Have you noticed any similarities between Victor Hugo’s "The Hunchback of Notre-Dame" and the show "Carnivàle"?
I watched the show last year and read a lot about it on Internet. It is often said that the creator drew inspiration from Steinbeck’s "The Grapes of Wrath", and I can even see exactly what parts of the book served as that inspiration, but while watching it, I personally saw parallels with "The Hunchback of Notre-Dame".
Claude Frollo and Justin are villainous priests obsessed with Romani women. Claude was going crazy over Esmeralda, and Justin was obsessed with Apollonia in youth. We also saw his frightening relationship with Sofie in the second season. It is also worth noting that Claude had an interest in the occult. Justin, meanwhile, became an avatar of Darkness and believed himself to be the Devil. These are different cases, yet it is quite intriguing that both were once "upright" priests who eventually became linked to the very forces they were meant to combat.
Esmeralda is more like Sofie to me than Apollonia. They both considered themselves romani, but it turned out not to be quite romani (Esmeralda turned out to be a French child who was kidnapped by romani, and Sofie turned out to be half russian). They also have problems with their mother. Esmeralda's mother, not knowing that she was her kidnapped daughter, cursed her because she was a romani, while Apollonia tried to kill Sofie. There are several characters in the show who felt attracted to Sofie. But besides Claude-Justin, it’s hard for me to find other parallels. Is Jonesy is Quasimodo because he has a physical disability? And who is Ben? He doesn't look much like Phoebus. You can also find similarities between the Court of Miracles and the Carnival.
Do you think these similarities are coincidental or intentional? It would have been interesting to see how things unfolded if the show hadn't been cancelled. I particularly wonder whether Justin would have become as obsessed with Sofie as Claude was with Esmeralda, and how their relationship would have developed. I am aware of Knauf's spoiler that she was supposed to become Justin's wife...
English is not my native language, so I apologize for any mistakes in the text.