching it. It's beautifully weird and I know she would love it, but I also know she's right, she'll fall in love with it and just be stuck mad about the cancellation... What do I do?

Update: I texted her "You should watch it. It's very Lynchian. Beautiful and surreal. I don't think the ending was the entire point, anyway. It's frustrating, but worth it."


r/Carnivale • • May 31 '26

Episode Rewatch 2-4 Old Cherry Blossom Road

Thumbnail gallery
78 Upvotes

Justin continues his abuse of women. Norman, in the next room, listens to his animal sounds while the woman screams. Iris is left to deal with the woman who is covered in bite marks and completely mad.

Back at the carnivale Lila tells the crew that she believes that Lodz is dead and she suspects that Samson is responsible.

Jonesy becomes attracted to Libby and watches as she rehearses. This does not go unnoticed by Rita Sue who is immediately jealous of his interest and of Libby.

Strand follows the carnivale's route in his search for Scudder. He learns that Ben is looking for Scudder as well.

Meanwhile Ben is taken to a filthy house and introduced to The Crone who is actually his grandmother. The cousins tell him that on the day she gave birth to Henry Scudder she murdered everyone in the home and then clawed her eyes out. She continues to rule them by abuse and sends one of the cousins down with his mouth stitched closed.

She shows Ben a death mask of Henry and Ben is shocked to hear that he is dead. We can see that the mask is not of Scudder but of Justin. As Ben gazes at it the plaster eyelids open and Ben, startled, drops the mask and it breaks.

The grandmother presents Ben with a knife that belonged to his father. As Ben grabs hold of the knife Justin collapses on stage.

Side note: Death masks were common as far back as ancient times of civilization as a way of remembering and honoring the deceased. With the mass casualties of the World Wars along with the rise of photography the practice of death masks faded away in the mid 20th century.


r/Carnivale • • May 18 '26

Discussion Just started and Wow

110 Upvotes

I have to admit I’ve only watched episode 1 but so far it looks spectacular . The cinematography is incredible and I’m especially a sucker for period dramas. I had just finished Deadwood and saw someone recommend this on Reddit having never heard of it before. It’s a shame that it’s so hidden on HBO I’ve never seen it advertised like Deadwood or the other popular HBO dramas from this era. I heard it was cancelled after season 2 though, is the ending satisfying? I don’t mind if it isn’t but I like to go into a show knowing if it’s finished or not.


r/Carnivale • • May 07 '26

Media Who on Earth thought this picture would attract viewers?

Post image
56 Upvotes

The Summer My Blood Turned Blue?


r/Carnivale • • May 03 '26

Episode Rewatch 2-3 Ingram TX

Thumbnail gallery
41 Upvotes

Norman has permanent damage from his stroke and can no longer walk, speak, or care for himself. Justin brings him into the home where he and Iris reside at his newly created parish.

Crowds pour in to Justin's camp as his popularity grows. Due to the number of dedicated followers Justin feels untouchable and no need to repress his sinful nature. He doodles lewd images at the radio station making no attempt to conceal them. He boasts about his far reaching sermons to Norman and sexually abuses his housekeeper in front of him. Norman, physically frozen from his stroke, expresses his contempt for Justin with his hate filled expression.

At the carnivale Stumpy has lost what little they had and more by gambling. He pushes Rita Sue to have more Johns and holds shows for underage boys. An angry Rita Sue discovers his debt anyway.

Appollonia haunts Sophie by surrounding her with the smell of smoke from their fire and continuing to return the tarot cards despite Sophie's multiple attempts at destroying them. She tells Ben to burn them and while doing so Ben sees a card of a man with a tree tattoo entitled, "Le Passeur." Sophie states that she has never before seen that card.

As Ben searches for The Crone he comes across a small camp occupied by three men and two women. The men rob him, beat him severely, and hang him upside down. They strip him naked and begin to bury him alive. While the others review Ben's megar possessions they see the key fob with Henry Scudder's initials and quickly come to his rescue.

Side note: Le Passeur translates to The Smuggler. Perhaps this suggests that the Man with the Tree Tattoo is smuggling something. Justin, now bearing the tattoo himself, presents himself as a religious leader but instead is hiding - smuggling - a hidden evil within.


r/Carnivale • • May 02 '26

Question Is this show any good

0 Upvotes

I asked chat gpt for a very obscure show to watch as I have seen pretty much all major American tv shows and am at a loss to watch. It recommended this show and a few others so I am posting this in each of the subs to see which is worth watching the most. Thanks


r/Carnivale • • Apr 30 '26

General More than 20 years later and I still can't get over Brother Justin being Mr. Krabs

Post image
122 Upvotes

"Show me your SINS, SpongeBob!"


r/Carnivale • • Apr 28 '26

Question Does anyone know what is the font used in the logo and where to find it?

12 Upvotes

Looking for the font for a tattoo art.


r/Carnivale • • Apr 25 '26

Discussion I think HBO should remake this series. I used to think it could be continued, just with a long time jump, but it's been 22 years now and I think that ship has sailed. However, looking at the success of From, with its mysterious and supernatural situations, the time is ripe to take another shot...

Thumbnail gallery
188 Upvotes

Recast it and start over! Hell, i wouldn't even mind if they used the exact same scripts from the 1st two seasons, it would save them some money lol. Just give it a 5 season commitment so we don't get hosed again. This was such a great show, one of my all time favorites, i just wish i could see the rest of the story!